Most Requested Songs Back These lists are dynamically compiled based on online requests made over the past year at thousands of events around the world, where #1 is the most requested song. Select a List: Cake Cutting List Results Artist Song Add to List 1 Maroon 5 Sugar 2 James Taylor How Sweet It Is (To Be Loved By You... 3 Archies Sugar, Sugar 4 DNCE Cake By The Ocean 5 Def Leppard Pour Some Sugar On Me 6 Natalie Cole This Will Be (An Everlasting Love) 7 Four Tops I Can't Help Myself (Sugar Pie, Hon... 8 Flo Rida & 99 Percent Cake 9 Old Dominion Make It Sweet 10 Bruno Mars Marry You 11 Jack Johnson Better Together 12 Beyonce Love On Top 13 Blake Shelton Honey Bee 14 Daryl Hall & John Oates You Make My Dreams Come True 15 Rihanna Feat. Chris Brown Birthday Cake 16 Nat King Cole L-O-V-E 17 Dan + Shay Speechless 18 Ray Lamontagne You Are The Best Thing 19 Ed Sheeran Perfect 20 Jason Mraz & Colbie Caillat Lucky 21 Michael Buble Everything 22 Queen You're My Best Friend 23 Stevie Wonder Signed, Sealed, Delivered I'm Yours 24 Foundations Build Me Up Buttercup 25 Frank Sinatra The Way You Look Tonight 26 Cake Love You Madly 27 Ed Sheeran Thinking Out Loud 28 Michael Buble How Sweet It Is 29 Average White Band Cut The Cake 30 Frank Sinatra Love And Marriage 31 Pat Benatar Hit Me With Your Best Shot 32 Dean Martin That's Amore 33 John Legend All Of Me 34 U2 Sweetest Thing 35 Zac Brown Band Loving You Easy 36 50 Cent Candy Shop 37 American Authors Best Day Of My Life Artist Song Add to List 38 Elvis Presley Can't Help Falling In Love 39 Etta James At Last 40 Sugarland Stuck Like Glue 41 Taylor Swift Lover 42 Christina Perri A Thousand Years 43 Harry Styles Watermelon Sugar 44 James Arthur Say You Won't Let Go 45 Lanco Greatest Love Story 46 Sixpence None The Richer Kiss Me 47 Taylor Swift Today Was A Fairytale 48 Jason Mraz I'm Yours 49 Lifehouse You And Me 50 Lonestar Amazed Back Copyright © 1998-2021.