"#$%&'()*'(+#!+,!-(./+.#%!0*.'(12%&!/3!! 4#56(#%!7(#)2%50*.'(12%!8*&&!79%1'.+:%'.3! ;('<!=+$%2!"+#(>*'(+#!-99.+*1<%& ?@:@2*'($%!A(&&%.'*'(+#! >@.!B.2*#)@#)!C%&!*D*C%:(&1<%#!E.*C%&! !"#$"%&%'%()&*+$(%+,-()!FA.G!.%.G!#*'GH! *#!C%.! 8*'<%:*'(&1<5=*'@.;(&&%#&1<*,'2(1<%#!I*D@2'J'! C%.!K#($%.&('J'!L+&'+1D! $+.)%2%)'!$+#! M@2(*#!-2%N*#C%.!71<*C%! )%/+.%#!*:!OPGQPGRPPQ!(#!A+.':@#C! L+&'+1DS!=+$%:/%.!OQOQ! https://doi.org/10.18453rosdok_id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`R5U_`a! b%*.X! OQRc! ! M+<*##%&!0*&&()!*#C!M@2(*#!71<*C%!1+#'.(/@'%C!%Z@*223!'+!'<(&!;+.D!F&<*.%C!,(.&'!*@'<+.&<(9HG! M@2(*#!71<*C%!'++D!9*.'!(#!'<%!C%$%2+9:%#'!+,!'<%!(#&'.@:%#'*2!&%'@9S!C(C!'<%!+9'(:(>*'(+#!*#C! :%*&@.%:%#'&S!*#*23>%C!'<%!C*'*!*#C!;+.D%C!+#!'<%!:*#@&1.(9'G! ! 0@/2(1*'(+#!O! [('2%X! !A3#*:(1! 1<*#)%&! (#! +9'(1*2! *#C! 1<%:(1*2! 9.+9%.'(%&! +,! '*.! /*22! *%.+&+2&! /3! *':+&9<%.(1!9<+'+1<%:(1*2!*)(#)! -@'<+.&X! V<@#2(#! 6(S! d@*#,@! \%S! M@2(*#! 71<*C%S! M+<*##%&! 0*&&()S! L*2,!T(::%.:*##S! A*9<#%!8%(C*#S!-2%N*#C%.!6*&D(#S!*#C!b(#+#!L@C(1<! M+@.#*2X! -':+&9<%.(1!V<%:(&'.3!*#C!0<3&(1&S!RPS!R_P5RU_! b%*.X! OQRP! ! M@2(*#!71<*C%!1+#'.(/@'%C!'<%!&(#)2%59*.'(12%!LB80"587!:%*&@.%:%#'&!*#C!.%$(&%C!9*.*).*9<&! (#!'<%!:*#@&1.(9'G! ! 0@/2(1*'(+#!_! [('2%X! !79*'(*223! 7<*9%C! 6*&%.! 0@2&%&! ,+.! '<%! 7(:@2'*#%+@&! A%'%1'(+#! +,! 0+231312(1! -.+:*'(1!\3C.+1*./+#&!*&!;%22!*&!0+&('($%!*#C!=%)*'($%!"#+.)*#(1!"+#&!(#!7(#)2%! 0*.'(12%!8*&&!79%1'.+:%'.3! -@'<+.&X! M@2(*#! 71<*C%S! M+<*##%&! 0*&&()S! L+/%.'! ".&()S! 7$%#! B<2%.'S! 8*.'(#! 7D2+.>S! [<+:*&!-C*:S!V<@#2(#!6(S!b(#+#!L@C(1<S!*#C!L*2,!T(::%.:*##! M+@.#*2X! -#*23'(1*2!V<%:(&'.3S!PRS!RQO^O5RQO^^! b%*.X! OQRP! ! M@2(*#!71<*C%!'++D!9*.'!(#!'<%!C%$%2+9:%#'!+,!'<%!(#&'.@:%#'*2!&%'@9S!C(C!'<%!:%*&@.%:%#'&S! *#*23>%C!'<%!C*'*S!9.%9*.%C!'<%!,()@.%&!*#C!;+.D%C!+#!'<%!:*#@&1.(9'G! ! ! ! """! V+#'.(/@'(+#&!'+!71(%#'(,(1!0@/2(1*'(+#&! ! ! 0@/2(1*'(+#!`! [('2%X! !L%&+#*#1%5%#<*#1%C!C%'%1'(+#!+,!:%'*2&!(#!*%.+&+2&!@&(#)!&(#)2%59*.'(12%!:*&&! &9%1'.+:%'.3! -@'<+.&X! M+<*##%&!0*&&()S!M@2(*#!71<*C%S!B22%#!"$*!L+&%;()S!L+/%.'!".&()S![<+:*&!?.f)%.5 g*C)%S!\%#C.3D!V>%1<S!8*.'(#!7D2+.>S![<+.&'%#!7'.%(/%2S!6%(!6(S!h@%!6(S!T<%#!T<+@S! \%#.(D!I*22).%#S!M*#*!8+2C*#+$*S!*#C!L*2,!T(::%.:*##! M+@.#*2X! -':+&9<%.(1!V<%:(&'.3!*#C!0<3&(1&S!OQS!cR_P5cRaO! b%*.X! OQOQ! ! M+<*##%&!0*&&()!*#C!M@2(*#!71<*C%!1+#'.(/@'%C!%Z@*223!'+!'<(&!;+.D!F&<*.%C!,(.&'!*@'<+.&<(9HG! M@2(*#!71<*C%!9%.,+.:%C!'<%!:%*&@.%:%#'&S!*#*23>%C!'<%!C*'*S!9.%9*.%C!'<%!,()@.%&!*#C!;+.D%C! +#!'<%!:*#@&1.(9'G! ! ! ! ! ! ! L+&'+1DS!C%#! ! ! ! ! K#'%.&1<.(,'!! ! ! ! ! ! ! "e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f)%.5g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f&2(#)S! *#C! 6@D*&! I.(%C%.(1(S! ,+.! 2+#)! *#C! (#'%.%&'(#)! C(&1@&&(+#&S! %&9%1(*223! +#! #+#5 &1(%#'(,(1!'+9(1&G! ! -!&9%1(*2!'<*#D&!/%2+#)!'+!*22!:3!,.(%#C&!*#C!,*:(23!;<+!<%29%C!:%!'<.+@)<!'<(&!'(:%!*#CS!+,! 1+@.&%S!'+!:3!9*.%#'&!;<+!*2;*3&!&@99+.'%C!:%G!I(#*223S!"!;*#'!'+!'<*#D!-##*56%#*!,+.!/%(#)! 3+@S!&@99+.'(#)!:%!*22!'<%!'(:%S!*#C!)($(#)!:%!'<%!&'.%#)'<S!"!#%%C%C!C@.(#)!:3!0<A!&'@C(%&G! ! [<*#D!3+@i! ! ! ! e! T@&*::%#,*&&@#)! ! T@&*::%#,*&&@#)! ! A(%! $+.2(%)%#C%! A(&&%.'*'(+#! /%,*&&'! &(1<! :('! C%.! B#';(1D2@#)! @#C! 49'(:(%.@#)! #%@*.'()%.! "+#(&*'(+#&:%1<*#(&:%#!(#!C%.!B(#>%29*.'(D%258*&&%#&9%D'.+:%'.(%!F7087HG!A(%&%![%1<#+2+)(%! %.:f)2(1<'!(#!B1<'>%('!C(%!:*&&%#&9%D'.+:%'.(&1<%!-#*23&%!C%.!1<%:(&1<%#!T@&*::%#&%'>@#)! %(#>%2#%.! 0*.'(D%2S! (#! -/<J#)()D%('! C%.! ]%;%(2()%#! E.fj%S! (#! %(#%:! )%&@#C<%('&5! @#C! D2(:*.%2%$*#'%#! g%.%(1<! @#'%.<*2/! $+#! OSa!k:! &+;(%! d@%22%#>@+.C#@#)! *':+&9<J.(&1<%.! -%.+&+2%G![.+'>!C%.!W/2(1<%#!@#($%.&%22%#!"+#(&*'(+#&:%'<+C%!C(%&%.!8%&&'%1<#(DS!(&'!C(%!-#*23&%! D*.>(#+)%#%.! 9+23>3D2(&1<%.! *.+:*'(&1<%.! ?+<2%#;*&&%.&'+,,%! F0-?&H! @#C! C%.%#! e%.'%(2@#)! (##%.<*2/!%(#>%2#%.!0*.'(D%2D2*&&%#!*@,).@#C!$+#!6(:('(%.@#)%#!C%.!"+#(&*'(+#!#@.!%(#)%&1<.J#D'! :f)2(1<G!T(%2!C(%&%.!-./%('!(&'!C(%!B#';(1D2@#)!#%@*.'()%.!"+#(&*'(+#&*#&J'>%!,W.!C(%! 7087!>@.! %,,(>(%#'%.%#!-#*23&%!+.)*#(&1<%.!@#C!*#+.)*#(&1<%.!71<*C&'+,,%!F0-?&S!8%'*22%HS!@:!>@!%(#%:! /%&&%.%#!*22)%:%(#%#!e%.&'J#C#(&!*':+&9<J.(&1<%.!-%.+&+2%!@#C!C%.%#!-@&;(.D@#)%#!*@,!C*&! ?2(:*! @#C! C(%! E%&@#C<%('! /%('.*)%#! >@! Df##%#G! ":! L*<:%#! C(%&%.! -./%('! ;@.C%! %.&':*2&! (#! 7087! C(%! 6*&%.! A%&+.9'(+#! F6AH! @#C! *#&1<2(%j%#C%! -#*23&%! $+#! 0-?&! :(''%2&! L%&+#*#>5 e%.&'J.D'%.! 8@2'(9<+'+#%#! "+#(&*'(+#! FLB80"H! :('! C%.! @#($%.&%22%#! 6*&%.! A%&+.9'(+#l"+#(&*'(+#! F6A"H!)%D+99%2'G!A%.!#%@*.'()%!"+#(&*'(+#&*#&*'>!%.2*@/'!C*/%(!C(%!-#*23&%!C%.!e%.'%(2@#)!$+#! 0-?&! *@,! B(#>%29*.'(D%2#! (#! ?+:/(#*'(+#! :('! D2*&&(&1<%#! 8%'<+C%#! >@.! d@%22%#>@+.C#@#)! (#! -/<J#)()D%('! C%.! 0*.'(D%2).fj%G! T@#J1<&'! ;@.C%#! /%(C%! I2@)>%('58*&&%#&9%D'.+:%'%.! %(#%&! 7087! 73&'%:&! >@.! A%'%D'(+#! 9+&('($%.! "+#%#! *@&! @#'%.&1<(%C2(1<%#! "+#(&*'(+#&9.+>%&&%#! $%.;%#C%'S! ;*&! %(#%#! e%.2@&'! C%.! #%)*'($%#! "+#%#! *@&! C%:! 6A"50.+>%&&! >@.! I+2)%! <*'G! A%:! )%)%#W/%.! &'%<'! ]%C+1<!C%.! "#,+.:*'(+#&)%;(##!>@.! e%.'%(2@#)! C%.! )%&@#C<%('&)%,J<.C%#C%#! 0-?&G! A(%&%! #%@*.'()%! "+#(&*'(+#&'%1<#(D! %.:f)2(1<'! #%@%! @#C! $%.'(%,%#C%! B(#/2(1D%! (#! 0*.'(D%2&3&'%:%S! ;(%! >@:! g%(&9(%2! '*.! /*22&G! A(%&%! 79%>(%&! /(2C%'! %(#%! K#'%.D*'%)+.(%! C%.! +.)*#(&1<%#! -%.+&+2%! @#C! '.(''! <*@9'&J1<2(1<! /%(! e%./.%##@#)&9.+>%&&%#! *@,S! C(%! *@1<! C(%! \*@9'@.&*1<%! C%.! 0-?5B:(&&(+#! C*.&'%22%#G! A%'*(22(%.'%! 0-?58*&&%#&9%D'.%#! )%/%#! C*/%(! \(#;%(&%!*@,!C*&!-/&+.9'(+#&5!@#C!-2'%.@#)&$%.<*2'%#!C(%&%.!0*.'(D%2!(#!C%.!-':+&9<J.%G!"#!%(#%.! ;%('%.%#! B$+2@'(+#&&'@,%! C(%&%.! 8%&&'%1<#(D! D+##'%#! %.&':*2&! 0-?&! :(''%2&! 6A5LB80"! &+;(%! +.)*#(&1<%!@#C!*#+.)*#(&1<%!g%&'*#C'%(2%!W/%.!%(#%#!$+22&'J#C()%#!6A"50.+>%&&!:('!9+&('($%#! @#C!#%)*'($%#!"+#%#!$+#!%(#>%2#%#!0*.'(D%2#!#*1<)%;(%&%#!;%.C%#G!A(%&%!8%'<+C%!/(%'%'!C*/%(! %(#%#S!/(&<%.!(#!C(%&%.![(%,%!#(1<'!:f)2(1<%#S!B(#/2(1D!(#!C(%!1<%:(&1<%!T@&*::%#&%'>@#)!C%&! 0*.'(D%2&! /%(! )2%(1<>%('()%.! g%&'(::@#)! C%.! e%.'%(2@#)! +.)*#(&1<%.! @#C! *.+:*'(&1<%.! 71<*C&'+,,%G!=%/%#!C%:!e+.D+::%#!@#C!C%.!e%.'%(2@#)!9*.'(D%2)%/@#C%#%.!0-?&!(&'!*@1<!C%.!