1 Marata(J) final.doc IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO. 175 OF 2018 Dr. Jishri Laxmnarao Patil, ] Member the Indian Constitutionalist ] Council, Age 39 years, Occu : Advocate, ] Having office at C/o 109/18, ] Esplanade Mansion, M. G. Road, ] Mumbai 400023. ...Petitioner ]..Petitioner. Versus 1. The Chief Minister ] of State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ] ] 2. the Chief Secretary, ] State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ]..Respondents. WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6 OF 2019 IN PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO. 175 OF 2018 Gawande Sachin Sominath. ] Age 32 years, Occ : Social Activist, ] R/o Plot No. 64, Lane No. 7, Gajanan Nagar ] Garkheda Parisar, Aurangabad. ]..Applicant. IN THE MATTER BETWEEN Dr. Jishri Laxmnarao Patil, ] Member the Indian Constitutionalist ] Council, Age 39 years, Occu : Advocate, ] Having office at C/o 109/18, ] Esplanade Mansion, M. G. Road, ] Mumbai 400023. ]..Petitioner. patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 2 Marata(J) final.doc Versus 1. The Chief Minister ] of State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ] ] 2. The Chief Secretary, ] State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ] ] 3. Anandrao S. Kate, ] Address at Shoop no. 12 ] Building no. 26, A, ] Lullbhai Compound, ] mumbai-400043 ] ] 4. Akhil Bhartiya Maratha ] Mahasangh, ] Reg. No. 669/A, ] Though. Dilip B Jagatap ] ts Office at.5, Navalkar ] Lane Prarthana Samaj ] Girgaon, Mumbai-04 ] ] 5. Vilas A. Sudrik, ] 265, “Shri Ganesh Chalwal, ] Juie Aunty Compound ] Santosh Nagar, Gaorgaon (E) ] Mumbai-64 ] ] 6. Ashok Patil ] A/G/001, Mehdoot Co-op Society, ] Mahada Vasahat Thane, 4000606 ] ] 7. Dr. Kanchan Patil-Vadgaon ] B-502, Silverstar Residency Sector-18 ] Kamote, Panvel-410206 ] ] 8. Subhash Balu Salekar, ] At 32/2, Shri. Ganesh Soc, ] Hanuman Nagar, B. Park ] Site Vikroli (W) Mumbai-799 ] patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 3 Marata(J) final.doc 9. Pandurang D. Shelakar ] 53 Dhulgaon, at Post Dhulgaon ] Tal. Yeola Dist. Nashik 401 ] ] 10. Nitesh Narayan Rane, ] Bungalow Pion Estate Juhu ] Tara Road, Santacruz, (W) ] Mumbai- 54 ] ] 11. Lakshaman M. Misal, ] Yashwant Complex A. Wing ] Room No. 508 Near shankwshwar ] Vidyalaya Road, Dombivali Thane, 43.] ] 12. Pravin A Nikam ] Plot No. 28 Sulbha Nagar, ] Yeola , Tal Yeola Dist Nashik ] ] 13. Vipul C. Mane ] 61,/402, MHB Colony ] Dindsohhi Magar, Malad ] Mumbai-97 ] ] 14. Vinod L. Pokharkar ] 3, plot no. 21 Skylark Society ] Sector 15, Koparkhairne, ] Navi Mumbai-43, ] ] 15. Dilip M. Patil ] 244/9, Laxmi Narayan Nagar ] Murkh Saink Vasahat ] Kolhapur, 416006 ] ] 16. Sandip P. Pol, ] Krashnai 2/7, Market Yard ] Satara 15001 ] ] 17. Vivek R. Kurade, ] Ashtavinayak colony ] Vidyanagar Karad, Dist Satara, ] ] patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 4 Marata(J) final.doc 18. Vinod S. Sable ] 602 A, Wing, Nikanth Nityanand Road,] Panvel Navi Mumbai 410106 ] ] 19. Krishna B. Naik ] 601, D. Annanya Dr, Raikar Marg, ] Mahim, Mumbai- 16 ] ] 20. Ankush S. Kadam ] SS-3, Room No. 724 Sec-18 ] Kopar Khairane, Navi Mumbai ] ] 21. Santosh P. Raijadhav, ] 15, Satyam Shivam CHS OPP. ] HP Petrol Pump Badlapur East Thane ] ] 22. Shahed Ali Ansari ] B-96, 9th Floor, Mithal Tower B Wing, ] Nariman Point, Mumbai-40023 ] ] 23. Akhil Maratha Federation ] Reg No. MH/MUM//2379-2015 ] GBBD Thr. Shri. Shashikant Pawar, ] Navalkar Lane, Prathana Samaj, ] Girgaon Mumbai -04, ] ] 24. Maharashtra Public Service ] Commission (MPSC) ] Main office 5th 7th 8th Floor, ] Cooprej Telephone Exchange building,] MahatrshiKarve Marg, ] Mumbai-400023 ] ] 25. Gawande Sachin Sominath, ] Age: 32 years, Occu: Social Activist ] R/o: Plot No.64, Lane No.7, ] Gajanan Nagar, ] Garkheda Parisar Aurangabad ]…RESPONDENTS WITH patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 5 Marata(J) final.doc CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7 OF 2019 IN PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO. 175 OF 2018 Ravindra s/o Bhanudas Kale. ] Age 39 years, Occu : Social activist ] R/o : Plot No. 64, Lane no. 7, Gajanan ] Nagar, GarkhedaParisar, Aurangabad. ]..Applicant. IN THE MATTER BETWEEN Dr. Jishri Laxmnarao Patil, ] Member the Indian Constitutionalist ] Council, Age 39 years, Occu : Advocate, ] Having office at C/o 109/18, ] Esplanade Mansion, M. G. Road, ] Mumbai 400023. ]..Petitioner. Versus 1. The Chief Minister ] of State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ] ] 2. The Chief Secretary, ] State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ] ] 3. Anandrao S. Kate, ] Address at Shoop no. 12 ] Building no. 26, A, ] Lullbhai Compound, Munkurd, ] mumbai-400043 ] ] 4. Akhil Bhartiya Maratha ] Mahasangh, ] Reg. No. 669/A, ] Though. Dilip B Jagatap ] Its Office at.5, Navalkar ] Lane Prarthana Samaj ] Girgaon, Mumbai-04 ] ] patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 6 Marata(J) final.doc 5. Vilas A. Sudrik, ] 265, “Shri Ganesh Chawal, ] Juie Aunty Compound ] Santosh Nagar, Gaorgaon (E) ] Mumbai-64 ] ] 6. Ashok Patil ] A/G/001, Mehdoot Co-op Society, ] Mahada Vasahat Thane, 4000606 ] ] 7. Dr. Kanchan Patil-Vadgaon ] B-502, Silverstar Residency Sector-18 ] Kamote, Panvel-410206 ] ] 8. Subhash Balu Salekar, ] At 32/2, Shri. Ganesh Soc, ] Hanuman Nagar, B. Park ] Site Vikroli (W) Mumbai-799 ] 9. Pandurang D. Shelakar ] 53 Dhulgaon, at Post Dhulgaon ] Tal. Yeola Dist. Nashik 401 ] ] 10. Nitesh Narayan Rane, ] Bungalow Pion Estate Juhu ] Tara Road, Santacruz, (W) ] Mumbai- 54 ] ] 11. Lakshaman M. Misal, ] Yashwant Complex A. Wing ] Room No. 508 Near shankwshwar ] Vidyalaya Road, Dombivali Thane, 43.] ] 12. Pravin A Nikam ] Plot No. 28 Sulbha Nagar, ] Yeola , Tal Yeola Dist Nashik ] ] 13. Vipul C. Mane ] 61,/402, MHB Colony ] Dindsohhi Magar, Malad ] Mumbai-97 ] ] patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 7 Marata(J) final.doc 14. Vinod L. Pokharkar ] 3, plot no. 21 Skylark Society ] Sector 15, Koparkhairne, ] Navi Mumbai-43, ] ] 15. Dilip M. Patil ] 244/9, Laxmi Narayan Nagar ] Murkh Saink Vasahat ] Kolhapur, 416006 ] ] 16. Sandip P. Pol, ] Krashnai 2/7, Market Yard ] Satara 15001 ] ] 17. Vivek R. Kurade, ] Ashtavinayak colony ] Vidyanagar Karad, Dist Satara, ] ] 18. Vinod S. Sable ] 602 A, Wing, Nikanth Nityanand Road,] Panvel Navi Mumbai 410106 ] ] 19. Krishna B. Naik ] 601, D. Annanya Dr, Raikar Marg, ] Mahim, Mumbai- 16 ] ] 20. Ankush S. Kadam ] SS-3, Room No. 724 Sec-18 ] Kopar Khairane, Navi Mumbai ] ] 21. Santosh P. Raijadhav, ] 15, Satyam Shivam CHS OPP. ] HP Petrol Pump Badlapur East Thane ] ] 22. Shahed Ali Ansari ] B-96, 9th Floor, Mithal Tower B Wing, ] Nariman Point, Mumbai-40023 ] ] 23. Akhil Maratha Federation ] Reg No. MH/MUM//2379-2015 ] GBBD Thr. Shri. Shashikant Pawar, ] Navalkar Lane, Prathana Samaj, ] Girgaon Mumbai -04, ] patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 8 Marata(J) final.doc ] 24. Maharashtra Public Service ] Commission (MPSC) ] Main office 5th 7th 8th Floor, ] Cooperage Telephone Exchange ] building, ] MahatrshiKarve Marg, ] Mumbai-400023 ] ] 25. Ravindra s/o Bhanudas Kale. ] Age 39 years, Occu : Social activist ] R/o : Plot No. 64, Lane no. 7, Gajanan ] Nagar, GarkhedaParisar, Aurangabad.]..RESPONDENTS WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 8 OF 2019 IN PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION NO. 175 OF 2018 Ramesh Shekhnath Kere. ] Age 40 years, Occu : Social activist ] R/o : New Hanuman Nagar, Galli No.4, ] Plot No. 94,GarkhedaParisar, Aurangabad. ]..Applicant. IN THE MATTER BETWEEN Dr. Jishri Laxmnarao Patil, ] Member the Indian Constitutionalist ] Council, Age 39 years, Occu : Advocate, ] Having office at C/o 109/18, ] Esplanade Mansion, M. G. Road, ] Mumbai 400023. ]..Petitioner. Versus 1. The Chief Minister ] of State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ] ] 2. The Chief Secretary, ] State of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, ] Mumbai – 400 032. ] patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 9 Marata(J) final.doc ] 3. Anandrao S. Kate, ] Address at Shoop no. 12 ] Building no. 26, A, ] Lullbhai Compound, Munkurd, ] mumbai-400043 ] ] 4. Akhil Bhartiya Maratha ] Mahasangh, ] Reg. No. 669/A, ] Though. Dilip B Jagatap ] Its Office at.5, Navalkar ] Lane Prarthana Samaj ] Girgaon, Mumbai-04 ] ] 5. Vilas A. Sudrik, ] 265, “Shri Ganesh Chawal, ] Juie Aunty Compound ] Santosh Nagar, Gaorgaon (E) ] Mumbai-64 ] ] 6. Ashok Patil ] A/G/001, Mehdoot Co-op Society, ] Mahada Vasahat Thane, 4000606 ] ] 7. Dr. Kanchan Patil-Vadgaon ] B-502, Silverstar Residency Sector-18 ] Kamote, Panvel-410206 ] ] 8. Subhash Balu Salekar, ] At 32/2, Shri. Ganesh Soc, ] Hanuman Nagar, B. Park ] Site Vikroli (W) Mumbai-799 ] 9. Pandurang D. Shelakar ] 53 Dhulgaon, at Post Dhulgaon ] Tal. Yeola Dist. Nashik 401 ] ] 10. Nitesh Narayan Rane, ] Bungalow Pion Estate Juhu ] Tara Road, Santacruz, (W) ] Mumbai- 54 ] ] patil-sachin. ::: Uploaded on - 27/06/2019 ::: Downloaded on - 27/06/2019 21:48:03 ::: 10 Marata(J) final.doc 11. Lakshaman M. Misal, ] Yashwant Complex A. Wing ] Room No. 508 Near shankwshwar ] Vidyalaya Road, Dombivali Thane, 43.] ] 12. Pravin A Nikam ] Plot No. 28 Sulbha Nagar, ] Yeola , Tal Yeola Dist Nashik ] ] 13. Vipul C. Mane ] 61,/402, MHB Colony ] Dindsohhi Magar, Malad ] Mumbai-97 ] ] 14. Vinod L. Pokharkar ] 3, plot no. 21 Skylark Society ] Sector 15, Koparkhairne, ] Navi Mumbai-43, ] ] 15. Dilip M. Patil ] 244/9,