the for of PO BOX 1379 VIC 3053 Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Defence Sub-Committee Medical Association for Prevention of War, Australia President Dr. Susan Wareham MBBS 15 Jacobs St, Evatt ACT 2617 Phone (h) (02) 6259 6062 (w) (02) 6241 6161 20 April, 2004 [email protected] President Elect 2005 Dr. Tilman Ruff MB BS(Hons), FRACP 52 Sussex St, Brighton VIC 3186 Mr Stephen Boyd Phone (h): (03) 9592 8643 (w) (03) 9721 4343 Vice-Presidents Secretary Dr. Harry Cohen AM, MBBS, FRACOG 121 Railway Pde, Subiaco WA 6008 Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Phone (h) (08) 9386 5268 (w) (08) 9381 9729 Defence and Trade Dr. Rachel Darken MBBS, DPM Dr. Gillian Deakin MD FRACGP MPH Parliament House Dr. Jason Garrood MBBS, FACRRM, DObst CANBERRA ACT 2600 Prof. Ian Maddocks AM, MD, FRACP 2ISA The Esplanade, Seacliff SA 5049 Phone (h) (08) 8296 6618 Dr. Bill Williams MBBS Secretary Dr. Carole Wigg MBBS, MBioeth. 4 St Ronan's Ct Dear Mr Boyd, Eltham VIC 3095 Phone (h) (03) 9439 7272 (w) (03) 9439 2967 Treasurer Thank you for extending the deadline to allow the Medical Association for Dr. Peter Sutherland MD, FRACP, FCCP Prevention of War (MAPW) Australia to submit our views to the Joint 37 Chrystobel Cres., Hawthorn VIC 3122 Phone (h) (03) 9818 4706 (w) (03) 9328 4285 Standing Committees inquiry into Australian-United States defence National Office, Executive Officer relations. Dimity Hawkins PO Box 1379 Canton (Melbourne) VIC 3053 Ph: +61 (0)3 8344 1637 Please find our submission attached. Fax: +61 (0)3 8344 1638 Web page: www.mapw.org.au Email: [email protected] We are more than happy to expand on or clarify the issues contained within Branch Coordinators the submission, though we note that the public hearings set down to hear Australian Capital Territory (MAPW) Dr. Rosie Yuille BSc MBBS(Hons) these matters have formally passed. If there is an opportunity to speak with 3 Shortiand Cres. Ainslie, ACT 2602 Phone (02) 6247 5742 members of the Committee however, we would appreciate the opportunity [email protected] for further discussion. New South Wales (MAPW) Dr. Gillian Deakin MD FRACGP MPH 38 Adelaide St, Wooilahra, 2025 Phone (02) 9389 5811 [email protected] Northern Territory (MAPW) Dr. Peter Tail MBBS, FRACGP Yours sincerely, PO Box 3903, Alice Spings NT 0871 Phone (h) (08) 8952 6160 (w) (08) 8951 4444 [email protected] Queensland (MAPW) Dr. Daniele Vilianas original signed II Langside Crescent, Hamilton, QLD 4007 Phone (h) (07) 38621009 [email protected] South Australia (Medact) Dimity Hawkins Dr. Jason Garrood MBBS, FACRRM, DObst Executive, Officer 11 Gould Rd, Stirling SA 5152 Phone (h) (08) 8339 5159 (w) (08) 8339 2677 Medical Association for Prevention of War (Australia) [email protected] Tasmania (Medact) Dr. Dougald McLean MD, FRANZCP 12 Derwent Waters, Claremont TAS 7011 Phone (h) (03) 6249 5778 [email protected] Victoria (MAPW) Assoc. Prof. Lou Irving MBBS, FRACP, FCCP 30 Downes Ave, Brighton VIC 3186 Phone (h) (03) 9596 6561 (w) (03) 9342 7000 [email protected] Western Australia (MAPW) Prof. Peter Underwood MD 31 Yilgarn Street, Shenton Park WA 6008 Phone (h) (08) 93817837 [email protected] Australian affiliate of International Physicians £c the Prevention of Nuclear War Patron: Sir William Refshauge FRCOG, FRACS, FRACP, PRAGMA, FRACOG for of (MAPW) 20 April "Tfte Defence sub-committee of the Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade will conduct an inquiry into Australia's defence relations with the US. Since World War Two, Australia and the United States (US) have developed strong defence relations. In particular, the last decade has seen a new level of defence relations encompassing Australian involvement in the first Gulf War, the invoking of the ANZUS Treaty, and Australian involvement in US led coalitions in Afghanistan and Iraq. The Defence Update 2003 commented that Australia's alliance with the US 'remains a national asset' and the 'United States' current political, economic, and military dominance adds further weight to the alliance relationship.'" by; Dr Sue Dimity MAPW MAPW Executive Officer P.O. Box VIC Australia Ph; +61 (0)3 8344 1637 or +61 475 465 [email protected] www.mapw.org.au Patron; Sir William Refshauge FRCOG, FRACS, FRACP, FRACMA, FRACOG 1. MAPW Australia submission - April 2004 Joint Standing Committee inquiry: Australia's Defence Relations with the United Summary of Principal Recommendations: MAPW (Australia) encourages the Australian government to work cooperatively within our region to truly strengthen the fabric of in the Asia-Pacific region. MAPW the Australian government to review our commitment to the ANZUS Treaty, RHAPW recommends an urgent examination be undertaken into how Australian participation in the Afghanistan and Iraq conflicts since 2001 has affected our security. MAPW recommends that Australia's policies and alliance with the US should be re-oriented to address the root causes of terrorism and the circumstances in which it flourishes; promote comprehensive human security, including its social, educational, economic, environmental and human rights dimensions; and strengthen the international rule of law, MAPW recommends that Australia use the leverage we are said to acquire through ANZUS to encourage the implementation of the legally-binding commitment of the US to work for the elimination of all nuclear weapons as agreed in the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). In particular, the steps outlined at the 2000 Review Conference of the NPT provide an excellent framework for this process. MAPW regards this as one of the most pressing security concerns not only for Australians, but for all people. Further, MAPW strongly urges the Australian Government to join those nations that are striving for the elimination of all nuclear weapons and other weapons of mass destruction, and to give the highest priority and attention to arms control and disarmament, particularly through UN and other multilateral fora. MAPW the Australian government to review the of the US-Australian Joint Defence Facility at Pine Gap at the earliest possible opportunity, especially in relation to the functions and control of the facility. Those functions associated with nuclear war fighting should be abandoned. MAPW strongly urges a reversal of the Government's decision for Australia to take part in the US Missile Defence system. As a preliminary step, this issue must have far greater parliamentary and public scrutiny. In particular, the following must be satisfactorily for the Australian people: » The nature and magnitude of the missile threat to Australia, rather than a simplistic and self-fulfilling 'we might have enemies in future' approach. • Possible ways of responding to the threat, including by the improvement of our relationships with potential enemies, and by a greater focus on missile control • The likely impact of MD on prospects for disarmament, especially nuclear disarmament « The role of Pine Gap in the proposed MD system • The likely impact of MD on the security of Australians • The possible social and economic cost to Australians, including the health, education and other essential services which are likely to be sacrificed to pay for our participation. 2. MAPW Aystralia submission - April 2004 Joint Standing Committee Inquiry: Australia's Defence Relations with the United States Introductions The Medical Association for Prevention of War (MAPW) Australia welcomes the opportunity to contribute to the Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade's inquiry into Australia's defence relations with the United States. The Medical Association for Prevention of War (MAPW) Australia is a national organisation of health professionals concerned with the effects of war and dedicated to the abolition of nuclear, biological and chemical weapons. Our organisation is committed to the promotion of health and human welfare through the avoidance of armed conflict. We promote the use of financial, technical and human resources for advancing health and welfare - not for developing and acquiring armaments. MAPW notes the opening words of the ANZUS Treaty: "Reaffirming their faith in the purposes and principles of the Charter of the United Nations and their desire to live in peace with all peoples and all Governments, and desiring to strengthen the fabric of peace in the Pacific Area" We believe that actions of the Governments of Australia and the US have not only failed to fulfil the purposes of the ANZUS Treaty, but have comprehensively undermined it. Therefore we believe that the 53-year formal defence alliance between the United States and Australia needs close review at this time. The MAPW submission to the Inquiry into Australia's defence relations with the United States will focus on the following areas: » The applicability of the ANZUS Treaty to Australia's defence and security • Australia's security needs • Australia's multilateral and international commitments « The value of US-Australian intelligence sharing and the US-Australian Joint Defence Facility at Pine Gap • The implications of Australia's dialogue with the US on missile defence and the development of space based military systems 3, Australia submission - April 2004 Joint Standing Committee Inquiry; Australia's Defence -Relations with the United The applicability of the ANZUS Treaty to Australia's defence security The ANZUS Treaty between Australia, New Zealand and the United States formally came into force in 1952. However, in 1975, the then New Zealand Prime Minister, David Lange, banned nuclear ships from visiting New Zealand's ports, which put the ANZUS Treaty under great strain . In 1986 New Zealand's participation in the ANZUS Treaty formally ended when the USA suspended its obligations under the Treaty2. There is absolutely no doubt that NZ was not compelled by its ANZUS commitment to accept into its harbours weapons which it regarded as a major threat to its own people and to global security.