Critical and Postcolonial Perspectives on Global Education: the CASE of POLAND

Critical and Postcolonial Perspectives on Global Education: the CASE of POLAND

Article 8 Critical and postcolonial perspectives on global education: THE CASE OF POLAND Magdalena uleta-Hulbo" University of Warsaw eywords: )lo*al education, 'o"tcolonial 'eda+o+,, -oland, "emi#'eri'/eral countr,, colonialit, - )lo*al education i" "/a'ed *, factor" of "u'ranational and local national nature. - )lo*al education need" reconce'tuali"ation to *e more inclusi0e and e.*race di0er"e e1'erience". - E1'lorin+ -oli"/ 2tri'le colonialit,3 /el'" to reco+ni"e t/e li.itation" of 4e"tern a''roac/e". Purpose: 5/i" 'a'er ai." to contri*ute to t/e academic de*ate on 'o"tcolonial 'er"'ective" on +lo*al education 'ro*lemati"in+ t/e conte1t of +lo*al education in -oland, a former Second 4orld countr, t/at doe" not fit to )lo*al Nort/#)lo*al Sout/ dic/oto.,. Approac%: 5/e article e1'lore" +lo*al education in -oland fro. a critical and 'o"t# colonial 'er"'ective. It e1amine" *ot/ "upra-national factor" "/a'in+ +lo*al education no6ada," (li7e mi+ration", co"mo'olitan turn, +ro6in+ ri+/t#6in+ 'o'uli"m, t/e culture of .ea"ure.ent) and "'ecific -oli"/ conte1t a" a countr, not onl, 2in#*et6een3, *ut 6it/ t/e e1'erience of 2tri'le colonialit,3. Findings: I ar+ue t/at ta7in+ into con"ideration t/i" co.'le1it, and multila,eredne"" of t/e -oli"/ "ituation, to+et/er 6it/ more +eneral, not countr,#"'ecific factor", can offer ne6 in"i+/t" and under"tandin+" of +lo*al education in -oland. It i" a nece""ar, "te' to SSE decoloni"e +lo*al education and ma7e it .ore inclusive. J 1 &NTROD(CT&ON Journal of Social Science I 6ill not e1a++erate "a,in+ t/at t/e recent decade /a" *een a time of +ro6in+ Education i.'ortance of +lo*al education 6/ic/ manife"t" in 8NES9O and Euro'ean 8nion 'olic, Vol. 19, No. 4 (2020) DOI 10.4119/!""e-3467 document" (A+enda 20$0, Su"taina*le Develo'ment )oal 4.&, DEA: 6it/in Euro'eAid), ''. 8-22 ado'tin+ national "trate+ie" of +lo*al education in "u*"e;uent countrie" or increa"in+ Corresponding author: =a+dalena >uleta#?ul*o!, @aculty of Education, 8ni0er"it, of War"a6, =o7oto6"7a 16/20, 00-561 War"a6, -oland, E#=ail: ..kuleta#/ul*o!Bu6.edu.'l 9ritical and 'o"tcolonial per"pective" 9 academic intere"t in +lo*al citiCen"/i' and +lo*al citiCen"/i' education ()oren D Eemini, 201&). Alon+ 6it/ t/e"e de0elo'.ent" and t/e 6ider 're"ence of +lo*al education, t/ere i" more and more critici"m, e"'eciall, t/i" informed *, critical and 'o"tcolonial t/eorie", of main"tream +lo*al education under"tandin+" for di"re+ardin+ local conte1t and i+norin+ t/e demand" of +lo*al education /etero+eneit,. Se0eral "c/olar" /ave 6arned us a*out t/e ri"7" and con"e;uence" of "tandardi"ation and /omo+eni"ation of +lo*al education (A*di, 2011F =annion, Bie"ta, -rie"tle,, D :o"", 2011F :e,nold", 201A). ?o6e0er, t/e"e critical voice" tend to focus on ne+lectin+ t/e 'er"'ective" of t/e )lo*al Sout/. )lo*al Nort/#)lo*al Sout/ dic/oto., /a" mono'oli"ed t/e attention of mo"t +lo*al education literature, o0erloo7in+ t/e co.'le1 and uno*viou" 'o"ition of 6/at used to *e called t/e Second 4orld (t/e former Soviet *loc< t/e Soviet 8nion and it" "atellite"). 5/i" 'a'er contri*ute" to t/e academic de*ate on 'o"tcolonial 'er"'ective" on +lo*al education 'ro*lemati"in+ t/e conte1t of +lo*al education in -oland – a countr, difficult to count a" t/e )lo*al Sout/ or t/e )lo*al Nort/. 5/e idea" of learnin+ for 6orld citiCen"/i' and +lo*al dimen"ion in education a''eared in -oli"/ 'eda+o+ical literature a" earl, a" at t/e *e+innin+ of t/e t6entiet/ centur, 6/en t/e -oli"/ educationali"t" related to t/e Ne6 Education =o0ement loo7ed at t/e 6a," to include to'ic" of international under"tandin+ and 6orld 'eace in education. S/ortl, after t/e Second 4orld 4ar, -oli"/ educational re"earc/er Go+dan Suc/odol"7i called for educatin+ citiCen" to *e re"'on"i*le *ot/ for t/e -oli"/ "tate and t/e +lo*ali"in+ 6orld and cultivatin+ a "en"e of 6orld communit, (Suc/odol"7i, 194&). ?o6e0er, e1ce't for "/a. 9ommuni"t internationali". i.'o"ed on 9entral and Ea"tern Euro'ean countrie", +lo*al education did not develo' in -oland neit/er t/eoreticall, nor 'racticall, until t/e 1990", 6/en it 6a" i.'orted fro. 4e"tern Euro'ean countrie" *, -oli"/ non#+o0ernmental or+ani"ation" (more in >uleta#?ul*o!, 2020). In t/i" 'a'er I e1'lore +lo*al education in -oland "een t/rou+/ a critical and 'o"tcolonial len", 'a,in+ attention to *roader "ocio-cultural condition" "/a'in+ +lo*al education no6ada," and fac# tor" "'ecific to t/e conte1t of -oland a" a countr, dou*le Iin#*et6eenI, 6it/ a uni;ue e1'erience of Itri'le colonialit,3. Dra6in+ on t/e 6or7" of "c/olar" 6/o e1'lored t/e 'o""i*ilit, of a''lication of 'o"tcolonial t/eorie" to t/e -oli"/ condition (=a,*lin, -ie7ut, D Valentine, 201%F Jar,c7i, 2010F 201&), I ar+ue t/at ta7in+ into account t/i" co.'le1it, and multila,eredne"" of -oli"/ conte1t, to+et/er 6it/ more +eneral, not countr,#"'ecific factor", can offer ne6 in"i+/t" and under"tandin+" of +lo*al education in -oland, it" develo'ment", condition, and c/allen+e"F and it i" a nece""ar, "te' to ma7e +lo*al education more inclusive. ?o6e0er, it "/ould *e "tated at t/e ver, *e+innin+ t/at t/in7in+ -oland 'o"tcoloniall, ma, lead to a tra' and 'arado1e"< a" No6ic7a-FrancCa7 (201&) 6arn" us, conclu"ion" de'end on t/e re"earc/erK" initial 'er"'ective and 'oint of de'arture. Gein+ a6are of t/i", I focus on t/e i.'lication" of 'o"tcolonial readin+ for +lo*al education. Fir"t, I *riefl, di"cus" more +eneral '/eno.ena and 'roce""e" t/at /a0e i.'lication" for /o6 +lo*al education i" conce'tuali"ed and a''roac/ed. 5/e"e include a co"mo'olitan turn in t/e "ocial "cience", mi+ration", radicali"ation of attitude", increa"e in 1eno'/o*ia and "ecuriti"ation di"cour"eF recent '/enomena affectin+ education in t/e 6orld H t/e culture of accounta*ilit, and mea"urement a" 6ell a" "trivin+ for evidence#*a"ed education. I al"o outline t/eir con"e;uence" for +lo*al education. Second, I e1amine t/e -oli"/ conte1t of +lo*al education, focusin+ on -olandL" 'er"'ective a" a "emi#'eri'/eral countr, (a" a former aid reci'ient and no6 Official De0elo'.ent A""i"tance do# nor, a countr, 6it/out a colonial le+ac, 6/ic/ it"elf /a" an e1'erience of totalitarian o''re""ion) (Starna6"7i, 201A) and it" co.'le1 e1'erience of 2tri'le colonialit,3. 5o+et/er 6it/ a -oli"/ 'aternali"m and e1'an"ioni". to6ard" Ea"tern nei+/*our" datin+ *ac7 to t/e 1%th centur,, recent 'olitical c/an+e" related to t/e rule of La6 and Justice con"ervative turn and ri+/t#6in+ 'o'u- li"m, it create" "i+nificant c/allen+e" for +lo*al education. 9ritical and 'o"tcolonial per"pective" 10 5/ird, I outline "ome recommendation" for +lo*al education t/at ma, /el' it face t/e"e c/allen+e". I call for "uc/ a conce'tuali"ation of +lo*al education t/at 6ould e.*race di0er"e e1'erience" and local conte1t" and 6ould decoloni"e it. ) S(PRANAT&ONAL FACTORS &NFL(ENC&N* *LO+AL ED(CAT&ON NO,ADA-S 5/e "/a'e, "co'e, and content of +lo*al education H li7e an, ot/er education H /ave *een t/e "ub!ect of a variet, of determinant" and influence" (economic, "ocial, cultural, demo+ra'/ic, en# vironmental, etc.). One of t/e., ver, conduci0e to t/e develo'ment of +lo*al education, i" t/e co"mo'olitan turn in t/e "ocial "cience" (Strand, 2010). G, co"mo'olitan turn I mean t/e +ro6in+ intere"t in co"mo'olitani". and +lo*al citiCen"/i'F a 6idel, ac7no6led+ed vi"ion of mu- tual interde'endence on a +lo*al "caleF ri"in+ number" of t/e t/eorie" of +lo*al citiCen"/i' and co"mo'olitan democrac,. It i" related to emer+in+ call" for co".o'olitan vi"ion, e.+. 8lric/ Gec7 (Bec7 D )rande, 2010) called for a co"mo'olitan turn in "ociolo+,, "imilarl,, )erard Delant, (200() advocated a critical co"mo'olitani"m a" an alternative for nationali"m and +lo*ali"ation. 5/e co".o'olitan turn manife"t" in t/e 'o'ularit, of +lo*al education in man, countrie", it" /i+/ 'rofile 6it/in Euro'ean education 'olicie", it" 're"ence in t/e 8nited Nation" A+enda 20$0 and Sustaina*le Develo'ment )oal".

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    17 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us