METRIC-AFFINE GRAVITY AND COSMOLOGY/ ASPECTS OF TORSION AND NON-METRICITY IN GRAVITY THEORIES by Iosifidis Damianosa Institute of Theoretical Physics Physics Department of Aristotle University of Thessaloniki A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of arXiv:1902.09643v1 [gr-qc] 25 Feb 2019 Philosophy Supervised by Anastasios Petkou and Christos Tsagas January 2019 aemail:diosifi[email protected] "Don't wish it was easier, wish you were better" Jim Rohn ii Preface General Relativity is, in its own right, a very elegant and mathematically well established Theory of Gravity. Even though it has passed many tests, it has some serious drawbacks and therefore cannot be regarded as the fundamental Theory to describe Gravitation. As it is well known the basic drawbacks of GR are, the inability to explain the late time Cosmological acceleration, the dark matter problem, the early Universe description and the fact that it is not renormalizable. Along with the aforementioned problems, there is also the need for the Grand Unification, that certainly demands that GR should be modified, at least in the microscopic world. Therefore, the past few years, there was a tremendous interest in Modified Gravity. In general, there are many ways to modify General Relativity. To name a few, one can consider extra fields (scalar, vector,... etc), extend the spacetime dimensions (n > 4), generalize the geometry to include torsion and so on (see for instance [1] for a more extensive discussion). Among the many approaches to modify gravity, in this Thesis we will consider modifications that arise due to the generalization of the spacetime geometry. In particular, we will study what is broadly known as Metric-Affine Theories of Gravity(MAG). The main feature of MAGs is that the underlying geometry is no longer Riemannian and possesses both torsion and non-metricity. In this generalized non-Riemannian geometry vectors rotate (torsion) and undergo a length change (non-metricity) when transported on the manifold (see detailed discussion in 1st Chapter). The geometry on the manifold can λ be fully described once a metric gµν and an independent affine connection Γ µν are given. In this framework fM; g; Γg, the metric and the connection are not a priori related and a relation among them may be found only after solving the field equations. This general procedure for solving for the affine connection for generic actions is also presented in this Thesis. The main advantage of MAG that distinguishes it from the rest of Modified Gravity Theories is that the modifications in this case are naturally produced by the generalization iii of the geometry and have a well established geometrical meaning. The new degrees of freedom that come from torsion and non-metricity are beautifully encoded in the affine connection. In addition, in the general Metric-Affine formalism, the connection couples with the matter fields and the inclusion of particle's spin is easily formulated into the Theory. This is what happens for instance in the so-called Einstein-Cartan Theory where the space apart from curvature, also possesses torsion (but zero non-metricity). There also exists the Weyl space which is torsionless but with curvature and a specific part of non-metricity. Therefore we see that many theories can be obtained as special cases of the general MAG. Another great advantage of Metric-Affine Gravity is that, when written in the language of differential forms, it can be seen as a gauge theory of gravity. Furthermore, Metric-Affine Gravity is an excellent tool that allows microscopic properties of matter to act as sources for the gravitational field since it takes into account the intrinsic characteristics of particles such as spin , dilation current, hypercharge etc.(as mentioned above). For more information on the advantages and motivation for MAG see [2]. Even though the extensive study of MAG has started a few decades ago there are many things that need to be addressed. To name a few, what is the role of projective invariance and its relevance to physics(if there is any) and how can we break it?. In addition, since both torsion and non-metricity can be determined once a connection is given, how can one solve for the affine connection for general theories? Can we classify Theories with dynamical/non-dynamical connections? Under which circumstances a connection becomes dynamical? How does the presence of torsion and non-metricity affects the Raychaudhuri equation and which are the most general modified Friedmann equations with torsion and non-metricity? Can we formulate actions that are conformally and/or projective invariant? The above questions are some of the many that are addressed in this thesis. To be more specific let us sketch the most important novel features about MAG that are presented in this thesis • A very detailed and extensive introduction into the generalized geometry is presented. The geometrical role of torsion and non-metricity is discussed in depth and many illustrative examples (most of which were absent from the literature) are given. • A new way to break the projective invariance in Metric-Affine f(R) theories of gravity is proposed, that treats the torsion and non-metricity vectors on equal footing. iv • The general proof on how to solve for the affine connection in MAG is presented (for the first time in the literature) and the results are collected in 3 subsequent Theorems. • The classification of a broad class of Theories that yield Einstein's Gravity in vacuum is presented and proved. • A method to excite torsion by coupling surface terms with scalar is extended to include also non-metricity. • The Kinematics of of torsion and non-metricity in FRW Universes is presented. The most general expression for non-metricity1 in such spaces is derived along with the modified Friedmann equations with non-metricity. • The peculiar Metric-Affine f(R) / R2 is extensively studied and the duality between torsion and non-metricity is derived for such Theories. The key point that allows to map vectorial torsion to Weyl non-metricity is found and a proof of the map is given. The cosmological solutions are also found for this peculiar case. • The most general form of the Raychaudhuri equation is derived (for the first time in the literature) for spaces of arbitrary dimension that have both torsion and non- metricity. The result is applied to Cosmology and Cosmological solution in the pres- ence of torsion and non-metricity are found respectively. For completeness we also derive the vorticity evolution equation. • Scale Transformations in Metric-Affine Geometry are considered and scale invariant Theories are constructed with respect to the three possible scale transformations in the Metric-Affine Geometry. The identities that come along with the Invariances are obtained and the parameter space, of Theories that respect each transformation, is found. Of course, the above list is but a very small contribution to the fruitful field called Metric-Affine Gravity and many other questions need to be answered. We will touch upon future projects and possible extensions of this study in the last chapter. 1For torsion the results were, for long time, known in the literature. v 0.1 Publications/Collaborations The content of this PhD Thesis is mainly based (but not restricted to) on the following publications (newest first) 1. "Exactly Solvable Connections in Metric-Affine Gravity" [3] 2. "Scale Transformations in Metric-Affine Geometry" [4] 3. "Torsion/non-metricity Duality in f (R) Gravity" [5] 4. "Friedmann-like Universes with Torsion" [6] 5. "Raychaudhuri Equation in Spacetimes with Torsion and Non-metricity"[7] 6. "Self tuning scalar tensor black holes" [1] where (most of) the publications were done in a collaboration with the respective Professors and Colleagues (see References and also Acknowledgments for more details). vi 0.2 Conventions/Notations Conventions/Notations ν δµ Kronecker's delta "µνρσ Totally antisymmetric Levi-Civita symbol p µνρσ = −g"µνρσ Levi-Civita tensor δµ1µ2...µk Generalized Kronecker delta ν1ν2...νk α gµν = gµν(x ) Metric tensor of general spacetimes g = det(gµν) Determinant of the metric tensor µν T r(Aµν) = g Aµν Generalization of the trace of a matrix Aµν in curved spacetimes ηµν = diag(−1; 1; 1; 1) Minkowski metric tensor α Γ µν Linear Affine Connection ~α Γ µν Levi-Civita connection (or Christoffel symbols) rµ Covariant derivative with respect to the Affine Connection µ R νρσ Riemann (or curvature) tensor λ λ Sµν ≡ Γ [µν] Torsion tensor Qαµν ≡ −∇αgµν Non-metricity tensor Ψ Collectively denotes matter fields L Lagrangian density δS [g;Γ;Ψ] p2 M Tµν ≡ − −g δgµν Energy-momentum (or stress-energy) tensor µν δS [g;Γ;Ψ] p2 M ∆ ≡ − λ Hyper-momentum Tensor λ −g δΓ µν a(t) Scale factor a_ H(t) ≡ a Hubble parameter p(t) Pressure of a perfect fluid ρ(t) Density of a perfect fluid ; φ Scalar fields κ = 8πG Gravitational constant G Newton's Gravitational constant 2 −1 mpl = κ Squared Plank mass A list of some of the conventions/notations that are used throughout the thesis is given above. We try to be as standard and self-consistent as possible with the conventions and vii there is an indication whenever a different notation is used. We furthermore adopt natural units, that is, c = 1 = ~. Notice also, that we have chosen the convention ηµν = diag(−1; 1; 1; 1) for the Minkowski metric tensor as this is the most common choice made in GR textbooks. As a result, for the Robertson-Walker metric we have2 dr2 ds2 = −N 2(t)dt2 + a2(t) + r2(dθ2 + sin2 θdφ2) (1) 1 − Kr2 We denote the symmetric and antisymmetric parts of a tensor with round and square brack- ets respectively.