Tracing Information Flow from Open Quantum Systems in Integrated Waveguides Jan Dziewior,1, 2, 3 Leonardo Ruscio,1, 2, 3 Lukas Knips,1, 2, 3 Eric Mayer,4 Alexander Szameit,4 and Jasmin D. A. Meinecke1, 2, 3 1Max-Planck-Institut fur¨ Quantenoptik, Hans-Kopfermann-Straße 1, 85748 Garching, Germany 2Department fur¨ Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universitat,¨ Schellingstraße 4, 80799 Munchen,¨ Germany 3Munich Center for Quantum Science and Technology (MCQST), Schellingstraße 4, 80799 Munchen,¨ Germany 4Institut fur¨ Physik, Universitat¨ Rostock, Albert-Einstein-Str. 23, 18059 Rostock, Germany Quantum simulation is one of the core areas in the development of quantum technologies [1]. Among the various simulation platforms, integrated waveguides have proven to be a powerful and versatile tool. One important aspect of quantum simulation is the analysis of open quantum systems. In most practical applications it is in fact essential to understand and control the dynamics between the quantum system and its environment. Typical effects of interest for example involve decoherence or memory effects, which lead to non-Markovian behavior [2,3]. In this work we establish integrated waveguides as a tool for the simulation of open quantum systems. Using polarization as well as a photon’s path degree of freedom, we implement the coupling of a qubit with a low di- mensional discrete environment. Based on a measure of non-Markovianity, we define and quantify specific types of information and information transfer between system and environment. Experimentally we implement and verify non-Markovian evolution in an optical waveguide array and analyze types of information flow between system and environment realizable through integrated photonics. INTRODUCTION of photons, as well as the scalability necessary to match the complexity of more realistic systems. The simulation is im- In recent years, growing attention has been given to the in- plemented by identifying the polarization as the quantum sys- vestigation of open quantum systems [4–8], which are ubiq- tem and the path as the environment. This allows to effectively uitous in quantum science where many experimental systems realize an open system through the interaction between these have significant interactions with their environment. Although two degrees of freedom by harnessing polarization-dependent their description is significantly more involved [9] it allows to coupling. capture common effects as decoherence and other instances of The relatively simple structure of our integrated circuit al- state deterioration as well as memory effects. Especially for lows to analytically calculate the full time evolution of system quantum information applications, a point of special interest is and environment states, thus expanding the usual perspective the flow of information from and to the open system, usually applied to open systems, which usually is focused solely on encapsulated in the concept of Markovianity. This concept is the effective evolution of the open system. We clearly observe classically well-understood and identifies stochastic processes a non-Markovian evolution of the system qubit and go beyond as Markovian if they are memory-less, such that the future the usual analysis to investigate the flow of information to the of the process depends only on the present state, but not on environment. By extending the concept of the BLP criterion its past [10, 11]. However, a straightforward generalization we distinguish different types of information stored in our sys- of this notion to the quantum realm is not possible and thus tem, some of which are never transferred to the reduced state several nonequivalent definitions exist (see, e.g., Ref. [12]). of the environment. Furthermore, we propose a different type Among the various possibilities, the so-called BLP criterion of array with a decisively different type of information flow, for non-Markovianity [13–15] used in this work stands out in- where all types of information are removed from the system sofar as it gives a direct operational meaning to information and transferred to the environment. in open systems as the degree of distinguishability of systems states with optimal measurements. TRACING INFORMATION arXiv:2103.11994v1 [quant-ph] 22 Mar 2021 One approach to the study of open quantum systems is quantum simulation, where the behavior of a complex system is simulated in a simpler or more controllable system whose In the field of open system research, the focus naturally lies evolution parameters can be directly mapped to the system of on the dynamics of the open system, which is analyzed in interest. In the diverse field of quantum technologies, inte- terms of a differential quantum master equation or effective grated quantum photonics has been established as a stable and dynamical maps [11]. Information flow and memory effects versatile platform, which allows the implementation of digital are also always expressed in terms of information present in, as well as analog quantum simulations. Such waveguide struc- lost from or returned to the system. The question where this tures have already found applications, for example, in quan- information actually flows to, i.e., whether it actually is trans- tum computation [16], quantum communication [17, 18] and ferred from the system to the environment or becomes stored quantum chemistry [19]. in correlations between the two, is usually not of primary in- In this work we demonstrate the particular suitability of terest and treated as a side-note at most, see, e.g., [12]. evanescently coupled waveguide arrays [20, 21] for the sim- In our approach we extend the scope of investigation, by ulation of open quantum systems both experimentally and explicitly asking where the information lost from the system through numerical simulations. We employ laser-written flows to, in particular to what extent it reaches the environ- waveguides in silica which provide a high degree of control ment. Following the BLP criterion here we define informa- over both the path and the polarization degrees of freedom tion as the ability to distinguish between two quantum states. 2 Polarization Laser Tomography b) V polarization 1.0 2 0.8 1 sys 0.6 0 1.00 0.4 -1 0.2 -2 0.0 0.75 H polarization 1.0 2 0.8 0.50 1 0.6 0 0.4 distance trace waveguide number waveguide -1 0.2 0.25 -2 0.0 0 10 15 20 30 40 50 0.00 propagation length [cm] env 1.00 0.75 c) H 0.50 R M trace distance trace 0.25 P L 0.00 0 10 20 30 40 propagation length [cm] V FIG. 1. Experimental setup, measurements, and simulations. a) Experimental setup consisting of a linearly polarized 780 nm laser coupled to the chip via a PM fiber on a 6-axis stage. At the output of the chip, polarization state tomography is performed using a λ/4 waveplate, a polarizer and a CCD camera. The black dashed lines indicate the propagation lengths at which measurements were performed. b) Transverse probability distributions of photons in the waveguide array as function of the propagation length for the input states jHi and jV i. The red dashed line indicates the maximal measured propagation length. c) Simulated evolution of the polarization states for j 1i (upper turquoise curve) and j 2i (lower purple curve) inside the Bloch sphere. d) Polarization and path trace distance behavior with simulations and mea- surements for different pairs of orthogonal test states jHi and jV i (red curves), jP i and jMi (blue curves) as well as j 1i and j 2i (green curves). Any choice of two states ρ1 and ρ2 corresponds to a certain is subjected to this interaction. Depending on the choice of type and amount of distinguishing information encoded in the the pair, the interaction might distribute the distinguishabil- parameters which are different for the two states. This distin- ity differently between system and environment or even allow guishability is quantified via the trace distance D between the distinguishability only from joint measurements. Thus we can two states, defined as characterize the interaction by identifying types of informa- tion which are transferred in different ways. This analysis en- 1 1 p 2 D(ρ1; ρ2) = kρ1 − ρ2k = tr (ρ1 − ρ2) : (1) compasses the original application of the BLP-criterion to wit- 2 2 ness non-Markovian information backflow, in the case where, To trace the flow of information, we consider two initially for a time-evolving interaction, DS increases with time. perfectly distinguishable pure system states, the so-called “test states”. For the test state ρ1 (ρ2), a certain unitary in- S S teraction results in changed reduced states of system ρ1 (ρ2 ) EXPERIMENTAL REALIZATION OF OPEN QUANTUM E E SYSTEMS and environment ρ1 (ρ2 ). After the interaction, even via optimal measurements on the system alone it might become harder or even impossible to decide in which of the two test We implement the quantum simulation with polarized pho- states the system initially was. This corresponds to an infor- tons propagating in an array of evanescently coupled inte- mation loss from the system, quantified by the trace distance grated waveguides. The polarization and the path degrees of S S DS = D(ρ1 ; ρ2 ). Conversely, after the interaction it might freedom form a composite system which is equivalent to an become possible to infer the initial test state via optimal mea- open quantum system (polarization) coupled to an environ- surements on the environment, indicating information transfer ment (path). A sketch of the experimental setup is shown in E E to it, quantified via the trace distance DE = D(ρ1 ; ρ2 ). Fig.1a. We use an array of laser-written structures in fused To analyze how a particular interaction transfers informa- silica (SiO2), composed of five waveguides lying in a plane tion we choose different pairs of test states, where each state parallel to the surface of the chip.