1 North Lanarkshire Council DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT Planning Applications for consideration of Planning and Environment Committee 3 ~ Committee Date : 2IStJune 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO ..........!-.- Ordnance Survey maps reproduced from Ordnance Survey with the permission of HMSO Crown Copyright reserved 2 APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 21STJUNE 2000 Page No. Application No. Applicant Developmenthocus Recommendation 5 N/00/00220/OUT Tulloch Properties Ltd Mixed Use Development Comprising Refuse Class 1 (Retail), Class 3 (Food & Drink) Public House and Hot Food Take-Away - 1-5 Greenfaulds Road, Carbrain, Cumbernauld 12 N/00/00295/JOUT MrGLinn Erection of Dwellinghouse (Outline) Refuse Site Off Coach Close, Kilsyth 15 N/00/00346/FUL Taywood Homes Ltd Residential Development (1 79 Refuse (P) Dwellings) - Land south of Southview Place and Lochend Avenue Gartcosh 34 N/00/00353/FUL Mrs M Kerr Erection of Domestic Garage Grant 2 1 Taggart Road Croy G65 9JJ 40 N/00/004 12/OUT Edaw Limited Outline Planning Application for the Grant (P) Formation of an Access and Development Platforms for a Petrol Filling Station, Fast Food Restaurant, Health Club, Hotel and Restaurant, Car Show Rooms and Associated Structural Landscaping Land Bounded by the A80, the B8048 and the Low Wood Auchenkilns Holdings, Cumbernauld. 56 N/00/00414/FUL Mr Robert Lawson Change of Use from Shop to Hot Food Grant Takeaway Outlet 67 Glenmanor Avenue, Moodiesburn 59 N/00/0043 1/FUL Persimmon Homes Erection of 60 Houses with Associated Grant Garages, Roads, Play Area and Open Space - Area 7A Craigmarloch, Cumbernauld 67 N/00/00456/OUT Mr & Mrs Melia Outline Application for the Development Refuse (PI of Five Dwellings - Land Currently Occupied by Redundant Farm Buildings Adjacent to Greenside Farm Waterhead Road, Palacerigg, Cumbernauld 74 N/00/0047 l/FUL Mrs Kim Hunter Siting of a Mobile Snack Bar Grant Parking Bay Adjacent to 22 Tannoch Drive, Lenziemill, Cumbernauld 77 N/00/00475/FUL Persimmon Homes Erection of 7 Dwellinghouses - Grant Land Between Plots 86 & 93, Area 6C, Craigmarloch Cumbernauld 82 N/00/00492/_OUT Mrs H Ralph Erection of Detached Dwellinghouse Refuse (In Outline)- 9 Drove Hill, Balloch, Cumbernauld 3 APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 21STJUNE 2000 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmenULocus Recommendation 86 Town Centre Initiatives Environmental and Landscaping Works, Grant Including the Erection of Steel Lattice Archway - Town Centre Entrance St Mungo’s Walk, Town Centre, Cumbemauld 89 N/0010056 l/FUL Patricia Moore Change of Use of Former Amusement Grant Arcade to Small Function Suite Forming and Extension to Existing Licensed Premises - 3 Tweed Walk, Town Centre, Cumbemauld Erection of Public HouseRestaurant and Grant 92 N/00/00596/FUL.. Whitbread - Tulloch Properties Hotel - Former Bus Garage Cumbernauld Road, Stepps 97 sustrans Use of Land as Cyclepath, Erection of Grant Public Artwork and Station Improvements Including Installation of CCTV Scheme - Drumgelloch Station, Bankhead Place Glasgow - Edinburgh Cycle Path, Airdrie 104 C/OO/OO 197RUL GAP Housing Association Erection of 108 Dwellinghouses With Grant Associated Roads and Environmental Improvement Work (Phase 1) Gap Housing Assoc. New Build Phase 1 Minch Way, Airdrie 109 C/00/003 16RUL Headway Developments Ltd Mixed Development Comprising Retail/ Grant (P) 3 Residential and Community Hall Headway Development Site, Coatbridge Road, Glenmavis, Airdrie 122 c/oo/oo33 3RUL Mr & Mrs P Brown Erection of Rear Conservatory and Grant WalyFence - 67 Main Street, Glenboig, Coatbridge ‘27 c/oo/oo349/FUL Turnberry Homes Erection of Residential Development Grant Comprising 2 1 Dwellinghouses and Formation of Access Road at 7 Old Monkland Road Coatbridge C/OO/OO3 87/FUL Camegies Leisure Group Change of Use of Part of Former Retail Grant Unit to Night Club Unit 1 3 1-35 Graham Street, Airdrie c/oo/oo459/FUL Crematoria Management Ltd Erection of Crematorium, Formation of Refuse (P) Vehicular Access, Roads and Parking - Laid to the East of Woodhall Mill Road, Calderbank, Airdrie 143 C/OO/OO473/FUL Mr Douglas Thomson Formation of Vehicular Access and Grant Driveway (In Retrospect) - 108 Woodside Street, Coatbridge. 146 C/OO/OO5 12/M Mr Sarfraz Majid Relocation of Flue (In Retrospect) Grant (Amendment to Application No. C/99/0 16 12RUL) - _. 76 Deedes Street, Airdrie I:DATA\COMM2\WORDWLAN21 -JW.dm 4 APPLICATIONS- FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 21STJUNE 2000 Page No. Application No. Applicant Developrnentnocus Recommendation 150 SI991008 8 6IOUT Eastlake Developments Ltd Extension and Alterations to Carfiin Grant (P) “Village” Masterplan Ex-Carfin Bond and Industrial Estate, Carfin, Motherwell 163 SI9910 154ffUL George Wilson (Stonehouse) Construction of Dwellinghouse in Lieu Grant Ltd of Play Area - Land to the west of 7 Carroll Crescent, Newarthill 170 SI9910 3381 FUL Mercury Personal Erection of 22.5 Metre High Refuse Communications Ltd TelecommunicationsMonopole Bruce Road, Carfiin 176 S100100 1951 FUL City Link Developments Ltd Residential Development (49 Units) Grant Site B2 Watling Street, Motherwell 182 S1001002361 FUL Orange PCS Ltd Erection of 20.0 Metre High Refuse TelecommunicationsMast - Shotts Bon Accord Club, Baton Road -. Shotts 188 S1001002431 FUL Thomas Richardson Erection of Pigeon Loft (Retrospective) Grant 166 Bonkle Road, Newmains 192 s1001003421 FUL Mr & Mrs Egan Extension to Dwellinghouse - Grant 11 Newlands Road, Uddingston 197 S/00/00436/ FUL National Transcommunications Retention of T.V. Mast - Grant Ltd Hartwood Hospital, Hartwood 200 S100100437LBC National Transcommunications Retention of T.V. Mast - Grant Ltd Harhvood Hospital, Hartwood 203 S1001004811 FUL R J Blyth Use of Land for Car Boot Sale - Refuse Harestonehill, Overtown Road, Wishaw 209 S1001004941 FUL Gilchrist & Lynn Ltd Residential Development comprising 3 1 Grant flats and terraced houses and associated car parking - Glencairn Street, Motherwell 2 16 S/OOl005091 FUL Motherwell College Erection of Classrooms and Student Grant Common Room - Dalzell Drive, Motherwell (P) N/00/00346/FUL If approved refer to Scottish Ministers (P) N/00/004 121OUT If approved refer to Scottish Ministers (P) Nl00100456lOUT If approved refer to Scottish Ministers (P) C/00100316/FUL If approved refer to Scottish Ministers (P) c/oo/oo459/FUL If approved refer to Scottish Ministers (P) S/99100886/FUL If aouroved refer to Scottish Ministers I:\DATA\COMM2\WORDWLANUI -JU.dW 5 Application No. : N/00/00220/OUT Date Registered: 8th March 2000 APPLICANT: TULLOCH PROPERTIES LTD, TULLOCH HOUSE, BUCHANAN BUSINESS PARK, CUMBERNAULD ROAD, STEPPS Agent: Smith Design Associates, 16 Lynedoch Crescent, Glasgow, G3 6E0 DEVELOPMENT: MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING CLASS 1 (RETAIL), CLASS 3 (FOOD & DRINK) PUBLIC HOUSE AND HOT FOOD TAKE-AWAY LOCATION: 1-5 GREENFAULDS ROAD CARBRAIN CUMBERNAULD Ward: 61 Grid Reference: File Reference: N/00/00220/OUT Site History: Section 6(1) Approval for Residential Development granted 11/05/95 N/97/00168/OUT Outline Approval for 1000 square metres retail granted 13/11/97 Development Plan Cumbernauld Local Plan Contrary to Development Plan: Yes CONSULTATIONS: Objection: No Objection: East Of Scotland Water West Of Scotland Water British Gas Transco Scottish Power The Coal Authority Conditions: S .E.P. A. (East) No Reply: Strathclyde Police REPRESENTATIONS: Neighbours: 3 Letters of Objection from Neighbours 1 Letter of Representation from a Neighbour Newspaper Advertisement: 1 Letter of Objection from a Residents Association COMMENTS: The applicants propose a mixed development comprising a 1 161 square metre retail unit, additional retail units totalling 697 square metres, a fast food outlet of some 306 square metres and a public house / restaurant of approximately 929 square metres with associated access and parking. The site lies to the south- east of, and is accessed from, Greenfaulds Road. It is separated from the railway line to the south by a public footpath and landscaping. The site is covered by industrial policies in the adopted Cumbernauld Local Plan, although Cumbernauld Development 7 Corporation granted consent for residential use of part of the site under Section 6(1) of the New Towns Act. This consent has now lapsed. RECOMMENDATION: Refuse permission for the following reasons: 1. The proposed development would be contrary to Policy IB1 of the adopted Cumbernauld Local Plan in that it is incompatibie with industrial and business use, and it would have an adverse effect on the existing shopping hierarchy. 2. The proposed development would be contrary to Policy SH7 and SH9 of the adopted Cumbernauld Local Plan in that it seeks to locate a retail development outwith the areas identified for such developments and it would have an adverse effect on the vitality and viability of both the existing Cumbernauld Town Centre and Local Centres. 3. The proposed development is contrary to National Planning Policy Guidance (NPPG 8) in that it fails to satisfy the sequential approach outlined therein in relation to the location of new retail development and other more appropriate sites exist for retail developments of this scale within the town centre which would be more appropriate in terms of sustaining its vitality and viability 4. The proposed development, if approved, would set an undesirable precedent as it would be likely to encourage further applications for similar developments in locations which would prejudice the vitality and viability of the Town Centre