Direct probe of the interior of an electric pion in a Cooper pair superinsulator M. C. Diamantini,1 S. V.Postolova,2, 3 A. Yu.Mironov,2, 4 L. Gammaitoni,1 C. Strunk,5 C. A. Trugenberger,6 and V.M. Vinokur7, 8 1NiPS Laboratory, INFN and Dipartimento di Fisica e Geologia, University of Perugia, via A. Pascoli, I-06100 Perugia, Italy 2A. V.Rzhanov Institute of Semiconductor Physics SB RAS, 13 Lavrentjev Avenue, Novosibirsk, 630090 Russia 3Institute for Physics of Microstructures RAS, GSP-105, Nizhny Novgorod 603950, Russia 4Novosibirsk State University, Pirogova str. 2, Novosibirsk 630090, Russia 5Institute of Experimental and Applied Physics, University of Regensburg, D-93025 Regensburg, Germany 6SwissScientific Technologies SA, rue du Rhone 59, CH-1204 Geneva, Switzerland 7Materials Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory, 9700 S. Cass Ave, Argonne, IL 60439, USA 8Consortium for Advanced Science and Engineering (CASE) University of Chicago, 5801 S Ellis Ave, Chicago, IL 60637, USA The nature of hadrons is one of the most fundamental mysteries of physics. It is generally agreed that they are made of “colored” quarks, which move nearly free at short scales but are confined inside hadrons by strong in- teractions at large distances. Because of confinement, quarks are never directly observable and, experimentally, their properties can be tested only indirectly, via high energy collisions. Here we show that superinsulating films realize a complete, one-color model system of hadron physics with Cooper pairs playing the role of quarks. We report measurements on highly controlled NbTiN films that provide a window into the interior of “Cooper pair mesons” and present the first direct evidence of asymptotic freedom, t Hoofts dual superconductivity confine- ment mechanism, and magnetic monopoles. INTRODUCTION superinsulation in titanium nitride (TiN) films [10, 12], niobium titanium nitride (NbTiN) films [13], and, albeit under a different name, InO films [14, 15]. The long- Quark interactions are described by quantum chromodynam- distance electromagnetic response of superinsulators is ex- ics (QCD), a non-Abelian gauge theory. A salient feature actly Polyakov’s compact QED [11] with the effective cou- of QCD is asymptotic freedom [1,2], the weakening of the pling constant interaction coupling strength at short distances (ultraviolet e2 = 4α f (κ)="g : (1) (UV) limit). At large distances (infrared (IR) limit), the eff quarks are thought to be confined within hadrons, which are Here α = e2=(~c) is the fine structure constant, κ = λ/ξ is physical observable excitations, by strings. Quarks them- the Ginzburg-Landau parameter of the superconducting ma- selves cannot be extracted from hadrons and be seen in iso- terial, with λ its London penetration depth and ξ its coher- lation. The mechanism for the transition from weak quark ence length and " is the dielectric permittivity of the normal interactions in the UV regime to confinement and strings in insulating state. Finally, g is the tuning parameter driving the IR regime remains an open issue. the system across the SIT, so that g ' 1 near the transition. ‘t Hooft [3] put forth an appealing confinement mecha- The function f (κ) is smooth and is O(1/κ) for κ 1 [11]. nism, the dual superconductivity where the condensate of Pure gauge compact QED in 2D is not renormalizable. How- magnetic monopoles [4] constricts the chromoelectric field ever, coupling the action to dynamical matter results in a into thin flux tubes binding quarks into mesons. He coined non-trivial fixed point [16, 17]. The same occurs in our case: the term “superinsulator”, as opposite to superconductor, for compact QED is induced by an underlying matter dynamics the confined quark matter with infinite (chromo)-electric re- from which it inherits the corresponding fixed point structure sistance. Polyakov showed that this confinement mecha- encoded in g. One can show [18, 19] that g, and hence also 2 nism occurs also in Abelian gauge theories, provided they the effective coupling eeff, have a Berezinskii-Kosterlitz- are compact and hence support topological excitations, mag- Thouless (BKT) (see [20] for a review) infrared (IR) fixed netic monopoles, which are instantons in 2D and solitons in point at the critical value gc, at which the string tension di- 3D [5,6]. The fact that the compact QED in the confinement verges. The tension, and thus the interaction strength, flow regime maps onto a confining string theory [7,8] makes it a to smaller values in the UV limit and, as a result, the induced perfect model for ’t Hooft’s dual superconductivity mecha- compact QED2 becomes asymptotically free, albeit this ap- nism. plies near the confining IR fixed point, instead of near the Remarkably, Abelian confinement emerged in a con- UV-free fixed point, as in QCD. densed matter realization of superinsulators, predicted first Confinement by strong interactions prevents a direct view arXiv:1906.12265v3 [cond-mat.supr-con] 27 Aug 2020 for Josephson junction arrays (JJA) in [9] and rediscovered on quarks despite that they move nearly free at small scales. in [10] in films experiencing the superconductor-insulator Since electric Cooper pair mesons are generated by much transition (SIT). These electric superinsulators constitute a weaker Coulomb interactions, they have a macroscopic di- new state of matter with infinite resistance at finite tem- mension and are accessible to direct experimental study. peratures due to electric strings binding Cooper pairs into Here we investigate superinsulators, which allow for a di- “electric mesons” [11]. Transport measurements revealed rect observation of the interior of electric mesons made of 2 Cooper pairs by standard transport measurements. We re- Ec1, enough electric pions can be created such that a chain of veal the transition from the confined to the asymptotic free them reaches from one end of the sample to the other. At this Cooper pair motion upon decreasing the distance between point, a single electric flux tube can traverse the sample end- electrodes, realizing the observation spatial scale. Using the to-end and the Meissner state is destroyed. For E > Ec1 elec- compact QED mapping we demonstrate the electric Meiss- tric fields penetrate the superinsulator in form of flux tubes ner effect and calculate the I-V-characteristics in the con- of typical width λel and the mixed state of the superinsula- finement regime. Comparing our experimental results with tor sets in. This is the dual state of the Abrikosov lattice in theoretical predictions yields the string tension and consti- superconductors. Finally, at the critical field Ec2, superinsu- tutes the first ever “look inside a meson,” directly confirming lation breaks down. asymptotic freedom and ’t Hoofts confinement mechanism by magnetic monopoles. Current-voltage characteristics RESULTS We start the derivation of the I(V) response by writing Strings and the Meissner and mixed states of a superinsulator down the compact QED potential for the interaction between Cooper pairs A quantitative theory of the response of a superinsulator to " ! !# a dc electric field rests on the fact that, in a superinsulator the c~π λel r U(r) = σ(T)r − + a ln − K0 ; (3) fundamental excitations are electric strings with linear ten- 24r r0 λel sion σ [11]. The electric Meissner state is obtained from the where the second term is the so-called Luscher¨ term [24]. dual analogue of the London equations [7,8, 21], describ- The third term is the screened 2D Coulomb potential (K is ing the electrodynamics of strings connecting charged parti- 0 the MacDonald function) that reduces to a ln(r=r ) at r λ cles. Deferring the technical derivation of the Meissner state 0 el and decays exponentially at r λ . At r>r , the Luscher¨ and its vanishing static electric permittivity, " = 0, to the el 0 SI term is negligible, so that U(r ) ' 0. Near the SIT, the end of the paper, we note here that the strings can be either 0 strength of the Coulomb potential becomes [11] closed, describing pure gauge excitations (the analogues of glueballs in QCD) [22] or open, representing Cooper pairs – 2 a = (4e =2πε0"d)( f (κ)=g) : (4) anti-Cooper pair dipoles (the analogues of mesons in QCD). The presence of such Cooper pair dipoles follows from ei- In the samples with sizes λel < L < ds, Cooper pairs feel nei- ther self-induced or imposed electronic granular structure of ther the string tension nor the Coulomb interaction screened a system supporting superinsulation. When a Cooper pair on the scale λel. As we show below this is the asymptotically tunnels from one granule to another it leaves behind a +2e free regime. charge excess representing a Cooper pair “hole”. This pic- To relate superinsulating parameters to observablep quanti- ture is fully supported by the experimental observation of the ties, note that strings of length ds have energy ~vσ. Hence charge BKT transition in such materials [13]. The energy to the energy to form a string chain spanning the entire system 2 create pure gauge excitations is ∆G = mv , with m being the is 2eVc1 = σL. Accordingly, one can introduce the lower gauge-field mass and v=c=(εµ)1=2 (µ ≈ 1 is the magnetic critical electric field for first string penetration the superin- permeability) being the light velocity in thep medium. Open sulating sample strings have the typical length d = O( ~v/σ) and a gap p s σ of the order O( ~vσ). The width of the strings is defined E = ; (5) c1 2e by the screening length λel = ~=mv [22]. Both ∆G and the string tension σ are expressed via the ultraviolet (UV) cutoff which corresponds to the lower critical field Bc1 in supercon- ' Λ0 = ~v=r0, where r0 ξ in films and is of order of the pla- ductors.