Article 5 Article 5 Agriculture for Development, 39 (2020) Sir George Stapledon FRS and his international grassland legacy Alan Hopkins and Roger J Wilkins Alan Hopkins is an independent consultant and Trustee of the Stapledon Memorial Trust. He was formerly Senior Research Scientist at the Institute of Grassland and Environmental Research, North Wyke, Devon. [email protected] Roger Wilkins is Honorary Research Associate at Rothamsted Research, a former Chairman of the Stapledon Memorial Trust, and former Deputy Director of the Institute of Grassland and Environ- mental Research. [email protected] This paper is based on a presentation by the authors at the advanced agricultural science and influenced policy TAA South-West seminar reported elsewhere in this issue. and adoption in practice, he also empathised with farmers and thought philosophically about the role of Abstract agriculture and the countryside for the population as a whole. Today, his achievements have largely become Sir George Stapledon (1882–1960) was one of the forgotten. His name does not appear among the lists of greatest agricultural scientists of the early and mid- 20th century thinkers as studied in today’s philosophy 20th century. His work profoundly affected grassland degree courses, though this is probably for no other science and agricultural production in the UK and reason than he was primarily a scientist. Yet, as we beyond. He has an enduring legacy from the institutions shall see, many aspects of his thinking were ahead he helped found and through the trust that carries his of his time. He saw the need for research to extend name. This article considers his early work on ecology across disciplines, an approach that was followed in and agronomy, progress on forage plant breeding, ley the establishment of the grassland research developed farming, and the influence of his later writings on land at Hurley and Aberystwyth in the UK, and emulated use policy and wider philosophical implications of the notably at many successful research institutes in the role of the land in terms of human wellbeing. Commonwealth. He also advocated the need for holistic Introduction approaches to deliver harmony between the science of agriculture and the wider environment, and the role of Sir George Stapledon was a scientist, botanist, ecologist, people as part of wider ecosystems – human ecology. teacher, philosopher, poet and visionary. He was a true The practical relevance of his work, especially in his polymath. In his lifetime, he was widely recognised for earlier writings on hill land improvement, ley farming, his contribution to grassland science in Britain and seed varietal improvement and the importance of land particularly for his role in lifting British agriculture in surveys, was clearly carried out in the context of the UK the first half of the 20th century. His influence was in the first half of the 20th century, but he also saw their also recognised in his lifetime, not only in Britain but worldwide application for a growing global population. throughout the British Empire and Commonwealth He had an instrumental role in the establishment of and beyond. As the founding Director of the Welsh many international organisations, and his international Plant Breeding Station (WPBS), he was instrumental legacy continues through the awards made to scientists in developing the scientific breeding of grasses and and practitioners by the Stapledon Memorial Trust that forage legumes in Britain. He greatly advanced our was set up in his honour. understanding of grassland agronomy and recognised that a vigorous agriculture was not just a means of Background and early career food production and national food security, but also provided a route to raising rural living standards. The early life of Reginald George Stapledon is relevant Although he wrote about agriculture, and greatly in terms of how his upbringing influenced his later 32 Agriculture for Development, 39 (2020) Article 5 career and philosophical thinking. Two important conditions were different to those of Britain. In 1922, sources of information are his biography by Robert Stapledon set out his Book of Words describing the Waller (Waller, 1962) and a Royal Society biographical methodology and procedures relating to the selection memoir (Russell, 1961). and breeding, and recording and evaluating of trials (Duller et al, 2019). Over the following decades, he He was born in 1882 into a Devonshire family that and his team followed an ecological approach to ran an international shipping company. We can developing new varieties, sourcing promising parent regard him as being a Victorian in the sense of having material from permanent pastures of repute for a Victorian upbringing, with leisure time to study fattening livestock, and leading to the release of the nature and practise gardening. He attended the improved ‘S’ strains. The approach was based on clear nearby United Services College and then read Natural agronomic objectives, with assessments that also took Sciences at Cambridge, but his career then went account of chemical analyses of herbage and their through some false starts. Two years at the family utilisation by the grazing animal (Duller et al, 2019). firm’s offices in Suez may have given useful experience in recordkeeping, but did not inspire him to continue The development of improved grasses and clovers in commerce. His entry to agriculture was through through scientific plant breeding was part of an overall working for a fruit grower in Kent, which was followed strategy to improve the UK’s farmland and address a by a return to Cambridge in 1907 to take a Diploma in fundamental national problem: the country could Agriculture. This was sufficient to launch his agriculture not feed itself. His experience of the effects of food career proper and he obtained a post at the Royal shortages during WW1, while much of the countryside Agricultural College, Cirencester, where he stayed for lay derelict, convinced him of the need to combine three years working in agricultural ecology. This was plant breeding with scientific agronomy. The hills a discipline that he largely developed himself, and and uplands, accounting for a third of the agricultural which alerted him to many of the problems of British land area, were identified as having potential to carry agriculture at the time, such as the use of unsuitable greater stock numbers if pastures were improved by and poor-quality seeds. This was a challenging period applications of lime and phosphate fertilisers, and to develop a career in agriculture. Decades of cheap with reseeding where feasible. Here we must mention food from the late 19th century had resulted in the Cahn Hill Improvement Scheme (1933–1947), over massive agrarian change, with the abandonment of 1,000 ha of agriculturally poor steep land rising to much of Britain’s arable farming to extensive grazing 600 m elevation near Devils Bridge. This presented and associated rural depopulation. Stapledon with an immense challenge to test his ideas for land improvement, which greatly exceeded George Stapledon was then fortunate in 1912 to be those of the Ministry of Agriculture, and which, offered a post as botanical adviser at the University despite opposition from economists, would provide College of Wales Aberystwyth, to conduct a botanical practicable results that would show Britain’s food survey in central Wales, to give advice to farmers, potential and that of its rural communities. His zeal and to teach. Later, during the First World War (WW1) for this scheme inspired many in their efforts to raise emergency, he served the Board of Agriculture in production during WW2. London and succeeded in establishing a seed testing station to address the scandal of inferior seed then Hill land improvement provided additional acres being sold to farmers. The war had exposed the so that similar numbers of livestock were carried importance of food security and the risks of relying on nationally, while at the same time releasing poorer imports while vast tracts of land were seriously under- lowland grassland for arable cultivation. This brings utilised. His views clearly gained the attention of those us to another of the pillars of his work and one with in authority. A grant from Lord Milford led to the which his name is inextricably linked: ley farming. establishment of WPBS at Aberystwyth in 1919, with George Stapledon did not invent ley farming – that George Stapledon being appointed as its Director, a attribution may go to Robert Elliot of Clifton Park. post he held alongside that of Professor of Agricultural Stanes et al (2008) also argued that in the Bedford Botany, until 1942. husbandry covenants the introduction of leys was legally enforced in the early 18th century and had The Aberystwyth period (1919–1940s) also become part of the south-west England farming systems, and that Stapledon would have been aware Until the 1920s, clovers and grasses were novel of this. Nevertheless, George Stapledon and his subjects for plant breeders. Available varieties were protégé William Davies can take credit for having essentially landraces, often selected for their ability to popularised the term ‘ley farming’ in the context of produce harvestable seed rather than for attributes rotational farming systems including grass or grass– of persistence, yield or high-quality forage, and many legume swards. There were some clear advantages: had been produced in countries where growing grassland on a mainly arable farm enabled the 33 Article 5 Agriculture for Development, 39 (2020) accumulation of soil organic matter which could be Research Committee, which had been established beneficial for the land and subsequent crops, while in 1909. The first Imperial Agricultural Conference in manures from any livestock kept would fertilise 1927 recommended the establishment of Imperial the land further. Writing in the late 1930s, he was Agricultural Bureaux for the dissemination of highly critical of permanent grassland farming in information on their respective agricultural subject general, though this view was likely influenced by areas throughout the countries of the British Empire.