Overview of Prisoners' Rights

Overview of Prisoners' Rights

Overview of Prisoners’ Rights John Boston Prisoners’ Rights Project New York City Legal Aid Society 199 Water Street, 6 th floor New York, N.Y. 10038 November 15, 2013 Prepared for Second Circuit Staff Attorneys’ Training Copyright 2013 by John Boston. Corrections and comments may be addressed to [email protected]. Table of Contents Introduction..................................................................................................................................... 1 I. Conditions of Confinement..................................................................................................... 1 A. The subjective element ....................................................................................................... 1 1. Conditions of confinement cases: deliberate indifference.............................................. 1 2. Use of force cases: malicious and sadistic treatment...................................................... 5 3. Calculated harassment unrelated to prison needs ........................................................... 6 B. The objective element: “sufficiently serious”..................................................................... 6 C. Recurring issues in medical care cases............................................................................. 10 1. Deliberate indifference.................................................................................................. 11 2. Deliberate indifference and negligence ........................................................................ 20 3. Serious medical needs................................................................................................... 21 4. Mental health care......................................................................................................... 23 5. Dental care .................................................................................................................... 28 D. Recurring issues in use of force cases............................................................................... 29 1. Intent requirement......................................................................................................... 29 2. Amount of force and justification................................................................................. 31 3. Bystander, supervisory, and entity liability .................................................................. 33 4. Sexual abuse.................................................................................................................. 34 E. Other conditions of confinement issues............................................................................ 35 1. Shelter ........................................................................................................................... 35 2. Crowding....................................................................................................................... 35 3. Food .............................................................................................................................. 36 4. Clothing......................................................................................................................... 37 5. Safety ............................................................................................................................ 37 6. Temperature and ventilation ......................................................................................... 40 7. Exercise......................................................................................................................... 40 8. Sanitation and personal hygiene ................................................................................... 41 9. Sleep.............................................................................................................................. 42 10. Noise......................................................................................................................... 42 11. Lighting..................................................................................................................... 43 12. Programs, activities, and idleness............................................................................. 43 13. Disability rights......................................................................................................... 44 i II. Prisoners’ Civil Liberties...................................................................................................... 49 A. The reasonable relationship standard................................................................................ 49 B. Scope of the standard........................................................................................................ 54 C. Application of the standard............................................................................................... 55 D. Particular civil liberties issues .......................................................................................... 62 1. Correspondence............................................................................................................. 62 2. Reading ......................................................................................................................... 63 3. Complaining.................................................................................................................. 67 4. Communication with the media.................................................................................... 70 5. Visiting.......................................................................................................................... 71 6. Telephones.................................................................................................................... 71 7. Voting ........................................................................................................................... 72 8. Religious exercise......................................................................................................... 73 a. Worship and ceremony ............................................................................................. 79 b. Dress and appearance................................................................................................ 81 c. Diet............................................................................................................................ 82 d. Names ....................................................................................................................... 83 9. Establishment of religion.............................................................................................. 83 10. Searches and privacy................................................................................................. 84 III. Procedural Due Process .................................................................................................... 93 A. Liberty in prison: Sandin v. Conner .................................................................................. 93 B. When prison discipline requires due process.................................................................... 96 C. Sandin and pre-trial detainees......................................................................................... 100 D. Sanctions involving the fact or duration of imprisonment: good time, parole, temporary release ..................................................................................................................................... 102 E. Prison discipline and habeas exhaustion......................................................................... 107 F. The process due............................................................................................................... 110 1. Disciplinary proceedings ............................................................................................ 111 a. Notice...................................................................................................................... 111 b. Hearings: the right to hear and to be heard............................................................. 112 c. Witnesses ................................................................................................................ 113 d. Confrontation and cross-examination..................................................................... 115 e. Documentary and physical evidence ...................................................................... 115 f. Assistance with a defense ....................................................................................... 117 ii g. Impartial decision-maker ........................................................................................ 118 h. Standards of proof and evidence............................................................................. 119 i. Urinalysis, polygraphy, and other scientific tests ................................................... 124 j. Written disposition.................................................................................................. 125 k. Confidential informants .......................................................................................... 126 l. False charges........................................................................................................... 129 m. Discipline and mental health............................................................................... 129 n. Punishment.............................................................................................................

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    177 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us