North Lan arkshire Council DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT Planning Applications for consideration of the Planning and Environment Committee Committee Date: 9 June 2004 Ordnance Survey maps reproduced from Ordnance Survey with permission of HMSO Crown Copyright reserved APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 9 JUNE 2004 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation 14 N/04/00329/FUL Mr C Ross Change of Use from Meeting Hall, Refuse Offices and Flat to Four Residential Flats 16 Edward Street Kilsyth 19 N/04/00488/FUL Mr R Shields Extension to a Dwellinghouse Grant 37 Grangeneuk Gardens Balloch, Cumbernauld 23 N/04/00550/FUL Mr David Gordon Erection of Residential Refuse (P) Development with Associated Landscaping, Parking, Infrastructure and Replacement Sports Provision Woodneuk Avenue / Junction M73 Gartcosh 37 N/04/00561/FUL Mr J Gibblin Extension to a Block of Flats Grant 7 Woodneuk Road Gartcosh 42 N/04/00630/FUL Mr & Mrs Burns Erection of a Conservatory Grant 24 Thorniecroft Place Condorrat 47 N/04/00631/FUL Mr Norman Norrie Alterations and Extension to a Grant Dwellinghouse 7 Nairn Way Westerwood, Cumbernauld 52 C/03/00844/FUL Mr Peter Campbell Erection of Residential Grant (P) Accommodation in association with Goat Breeding Business Land Adjacent to Garden Wood & to the North of Airdrie Road Caldercruix 58 C/04/00046/0UT Mr B Collum Erection of Dwellinghouse (in Refuse outline) on land west of 24 Arthur Avenue, Airdrie 63 C/04/00095/FUL Mr & Mrs Carraghar Erection of Front Porch, Two Grant Storey and Single Storey Rear Extension at 135 Old Monkland Road Coatbridge 68 C1041001 OOlFUL Persimmon Homes Erection of 18 Dwellinghouses on Grant (West Scotland) Ltd land at the Former Tinsley Wire Site, Souterhouse Road, Coatbridge 76 C/04/00157/FUL F. Gray Erection of Two Dwellinghouses Refuse on land south of 16-20 Quarry Road, Airdrie APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 9 JUNE 2004 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation 81 C/04/00194/OUT Mr James Greenaway Redevelopment of GaragelScrap Grant Yard for Residential Development at Forrestfield Garage 105 Airdrie Road Caldercruix 90 C/04/00404/FUL A i3 D Stores Change of Use of Shop to Hot Grant Food Takeaway at 224 Main Street, Caldercruix 95 C/04/00445/FUL James Smith Change of Use from Open Space Grant to Private Garden Ground at 16 Stonehaven Crescent Airdrie 100 C/04/00449/FUL Mr Peter Ross Erection of Extension to form Refuse Glazed Stair Enclosure at 16 Academy Street Coatbridge ML5 3AU 106 C/04/00468/FUL MM 02 (UK) Limited Erection of 10m high Grant Telecommunications Monopole and 2 associated cabinets on land SW of junction of Bankhead Avenue with Viewfield Road Coatbridge 110 C/04/00557/FUL Mr and Mrs McKenzie Rear extension to dwellinghouse Grant at 55 Drummore Avenue Carnbroe Coatbridge 115 C/04/00589/FUL Mr B Docherty Erection of Two Storey and Single Grant Storey Rear Extension at 52 Woodlands Drive Coatbridge 120 C/04/00616IFUL Mr Koon Yau Chan Change of Use from General Refuse Store to Hot Food Take Away at 4 Centre Street Glenboig 126 C/04/00625/FUL James Forsyth Erection of Vehicle Repair Shed Grant Coatbridge Ltd (in Retrospect) on land south of Kirkstyle, Woodside Street, Coatbridge 129 02 (UK) Ltd Erection of 15m High Grant Telecommunication Monopole and Associated Cabinets at land south of 6 South Caldeen Road Calder Street Coatbridge 133 C/04/00742/FUL The Segton Bar Extension to Public House at Grant 22 Sunnyside Road, Coatbridge 137 S/03/01814/FUL Barley Bank Ltd Construction Of 24 Hour Grant (P) Operational Class 5 Industrial Warehouse For Commercial Vehicle Servicing And Repairs With Ancillary Commercial Vehicle Sales Area and Parking Land East Of Bairdsland View Bellshill APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 9 JUNE 2004 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation 145 S/04/001 30/0 UT Mr & Mrs K Morrison Residential Development Refuse (P) Land At 19 - 23 Maryville View Uddingston 155 S/04/00269/FUL Mr & Mrs Freeman Two-Storey Side and Rear Grant Extension to Dwellinghouse 17 McCallum Gardens Bellshill ML4 2SR 160 S/O4/00300/FUL Mitchells & Butlers Conversion of Existing Play Barn Refuse Retail Ltd. Attached to Public House and Erection of New Extension to Form Twenty-Eight Bedroom Ancillary Hotel Strathclyde Park Inn Strathclyde Park Hamilton Road Motherwell 165 S/04/00391/FUL Mr & Mrs Guilley Erection Of Conservatory Grant 11 Triton Place Bellshill ML4 1JN 170 S1041004221FUL 02 (UK) Ltd Installation of 6 Additional Grant Antennae, 2 Transmission Dishes and Associated Ground Based Equipment Land At Braidhurst Industrial Estate Newhut Road Motherwell 175 S/04/00423/FUL Alex McClair Change of Use from Industry to Grant Swimming Studio Unit 19 Motherwell Business Centre Coursington Road Motherwell MLI 1PW 180 S/04/00432/OUT Mr & Mrs R Martin Residential Development Refuse (P) Land At Roundknowe Farm Lodge Roundknowe Road Uddingston 192 S/04/00446/FUL Mr Niall Tutton 3 Metre Extension in Height to Refuse Existing Structure and Installation of 3 Dual Polar Antenna Dishes and 2 Equipment Cabinets Land West Of Horsley Brae Wishaw 198 S/04/00448/FUL George Wimpey West Residential Development Grant (P) Scotland Ltd Comprising 14 Dwellinghouses and Partial Amendment to the Site Layout Previously Granted (No S/02/01603/FUL) Affecting 12 Dwellinghouses Land East Of Hattonrigg Road Bellshill APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 9 JUNE 2004 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation 207 S/04/0047O/FUL SMS Construction Residential Development of 8 No Grant Flats, 8 No Detached Dwellinghouses, 2 Serviced Plots and Formation of Access Road Former Benhar Primary School West Benhar Road Harthill Shotts ML7 5PB 212 S/04/00473/FUL Roman Road Hall Refurbishment and Extension to Grant Church Hall Roman Road Hall 14 Roman Road Motherwell 21 5 S/04/00486/FUL James Duncan Change of Use from Shop (Class Refuse 1) to Hot Food Shop 115 High Street Newarthill Motherwell MLI 5JH 220 S/04/00679/FUL 02 (UK) Ltd Installation of 12.5 Metre High Refuse Telecommunications Mast & Associated Ground Equipment Land South West Of The Loanhead Road Junction, A723, Carfin Motherwell 225 S/04/00713/FUL Vodafone Ltd Erection of 17.4 Metre High Grant Telecommunications Mast and Associated Ground Equipment 5 Hunter Street Bellshill ML4 1RN (P) N1041005501FUL If approved, refer to the Scottish Ministers. (P) C/03/00844/FUL If granted, requires a Section 75 Agreement (P) S/03/01814/FUL If granted, requires a Section 75 Agreement (P) S/04/00130/FUL If granted, refer to Scottish Ministers (P) S/04/00432/FUL If granted, refer to Scottish Ministers (P) S/04/00448/FUL If granted, refer to Scottish Ministers Application No: N1041003291FUL Date Registered: 10th March 2004 Applicant: Mr C Ross Meadowbank House Wyndford Road Ban knock FK4 IUD Develop ment : Change of Use from Meeting Hall, Offices and Flat to Four Residential Flats Location: 16 Edward Street, Kilsyth Ward: 66: Banton and Kilsyth East Councillor Tom Barrie Grid Reference: 271 909 6781 79 File Reference: N/04/00329/F UL Site History: Development Plan: The property is covered by residential policies in the Kilsyth Local Plan. Contrary to Development Plan: No Consultations: Representations: 1 Representation Letter Newspaper Advertisement: Not Required Comments: The application is for the change of use from meeting hall, offices and flat to four residential flats at 16 Edward Street, Kilsyth. The building was occupied until recently by the Salvation Army. The key issue in the consideration of this application relates to the lack of dedicated off-street parking for the residents of the proposed flats. The applicant has argued that the proposal will allow the effective reuse of an existing building and, by removing the hall use, will stop high on-street parking levels during meetings, concerts etc. Notwithstanding the above, it is considered that day to day parking associated with the four flats will lead to unacceptable on street parking pressure to the detriment of road safety. The lack of curtilage parking is contrary to North Lanarkshire Council's current roads guidelines. It is recommended that planning permission be refused. The Committee should note that the applicant has requested a site visit and a hearing prior to the determination of the application. g Hall 18 EdwdStrict Recommendation: Refuse for the Following Reasons:- 1. In the interests of road safety in that the lack of any curtilage parking for the occupants of the proposed residential units means that there will be an unacceptable increased level of daily on- street parking on Edward Street and surrounding roads. 2. The proposed development is contrary to North Lanarkshire Council Roads Guidelines in that no curtilage parking is proposed for the occupants of the proposed residential units. 3. That should planning permission be granted for this development a precedent may be set which would make it difficult for the planning authority to refuse similar applications with no curtilage parking. Background Papers: Application form and plans received 10th March 2004 Letter from Mr Colin McMenemy,l3 William Wilson Court, Kilsyth, G65 9PD received 23rd March 2004. Any person wishing to inspect these documents should contact Mr. Dean at 01236 616459. APPLICATION NO. N/04/00329/FUL REPORT 1. Description of Site and Proposal 1.1 This application is for the change of use from a meetin hall, offices and flat to four residential flats at 16 Edward Street, Kilsyth. The building, which was used until recently by the Salvation Army, consists of a two storey front section which contains the existing flat and offices and a single storey rear section which contains the hall.