Version October 23, 2019 A Preprint typeset using LTEX style emulateapj v. 08/22/09 ARE 2I/BORISOV AND OORT CLOUD COMETS ALIKE? Zdenek Sekanina Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, 4800 Oak Grove Drive, Pasadena, CA 91109, U.S.A. Version October 23, 2019 ABSTRACT The interstellar comet 2I/Borisov bears a strong resemblance to Oort Cloud comets, judging from its appearance in images taken over the first six weeks of observation. To test the proposed affinity in more diagnostic terms, 2I is compared to Oort Cloud comets of similar perihelion distance, near 2 AU. Eight such objects are identified among the cataloged comets whose orbits have been determined with high accuracy. This work focuses on three particular characteristics: the light curve, the geometry of the dust tail, and the dust parameter Afρ. Unlike Oort Cloud comets with perihelia beyond the snow line, Oort Cloud comets with perihelia near 2 AU show strong evidence of the original halo of slowly accelerating, millimeter-sized and larger icy-dust grains only in early tail observations. The dust tail in later images is primarily the product of subsequent, water-sublimation driven activity nearer perihelion but not of activity just preceding observation, which suggests the absence of microscopic- dust ejecta. Comet 2I fits, in broad terms, the properties of the Oort Cloud comets with perihelia near 2 AU and of fairly low activity. Future tests of the preliminary conclusions are proposed. Subject headings: comets: individual (2I/Borisov, Oort Cloud comets) — methods: data analysis 1. INTRODUCTION 2. THE ORBIT ECCENTRICITY The era of interstellar comets is upon us, having had so Although the orbit eccentricity of 2I/Borisov is much far the flavor of a bizarre story. Less than two years af- higher than that of 1I/‘Oumuamua, both values are ap- ter the hectic weeks with a weird cometary cocoon des- proximately what one expects, if either object arrived ignated 1I/‘Oumuamua, whose nature is still shrouded from a star system whose velocity relative to the Sun is in mystery, Gennady Borisov, a Russian amateur as- near a statistically averaged value determined by model- tronomer, has pulled the proverbial rabbit out of a hat ing the kinematics of main-sequence stars and the Sun’s by discovering, on 2019 August 30, the first active inter- motion with respect to the Local Standard of Rest (LSR). stellar comet, of apparent magnitude 18, with a 65-cm For the averaged velocity Vrel of an interstellar object telescope (!) of his own design (Green 2019, O’Callaghan upon its approach to the Sun one finds 2019). Borisov’s find is a stunning achievement by any 2 2 2 measure, especially in the light of the post-‘Oumuamua hVreli = Vsun + hσVi, (1) nearly universal consensus that instrumentation more where V is the Sun’s velocity with respect to the LSR powerful than currently available is needed to success- sun and σV is the mean dispersion of star velocities, which fully search for further interstellar objects. While this according to Dehnen & Binney (1998) is a function of perception is prudent in follow-up studies, Borisov’s dis- the B−V color, increasing from blue to red stars. These covery demonstrates that ever bigger telescopes are by no authors find a color independent V = 13.4 km s−1 and sun1 means indispensable in meeting the basic objective. 2 2 −1 While the comet’s interstellar origin had been flagged from their results it follows that hσVi = 28.3 km s for stars in the B −V range of +0.14 to +0.47 mag. Equa- by a hyperbolic-motion search code on September 8 1 2 2 −1 (Guzik et al. 2019), the official designation 2I/Borisov tion (1) yields hVreli = 31.3 km s and the eccentricity was inexplicably delayed until September 24, or 25 days e is related to the perihelion distance q (in units of AU) arXiv:1910.08208v2 [astro-ph.EP] 22 Oct 2019 after discovery. To assign the designation 1I to ‘Oumua- by 2 mua took only 19 days, even though groundbreaking and hVreli e =1+ 2 q, (2) time-consuming IAU negotiations were then involved. Vearth The new comet is bound to trigger revised estimates of −1 the population of interstellar comets. On the one hand, where Vearth = 29.78 km s is the Earth’s mean orbital one should be wary of the law of small numbers, on the velocity. For ‘Oumuamua q =0.255 AU and the pre- other hand it is true that discoveries of comets of appar- dicted e =1.28 is close to the actual value of 1.20; for ent magnitude around 18 have been fairly common for Borisov’s comet q =2.01 AU and the predicted e =3.22 close to 70 years, essentially since the time the 122-cm is not too far from the actual value of 3.36.1 Schmidt telescope became operational at Palomar in late On the other hand, the eccentricity effect on orbital 1948 (e.g., Harrington 1952). Records show that comet velocities of the two objects turns out to be dramatic. C/1954 M1 was at the time of discovery of magnitude At the perihelion and discovery times the parabolic limits 19 (e.g., Porter 1955). It thus took at least 65 years to were exceeded, respectively, by 8 percent and 21 percent discover the first interstellar comet as faint as 2I/Borisov for 1I/‘Oumuamua, but by 48 percent and 66 percent in at a fairly large geocentric distance. the case of 2I/Borisov. Electronic address: [email protected]. 1 Comparison made with the elements in MPEC 2019-T116. 2 Sekanina Table 1 Oort Cloud Comets As Potential Analogs for 2I/Borisov Perihelion Original barycentric Perihelion First Covered Number Orbit distance reciprocal semimajor time obs. orbital arc of obs. quality −1 a Comet q (AU) axis (1/ab)orig (AU ) (TT) used (days) used code C/2011 L2 (McNaught) 1.938 −0.000 024 2 ± 0.000 004 7b 2011 Nov 01.27 −152 240 52 1A C/2018 C2 (Lemmon) 1.957 +0.000 037 0 ± 0.000 000 7c 2018 Jun 02.22 −125 272 1645 1A C/2006 L2 (McNaught) 1.994 +0.000 009 8 ± 0.000 001 7d 2006 Nov 20.20 −159 388 380 1A e C/2014 AA52 (Catalina) 2.003 +0.000 029 4 ± 0.000 000 9 2015 Feb 27.65 −419 624 365 1A C/2008 J6 (Hill) 2.004 −0.000 025 3 ± 0.000 002 3f 2008 Apr 10.94 −230 471 337 1A C/1907 E1 (Giacobini) 2.052 +0.000 025 1 ± 0.000 019g 1907 Mar 19.61 −10 354 67 1B C/2011 R1 (McNaught) 2.080 +0.000 031 1 ± 0.000 000 3h 2012 Oct 19.62 −739 1246 1304 1A C/1948 E1 (Pajduˇs´akov´a-Mrkos) 2.107 +0.000 033 7 ± 0.000 004i 1948 May 16.61 −64 698 95 1A Notes. a Time reckoned in days from perihelion: negative means before perihelion; may include pre-discovery observations. −1 b Nakano (NK 2197) lists −0.000 046 ± 0.000 008 6 AU . −1 c Nakano (NK 3761) lists +0.000 028 ± 0.000 000 7 AU . −1 −1 d Kr´olikowska & Dybczy´nski (2013) list +0.000 012 9 ± 0.000 001 4 AU , while Nakano (NK 1713) finds 0.000 000 ± 0.000 001 6 AU . −1 e Nakano (NK 3124) lists +0.000 016 ± 0.000 001 0 AU . −1 f Nakano (NK 2397) lists −0.000 019 ± 0.000 003 9 AU , while Kr´olikowska & Dybczy´nski (2013) from only post-perihelion observations find −1 +0.000 025 4 ± 0.000 004 0 AU . −1 g Kr´olikowska et al. (2014) list +0.000 033 8 ± 0.000 021 6 AU . −1 h Nakano (NK 2647) lists +0.000 020 ± 0.000 000 4 AU . −1 i Kr´olikowska et al. (2013) list +0.000 037 3 ± 0.000 002 7 AU . 3. 1I/‘OUMUAMUA CONTRA 2I/BORISOV: TRAITS Osterbrock (1958) noted that the tails of comets Baade SHARED WITH OORT CLOUD COMETS and Haro-Chavira were oriented about midway between Investigations of the physical and compositional prop- the antisolar direction and the orbit behind the nucleus. erties of 2I/Borisov have already begun (e.g., Guzik et This puzzle was eventually settled by Sekanina’s (1973, al. 2019, Fitzsimmons et al. 2019, Yang et al. 2019; de 1975) proposal of the conservation-of-momentum law’s Le´on et al. 2019; Dybczy´nski et al. 2019; Jewitt & Luu effect on sizable dust grains released at very low velocities 2019; Kareta et al. 2019) and will surely continue. Cur- from the nucleus far from the Sun (up to 10 AU or more) sory inspection of the appearance of the comet sug- on the way to perihelion. The problem of activity of gests its striking similarity to Oort Cloud comets, unlike Oort Cloud (and some other) distant comets long before 1I/‘Oumuamua, which has often been described as an ob- perihelion was recently revisited by Meech et al. (2009). ject unlike any other ever observed. Yet, ‘Oumuamua If active interstellar comets, such as 2I/Borisov, and could be a piece of debris of a dwarf interstellar comet, Oort Cloud comets are alike, their similarity should ex- which, because of its small perihelion distance, had disin- tend far beyond their mere appearance. If so, it is es- tegrated near perihelion (Sekanina 2019a). Intrinsically sential that the dependence of cometary activity on he- faint, dust-poor Oort Cloud comets with perihelia closer liocentric distance be recognized in undertaken tests of to the Sun than ∼0.5 AU are known to do just that diagnostic physical signatures.