1 of 65 ABA.2461.2019.doc IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CRIMINAL ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.2461 OF 2019 Gautam Nav"ak$a, Age 6( )ear+% R,-.Flat N-.2% R-/ N'$*u E01"av'% N'2 D'"$3.110 019. A44"3cant !'*sus T$e Stat' -5 Maharasht*a R'+4-06ent 7ITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO.1 OF 2019 IN CRIMINAL ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.2461 OF 2019 T$e Stat' -5 Maharasht*a A44"3cant !'*sus Gautam Nav"ak$a R'+4-06ent D*.Yug M-$3t C$aud$*) 23t$ Ms.Ragi03 A$uja 23t$ Ms.Pay-+$3 R-) 5-* ap4"3cant 30 ABA N-.2461 -5 2019 and 5-* R'+4-06ent 30 I.A. N-.1,2019. S t.A*una S. Pa3% S4'13al Pub"3c P*-secut-* 5-* Stat',R'+4-06ent. D*.S$3!aj3 Pawar% ACP and I0!est3gat3ng Of531'*. CORAM : PRA;ASH D. NAI;% J. Date -5 R'+'*!3ng t$e Or6'* : 1<t$ D'1' 9'* 2019 Date -5 P*-0-uncing t$e Or6'* : 14t$ F'9*ua*) 2020 PC : 1. T$3+ 3s an ap4"3cat3-n 5-* ant3134at-*) 9ai" u06'* Sect3-n 4/< -5 C-6' -5 C*3 3nal P*-1'6ur'% 19</ =`C*.P.C?@. T$' ap4"3cant 3+ ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:19:44 ::: 2 of 65 ABA.2461.2019.doc a44*'$'0630& a**est 30 1-nnect3-0 23t$ CR N-.4 -5 201< *'&3+t'*'6 23t$ A3+$*a 9agh P-"31' Stat3-0% Pune. T$' 53*st 305-* at3-0 *'4-*t =`FIR?@ 2as "-6&'6 -0 <t$ Januar) 201<. T$' -55'01'+ 2'*' *'&3+t'*'6 und'* Sect3-0+ 1B/.A% B0B=1@=9@% 11(% /4 -5 I063an Penal C-6e. 2. T$' FIR 2as "-6&'6 9) -0' Tushar Ram'+$ Da ugade. It 2as a""'&'6 t$at t$'*' 2as a 4*-&*a ' at S$an32ar 7ada, at Pune -0 /1st D'1' 9'* 201( -*ganiC'6 9) El&ar Par3+$ad. T$e 53*st 305-* ant att'06'6 t$' 4*-&*a ' at ab-ut 2 4 -0 /1st D'1' 9'* 201(. T$'*' 2'*' 5'2 +4eak'*+% 1- 4'*'+% +30&'*+ and -t$'* 4'*5-* '*+ 4*esent -0 t$' stage. T$' 305-* ant 2as #0-230& ;ab3* ;ala Manch and 3t+ ' 9'*s. He $ad *ead ab-ut t$' -0 +-13al '63a a06 30 t$' 0'2+4ap'*s. S- ' -5 t$' 4'*5-* '*+ enact'6 +$-*t 4"ay+% 4'*5-* '6 6ances a06 sang +-ngs. A11-*630& t- t$' 53*st 305-* ant% t$' 4'*5-* ances 2'*' 4*-!-cat3!' 30 natur' and $ad '55ect -5 1*eat30& 1- una" 63+$ar -0). P*-!-cat3!' +4''1$'+ 2'*' 6'"3!'*'6. F'2 -98ect3-nab"' and 4*-!-cat3!' 9--#+ 2'*' #'4t 5-* sa"' at t$' !enue. T$' 9anned -*ganizat3-0 C- u03+t Part) -5 I063a =Mao3st@ =5-* +$-*t `CPI =M@?@ 2as 30+3&$t30& !3-"'01' 9) 1*eat30& 1- una" 63+$ar -0). T$' ' 9'*+ -5 ;ab3* ;ala Manch +4*ead $at*'6 t$*-ug$ t$'3* +-0&+% 4"ay+ and +4''1$'+ causi0& ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:19:44 ::: 3 of 65 ABA.2461.2019.doc '0 3t) 9et2''0 6355'*ent 1- unit3es. A+ a *esult% t$'*' 2'*' 3nstances -5 !3-"'01'% ar+-n and st-0' 4'"t30& 0ear B$3 a-;-*egaon. /. T$' FIR 2as *'&3st'*'6 against Sud$3* D$aval'% Sagar G-*#$'% Ha*+$al3 P-t6ar% D34ak D$enga"'% J)-t3 Jagtap% Ra '+$ Gay1$-* and -t$'*s. T$' 30!est3gat3-0 4*-1''6'6. Sect3-0 120.B -5 IPC 2as ad6'6 -0 6t$ Mar1$ 201<. T$' 30!est3gat3-0 2as t*ans5'**'6 t- C*3 e B*anch% Pune. 4. A11-*630& t- 4*-secut3-0% 6ur30& t$' 1-ur+' -5 30!est3gat3-0% sea*1$ 2as 1-06uct'6 -0 1(t$ A4*3" 201< at t$' *'+36ent3al 4*' 3+'+ and 2-*# 4"aces -5 R-na 73"+-0 =R/-.D'"$3@% Sur'06*a Gad"30& =R/-.Nagpur@% Sud$3* D$aval' =R,-.Mum9ai@% Ha*+$al3 P-t6ar =R/-.Mum9ai@% Sagar G-*#$' =R/-.Pune)% D34ak D$enga"' =R/-.Pune)% Ram'+$ Gay1$-* =R/-.Pu0'@% J)-t3 Jagtap =R/-.Pune). It 3+ al"'&'6 t$at 6ur30& t$' sea*1$ 6-cument+ 2'*' *'1-!'*'6 5*- t$'3* *'+4ect3!' 1- 4ut'*+,"apt-4+,4'0 6*3!'+, ' -*) car6+ etc.. D355'*ent 6-cument+ 2'*' 5-und t- $av' 9''0 1*eat'6 -* #'4t 30 t$' *'+4ect3!' 1- 4ut'*+,"a4t-4+,4'0 6*3!'+, ' -*) ca*6+,6'!31'+ -0 6355'*ent 6ates. T$' +'3C'6 a*t31"'+ 2'*' +'nt t- F-*'0+31 S13'01' Lab-*at-*) 5-* anal)+3s. T$' 1"-0'6 1-43'+ 2'*' *'1'3!'6 9) t$' 30!est3gat30& ag'01). A11-*630& t- 4*-secut3-0% 5*- t$' +'3C'6 and ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:19:44 ::: 4 of 65 ABA.2461.2019.doc *'1-!'*'6 at'*3al% 3t 2as *'!eal'6 t$at -t$'* 4'*+-0+ ar' al+- 4art -5 1*3 3nal 1-0+43*acy. Based -0 30!'+t3gat3-0 t$' 4*-!3+3-0+ -5 Sect3-0+ 1/% 16% 1(% 1<% 1<.B% 20% /< /9 a06 40 -5 U0"aw5u" Act3!3t3'+ =P*'!ent3-0 @ Act% 196( =`UAPA Act? 5-* +$-*t@ 2'*' ap4"3'6 -0 1(t$ May 201< against Sur'06*a Gad"30&% R-na 73"+-0% S$- a S'0% Mah'+$ Raut% C- *ad' M D M3"306 T'"tum96'% C- *ad' P*akash D Nav30 D Ritupan G-+2am3% C- *ad' Mangalu and C- *ad' D34u. Sea*1$ 2as 1-06uct'6 at t$' *'+36'01' -5 S$- a S'0 and Mah'+$ Raut -0 6t$ Jun' 201<. Sear1$ 2as 1ar*3'6 -ut at t$' 4"ace -5 *'+36'01' -* 2-*# 4"ace -5 a44"3cant% P.Aarava*a Rao =R,-. Hy6'*abad@% A*un F'**'3*a =R,-.T$ane)% Sud$a B$a*ad2aj =R/-.Far36aba6@% A'*0-n G-nsa"!es =R,-.Mum9ai@. B. T$' accused Su*'06*a Gad"30&% R-na 73"+-0 a06 Sud$3* D$aval' 2'*' a**est'6 -0 6t$ June 201<. A11-*630& t- t$' 4*-secut3-0% 9as'6 -0 301*3 3nat30& at'*3al% -t$'* 4'*+-0+ 2'*' ad6'6 as accused% !3z.P.Aarava*a Rao% A*u0 F'**'3*a, A'*0-0 G-nsal!'+% Sud$a B$a*ad2aj% a44"3cant% Ana06 T'"tum9ad' and Stan S2am). C$ar&' +$eet 2as 53"'6 against ar*est'6 accused und'* Sect3-0+ 121% 121.A% 124.A% 1B/.A% B0B=1@=9@% 11(% 120.B *,2 /4 -5 I063an Penal C-6' and und'* Sect3-0+ 1/% 16% 1(% 1<% 1<.B% 20% /<% /9 and 40 -5 UAPA Act. ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:19:44 ::: 5 of 65 ABA.2461.2019.doc 6. T$' a44"3cant 2as ad6'6 as an accused -0 2206 August 201<. T$' a44"3cant 4*'5'**'6 7*3t Pet3t3-0 N-.2BB9 -5 201< 9'5-*' D'"$3 Hi&$ C-urt +''#30& 3ssuance -5 7*3t -5 Habeas C-*4us 5-* $3+ *'"eas' 5*- cust-6) and quest3-030& t$' "egal3t) -5 $3+ a**est. T$' a**est -5 a44"3cant 2as stay'6 9) D'"$3 Hi&$ C-urt and 3nt'*3 4*-t'1t3-0 -5 $-use ar*est 2as &*ant'6. B) -*6'* 6at'6 1st Oct-9'* 201<% t$' a**est -5 ap4"3cant 2as set asi6' 9) D'"$3 Hi&$ C-urt. T$' sai6 -*6'* 2as 1$al"'0&'6 9'5-*' t$' Ho0?9"e Sup*' e C-urt 9) t$' 4*-secut30& age01). (. On 29t$ August 201< 7*3t Pet3t3-0 N-.260 -5 201< =R- 3"a T$a4ar a06 -t$'*+ As. U03-0 -5 I063a and -t$'*+ . =201<@10.SCC. (B/@ 2as 4*'5'**'6 9'5-*' t$' Ho0?9"' Sup*' ' C-urt 9) 53!' ' 3nent $3+t-*3ans and acad' 31+ 1$a""'0&30& t$' act3-0 -5 Maharasht*a P-"31' 30 *ai630& $- '+ and ar*est30& $uman *3&$t+ act3!3st+% 8-urna"3+t+% ad!-cat'+ and 4-"3t3cal 2-*#'*s. T$' &*3'!ance -5 t$' 4et3t3-0'*+ 2as t$at t$' act3!3st+ 0am'") Gautam Nav"ak$a =ap4"3cant@% Sud$a B$arad2aj% Aaravara Rao% A*un F'**'3*a and A'*0-0 G-nsal!'+ 2'*' ar*est'6 -0 2<t$ August 201< 5*- t$'3* $- '+ at N'2 D'"$3% Far36aba6% Mu 9ai% T$ane a06 Hy6'*abad 23t$-ut any 1*'639"' at'*3al and '!36'01' 30 1-0nect3-0 23t$ FIR ::: Uploaded on - 14/02/2020 ::: Downloaded on - 14/02/2020 15:19:44 ::: 6 of 65 ABA.2461.2019.doc N-.4 -5 201< *'&3+t'*'6 23t$ A3+$*a 9agh P-"31' Stat3-0% Pune. T$' 4*-secut3-0.*'+4-06ent -44-+'6 t$' 4et3t3-0 9) 53"30& *'4"). Dur30& t$' 1-ur+' -5 $ear30& -5 t$' sai6 4et3t3-0% 5-* a" a44"3cat3-0+ 2'*' 53"'6 -0 9'$al5 -5 Sud$a B$a*ad2aj% A*u0 F'**'3*a and A'*0-0 G-nsal!'+% 2$- 2'*' u06'* $-use a**est% stat30& t$at t$') ay 9' 4'* 3tt'6 t- 4u*sue t$' 2*3t 4et3t3-0 53"'6 9) t$' . T$' Ho0?9"' Sup*' ' C-urt $ad 'Ft'06'6 4*-tect3-0 -5 $-use a**est &*ant'6 t- t$' a44"3cant and -t$'*s.