Pakistan J. Zool., pp 1-8, 2021. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17582/journal.pjz/20200604180627 Conflicts Involving Brown Bear and Other Large Carnivores in the Kalam Valley, Swat, Pakistan Arshad Ali1, Muhammad Nasir Khan Khattak2*, Muhammad Ali Nawaz3 and Shoaib Hameed3 1Department of Zoology, Hazaara University, Mansehra 2Department of Applied Biology, College of Sciences, University of Sharjah, United Arab Emirates 3Department of Animal Sciences, Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad ABSTRACT Article Information Humans living close to carnivore habitats sometimes develop a negative attitude towards them because Received 04 June 2020 of the damages they cause. Such an attitude has costs, both for wild carnivores and local communities. Revised 02 July 2020 Human costs are mostly in the form of economic loss to property and infrastructure, damage to crops, and Accepted 07 July 2020 depredation on livestock. In northern Pakistan where large carnivores like common leopard (Panthera Available online 21 October 2020 pardus), snow leopard (Panthera uncia), Asiatic black bear (Ursus thibetinus), Himalayan brown bear (Ursus arctos isabellinus)), grey wolf (Canis lupus), and lynx (Lynx lynx) often encounter humans and Authors’ Contribution MNKK and MAN designed the contribute to significant economic losses. The present study was conducted in Kalam Valley, District study and questionnaire. AA and SH Swat, Pakistan to estimate the occurrence of brown bear and conflicts with humans. Data about the performed the fieldwork. MNK, MAN presence-absence and depredation in five years (2009-2013) were collected from 86 households in the analysed the data. AA wrote the first area. Total losses in Kalam Valley during the five year period were 72 animals. The brown bear predation draft. MNKK, MAN and SH revised was estimated as 29% of total predation in the area that killed 15 goats, 2 sheep, and 4 cattle. The snow and finalized the drafts. leopard and wolf predation was 31% and 39%, respectively. To estimate the occurrence, 10 transects were laid out in each survey area with 100 m length and 50 m width. Each transect was laid out with minimum Key words Large carnivores, Conflict, distance of one km from each other. Higher sign density was found in the forest compared to the other Distribution, Conservation, Kalam habitats. Twenty brown bear signs were recorded at four sites of the study area. According to signs, brown bear was widely distributed in Batendar area, while Jaba had the least distribution. Estimated livestock predation per household was 0.84 ± 1.13 animals. The total economic loss was PKR 20,207 or US$ 196 per household/year. The economic loss due to brown bear was PKR 5860 or US$ 58, snow leopard as PKR 6264 or US$ 63 and wolf as PKR 7880 or US$ 78 per household/year. Livestock predation and crop damages resulted in ruthless killing of large carnivores including brown bear in the area, which makes conservation efforts difficult. INTRODUCTION communities, because people living near carnivores tend to belong to the lowest income categories. As a result, rural umans living close to Onlinecarnivore habitats sometimes First people often Article have low tolerance towards carnivores, their H develop a negative attitude towards them, because of conservation, and the conservation of other non-conflict damages they cause, thus causing conservation challenges species. Humans often incorrectly identify offenders that (Woodroffe et al., 2005). Large carnivores are more cause the most losses (Linkie et al., 2007). Sometimes, disposed to such conflicts, as they often attack the livestock large carnivores also attack humans, causing injuries (Treves and Karanth, 2003). or even death (White and Gehrt, 2009) that may lead to Human-carnivore conflicts have costs, both for wild poisoning or shooting of the carnivores by humans (Frank carnivores and local communities. Human costs are mostly et al., 2005). in the form of economic loss to property and infrastructure, There are only a few studies on human-carnivore damage to crops, and depredation on livestock. Human- conflicts in Pakistan (Dar et al., 2009; Din and Nawaz, carnivore conflicts have large and unequal effects on rural 2010; Bibi et al., 2013; Hameed et al., 2013; Perveen and Abid, 2013; Kabir et al., 2014), although these conflicts * Corresponding author: [email protected], are widespread. This is particularly the case in northern [email protected] Pakistan, where common leopard, snow leopard, Asiatic 0030-9923/2021/0001-0001 $ 9.00/0 black bear, Himalayan brown, grey wolf, and Eurasian Copyright 2021 Zoological Society of Pakistan lynx often cause significant economic losses. We designed 2 A. Ali et al. this study to document the occurrence of large carnivores for tourists. The climate is harsh during winter (November, in Kalam Valley of Swat, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, northern December, January, February) with frequent snowfall and Pakistan, and to estimate the magnitude of economic moderate during summer (June, July, August) Rain is damages they cause to the humans living in the valley. frequent in March and April, but summer (June-August) and autumn (September and October) are relatively dry MATERIALS AND METHODS seasons (Hamayun et al., 2006). About 160 km2 forest is dominated by silver fir(Abies Study area pindrow), spruce (Picea smithiana), deodar (Cedrus Our study was conducted in the Kalam valley, District deodara) and kail or blue pine (Pinus wallichiana) (Stucki Swat, northern Pakistan (Fig. 1). Swat is a mountainous and Khan, 1999). The broken mountains with steep terrain green valley, which lies between 34°-40° to 35´ N latitude support populations of mountain ungulate species, like and 72°-74° to 60´ E longitude with elevation ranging Kashmir markhor (Capra falconeri cashmiriensis) and between 2000 and 3900 meters above sea level. It is located Himalayan ibex (Capra ibex sibirica). The valley provides approximately 160 km north of Islamabad, the capital city habitat to a variety of wildlife, including musk deer of Pakistan. The total area of Kalam Valley is approximately (Moschus chrysogaster), markhor, and Rhesus monkey 1600 km2. The highest temperature in July is 38°C and (Macaca mulatta) among mammals and phasianids like lowest during January is -4 °C.. Kalam is a spacious sub- monal pheasant (Lophophorus impejanus), Koklass valley of Swat. It is located at a distance of 99 kilometers pheasant (Pucrasia macrolopha), snow cock (Tetraogallus (62 miles) from Mingora in the upper reaches of Swat himalayensis), chukor partridge (Alectoris chukar) , and valley along the River Swat. Kalam is known for its lakes, see see partridge (Ammoperdix griseogularis), and a waterfalls, and lush green hills and is a popular destination variety of small songbirds (Ahmad et al., 2004). Study species Most of the large carnivores in Northern Pakistan do not have a favorable conservation status. Their habitats are being reduced and local people often persecute them. The Himalayan brown bear occurs in small populations in Pakistan and is listed in Appendix 1 of CITES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora). Historically, it occurred in the Western Himalayas, Karakoram, Hindu Kush, Pamir, Western Kulan Shan, and Tian Shan ranges (Nawaz, 2007). The common leopard is the most widely distributed of all the cat species in the world. It is found in every kind of habitat ranging from the rain forests to tropics to deserts and temperate regions. Leopards face several threats to their survival, Online Firstincluding Article direct poaching, diminishing prey base, habitat fragmentation and habitat degradation. It is classified as a vulnerable species in the IUCN Red Data List (IUCN, 2020). It serves as a flagship species in several protected areas of Pakistan. In several protected areas of Pakistan, it occurs throughout the northern mountain ranges (Malik, 1997), with an estimated population of 100-450 in an area of approximately 80,000 km2 making the overall habitat of this species in Pakistan where half of it is considered to be the primary habitat (Malik, 1997). The grey wolf is distributed throughout Pakistan (Roberts, 1997) and is listed as an endangered species in Fig. 1. Map of the study area (Kalam Valley, Swat District, the Red List of Pakistan mammals (Sheikh and Molur, Pakistan). The inlaid map shows the location, habitat type 2005). Globally, it is considered as a least concerned and elevation of the large carnivore signs found in each species (IUCN, 2020). The Eurasian lynx is listed as site of the study area. near threatened (NT 3.1) in the IUCN Red List (Global: 3 Conflicts Involving Brown Bear and other Large Carnivores 3 Category 5b. Regional (Asia): Category 3). livestock, depredation of livestock by large carnivores, sighting of carnivores and perception about brown bear Study design and other large carnivores. The study comprised of two parts i.e. the occurrence We categorized human acceptance of wildlife species of large carnivores in the region and conflicts with humans. into four categories, with four being the highest level of acceptance, and asked about the species’ perceived danger. Occurrence of large carnivores We asked about the livestock owned per household and We conducted a field survey in four areas of Kalam mortality due to disease in the past five years. We also Valley in September–October 2014 to document the inquired about crop damages in the area by the large occurrence of large carnivores. We divided the area carnivores by season (winter, spring, summer and autumn) into four major sites namely Batender, Desan valley, of the previous year/s. In case of sighting of any large Shateer and Jaba. Transects were plotted in randomly carnivores, we further confirmed by asking general and selected feasible landforms where large carnivore signs specific questions about large carnivores’ appearance to were likely to be found, such as ridgelines, cliff bases, avoid bias in the data. Geographical information system river bluffs, saddle, and forest.