97%of AIM-insured AttorneysRenew Their Malpractice InsuranceWith AIM A:PLJC,.LJTION APPLICATION ~t,~t.~t,O( . ... ' ..·, . ' .. ··,· They know the importance of insuring with a company that is here to stay and the danger of being left without coverage by other insurers who may not be committed to serving Alabama attorneys. All malpractice insurance companies are NOT the same: AIM: For the Difference (We're here to stay!) ''.AMutual Insurance Company Organized by and for Alabama Attorneys" Attorneys Insurance Mutual of Alabama , Inc.* 22 Inverness Center Parkway Te lephone (205) 980-0009 Suite 340 To ll Free (800) 526 - 1246 Birming h am. A labama 3524 2- 4820 FAX(205)980 - 9009 '*C H A RTER M EMBER : NATIONAL ASSO C IAT ION OF BAR - RELATED INSURANCE C OMPANIES TnJ ~[r@ITDiJD@(?@~ er@@OlJ@U@ g@er @ .Fo1 SOLID b\O@@®uuu®~(r@@Uo@@ Automobile Insurance Law by Davenport e>1989 Criminal Off enses & Defenses in Alabama by Ch,arkas. Ch,arkas. & Ve,gas "'1982 Criminal Trial Practice 2nd Ed. by Ch,arkas "'1988 Criminal Trial Practice Forms 2nd Ed. by Ch1arkasC>1988 Divorce. Alimony & Child Custody w I Forms 2nd Ed. by Mccur ley & Davis c,1988 Evidence by Schroeder. Hoffman & Thigpen e1987 Equity 2nd Ed. T,lley·s by Hansford ©1985 Law of Dam ages 2nd Ed. by Gamble ~1988 Limitations of Actions & Notice Provi sions by Hoff c,1984 REVISED/ Workmen's Compensation w/Fo rm s 2nd Ed. by Hood. Hardy & Saad© 1990 EXPANDED/ • Including Current Supplement , if applicable • BONUS OFFER Buy any 2 o f l he above titles and receive 7 % OFF the TOTAL RETAIL PRICE . or any 3 - 9 % OFF. or any 4- 12 % OFF. or any 5- 15 % OFF. or any 6 - 20 % OFF THEM HARRISONCOMPANY , PUBLISHERS 3110 C,os.s,n.gP11 k •P O 8o .. 7S00 • NOt'-fOlal. GA 30091 •7S00 90-K9 THEALABAMA LAWYER May 1991/ 113 IN BRIEF MAY1991 Volume52, Number 3 Pubbhld NYen ttrnN • .,ear (the sawnin mue• • ON THE COVER: Spring heralds new growthas epitomizedby daisiesand other bof diredo,y oc>lian) by The,._,,,. Sme 8¥ . P.O. Box415e, Mon,-,y. Alabom,36101. wildflowersin a rield in MontgomeryCounty. Pi,01ob/lJ.1~c ... ,,.,,., /,/o,J/pO""'ll Phone (205)261f.1515. FAX {205) 269•1501. RabonA. Hu- ..............- .... ..-............ .... .Edi10< INSIDE THIS ISSUE: SUsanShlroc:k o.PIOla .AtlOdawEdtot Alternati ve Dispute Resoluti on: An Intr oduction Malgarel I.Mpny ~ - Bg Jack Clarke........................................ _ ...................... ............................................126 8C*d ol Edlklri Cnticshlr.'t fr<qumtlychargtd lhat tml pfOCffllings.,..unduly cxP<ruM •nd ume-<on,uming.It" um• Q~ tl Hnti., . BiMllinV"M' • w Ge_w'fw... L.a1*I • Ktlll\ B. Norman, Monlgomrt!Y • John I CoillfflM.JI , Binn• (or lht bar to coruidtr .1ltemativemethods (or disputt.rtsolulion. ll'ICINffl• Hon , HUQhMldclox , Motllgonlef')' • Cnl H S'lowan. Bltt!W',Q!\llm• t..Mh Melt!~• . Simlngti.m • ciw.111Thotllea. TI.IKalooM• Crtlg G Cornwell,.MontQOmlf)' • f0tr1M Llt:a,. Mediation in Alabama M:ol:lit. • And,ew f camPoelt. B1tm1not1,.m , w Sc .. ,. Bv Keith Watkinsand J. Noah Punderburg............................................................... .133 8ima.. Jf_,..,.,..Oty . ~ R. Mila.lllin•P.,. • Mc:hMIIL "°°""1:1..OMtd9ft • CIII KIMI. Mc>IIJPNJ • Mediationmay PfOYld• • spttdy , leu cottly methodol di>puteraolution. WW.. C. a.., t C •t • Wlliarn J ~ Te Qll!ltM:I. • ~If L LuMr Uioolt • Mp L ~ Jf., Tbe Mini-trial and Summary Juzy Trial Mon!gomer, • LeonerCIA M.lndn1, Hwntt Y1lie • At,n T. ~. """"'Cl"lm • J.I . S.,,,,,. J<•• - • .__ o. Bg Robert1¥. Bradford, Jr. .......................................................................................... 150 T•rSOt,Pt1av111 , H Wl!Uamw~. ~e,y In cample,tclvll wt:s , lltJga.ntshavt foundthat a mini-trialmay serve a5 the g.,Jvanh.lngforce to promptI Board OCBar Comml•,1on1,.. 1.1,1,on__ ,_,_,,. ....... ,... - ..w ,......,~ F-,.nt: settlement. .......~AbiD0&.1_,, ... ~ --- - Nonpartisa n Jud icial Elections and the State Bar _______ Jc,lnA.0..-., ~ \ice O f 4 Bg DavidA Bagwel/........................................................... ..........................................156 RligNld T ...... Wo.z;.c:zwa1 .s.r...y The wudomof p&rllWI d<dlon o/ ,udlci>Iol!iCUl continua to d'11wdebo.le. The Alahlml SL\t<Bar now lloirdol Comml..... hu adopted• ruolutlon •dvc)QtingnonpArtlilln tlccUon of Judge,. Ill c.toJII. EdtrttrdP T\lt!W , Jr... Cha.om• 2nd Clrwl. "'-"'1 L Ttwlff'WI,Hl:)'ntVlllo • "" Ci'Q.lit.l.,ynn AocM111oon JacbOft. Cltyton • 411'1Clteue. Aldit T. Aeevff. Jt, Se1tN• ~ CRuil, Governor Proclaims Law Day U.S.A. in Alabama .....................................176 John F. DIiion, IV, Mt;.aroar Clly • fCI\ Craiil, ,._ No. 1, Wlht" P Cfowncw.t , T\IIC:IIIOOA• 61r1CtQlil, PIIClt No. to JoM A. 0-.... ~ • 7'I C¥Q1IC.N1V F F"M... » Mleon • ttit ClrCIIII.A.J. COltftW\, O.C.C¥t • ""- Qcur&,_ President'sPage ........................... ......116 MCLENews ........................................ 145 Wllilm 0. s:nc.,.Jt . fo,t ~ • 1CW\QoA. "'°'No. ,. ~K. ...... ........ , . 1oti0ftul. ..... Ho 2. ExecutiveDirector's Report ............... 118 DisciplinaryReport .... ..........................152 ~Le-,.,._ ~ • 10fl OrclillC.~ No, S, .la"""$, Lloyd, BltmillOt,,m • 10th ClrQllfl. PIIOI No c, LegislativeWrap-Up .................. .........120 Profile............................................ .....154 $amuel A. Rumott, ,if., Bim*lgtla,n • Ioctl Cltt:ul P$loe No. Bar Briefs...................... ......................122 Young Lawyers'Section ....... ..............160 $, TitnOttlyL. OillatCI,Blfmln;tiam • 10th Cl~, Ptlce No, 6, ome L 81,in. Jr., 0-mlnghMl'I• 1Olh Ciro.l!L~ No 7, J , AboutMembers, Among Firms .........124 BuildingAlabama's Courthouses .. ....162 MMOt1O.V., ~ • lOII\Cl!M Pltoe No, I, Drlyt0t, N, .limes. Bii'r~ • 1Olh CilcuC, Piao. No ~ C:-,. S. Memorials..................... ......................140 BuildingFund Honor Roll....... .......... 164 - ... _..,_ ..... -.. - 0...00,-., ............ ~ • 110, Crcuil. fllibet'I M, M1l k .. Opinionsof the CeneralCounsel ...... 142 RecentDecisions ....................... .........168 ~. ,m Q,oA, .- c. CaAewlr"~ • tll.'ft ~ 9'IKII ,- 1, w:iot' H. I.OIi.JI .., MoOlt • 131t e.cut. Cl.£ Opportunities...... .......................144 ClassifiedNotices .............................. .174 ~ No. 2. nroo,o HolfflN..M::lbilt • ,,in C1ro;i1t.Pieo. No. l, Lin')' u. Sim,,Mobllt • 13P. C~ult, l"!.c. Ho.•. e.,,pm,n T. Aowt, Mot>llt • 1411'1Clrcull . Jtfty K.Setman. Jupec, • 1511'1Cl 1c.111, Plact, No, t, R!Cfiaitd H QIU, Mont• OOffl'l"Y• 151hClrcull. Plocit Ho-2. Chlrlft M C,ooti., Mont• ALABAMA STATE BAR HEADQUARTERSSTAFF gornecy, !&It!~ P1.ee Ho..3 • ..._,.. fl SN1e, Mont· 415 Dexter Avenue. Montgomery, AL 36104 (205) 269-1515 gorn.,y. 1.$4hCir*- PIia No. ~ H..E.k,.,.; • '"' Cima. oec,i:,e: p Font. 4-oln. '"' OWo.all.Aic:lwG s .,....,.. e-..o.- Reglnll<IT.-CAE MCl.f&CommllleeSecrm.vy o-,new-. Dl!ftloolll • '"' Clralll, Cof'lradM.. F"OMII,.,, . Col;: .... 0naoro1~ ____ __ a_ RNrw:1115ec:re1ary.___ - -- lllJ'I ~ J. "°°-'I Fall,. Praldll • 20ft ~ AUlul R e..-"'*""' _ ....._ -Margo,., Boone UW)'ot Relenal Secte'"1y •• .Joy ~Ing« &ft*'- Jf.. ~ • :lt• Ora.JC.~ E. Har\.~ .• !Nwlon . PvblrcauontOlrte1or _,_ , ............... - .Matgare1tdurphy GraphicAtta Supervisor,_, ___ ....... Maggi& Stulllf PIIICeNo . 1, Glotilf W, Roye,, Jt_ Hl#I._. • Cd CifOA. AdmlS5ionsSOclolory .. ...................Normo J Robbins IOI.TAOI,...., ........._ ••, .......................... TracyDani .. ....."'4.ot No. 2. S. Oai,i.l Rowo,Hu n16V!llt• t •th 0111:ulLW , ~-·-·~-·-­\II~ Hatnil, Momoo™'1pSotvlco1 ...... ..................Al,oo Jo Hendrix Recep<lonlst .................- ...............Evelyn M tCuCloch AllenGroc:t\Ollkl. F.,..ei• • 2$th CIN;Ut.._ IIOI\ Ion • aethCirw!, . ltow•n H. Brautll , Ptltnl• Cfly • 211t! ALABAMA STATE BAR CENTER FOR PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY CitQIIJL T.J, CwnN , Altltnville • 2llh CltCWilt,.Jol\n &ri. 1019 Sou1h Perry Street Mootgome,y. Al 36104 (2051269-1515 30mc,,-.a.,----... c«:ui1. W•YJ"M G Shenef ,...... OneCM'lla.-.• JIit -· Cl,Qlil. Gtneralc.u,-, _ _-.w Homo ~ • 33111Cirwc. Wi11am8. ~ OIA • '4th --Counoel---···---..........----·- ...............-- ..J Anlhony Mcl.ain C.-a.lC.Jeffy C. POICII.AutMlvAI • 3Sltl c-o.;lt. WillWII D. Assls1ontGtno-.1 Counoel---·-·-- ............____ . __ ....., ............-····----- .............L GilbenKendrick -ll--·----­M•IU,n, Evttgre•n • 36111Citcull, Rodtotk M Al•.Llf'det, Amiant Gef\Gral Counsel ..................................................................... ............................................ ... M,lton L MOit MtMJllOn• 371h Clte1111,J, Tu11BatrMt, ~ • ~lh Ci,cult Adminls118tlvoSta.tf .. ..............................................Vivian Freeman. Che,yt Rankin.Bonnlo Mo tnot. Vidd Glawott, Slec,hetlM t<tMlmtf , Scotliboto • 39th Clrd+ W'.ri1tonV , ~.Jr ., AINM • 401hC!tCl.it Roblrt J, T.il, Rocldo,d. h ~ ~ ~ ~7). IN olftOtl putiicataond lt'e AIAOlrNSallt e.. 11putlWIIIICI N'V9t! llnlef .t l'Nf ~ .. 1M NIIOMti9 U.,..,• ~ Mwe"I IIIMt I ~ tor$t.5 l'IIOl'ftl ot ~ . ,__, (at bar ditwclDty ......,,_ M.ardl.W.,. ./1,#f, """"'°"·w NowfllNf: V... wl ..o. I ; • • c,w .,_." IN UMllt ~ #Id S20 1* ,-, OliltliOeCl1lt ~in ..... ~- IICM of l')t ........ MCWa19Jra,e ti N 00.0 OC..,,._09oW'9flltlowd ofw:ac I I UMlo S-... 0,, "8 ~ Sta S.. •t$ 0.... Al'W'Uf. OI .. ~a.lat. Sc -z5 ......,.. S.. Bl,....._...._nw AIIDil,M i..,,..• 11W1OI ._ ~..,. ...... ,. ........ ,°'SnO't ........ S;S...... b • ~$15ofNlfl*...-dStt .,clew••n.~~ .cw- doftlCII,..,...,.~...,­dlli!l pouot. IOI 1M jw'Nl1 WIG $1$ to,