LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEENSHIRE VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE Hearing on 10th September 2014 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 3, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 1 15962/50212 HOTEL MOUSTAFFA NASSER P 26,500 A 26,500 HUNTLY HOTEL 5,000 R 5,000 18 THE SQUARE 21,500 N 21,500 HUNTLY D M HALL A 2 85332/50034 WASTE WATER TREATMENT WORKS SCOTTISH WATER P 3,000 3,000 GARTLY HEAD OFFICE HUNTLY PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A 3 16361/50055 SALMON FISHINGS ANDREW HIGGINS P 2,300 S 0 UPPER CASTLE 0 0 HUNTLY RIVER DEVERON 4 16363/50056 SALMON FISHINGS ANDREW HIGGINS P 1,200 S 0 LOWER CASTLE 0 0 HUNTLY RIVER DEVERON 5 81368/50058 STORES ETC SPARROWS OFFSHORE SERVICES LTD T 106,000 106,000 MIDDLEMUIR FARM FAO FACILITIES MANAGER WHITECAIRNS ABERDEEN J & E SHEPHERD A 6 81159/50231 WASTE RECYCLING CENTRE TAYLORS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LTD P 192,000 192,000 EASTER HATTON BALMEDIE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 7 85333/50035 SEPTIC TANK SCOTTISH WATER P 160 160 CORSEHILL VIEW HEAD OFFICE PARKHILL PROPERTY SERVICES DYCE GERALD EVE LLP A 8 85628/50243 WORKSHOP ETC ARCHER (UK) LIMITED T 258,000 258,000 BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE (WEST) KINELLAR ABERDEEN WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A 9 85628/50244 WORKSHOP ETC ARCHER (UK) LIMITED T 595,000 595,000 BLACKBURN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE (WEST) KINELLAR ABERDEEN WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A 10 17755/49940 WORKSHOP ETC SCHLUMBERGER OILFIELD UK PLC P 505,000 505,000 WESTHILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ENTERPRISE DRIVE F G BURNETT LTD A 11 85651/50061 OFFICE PROSERV T 408,000 408,000 PROSERV HOUSE PROSPECT PARK PROSPECT ROAD J & E SHEPHERD A ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK 12 56083/50062 SUPERSTORE TESCO STORES LTD P 875,000 875,000 TESCO ENDEAVOUR DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK G L HEARN A 13 85619/50052 OFFICE JEE LTD T 80,000 80,000 31 ABERCROMBIE COURT PROSPECT ROAD ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED A 02/10/2015 Page 1 of 4 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 14 80673/49932 OFFICE AMEC GROUP LTD T 218,000 218,000 PAVILION 3 WEST POINT PROSPECT ROAD ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK GVA JAMES BARR A 15 17930/49971 FOOTBALL GROUND INVERURIE LOCO WORKS FOOTBALL CLUB P 14,500 14,500 HARLAW DRIVE INVERURIE RYDEN LLP A 16 85690/50064 SHOP INSPIRE FLOORING LTD P 19,000 19,000 24 HIGH STREET INVERURIE 17 85518/50021 STORES SMART STORAGE SOLUTIONS LTD T 158,000 158,000 UNITS 5 & 12 KIRKWOOD COMMERCIAL PARK THAINSTONE D M HALL A 18 85575/50050 WORKSHOPS ETC SCOTVALVES SERVICES LTD T 210,000 210,000 SITE F PER PETROFAC FACILITIES TOFTHILLS AVENUE MANAGEMENT LTD MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE F G BURNETT LTD A 19 85575/50097 WORKSHOPS ETC SCOTVALVES SERVICES LTD T 296,000 296,000 SITE F PER PETROFAC FACILITIES TOFTHILLS AVENUE MANAGEMENT LTD MIDMILL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE F G BURNETT LTD A 20 18431/50059 HALL WILLIAM HOWARD & JACQUELINE HOWARD P 1,050 1,050 MELDRUM & BOURTIE CHURCH BOURTIE INVERURIE 21 18681/49955 HOTEL MELDRUM ARMS LTD T 38,750 A 38,750 MELDRUM ARMS HOTEL 750 R 750 SOUTH ROAD 38,000 N 38,000 OLDMELDRUM 22 52720/50220 SHOP ETC KELLOCKBANK COUNTRY EMPORIUM T 60,500 60,500 KELLOCKBANK INSCH RYDEN LLP A 23 18802/50236 HOTEL G & G PARTNERS P 29,900 29,900 COMMERCIAL HOTEL 17 COMMERCE STREET INSCH 24 42373/49928 CAR PARK THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 28,000 28,000 BALMACASSIE PARK & RIDE PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES ELLON 25 85453/50026 SHOWHOUSE B D W EAST SCOTLAND LTD P 17,250 17,250 CASTLEWELL T/A BARRATT EAST SCOTLAND ELLON RYDEN LLP A 26 85348/49962 SHOWHOUSE DANDARA LTD P 19,000 19,000 10 BAIN'S PARK TARVES GVA JAMES BARR A 27 19639/50211 HOTEL WHITECAIRN ESTATES LTD P 10,750 10,750 ABERDEEN ARMS HOTEL 10 THE SQUARE TARVES 02/10/2015 Page 2 of 4 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 28 85529/50027 SHOWHOUSE CLAYMORE HOMES LTD P 17,750 17,750 15 FLEEMAN PARK UDNY GREEN RYDEN LLP A 29 85334/50036 WASTE WATER TREATMENT WORKS SCOTTISH WATER P 475 475 COULL HEAD OFFICE ABOYNE PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A 30 85337/50045 WASTE WATER TREATMENT WORKS SCOTTISH WATER P 7,000 7,000 INCHMARLO HEAD OFFICE BANCHORY PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A 31 20839/49976 REFUSE TIP THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL P 127,000 127,000 CROWSNEST PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES BANCHORY ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL A 32 34809/50018 GOLF COURSE INCHMARLO LAND COMPANY LTD P 55,000 55,000 INCHMARLO GOLF CENTRE INCHMARLO BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A 33 85313/49977 DISTRICT HEATING FACILITY HOBESCO LTD T 250,000 250,000 HILL OF BANCHORY BIOMASS ENERGY CENTRE BANCHORY BUSINESS PARK BURN O'BENNIE ROAD F G BURNETT LTD A 34 82716/49942 YARD LOXLEY ABERDEEN LTD P 61,000 61,000 BADENTOY CRESCENT PER PETERKINS PORTLETHEN RYDEN LLP A 35 21197/49978 WORKSHOP ETC VOLVO GROUP UK LTD P 108,000 108,000 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE PORTLETHEN GVA JAMES BARR A 36 21197/50089 WORKSHOP ETC VOLVO GROUP UK LTD P 121,000 121,000 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BARCLAYHILL PLACE PORTLETHEN GVA JAMES BARR A 37 85335/50037 WASTE WATER TREATMENT WORKS SCOTTISH WATER P 1,700 1,700 MARYCULTER HEAD OFFICE ABERDEEN PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A 38 85298/49980 WIND FARM M C POWER LTD T 296,000 296,000 MEIKLE CAREWE NETHERLEY STONEHAVEN GERALD EVE LLP A 39 83121/49905 WIND FARM TULLO WIND FARM LTD T 440,000 440,000 TULLO WIND FARM LTD C/O ENECO WIND UK LTD TULLO FARM LAURENCEKIRK MATHESON A 40 85338/50038 SEPTIC TANK SCOTTISH WATER P 140 140 MILL O FOREST HEAD OFFICE MILL OF FOREST ROAD PROPERTY SERVICES STONEHAVEN GERALD EVE LLP A 41 22541/49943 SHOP GREGGS BAKERS T 14,750 14,750 31 MARKET SQUARE STONEHAVEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 02/10/2015 Page 3 of 4 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 42 22583/50012 CARAVANS THE CARAVAN CLUB O 19,500 19,500 QUEEN ELIZABETH SITE PER TONY BARNETT HEAD OF ESTATES BEACH STONEHAVEN CHARLES F JONES & SON A 43 22725/49944 SHOP FOUNTAINHALL WINES LTD T 16,750 16,750 6 MARKET SQUARE STONEHAVEN RYDEN LLP A 02/10/2015 Page 4 of 4 .