¢¡¤£¦¥¨§ © §£¦¥¦£© §£! " $#% &§ © ' ()"*§+#¥,-£ .0/21436587%9;:36<>=?@/A1436BC367%9A36<;=A36D EGF$HA36DJILKMFN<OI,P6QR¦9;FNP8DSF$IL:T7U36B3V<>=XWYH>H>BT:CF$=ZFN7%9A36<;:C7N[ \]<;:T^8F$D_[S:TIa`bP6QdcaBCBT:C<>P6:C[43eI,\]D_f>36<A3egihj9A36KMHA36:C56<lk \]DSfA36<A3;k;cimon;prq8stp8kA\G?uW v!F$`xw¨P8D_=;[NyjZz>BTI_:CH>9>36[_FG{APrw|[$k2I_z>D_f;z>BCF$<>7NFVkAHA36DSI_:C7$z>B}3VI_FY{APrw|[Nk2=>D_365M36<>=BC:~QIUk HA36DJIL:C7$BCF%ILz>DSf>z>BTFN<>7$F!:C<OILF$DL367-IL:CP6< ] ;u2 W=>:CDSFN7$I,<z>KMFNDS:C7U3VB[_:CKz>B}3VI_:CP8<E!G?>¦:C[|z>[SFN=I_P[JILz>=t`I_9>F"F$@FN7$I]P6Q3MQD_F$FN[JILD_FN36K :T[_P6I_D_P8H>:T7]I_z>D_f>z;BCFN<OI4{>P&wP8<xI_9>FG=>D_36536<>=bBT:TQIjQP6D_7NF$[4P8<X3[SH>9>FNDS:C7N36BlHA36DJIL:T7NBCFV/R¦9>F!HA3VDJg I_:C7NBTFG=>:C36KF-ILF$D4:C[|36fP8z;IGp8/I_PpUsI_:CKMFN[jI_9>F"v!P8BCKMP858P8DSPr^[S7U36BTF6k;I_9>FHA36DJIL:C7$BCF!|F$`u<>P6BC=>[ <z>KfFNDY:C[!36fP8z;IGn8sILPxn8s8s;k*36<>=IL9;FQD_FNF$[SI_D_FU3VK ILz;D_f>z>BTFN<>7$F:C<OILF$<>[_:~Ia`:T[G36fP8z;IprsILP 6¢b/Xc£I:C["[_9>Prw|<¤I_9A3VII_9>FQDSFNF$[SILDSFU36K¥I_z>D_f>z;BCFN<;7NFx=>PuFN[ <>P6I 9A3U^8Fb3[_z>f;[SI%3V<I_:}36B¨36<>= ¡ [J`t[JILF$K3VI_:C7F$@FN7-IP8<)IL9;FMI_:CKMF-gi3U^6FNDL3V58FN=KFN36<=>DL365;/R¦9>FM[SIL36<>=A36DS=¤=>D_3657NP8DSD_FNBC3VIL:TP8< fA3V[_FN=¤P8<¤IL9;F:C<;[SI%3V<IL36<>F$P8z>[P6D KMFU36<¤[_BC:TH^6FNBTPt7$:TIa`D_F$[_z>B~IL[:T<¤3D_FU3V[_P8<A3Vf>BT`367$7Nz>D_3VILF H>DSFN=>:T7$I_:CP8<bP6QI_9>F!KFN36<b=>D_365P8f;I%3V:C<>F$=xQD_P8K¦IL9>FE!Y?@/>§,P&w¨F$^6FND$kI_9>F367N7$z>DL3V7$`bP6Q0H>DSF-g p =>:T7$I_:CP8<oPVQ,I_9>Fx:T<>[SIL36<OI%36<>F$P8z>[=>D_365=>F$7ND_FN36[_F$[Mw|:~IL9¨:T<>7NDSFU36[S:C<>5H>36DSI_:C7NBTF[S:C©NFV/¤ªAP8D IL9>F [SK36BTBCF$D,H>36DSI_:C7NBTFN[$kI_9>FBTP&w«QDSFN¬z>F$<>7$`P8[_7$:CBCBC3VIL:TP8<>[¦:T<IL9>FE!G?=;DL365b3VD_F w¨FNBTBd7N36H;I_z>D_F$= fO`I_9>F[SI%3V<>=A36DS=¤=>D_365>kf>z;IQP8DGI_9>FB}36DS58FNDYHA36DSI_:C7$BCFN[![S:C58<;:T­A7N36<OI=>:T@FNDSFN<>7$FN["F-®t:C[JIF$^8F$< QP8D|IL9;FBCPrw¯QDSFN¬z>F$<>7$`7NP8KMH@P6<>FN<OIL[$/|ca<>7NBTz>[_:TP8<P6QI_9>F3V=>=>FN=ugaK36[_[]36<>=9;:C[SI_P8DS`bQP6D_7NF$[Nk 7$P8KH;z;ILF$=°fA36[SFN= P6<°IL9>FX{Az>:T=±^6FNBCPu7N:~Ia`²3VIMIL9>F7NFN<OI_FNDPVQGIL9>FHA36DJIL:C7$BCFVk¨=>PuFN[<>P6I:CKg H>DSPr^8FI_9>FH>D_F$=>:C7-IL:TP8<l/xEG:~*F$D_F$<I"F$[SIL:TK3eILFN[P6Q¨IL9>F{Az>:T=^6FNBTPt7$:TIa`[SFNFN<¤f`I_9>FMHA36DSI_:C7$BCF 36DSFxF-®;36KM:C<;FN=l/)c£I:T[[_9>Prw|<¨IL9>3VIIL9;FbKFN36<o=>D_365:C[:T<>[_F$<>[_:~IL:~^8FI_PIL9>F{>z>:C=o^6FNBCPu7N:~Ia` KMFU36[Sz>D_F$=b3VI¨IL9>FGH>36DSI_:C7NBTF]7$FN<OILF$DNk>P6D¨P8ftI%36:T<>FN=xfO`3U^8FND_3658:T<>5Pr^8F$D¦3 {Az>:T=^6P8BCz>KMFYPVQIL9>F P8DS=>FNDP6Q,IL9;FH>36DSI_:C7NBTFx[_:T©NFV/²R¦9;F{Az;7$ILz>3VIL:TP8<>[=>:TK:T<>:C[S9¨36[IL9>FX[S:C©NFXP6Q,IL9;F3U^6FNDL3V58:C<>5 ^6P8BCz>KMF:T<>7NDSFU36[SFN[$/R¦9>FbF$@FN7-IP6Q,:C<>7$D_FN36[_:T<>5QDSFNFN[JILDSFU36K³ILz>DSf>z>BCF$<>7NFb:T<OILFN<;[_:TIa`QP8D"IL9>F [_36KF HA36DJIL:C7$BCF"[_:T©NF:T[Y[SI_z>=>:TFN=l/ªBTz>7$I_zA3VI_:CP8<>[]:C<IL9>F=;DL365X36<;=BC:~QI]QP8DS7NF$[!36D_F [_9>Prw|<ILP [S7U36BTFw|:~IL9IL9>F"KFN36<=>DL36536<>=XQD_F$FN[SI_D_FN36K :C<OILF$<>[_:~Ia`8/4R¦9>F [SIL36<>=A36DS==>D_365w|:TIL9;P8z;I,IL9>F 36=;=>FN=tg£K3V[_[,36<>=X9>:T[SILP6DS`xQP8DS7NF$[,H;D_Pr^u:C=>F$[|I_9>Ff@F$[SI]36H>H;D_PU®t:CK3VIL:TP8<xILPIL9;F E!Y?xD_FN[Sz>BTIN/ ¡ ´jµ¶´·x¸¹ºX»¼½¦¸¾NºM· EG:T[_HFND_[SFN=¨HA3VDSIL:T7Nz>BC3VILFM{APrw|[36fP8z><>=¨:T<o<A3VI_z>D_Fb3V<>=¨:C<¨F$<>58:C<;FNFNDS:C<>536H>H>BT:C7U3eIL:CP6<>[N/ca< KMP8[SI7U36[SFN[$kI_9>Fj{Az;:C=H>9>36[_F¦:T[dILz;D_f>z>BTFN<OIU/R¦9>F4:C<OI_FNDL3V7$IL:TP8<fF$Iaw¨FNF$<MI_9>Fj{Az>:T=H>9A3V[_F|36<>= I_9>FHA3VDSIL:T7Nz>BC3VILFH;9A36[_F:C[f>:~g£=>:CDSFN7-IL:CP6<A36B¿y!I_9>F7N36D_DS:CFNDigaH>9>36[_FILz>DSf>z>BTFN<>7$F:C<t{Az>FN<;7NFN[ IL9>F =>:T[_HFNDS[_:CP6<36<>=H>D_F-QFNDSFN<OIL:C36BA367$7Nz>Kz;B}3VI_:CP8<PVQI_9>F¦HA36DJIL:T7NBCF$[w|9>:T7%9M:T<ILz>DS<KPu=>z>BC3VILFÀIL9>F {Az;:C=I_z>D_f;z>BCF$<>7NFV/W4IjIL9;FGBCF-^8FNBP6Q3 [_:C<;58BCF|HA36DJIL:T7NBCFVkOIL9>FGF-*F$7$IjP6QlQD_F$FN[JILD_FN36KÁILz>DSf>z>BCF$<>7NF :T[4ILPKPu=>:~Q`I_9>F!=>DL3V5QP6D_7NF7$P8KH>36D_F$=XI_PIL9A3VI,:T<X3[JILFN36=;`Xz><>:~QP8D_K¦{APrwÁP6QILF$<7N36BCBTFN=  [JI%36<;=A36D_==>DL3V58Ã-/¦Ä!<IL9>F P6IL9;FND,9A36<>=lk@3H>36DSI_:C7NBTF!7U36<KPu=>:TQ`QD_F$FN[SI_D_FN36KÅILz>DSf>z>BCF$<>7NF fO`I_9>F4QP8D_K3VI_:CP8<PVQl3Gwj36Æ6FVktHFNDS:CPu=>:C7¨[_9>F$=>=>:C<;5 P6Q^8P6DSIL:T7NF$[Nku36<>=wj36Æ6F|ILz>DSf>z>BTFN<>7$F6/R¦9>F 7$P8BCBTFN7$I_:T^6FGF$@FN7-IYP6QI_9>FH>D_F$[_FN<;7NFPVQ3=>:T[SILDS:Cf>ztIL:CP6<xP6QdHA36DSI_:C7$BCFN[¦7N36<bQz>DSI_9>FND|KMPt=;:TQ`MIL9>F F-*F$7$IL:~^8FM=>DL3V5QP8DS7NFP8<¤3H>36DSI_:C7NBTF=>z>FILP[_7$D_F$FN<>:T<>5F-*F$7$I36<>=)IL9>F$D_FNfO`:C<t{Az>FN<;7NFIL9>F KMFU36<¤[_F-I_ILBT:C<>536<>=¤=>:C[SH@F$D_[S:CP8<¤7%9A36DL3V7$ILF$D_:T[SIL:T7N[$/?u:CKM:CB}3VD_BT`6k*IL9;F7NP6BCBCF$7$I_:T^8FMF$@FN7-IP6QjIL9>F =>:T[_HFNDS[_:CP6<P6QjH>36DSI_:C7NBTFN[Yw|:TBCBd=>F$I_FND_KM:C<;FIL9>FM3VISILF$<uz>3VIL:TP8<P8D36z>56KF$<IL3VIL:TP8<P6QÀIL9;F{Az>:C= I_z>D_f>z;BCFN<;7NF6/ ca<bIL9>:T[jHA3VH@F$D4wjFGw|:TBCB@36=>=>DSFN[_[4I_9>F!F$@FN7-I|P6QIL9>F]QD_FNF$[SI_D_FU3VKÇILz>DSf>z>BTFN<>7$F!P8<xIL9>FY=>DL365 36<;=¨BC:TQIQP8DS7NF$[P8<¨3[_:T<>58BTFHA3VDSIL:T7NBTF6/ȤFx7%9>PuP8[_FxI_P:C<O^6FN[SI_:C5O3eILFI_9>Fx[_:TKH;BCFN[JI7N36[_FbP6Q 36<):T[_P6I_D_P8H>:T7 QDSFNFN[JILDSFU36KÉI_z>D_f;z>BCF$<>7NFP6Q¨R3U`uBCP6DGK:T7NDSP8[_7N36BCF|F$`u<>P6BC=>[!<z>KfFNDF$¬uz>36BILP prnVÊ>/R¦9>F¦Iaw¨P:TKHP8DSIL36<OIHA3VDL36KMF$I_FND_[+P6QIL9;F,H;D_P8f>BTFNKË36D_F¦IL9;FN<IL9>F|DL3eIL:CP!PVQ@I_9>F|HA36DSI_:C7$BCF =>:C36KMF$ILF$DÌILPI_9>FvP6BCKMP858P8DSP&^[_7N36BCFÍ@kd36<>=¤I_9>FM:C<OILF$<>[_:~Ia`¤PVQ4QD_F$FN[SI_D_FN36K¥ILz>DSf>z>BCF$<>7NF =>F-­A<>F$=36[dIL9>F¦D_3VIL:TPGP6Q2IL9>F¦DSPtPVISgaKMFU3V<tga[S¬uz>36D_FD_KM[%0I_z>D_f;z>BCF$<I{Az>7$I_zA3VI_:CP8<I_PI_9>F4KMFU36< DSFNB}3eIL:T^6FM^6FNBTPt7$:TIa`)fF$Iaw¨FNFN<¨I_9>FHA3VDSIL:T7NBTF36<;=¤IL9>F[_z>DSD_P8z;<>=>:C<;5{Az>:T=l/XR¦9>Fx=>:C36KF-ILF$D P6Q I_9>FGHA36DJIL:T7NBCF]z><>=>F$D47NP6<>[_:T=>FND_3VIL:TP8<x:C[¨^63VD_:CF$=QD_P6KÇ36fP8z;IYpGILPbprs"IL:CKMFN[ÀIL9>FGvP6BCKMP858P8DSP&^ Î [S7U36BTF6k,36<>= I_9>FILz;D_f>z>BTFN<>7$F:C<OI_FN<>[S:TIa`±:C[^V36DS:CF$=°QD_P8K prs¤I_P 8¢x/hjP8<;[_FN¬z>F$<OILBT`°IL9>F ¡ HA3VDSIL:T7NBTF,F-`t<;P8BC=>[<z>KfFND$kdf>36[_F$=¤P8<)IL9>FMD_F$B}3VI_:T^6F^8FNBTPt7$:TIa`)3V<>=¤H>36DSI_:C7NBTF=>:}3VKF-ILFND$k:C[ :T<XI_9>FDL36<;58Fn8sILPMn8s8st/ hjP8<>[S:C=>F$DIL9;F7U3V[_FP6Q!3¤HA36DJIL:C7$BCF[_F-I_ILBT:C<>5)IL9;D_P8z>569Ï3¤ILz;D_f>z>BTFN<OI{>P&w/'R¦9>FKMFU36< [SF$I_I_BC:T<>5¦^8FNBTPt7$:TIa`P6QtIL9>FÀHA36DJIL:T7NBCFH;D_Pr^u:C=>F$[3|7NP8<O^8F$<>:CF$<OIKMFU36[Sz>D_FÀP6Q;I_9>FÀKFN36<=>D_365|QP8D_7$F6/ ca<bF®;HFNDS:CKMFN<OIL[¨IL9>FGKMFU3V<x=>DL3V57NPuF$ÐM7N:TFN<OI¦:T[j7NP6KH>ztILFN=bf>36[_F$=bP8<xIL9>FYKFN36[_z>DSFNKMFN<OI¦P6Q I_9>FGKMFU36<b[SF$I_I_BC:T<>5^8F$BCPu7N:~Ia`bÑ;Ò36<>=3QP8D_7$FGfA36BC36<>7$FGf@F-IawjF$FN<XIL9>F!56DL3U^u:TIa`36<>=bIL9>FY=>DL365 QP8DS7NF"36[$y p Ê Ó¦ÔÕ Jp& Ì@×ØÏp& ÑÙ Î@Ö Ò¤Ú w|9>F$D_F|×:T[IL9>F¦H>36DSI_:C7NBTF-g¿ILPVg¿{Az>:C==>FN<>[S:TIa`D_3VIL:TP>kO36<;= :C[I_9>F,367N7$FNBTFNDL3eIL:CP6<=>z>F¦ILP58D_3r^u:~Ia`8/ Ö c£QuIL9>FÀ36Kf>:CF$<I*{APrwo:C[[JI%3656<A36<OIUk6Ñ>Ò7NP6D_D_F$[_HP8<>=>[ILP4I_9>FILF$D_KM:C<A36Be^8F$BCPu7N:TIa`G36<>=IL9>F+3Vf@Pr^8F DSFNB}3eIL:CP6<`u:TFNBC=;[I_9>Fj[JI%36<;=A36D_= =>DL3V5Y7NPuF$ÐM7$:CFN<OId7NP8DSD_F$[_HP8<>=>:T<>5]I_PG3|z><>:TQP6D_K¯<>P6<I_z>D_f;z>BCF$<I {APrw/4ca<3I_z>D_f;z>BCF$<I,{APrwk29>PrwjF-^8F$DNk@I_9>FNDSF36DSF!IawjPMwjF$BCBz><>=>F$D_[JILPuPt=KF$7%9A36<>:T[_KM[|I_9A3VI :T<;{Az>F$<>7NF4I_9>F¦KFN36<[_F-I_ILBT:C<>5YDL3VI_F6/R¦9>F4­>D_[SIÀ:T[=>z>F4I_PGIL9>F|<>P8<ugaBC:T<>FU3VDd=>F$H@F$<>=>F$<>7NF,P6QIL9>F =>D_365P6<IL9>F]D_F$B}3VI_:T^8F|^8F$BCPu7N:~Ia`M3VIj­A<;:TILF]|F$`u<>P8BT=>[j<z>KfFNDS[N/+ªAP8D+IL9>F][L36KMFY=;FN<>[S:TIa`DL3VI_:CP ×3V<>=o=>:C36KF-ILF$D"Ì2k0IL9>FKFN36<¤[SF$I_I_BC:T<>5^6FNBTPt7$:TIa`):C<¤3I_z>D_f>z;BCFN<OI {APrwÁ:C["BCFN[S[ I_9A36<¤I_9A3VI :T<X3[JI%3656<A36<OI¦{APrwÁÛZFN:Ûk>WY=>DS:}36<XÜݧY36<;DL3VISIa`AÞ%/R¦9>F[_F$ISILBT:C<>5^6FNBCPu7N:~Ia`x=>F$7NDSFU36[SFN[|w|:TIL9 :T<>7NDSFU36[S:C<>5GI_z>D_f>z;BCFN<;7NF,:C<OILF$<>[_:~Ia`36<>=IL9;F,DSFN[Sz>BTI_:C<>5KMFU36<=>D_365"36[58:T^6FN<MfO`Jp&:T[9>:C589;FND I_9A36<IL9A3eI+fA36[_F$=P6<I_9>F4ILF$D_KM:C<A3VBt^8F$BCPu7N:~Ia`:C<3![JI%3658<>36<OI{APrw/R¦9>:C[+F-*F$7$I+w|:CBTBt=>F$7NDSFU36[SF w|:~IL9=;FN7NDSFU36[S:C<>5,F-`u<>P8BC=;[j<z>KfFNDj36<>=w|:TBCBAF$<I_:CDSFNBT`^V36<;:C[_9:C<IL9>F]BC:T<>FU36D¨?uI_P8Æ6F$[jBT:CKM:TIU/ R¦9>F![SFN7$P8<>=lkA3V<>=bKP6D_FY7$P8KMH>BCF®*ktKF$7%9A36<>:T[_K¦:C[4=;z>FYILPI_9>FGH>DSF$QF$D_FN<OI_:}36B*I_DL3&ßSF$7$I_P8D_:TFN[4P6Q QDSFNFNB~`)Q36BCBT:C<>5HA36DJIL:C7$BCF$[N/.d36DSI_:C7NBTFN[ =>P<>P6I[L36KMH>BCFMIL9>FILz>DSf>z>BCF$<OI{APrw¦z><>:TQP6D_KMBT`8kdf>z;I Ê 101 Uhlerr & Sinclair (1970) I = 0.4 Torobin & Gauvin (1961) X 0.3 0 0.2 Clamen & Gauvin (1969) D 10 XX C XX X Standard drag curve 10-1 0.2 I = 0.4 0.3 I = 0.1 Clift & Gauvin (1970) 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 Re ª:T58z>DSF¦p8yW²[Sz>KMK36DJ`!P6QtIL9>F+D_F$[_z>B~IL[0P8<IL9>FÀF$@FN7-IP6QtILz>DSf>z>BTFN<>7$F¨P8<"IL9>F+=>D_365,7NPuF$ÐM7N:TFN<OIU/ .+DSFN[SFN<OI,D_FN[Sz>BTI_[Náâ¢ã!P8D_FGÜËhjDSP&w¨F6áäÞ¿å!æç?t36<>Æe3658:TD_:@ÜÝ|z;¦áäÞ¿è]éMêl3VD_:C<ÜÝ,:C7%9>P6BC[Náìë]í à Ȥ36D_<;:C7U3îNï¨ð8ñ~òTáôóGõÅ|z>=>P8B~QÜË14367%9A36BTP>á÷ö¦ø1jDSz>7U3eILPîNïjð8ñ~òC/ å H>DSF$QF$DD_F$58:CP8<;[P6Q|=>Prw|<Ow43V[_9²7NP8KMHA36DSFN=oILPDSFN58:TP8<>[ P6Q|z>Htg£KPr^u:C<>5{Az>:C=¢[_F$FxÈo36<;5Ü Ù Z3&®;F-` /R¦9z>[¨I_9>FYKMFU36<{Az>:T=M^6FNBTPt7$:TIa`[_F$FN<xfO`M3"HA36DSI_:C7$BCF¦=>:~*F$D_[+QD_P8KËI_9>F|ILD_z;F]KMFU36< P8ftI%36:T<>FN=xfO`3U^8FND_3658:T<>5Pr^8F$D4IL9>FGF$<OIL:CDSFY^8P6BCz>KMFYP6Q{>z>:C=l/\]<>BT:CÆ6F,IL9>FYF$@FN7$I4P6Q<>P8<>BT:C<>FN36D =>D_365!=>F$H@F$<>=>FN<;7NF6kuIL9>F|F-*F$7$IÀP6QH>D_F-QFNDSFN<OIL:C36B>ILD_3&ßSFN7-ILP8DJ`:C[I_P:C<>7$D_FU3V[_F4IL9;F,KMFU3V<[_F$ISILBT:C<>5 ^6FNBCPu7N:~Ia`8/4R¦9z>[]IL9>F"=>DL3V57$PtF-Ð7$:CF$<IYF$^V36BTzA3VILF$=fA3V[_FN=P8<oip&4ILFN<;=>[]I_PfF