( 1 ) cra43.20 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION NO. 43 OF 2020 Maharash ra Gra!"# Ba#$ .. A%%&"'a# Thr()*h " s R+*"(#a& Ma#a*+r, -(r"*"#a& Mr.Ash($ s.(. Na#/&a& Ga a#", /+0+#/a# 1 A*+. 23 4+ars, O''. S+r5"'+, R.(. La )r, D"s . La )r. V+rs)s A#6ar s.(. Ha7" A7"7 8a'h'h", .. R+s%(#/+# A*+. 49 4+ars, O''. B)s"#+ss, -(r"*"#a& R.(. :)r+sh" Ma#;"&, Gra"# Mar$+ , %&a"# "001 Ga#7*(&a", La )r, D"s . La )r. Mr.M"&"#/ M. Pa "& <B++/$ar=, A/5('a + 0(r h+ a%%&"'a# . Mr.G.R. S4+/, A/5('a + 0(r h+ r+s%(#/+# . CORAM > N.J.JAMADAR, J. RESERVED ON > [email protected]? PRONOUNCED ON > 23.04.202? J U D G M E N T >A 0?. Th+ &+*a&" 4, %r(%r"+ 4 a#/ '(rr+' #+ss (0 a# (r/+r %ass+/ B4 h+ &+ar#+/ 9 h J("# C"5"& J)/*+, J)#"(r D"5"s"(#, La )r, (# a# a%%&"'a "(# -ECh.?91 0(r r+7+' "(# (0 %&a"# , )#/+r Or/+r VII R)&+ ??</= (0 h+ C(/+ (0 C"5"& Pr('+/)r+, ?@03 - h+ C(/+1, 6h+r+B4 h+ &+ar#+/ ::: Uploaded on - 23/04/2021 ::: Downloaded on - 23/04/2021 22:12:03 ::: ( 2 ) cra43.20 C"5"& J)/*+ 6as %+rs)a/+/ ( r+7+' h+ a%%&"'a "(# %r+0+rr+/ B4 h+ %+ " "(#+r./+0+#/a# ABa#$, "s assa"&+/ "# h"s r+5"s"(# a%%&"'a "(#. 02. Th+ Ba'$*r()#/ 0a' s &+a/"#* ( h"s r+5"s"(# a%%&"'a "(# 'a# B+ s a +/, "# Br"+0, as )#/+r >A a1 Th+ r+s%(#/+# .%&a"# "00 /+a&s "# h+ B)s"#+ss (0 r"'+. I# h+ 4+ar 20?3, h+ %&a"# "00 ha/ a5a"&+/ 'ash 'r+/" 0a'"&" 4 (0 Rs.22 &a$hs 0r(! h+ /+0+#/a# . Th+ &"!" 'a!+ ( B+ +#ha#'+/ B4 Rs.20 &a$hs "# h+ 4+ar 20?4. A*a"#s h+ sa"/ 0a'"&" 4, h+ %&a"# "00 ha/ !(r *a*+/ "!!(5aB&+ %r(%+r 4 B+"#* %&( N(.2 "# &a#/ S)r5+4 N(.334.B.2 -s)" %&( 1. Th+ s)" %&( "# 6h"'h s+')r" 4 "# +r+s 6as 'r+a +/ 6as 5a&)+/ a Rs.?,20,00,000.A. Th+ %&a"# "00 '(!!" +/ /+0a)& "# %a4!+# (0 h+ "#s a&!+# s a#/ h+ "# +r+s a''r)+/ (# h+ a!()# a/5a#'+/ B4 h+ Ba#$. Th+ /+0+#/a# .Ba#$ "ss)+/ a #( "'+ (0 sa&+ (0 h+ s)" %&( , "# 6h"'h s+')r" 4 "# +r+s has B++# 'r+a +/, B4 "ss)"#* a ::: Uploaded on - 23/04/2021 ::: Downloaded on - 23/04/2021 22:12:03 ::: ( 3 ) cra43.20 %)B&"'a "(# "# h+ #+6s%a%+r /a +/ 30 h A)*)s , 20?3. B1 Th+ %&a"# "00 "#s " ) +/ a s)" B+"#* RCS N(.4D9 (0 20?3 6" h h+ ass+r "(#s ha h+ /+0+#/a# .Ba#$ %r('++/+/ ( "#5($+ h+ %r(5"s"(#s )#/+r h+ S+')r" "sa "(# a#/ R+'(#s r)' "(# (0 F"#a#'"a& Ass+ s a#/ E#0(r'+!+# (0 S+')r" 4 I# +r+s A' , 2002 -A' , 20021 "# a h"*hha#/+/ !a##+r a#/ ) +r /"sr+*ar/ ( h+ (00+r !a/+ B4 h+ %&a"# "00 ( '&+ar h+ /)+ a!()# )#/+r (#+ "!+ s+ &+!+# %&a#. Th+ %&a"# "00 a5+rr+/ ha h+ /+0+#/a# ha/ #( "ss)+/ #( "'+ )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<2= (0 h+ A' , 2002, 6h"'h "s a %+r+!% (r4 r+E)"r+!+# B+0(r+ "#" "a "#* !+as)r+s )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<4= (0 h+ A' , 2002. Th+ /+0+#/a# .Ba#$ %r+%ar+/ a 0a&s+ r+'(r/ ( sh(6 ha " has (B a"#+/ %(ss+ss"(# (0 h+ s)" %&( , 6h"'h 6as ( B+ s(&/ B4 6a4 (0 a)' "(# "# +r!s (0 #( "'+ (0 sa&+ /a +/ 30 h A)*)s , 20?3. '1 Th+ /+0+#/a# .Ba#$ %r+0+rr+/ a# a%%&"'a "(# -ECh.?91 0(r r+7+' "(# (0 h+ %&a"# as 7)r"s/"' "(# (0 ::: Uploaded on - 23/04/2021 ::: Downloaded on - 23/04/2021 22:12:03 ::: ( 4 ) cra43.20 h+ C"5"& C()r ( +# +r a"# a#/ r4 h+ s)B7+' !a +r (0 h+ /"s%) + "s +C%r+ss&4 Barr+/ B4 h+ %r(5"s"(#s (0 S+' "(# 34 (0 h+ A' , 2002. S"#'+ s%+'"a& 0(r)!s ha5+ B++# '(#s " ) +/ ( +# +r a"# h+ /"s%) + ar"s"#* () (0 !+as)r+s a$+# )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<4= (0 h+ A' , 2002, h+ C"5"& C()r has #( 7)r"s/"' "(# ( +# +r a"#, r4 a#/ /+'"/+ h+ s)" . Th)s, h+ %&a"# B+ r+7+' +/. /1 Th+ %&a"# "00 r+s"s +/ h+ a%%&"'a "(#. I 6as '(# +#/+/ ha h+ Tr"a& C()r ha/ '(#s"/+r+/ h+ 'ha&&+#*+ ( h+ 7)r"s/"' "(# (0 h+ C()r 6h"&+ /+'"/"#* h+ a%%&"'a "(# 0(r "# +r"! "#7)#' "(#, a#/ r+s ra"#+/ h+ /+0+#/a# 0r(! '(#/)' "#* a)' "(# sa&+ (0 h+ s)" %r(%+r 4 "&& /+'"s"(# (0 h+ s)" . Th+ a%%+a& h+r+ a*a"#s a&s( 'a!+ ( B+ /"s!"ss+/. Th)s, h+ /+0+#/a# 'a##( a*a"# a*" a + h+ "ss)+ (0 7)r"s/"' "(# (0 h+ C"5"& C()r ( +# +r a"# h+ s)" . +1 Th+ &+ar#+/ C"5"& J)/*+, a0 +r a%%ra"sa& (0 h+ r"5a& '(# +# "(#s a#/ s)B!"ss"(#s a'r(ss h+ Bar, 6as ::: Uploaded on - 23/04/2021 ::: Downloaded on - 23/04/2021 22:12:03 ::: ( 5 ) cra43.20 %+rs)a/+/ ( r+7+' h+ a%%&"'a "(# 0(r r+7+' "(# (0 h+ %&a"# . Th+ &+ar#+/ C"5"& J)/*+ 6as (0 h+ 5"+6 ha h+ %r(5"s"(#s (0 h+ s a ) + "# E)+s "(#F A' , 2002, ha5+ #( B++# '(!%&"+/ as h+ %&a"# "00 '&a"!+/ ha h+ /+0+#/a# ha/ #( "ss)+/ #( "'+ )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<2= (0 h+ A' , 2002 a#/ h)s h+ 7)r"s/"' "(# (0 h+ C"5"& C()r 6as #( ()s +/. I 6as 0)r h+r (Bs+r5+/ ha h+ E)+s "(# as ( 6h+ h+r s)'h #( "'+ 6as "#0a' "ss)+/ B4 h+ /+0+#/a# 6as a !a +r 0(r r"a& a#/, h)s, h+ a%%&"'a "(# 'a!+ ( B+ r+7+' +/. B+"#* a**r"+5+/ B4 a#/ /"ssa "s0"+/ 6" h h+ a0(r+sa"/ (r/+r, h+ /+0+#/a# .Ba#$ has "#5($+/ h+ r+5"s"(#a& 7)r"s/"' "(# (0 h"s C()r . 03. I ha5+ h+ar/ Mr.Pa "&, &+ar#+/ C()#s+& 0(r h+ a%%&"'a# ./+0+#/a# a#/ Mr. S4+/, &+ar#+/ C()#s+& 0(r h+ r+s%(#/+# .%&a"# "00. 04. Mr.Pa "&, &+ar#+/ C()#s+& 0(r h+ a%%&"'a# 6()&/ )r*+ ha h+ &+ar#+/ C"5"& J)/*+ '(!!" +/ a *ra5+ +rr(r "# ass)!"#* h+ 7)r"s/"' "(# (5+r h+ s)B7+' ::: Uploaded on - 23/04/2021 ::: Downloaded on - 23/04/2021 22:12:03 ::: ( 6 ) cra43.20 !a +r (0 h+ s)" , 6h"'h "s '&+ar&4 6" h"# h+ %r(5"#'+ (0 h+ 0(r)! '(#s " ) +/ )#/+r h+ A' , 2002. I 6as )r*+/ ha h+ &+ar#+/ C"5"& J)/*+ '(!%&+ +&4 !"s/"r+' +/ h+rs+&0 "# a$"#* a 5"+6 ha s"#'+ " 6as a5+rr+/ "# h+ %&a"# ha #( "'+ )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<2= (0 h+ A' , 2002 6as #( "ss)+/ B+0(r+ "#" "a "#* h+ !+as)r+s )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<4= (0 h+ A' , 2002, s+' "(# 34 (0 h+ A' , 2002 6()&/ #( ()s h+ 7)r"s/"' "(# (0 h+ C"5"& C()r . A Ba&/ ass+r "(# "# h+ %&a"# ha #( "'+ )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<2= (0 h+ A' , 2002 6as #( "ss)+/, 6()&/ #( '(#0+r 7)r"s/"' "(# (# h+ C"5"& C()r , 'a#5ass+/ Mr. Pa "&. I# 5"+6 (0 h+ %r(5"s"(#s '(# a"#+/ "# s+' "(# ?D (0 h+ A' , 2002, h+ E)+s "(# as ( 6h+ h+r h+ !+as)r+s r+0+rr+/ ( "# s)BAs+' "(# <4= (0 S+' "(# ?3 (0 h+ A' , 2002 a$+# B4 h+ s+')r+/ 'r+/" (r ar+ "# a''(r/a#'+ 6" h h+ %r(5"s"(#s (0 h+ A' , 2002 a#/ h+ R)&+s !a/+ h+r+)#/+r, sE)ar+&4 0a&&s 6" h"# h+ %r(5"#'+ (0 h+ a) h(r" 4 (0 h+ D+B R+'(5+r4 Tr"B)#a& a#/, h)s, h+ &+ar#+/ C"5"& J)/*+ '()&/ #( ha5+ ass)!+/ h+ 7)r"s/"' "(# (# h+ sa"/ '()# , s)B!" +/ Mr. Pa "&. ::: Uploaded on - 23/04/2021 ::: Downloaded on - 23/04/2021 22:12:03 ::: ( 7 ) cra43.20 02. I# (r/+r ( &+#/ s)%%(r ( h+ a0(r+sa"/ s)B!"ss"(#s Mr.Pa "& %&a'+/ r+&"a#'+ (# h+ 7)/*!+# s (0 h+ S)%r+!+ C()r "# h+ 'as+s (0 Ja*/"sh S"#*h Vs. H"ra&a& a#/ Ors, <20?4= ? SCC 4D@, A) h(r";+/ O00"'+r, S a + Ba#$ (0 I#/"a Vs. A&&64# A&&(4s Pr"5a + L"!" +/ a#/ Ors., <20?3= 3 SCC ?20 a#/ (0 h"s C()r "# h+ 'as+ (0 Ba#$ (0 Bar(/a Vs. Para!()# C(#/)' (rs L /., 2020<2= BCR D9. 09. I# (%%(s" "(# ( h"s, Mr. S4+/, &+ar#+/ C()#s+& 0(r h+ r+s%(#/+# .%&a"# "00, s)%%(r +/ h+ "!%)*#+/ (r/+r. I 6as s () &4 s)B!" +/ ha h+ &+ar#+/ C"5"& J)/*+ '(!!" +/ #( +rr(r "# r+7+' "#* h+ a%%&"'a "(#, as " "s a '&+ar 'as+ (0 #(#A'(!%&"a#'+ (0 h+ !a#/a (r4 #( "'+ )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<2= (0 h+ A' , 2002. Fr(! h+ %&+a/"#*s (0 h+ %ar "+s, a''(r/"#* ( Mr.S4+/, " B+'(!+s +5"/+# ha h+r+ "s #( '&+ar '(# +# "(# (# h+ %ar (0 h+ /+0+#/a# ha s)'h #( "'+ )#/+r s+' "(# ?3<2= (0 h+ A' , 2002 6as "ss)+/ a#/ s+r5+/ (# h+ ::: Uploaded on - 23/04/2021 ::: Downloaded on - 23/04/2021 22:12:03 ::: ( 8 ) cra43.20 %&a"# "00.