Innerspring Mattresses RATINGS For the latest ratings and information, visit 121 Rated Models 1 2 3 4 5 (as of June 2021) WORSE BETTER OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 5/5 Avocado Green 2, 5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 85 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 5/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 5/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Casper Original Hybrid (2020) PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 5/5 ! Recommended 81 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 5/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 5/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - SleepFresh Hybrid PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 81 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Ethan Allen EA Signature Platinum Plush 1, 2 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 5/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 81 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 5/5 Charles P. Rogers Powercore Estate 5000 2 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 80 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 5/5 Avocado Green Mattress Pillowtop 2, 5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 79 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Response Performance PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Briar Rose 11.5" Cushion Firm AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 78 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Casper Wave Hybrid PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 78 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Beautyrest BR-800 12" Medium Firm PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 $ Best Buy AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 77 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Consumer Reports | CR.org INNERSPRING MATTRESSES | RATINGS | PAGE 2 1 2 3 4 5 121 Rated Models WORSE BETTER (as of June 2021) OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 5/5 Charles P. Rogers Real Bed 2 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 77 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - Big Fig The Mattress for a Bigger Figure PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 77 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Tuft & Needle Nod Hybrid PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 7 MAT-NODH-01-Q AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 $ 76 Best Buy LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Kingsdown Select Malbec 14.5" Plush PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 76 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Hotel Collection by Aireloom PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 1, 7 Coppertech 12" Firm Tight top AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 ! Recommended 76 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 5/5 Charles P. Rogers St. Regis Pillowtop PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 76 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Posturepedic Performance Copper II 7 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 76 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Beautyrest Silver BRS900-TSS PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 7 Medium Firm Tight Top AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 $ Best Buy 75 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Leesa Legend PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 75 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Posturepedic Premium Silver Chill 7 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 75 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Consumer Reports | CR.org INNERSPRING MATTRESSES | RATINGS | PAGE 3 1 2 3 4 5 121 Rated Models WORSE BETTER (as of June 2021) OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Beautyrest PressureSmart 11.5" Firm PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 $ Best Buy 75 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Posturepedic Lawson LTD PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 1 Cushion Firm AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 $ 75 Best Buy LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 King Koil Luxury Almond 13" Plush PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 75 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - Diamond Intention Hybrid PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 ! Recommended 75 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Tuft & Needle Hybrid with Pillow top 7 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 74 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Nest Bedding Alexander Signature OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Hybrid Copper Infused Thermic Phase PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Change Cooling Fabric 1 74 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 ! Recommended OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Denver Mattress Doctor’s Choice Plush PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 $ Best Buy 74 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - Allswell Luxe Hybrid PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 $ Best Buy 74 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Beautyrest Black L-Class 1, 7 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 ! Recommended 73 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - Bedgear M3 1.0 Medium Firm 7 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 73 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Consumer Reports | CR.org INNERSPRING MATTRESSES | RATINGS | PAGE 4 1 2 3 4 5 121 Rated Models WORSE BETTER (as of June 2021) OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Saatva Flagship Luxury Firm Eurotop PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 73 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Purple 3 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 73 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Purple 2 Hybrid Firm PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 73 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Posturepedic Performance PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 1 Lawson Euro Pillowtop AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 ! Recommended 73 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Trelleburg II PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 11.5" Firm Mattress AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 ! Recommended 73 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - Birch by Helix Natural PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 73 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - Puffy Lux Hybrid PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 ! Recommended 73 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Denver Mattress Doctor’s Choice Euro Top AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 72 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 1 Ethan Allen EA Signature Firm AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 72 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Duxiana DUX 1001 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 72 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 5/5 Consumer Reports | CR.org INNERSPRING MATTRESSES | RATINGS | PAGE 5 1 2 3 4 5 121 Rated Models WORSE BETTER (as of June 2021) OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Response Performance Elm PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Avenue Firm 11 1 72 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 1, 7 Kingsdown Crown Imperial Empire AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 72 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Casper Nova Hybrid AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 72 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Response Performance Beech Street PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Eurotop Cushion Firm 1, 7 72 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Sealy Posturepedic Essentials Trust II 7 72 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Ikea Hidrasund 72 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Helix Sleep Midnight Luxe 1, 7 72 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Stearns & Foster Estate Hurston 14" PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Cushion firm tight top 72 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Sealy Posturepedic Response Performance PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Mountain Ridge IV Cushion Firm Pillow Top 71 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Stearns & Foster Estate Rockwell Luxury PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Ultra Firm 13.5 Inch 7 71 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 Consumer Reports | CR.org INNERSPRING MATTRESSES | RATINGS | PAGE 6 1 2 3 4 5 121 Rated Models WORSE BETTER (as of June 2021) OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 DreamCloud Tight Top 71 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Leesa Hybrid Mattress AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 71 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 1, 7 Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Cassatt AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 71 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 Brentwood Home Oceano 14" Gel Memory PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Foam Medium Eurotop Hybrid AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 71 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 MLily Fusion Luxe AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 70 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT - Modern Sleep Palmetto Hybrid Foam and PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Innerspring 12-Inch AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 70 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 3/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Sealy Posturepedic Performance Kelburn II 70 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 4/5 The Original Mattress Factory Orthopedic PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Luxury Firm 70 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 OVERALL SCORE COMFORT 3/5 Serta Perfect Sleeper Hybrid PETITE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 Standale II Luxury 1, 7 70 AVERAGE SIDE SLEEPER 4/5 LARGE/TALL SIDE SLEEPER