Information 1 09 G 10904 F | ISSN 1434-8853 | März 2009 Institut der beim Europäischen Patentamt zugelassenen Vertreter Institute of Professional Representatives before the European Patent Office Institut des mandataires agréés près l’Office européen des brevets I – Information concerning epi 5 From the Secretariat II – Contributions from epi Members and other contributions 6 Problems arising from Rule 164 EPC 11 The WARF Decision – There is more to an invention than its claims 14 Invalidation proceedings as a counter-attack according to split litigation systems 20 Claim drafting for the EPC 2000 22 Zur Patentbarkeit von Medizintechnik-Verfahren in Japan 29 Book Review Institut der beim Europäischen Patentamt zugelassenen Vertreter Institute of Professional Representatives before the European Patent Office Institut des mandataires agréés près l‘Office européen des brevets Redaktionsausschuss / Editorial Committee / Commission de Rédaction Walter Holzer Terry Johnson Eva Liesegang Thierry Schuffenecker Postanschrift / Mailing address / Adresse postale epi Postfach 26 01 12 D-80058 München Tel. (089) 24 20 52-0 Fax (089) 24 20 52-20 e-mail: [email protected] www.patentepi.com Verlag / Publishing House / Maison d'édition Carl Heymanns Verlag Eine Marke von Wolters Kluwer Deutschland GmbH Luxemburger Straße 449 D-50939 Köln Tel. (0221) 94 373-7000 Fax (0221) 94 373-7201 Kundenservice: Tel. (02631) 801-2222 [email protected] www.heymanns.com Anzeigen / Advertisements / Publicité Carl Heymanns Verlag Eine Marke von Wolters Kluwer Deutschland GmbH Druck / Printing / Imprimeur Grafik + Druck GmbH, München ISSN 1434-8853 © Copyright epi 2009 Vierteljahreszeitschrift Abonnement im Mitgliedsbeitrag enthalten, für Nichtmitglieder € 46,00 p.a. zzgl. Versandkosten (€ 9,90 Inland / € 14,00 Ausland), Einzelheft € 18,00 zzgl.Versandkosten (ca. € 2,27 Inland/ ca. € 3,20 Ausland) je nach Heftumfang. Preise inkl. MwSt. Aufkündigung des Bezuges 6 Wochen vor Jahresende. Quarterly Publication Subscription fee included in membership fee, for non-members € 46,00 p.a. plus postage (national € 9,90 / abroad € 14,00), indivi- dual copy € 18,00 p.a. plus postage (national about € 2,27, abroad about € 3,20) depending on the size of the issue, VAT included. Cancellation of subscription is requested 6 weeks before any year’s end. Publication trimestrielle Prix de l’abonnement inclus dans la cotisation, pour non-membres € 46,00 p.a., frais d’envoi en sus (national € 9,90 / étranger € 14,00), prix à l’unité € 18,00, frais d’envoi en sus (national environ € 2,27, étranger environ € 3,20) selon le volume du numéro, TVA incluse. Résiliation de l’abonnement 6 semaines avant la fin de l’année. Das Institut ist weder für Erklärungen noch für Meinungen verantwortlich, die in Beiträgen dieser Zeitschrift enthalten sind. Artikel werden in der oder den Amtsprachen (deutsch, englisch, französisch) wiedergegeben, in der bzw. denen diese Artikel eingereicht wurden. The Institute as a body is not responsible either for the statements made, or for the opinions expressed in the publications. Articles are reproduced in the official language or languages (German, English or French) in which they are submitted. L’Institut n’est pas responsable des opinions exprimées dans cette publication. Les articles sont publiés dans celle ou celles des trois langues officielles (allemand, anglais ou français) dans laquelle ou lesquelles ils ont été proposés. The trade mark ”epi” is the property of the Institute and is registered nationally in Germany and as a Community Trade Mark at OHIM. Information 1/2009 Table of Contents 1 Table of Contents Editorial ......................2 The WARF Decision – There is more to an invention than its claims, by S. J Mitchell and G. W. Schlich . 11 I – Information concerning epi Invalidation proceedings as a counter-attack according to split litigation systems, by A. Clerix . 14 Reports Claim drafting for the EPC 2000, by N. Fox ....20 Zur Patentbarkeit von Medizintechnik-Verfahren Disciplinary Committee Report, by P. Rosenich....3 in Japan, by S.R. Huebner .............22 One patent too many in your portfolio?, by B. Batchelor and S. Jones ............24 European Qualifying Examination European Patent Attorney, by C.E. Eder ......28 epi Tutorials 2009..................4 Book Review Information from the Secretariat Procedural law under the EPC 2000, a practical guide for patent professionals and candidates for Next Board and Council meetings ..........5 the EQE, by P. Watchorn and Andrea Veronese Contact data of EPO Legal division .........5 – Review by D. Harrison ..............29 Deadline 2/2009 ..................2 „Pagenberg/Beier, Lizenzverträge – License List of professional Representatives as Agreement“ 6. Auflage 2008 – Review of 31.12.2008 ...................5 by Prof. Lehmann .................30 Themed edition 3/2009 .............. 10 VESPA/VIPS Prüfungstraining für die Europäische Eignungsprüfung 2010 .............. 32 Letters to the Editor epi Disciplinary bodies and Committees ...... 33 epi Board.....................U3 Comments on the article „Diamanten, Peanuts und Patente“ (epi Information 4/2008), by K. Pinnekamp .................31 II – Contributions from epi Members and other contributions Articles Problems arising from Rule 164 EPC, by E. A. Kennington ................6 2 Editorial Information 1/2009 Editorial T. Johnson (GB) There is a popular radio programme in the U.K. called less task, and I venture none more so than following Oral „Just a Minute“. Four panellists are asked in turn by a Proceedings, where often track has to be kept of count- Chairman to speak for one minute on a topic (previously less Requests. unknown) given them by the Chairman. Each contestant But are we alone thinking that, since the Written has to speak with relevance to the topic and inter alia Decision is also issued and that this is invariably detailed without hesitation, or repetition. If the speaking contest- yet germane to the proceedings in question, Minutes are ant errs, the other contestants can interrupt. Points are superfluous, not to say in some cases irrelevant. In our awarded for valid interruptions and for being the experience, they seem to be getting shorter, and without speaker at the end of the minute allotted to the topic. meaningful input. We know of one case where the The programme is a comedy programme perhaps Minutes of a 10-hour Oral Proceeding were just ten lines peculiar to the so_called British sense of humor. long, – one line per hour! „What?“ dear reader, you may say, has this to do with the EPC? Should the Minute be up? My answer is „Minutes“ those reports issued accord- On a different note we take a minute to welcome Mr. ing to Rule 124EPC by a Board following Oral Proceed- Benoît Battistelli who has been appointed the next Chair- ings, and which are provided to the party(ies) to the man of the Administrative Council. We wish him well for proceedings. his three year term starting on 5th March, 2009. At the As someone who has written Minutes of countless same time, we also wish the outgoing Chairman, Mr. meetings, I know that their production can be a thank- Roland Grossenbacher, every good wish for the future. Nächster Redaktions- Next deadline for Prochaine date limite pour schluss für epi Information epi Information epi Information Informieren Sie bitte den Redaktion- Please inform the Editorial Commit- Veuillez informer la Commission de sausschuss so früh wie möglich über tee as soon as possible about the rédaction le plus tôt possible du sujet das Thema, das Sie veröffentlichen subject you want to publish. Dead- que vous souhaitez publier. La date möchten. Redaktionsschluss für die line for the next issue of epi Infor- limite de remise des documents pour nächste Ausgabe der epi Information mation is 11 May 2009. Documents le prochain numéro de epi Informa- ist der 11. Mai 2009. Die Dokumente, for publication should have reached tion est le 11 mai 2009. Les textes die veröffentlicht werden sollen, the Secretariat by this date. destinés à la publication devront être müssen bis zum diesem Datum im reçus par le Secrétariat avant cette Sekretariat eingegangen sein. Issue 2-2009 will be available on-line date. on the epi website by the end of Die Ausgabe 2-2009 wird auf der epi June 2009. Kindly note that your L’édition 2-2009 sera disponible en Website ab Ende Juni 2009 on-line personal copy will reach you by mid- ligne sur le site de l’epi à la fin de du verfügbar sein. Bitte beachten Sie, Juli 2009. mois de juin 2009. Merci de noter dass Sie das Heft Mitte Juli 2009 que vous recevrez votre numéro mi- erhalten werden. juillet 2009. Information 1/2009 Reports 3 Report of the Disciplinary Committee P. Rosenich (LI) Chairman 1. epi Disciplinary Committee Fixed Chambers Council, this means that the new incoming member will not be able not participate in our annual DC-meeting As from October 2005 the Chambers were: (which takes place just before the Council meeting). These meetings are especially useful for new members in Chamber Kinsella GB order to get as quickly as possible into their functions as Chamber Monain FR full members of our Chambers. Chamber Katschinka DE For that reason Council was asked, if it could approve Chamber Fröhling GB a „preliminary participation“ of a proposed new Chamber Norgaard GB Member at a DC-meeting. Chamber Rosenich GB, DE Of course such „preliminary participation“ would only work if there is only one candidate from the respective As from October 2008 the Chambers are: country available (or nominated). If Council decided not in the negative and DC found Chamber Kinsella GB that such invitations are possible at the discretion of the Chamber Monain FR Chairman of DC. Chamber Markó DE Chamber Fröhling GB 3. Meeting of Disciplinary Committee – for In- Chamber Norgaard GB formation only Chamber Rosenich DE,GB The DC discussed a number of topics in its meeting and Information concerning epi Chamber Gil Vega GB reported the outcome of these discussions directly at the Chamber Pop FR Council.