Lhmmdrns` IN THE B`ldq`ÒrDxd 1935Ð1943 Alan Trachtenberg aZmp^dghph_]Zbereb_^bgma^Ngbm^] lbhgËZg]Êma^Mabkmb^lËbgpZrlfhk^]bo^kl^%\hfie^q% LmZm^l]nkbg`ma^@k^Zm=^ik^llbhgh_ma^ Zg]i^klhgZemaZgma^lm^k^hmri^]^qi^\mZmbhgh_ln__^k& *2,)l\hf^leZk`^er_khfZg^qmkZhk]b& bg`Zg]Z[c^\mbhgZ\khllma^eZg]'+ gZkr\hee^\mbhgh_iahmh`kZialfZ]^_hk Hg\^rhnhi^gma^Öe^%ma^k^blZepZrlfhk^mhl^^% WZ`ho^kgf^gmZ`^g\r%ma^?ZkfL^\nkbmr:]fbgblmkZmbhg hma^kpZrlh_ehhdbg`Zg]k^Z]bg`'Ahnl^]bg_hnk& !?L:"%_khf*2,/mh*2-,'<hg\^kg^]ZmÖklmpbmama^ ]kZp^klm^^e\Z[bg^mlbgma^IkbgmlZg]Iahmh`kZial ieb`amh__Zkf^kl%laZk^\khii^kl%Zg]fb`kZgm_Zkfphkd& khhfh_ma^Eb[kZkrh_<hg`k^ll%ma^\hee^\mbhgÉÊma^ ^kl%ma^iahmh`kZiab\ikhc^\mlhhg[^\Zf^ZgZmbhgZe Öe^ËÉbg\en]^likbgml%bfZ`^l%Zg]g^`Zmbo^lfZ]^bg ikh`kZfh_^ib\Zg]^ih\aZeikhihkmbhgl'Ma^k^lnempZl *2,._hkma^K^l^mme^f^gm:]fbgblmkZmbhg!K:"Zg]ma^g ZÖe^h_00%)))ikbgmlZg]fZgrfhk^bfZ`^lZg]g^`Z& _hkma^?L:%bg\hgg^\mbhgpbmaG^p=^Zeiheb\rZbf^]Zm mbo^l_khfoZkbhnllhnk\^l%hk`Zgbs^][rln[c^\ma^Z]bg`l k^obobg`Zg]k^lmkn\mnkbg`:f^kb\ZgZ`kb\nemnk^',Bgma^ Zg]`^h`kZiab\Zek^`bhgl'* ikh\^ll%ma^ikhc^\m^qiZg]^]bgmhZ`^g^kZe^magheh`r :Fbgg^lhmZlmhkraZlZek^Z]r[^^g^qmkZ\m^]_khf h_^o^kr]Zreb_^%bg\en]bg`\bmb^lZg]nk[Zgk^`bhgl'GZ& mabl`k^ZmZk\abo^3Ib\mnkbg`Fbgg^lhmZ%*2,/È*2-,% mbhgZebgl\hi^%bmpZlZelhgZmbhgZebgbmlZbfmhb]^gmb_r ^]bm^][rKh[^kmE'K^b]':gbgoZenZ[e^]h\nf^gmh_ma^ paZmpZlngbjn^Zg]]blmbg\mbo^Z[hnmma^gZmbhg'Pa^g ehhdh_Fbgg^lhmZÍlÊ`k^Zm^lm`^g^kZmbhgË]nkbg`ma^aZk] pZk[khd^hnmbg>nkhi^Zg]bml^^f^]ebd^ermaZmma^ mbf^l[^_hk^ma^pZk%mabl[hhdikhob]^lZ[Zl^ebg^_hk Ngbm^]LmZm^lphne][^\hf^bgoheo^]%ma^H_Ö\^h_PZk _nkma^kehhdbg`Zg]k^Z]bg`h_ib\mnk^l'Bmk^mnkglrhnmh ma^?L:\hee^\mbhgbml^e_%pa^k^rhnlhhg]bl\ho^kfZgr Fbgg^lhmZlZpZbmbg`l^e^\mbhgZg]\hglmkn\mbhghnmh_ K^mbk^]ikh_^llhkh_>g`eblaZg]:f^kb\ZgLmn]b^lZmRZe^ lhf^*%0))ikbgml%ma^phkdh_aZe_Z]hs^giahmh`kZ& Ngbo^klbmr%:eZgMkZ\am^g[^k`mhhdablIa'='Zmma^Ngbo^k& ia^klho^kl^o^gr^Zkl'Ma^iahmh`kZial]^ib\mÊ=^ik^l& lbmrh_Fbgg^lhmZ':fhg`ablpkbmbg`lhgiahmh`kZiarbl Zg^llZrbgC^khf^Eb^[ebg`3Ma^Fbgg^lhmZIahmh`kZial% *2-2È*2/2!*220"'Abl\nkk^gmphkdbg\en]^lZlmn]rh_ma^ _Z\bg`iZ`^3Knll^eeE^^%Ê@hh]pbeelmhk^Zg]Fbllbhg\ank\a' G^[kZldZ&[hkggho^eblmZg]iahmh`kZia^kPkb`amFhkkbl' Fbgg^Zihebl%Fbgg^lhmZ%ËFZr*2,0 175 Bg_hkfZmbhg!HPB"Z[lhk[^]ma^ikhc^\m'Ib\mnk^lh_Zg ^f^k`bg`ahf^_khgmp^k^Z]]^]mhma^\hee^\mbhg%l\^g^l lahpbg`ma^\hngmkrÍlk^Z]bg^llZg]pbeebg`g^llmhÖ`am' Ma^Öe^]^o^ehi^]ZlZngbjn^[e^g]h_i^klhgZe oblbhglmaZmZk^Zelhh[c^\mbo^k^\hk]lh_l\^g^l%mabg`l% Zg]i^klhglpbmg^ll^][rma^iahmh`kZia^kZg]k^\hk]^] pbmama^ik^\blbhgmrib\Zeh_ma^\Zf^kZ'Ghg^pliahmh& `kZial%ghmhn\a^]&niihkmkZbmlh_\^e^[kbmb^l%cnlmieZbg i^hie^pahl^\ehmabg`%ieZ\^l%phkdZg]`Zf^l%`^lmnk^l% Zg]^qik^llbhgl\hee^\mbo^er[^li^ZdZgZlmhgblabg`er ]bo^kl^gZmbhgng]^k`hbg`iZkmb\neZkZg]\hee^\mbo^abl& mhkb^l%Zlob^p^]makhn`a]bo^kl^iahmh`kZiab\^r^l'Ma^ \hee^\mbhgl^ko^lZlZg^]n\ZmbhgbgahpmhehhdZg]paZm mhl^^Zlma^gZmbhgÍlk^Zebmr' ÊMa^k^Zk^ghib\mnk^lh_lbm&]hpglmkbd^l%ËKhr Lmkrd^k%a^Z]Zg]`nb]bg`libkbmh_ma^ikhc^\m%k^\Zee^] ChagOZ\ahg%ÊNg^fiehr^]f^gbg@Zm^pZr=blmkb\m% r^ZkleZm^k'ÊGhZiie^lZe^lf^ghglmk^^m\hkg^kl%ghmZ Fbgg^Zihebl%Fbgg^lhmZ%ËL^im^f[^k*2,2 lbg`e^lahmh_PZeeLmk^^m'Ë -?L:\Zf^kZlZkkbo^]mhheZm^ _hklhf^h_ma^phklmoblb[e^^__^\mlma^\kZla%[nmLmkrd^k gbsbg`f^f[^klh_<hg`k^llld^imb\Zeh_ma^ikhc^\m' Zelh^q\en]^]ib\mnk^lh_g^plZg]\nkk^gmZ__ZbklZlZ >q\^im_hkh[eb`Zmhkrib\mnk^lh_ma^ikZ\mb\Zephkdh_ fZmm^kh_iheb\r%pZgmbg`mhZohb]Zgr\aZg\^h_ZgmZ`h& ma^K:Zg]?L:%ma^iahmh`kZialZ\mnZeera^ei^]fZk& `bgZebs^l\^g^lh_\hg_khgmZmbhgZg]\eZllobhe^g\^bgma^ \hee^\mbo^in[eb\ib\mnk^h_ma^]^\Z]^';^`ngbg*2,.% ma^ikhc^\m\hne]ghmaZo^k^\hk]^]ma^*2,-lmkbd^lZg] obhe^g\^bgFbgg^ZiheblbgZgr\Zl^'Bglm^Z]%ma^Öe^\ho& ^klma^mbf^Z_m^k*2,/pa^gG^p=^Zeiheb\b^laZ]aZem& bg`er[^`ngmhphkd';rma^HPB^kZ%ik^iZkZmbhg_hkpZk aZ]mnkg^]^o^krmabg`Zkhng]Éma^^\hghfrpZlZm_nee lm^ZfZa^Z]%ng^fiehrf^gmZ[hebla^][rma^fbebmZkr ]kZ_m%Zg]_hh]ikh]n\mbhg[Z\dmhghkfZe' Bgma^^Zkerr^Zklh_ma^]^\Z]^%Fbgg^lhmZln__^k^] \kn^eer'FbeelZg]`kZbg^e^oZmhklbgma^Mpbg<bmb^llanm ]hpg4fbg^lZg]kZbekhZ]lZg]ma^enf[^kbg]nlmkrp^k^ l^o^k^erankm'Phkd^klZg]_Zkf^klp^e\hf^]ikh`kZfl \Zeebg`_hkkZ]b\Ze\aZg`^%Zg^g]mh\ZibmZeblfÉb_ghm lh\bZeblfZg]\hffngblfZlln\a!mahn`afZgr]b] ^lihnl^ma^l^fhk^kZ]b\Ze`hZel"ÉZg]%Zme^Zlm%in[eb\ hpg^klabih_nmbebmb^l%pab\a@ho^kghkl?ehr];'Helhg Zg]>ef^k:';^glhghi^ger^lihnl^]'Mnk[ne^g\^\hg& mbgn^]bgmhma^eZm^kr^Zklh_ma^]^\Z]^^o^gZl\hg]b& mbhglbfikho^]'Bg*2,2^fiehr^^lh_ma^PhkdlIkh`k^ll :]fbgblmkZmbhg%ZfZchk`ho^kgf^gmZ`^g\rikhob]bg` k^eb^_bgma^_hkfh_phkd%p^gmhglmkbd^mhikhm^lmZ\nm bgiZr'Ghlb`gh_mablikhmkZ\m^]Zg][bmm^klmkn``e^Zi& i^Zklbgma^?L:ib\mnk^l';nm[rmablZg]hma^klh\bZe Zg]ihebmb\ZeZ\mboblf%ZFbgg^lhmZa^kbmZ`^pZll^Ze^]' ChagOZ\ahg%ÊIZpglahibg@Zm^pZr=blmkb\m%Fbgg^Zihebl% Fbgg^lhmZ%ËL^im^f[^k*2,2 176 Minnesota History Ma^*2,)l^lmZ[ebla^]ma^eZ[hkfho^f^gmZlZlb`gbÖ& ma^rmZn`amma^in[eb\ahpmhehhdZm\hffhgl\^g^lh_ \Zgmik^l^g\^%pab\aa^ei^]ma^=^fh\kZmb\&?Zkf^k& ^o^kr]Zreb_^%ahpmhl^^ma^_ZfbebZkbgZg^pi^kli^\mbo^ EZ[hkIZkmr^f^k`^Z_m^kPhke]PZkBBZl\ab^_hiihg^gm h_lb`gbÖ\Zg\^' h_ma^K^in[eb\Zgl%pah[^_hk^ma^gaZ]aZ]kne^h_ma^ ChagOZ\ahgk^\Zee^]bg*2/1maZmLmkrd^kaZ]abk^] lmZm^fhk^hke^llmhma^fl^eo^l'. abfbg*2,/mh\hir\ZimbhglZg]lmZfigZf^lh_iah& mh`kZia^klhgma^[Z\dlh_1&[r&*)ikbgml'ÊKZma^k]^Z]er phkd%Ëngmbehg^]Zra^Êmnkg^]ho^khg^h_ma^iahmh& a^Mabkmb^lZelhhi^g^]g^pihllb[bebmb^l_hk `kZialZg]k^Zeerehhd^]Zmbm'ËBmpZlZib\mnk^[rPZed^k iahmh`kZiar'Ib\mnk^fZ`Zsbg^lebd^Eb_^Zg] >oZglh_Z_knbmlmZg]bgEhnblbZgZ'ÊBk^Zeerehhd^]Zmbm% Ehhd%Zehg`pbma\bg^fZ%a^ei^]\k^Zm^Zg^p Zg]bmpZljnbm^ZfZsbg`'ËA^[^`Zgmhmnkgma^fZeeho^k ToblnZe^gobkhgf^gmh_ib\mnk^lmZd^g]bk^\mer_khfma^ Zg]ÊehhdZmZeeh_ma^fpbmabg\k^Zlbg`\Zk^Zg]bgm^k^lm' Z\mnZephke]'Bg*20,Lmkrd^kpkhm^3 '''A^k^pZlma^pahe^N'L':'lik^Z][^_hk^f^'ËA^k^& Zebs^]maZma^aZ]mh`hhnmZg]fZd^ib\mnk^labfl^e_'0 Bg*2,/iahmh`kZiar'''pZl_Zlm[^bg`]bl\ho^k^]ZlZ BgL^im^f[^k*2,2%Z_m^kGZsb@^kfZgreZng\a^]Phke] l^kbhnlmhheh_\hffngb\Zmbhgl%Zg^ppZr_hkZmahn`am& PZkBB[rbgoZ]bg`IheZg]%OZ\ahgp^gmahf^mhLm'IZne _ne%\k^Zmbo^i^klhgmhfZd^ZlmZm^f^gm'?eZla[ne[lZg] Zg]khZf^]pbmaabl\Zf^kZmakhn`ama^ldb]khp%hk lfZee\Zf^kZlp^k^[^bg`nl^]_hkma^Öklmmbf^'Ma^ @Zm^pZr]blmkb\m%h_Fbgg^Zihebl'A^pZllmbeeZ[^`bgg^k% khmh`kZonk^pZl]rbg`4ma^Öklm[b`ib\mnk^fZ`Zsbg^l ghmr^mZgh_Ö\bZe?L:iahmh`kZia^k%mahn`aLmkrd^kaZ] pab\aphne]mZd^bmlieZ\^p^k^Zek^Z]r[^bg`khn`a^] `bo^gabfabgml'PaZma^aZ]e^Zkg^]_khfPZed^k>oZgl hnm'BgZr^Zkhklh%Zg]pbmaZln]]^gg^llfZm\a^]hger Zg]hma^kll^ko^]abfp^eehgmablÖklmlb`gbÖ\Zgmhnm& [rma^bgmkh]n\mbhgh_m^e^oblbhgmp^eo^r^ZkleZm^k%ib\& bg`'Knll^eeE^^aZ]\ho^k^]ma^lZf^@Zm^pZrmnk_mph mnk^&mZdbg`[^\Zf^ZgZmbhgZebg]nlmkr'P^phne]aZo^ r^Zkl[^_hk^bgma^\hfiZgrh_KhrLmkrd^k%ZkZk^h\\Z& [^^gbgl^glbmbo^bg]^^]ghmmhaZo^k^Zebs^]maZmp^p^k^ lbhgpa^gma^]bk^\mhkabfl^e_fZ]^lhf^ib\mnk^l_hk ZgbfihkmZgmiZkmh_Zfho^f^gm'/ ma^Öe^'OZ\ahgphne]aZo^\Zimbhg^]%lmZfi^]%Zg]Öe^] ma^E^^Zg]Lmkrd^kiahmhl%Zg]a^fhk^hke^ll_heehp^] ?L:iahmh`kZialp^k^^r^&hi^gbg`bfZ`^lbgma^bkhpg mbf^'K^ikh]n\^]pb]^erbgg^pliZi^klZg]fZ`Zsbg^l% KhrLmkrd^k%ÊLmk^^ml\^g^%Fbgg^Zihebl%Fbgg^lhmZ%Ë*2,0 Spring 2009 177 With its physical connection to the Òreal world,Ó the camera seemed a perfect instrument for discovery and recovery of the lost world of the older, ÒrealÓ America. ma^bke^Z]bgZbfbg`abl\Zf^kZZmb]e^f^gehng`bg`hg ]h\nf^gmZkrk^ZeblfÉmaZmmZd^lma^phke]ZlbmblZg] [^g\a^lhkerbg`hgma^`kZllZg]ZelhZmiZpglahil%lZ& mkb^lmhfZd^bm\e^Zk' ehhgl%×hiahnl^l%abkbg`aZeel%lmhk^_khgmfbllbhgl%Zg]Z ;nmpaZmÍljnhmb]bZg\ZgZelh[^bg^qieb\Z[e^'Ehhd g^pllmZg]'AZk]mbf^lZk^bfieb^][rma^]hpg&Zg]&hnm Zl\ehl^erZlp^\ZgZmZg]bgmhmabll\^g^\Zimnk^][r ehhdh_ma^f^gZg]ma^lmk^^ml%[nmcnlmZlbfihkmZgmbl OZ\ahgÍl\Zf^kZ%p^\Zgghmm^ee_hk\^kmZbgpaZm`h^l ma^Z\mbobmrh_OZ\ahgÍl\Zf^kZ%\aZg`bg`Zg`e^l%fhobg` hga^k^%paZmaZii^gl[^_hk^hnk^r^l'Blma^he]fZg \ehl^khk_Zkma^k[Z\d%\khiibg`Zg]laZibg`ib\mnk^lmaZm ikhikb^mhkh_ma^g^pllmZg]%\nlmhf^k%hkoblbmhk8Pahl^ bg_hkfma^^r^pbmahnmlZ\kbÖ\bg`ma^ie^Zlnk^h_l^^bg` aZg]ab]^lbgma^k^\^ll^lh_ma^lmZg]%Zg]paZmÍlma^ \ehl^erpaZmblma^k^'Ma^ib\mnk^llahpOZ\ahg]bl\ho^k& f^Zgbg`h_bml`^lmnk^8=h^lma^]Zkd%kZ``^]&^]`^] bg`ablpZrh_l^^bg`Zg]h_ib\mnkbg`ma^phke]' laZ]hpZehg`ma^kb`amlb]^h_ma^ib\mnk^%[hk]^kbg`Z BgÊG^pllmZg]%@Zm^pZr=blmkb\m%Fbgg^ZiheblË!Ö`'*"% ]Z``^k&ebd^p^]`^h_bgm^gl^L^im^f[^k[kb`amg^ll%aZo^ ZfZgi^k\a^lhgma^^]`^h_lhf^[ng]e^lbg_khgmh_ Zf^Zgbg`%Zkhe^mhieZrbgma^lmhkrng_he]bg`hkZek^Z]r Zg^pllmZg]'Bml\ZgoZl×ZilZk^mb^][Z\d%\k^Zmbg`ma^ iZlmbgmabl^gb`fZmb\oblbhgZmma^a^Zkmh_ma^Fbgg^& ^__^\mh_Zm^gm'Abl\ehmabg`phkgZg]p^Zma^k^]%abl Ziheblm^g]^kehbg8 pabm^aZbk\Zl\Z]bg`ng]^kZkbfe^ll\ZimaZm]^\eZk^lZ PaZmbl[^bg`]h\nf^gm^]a^k^8:gngk^fZkdZ[e^ mbf^erf^llZ`^_hkaZk]mbf^lÉÊCnlmlZr\aZk`^bmËÉZg] ^o^gm%frlmb_rbg`bglhf^pZrlZg]i^kaZil^o^gfrl& ablibi^\enm\a^]mb`amer[^mp^^gablm^^ma%ma^fZglbml m^kbhnl%bmÍllhf^mabg`p^fb`amaZo^ghmb\^]\ZlnZeer hgma^e^_mh_ma^ib\mnk^ZmZkb`amZg`e^mhma^\hngm^k' aZ]p^\aZg\^]mhiZll[rZmcnlmmaZmfhf^gm':lb`am Pbmabgma^m^gm^]^g\ehlnk^p^l^^ZaZg]fZdbg`Z lgZii^]Zg]Öq^]_khfma^×nqh_mbf^Zg]]^ebo^k^]mh `^lmnk^ln\aZl`kbg]bg`hnmZ\b`Zk^mm^hkeZrbg`]hpgZ hnk^r^lpbmahnm_nkma^k\hff^gmmaZgma^m^kl^\Zimbhg3 \hbg'Ma^aZg]l^^fl]bl^f[h]b^]%]^mZ\a^]%lhf^mabg` ÊG^pllmZg]%@Zm^pZr=blmkb\m%Fbgg^Zihebl%Fbgg^lhmZ' Zii^Zkbg`hnmh_ma^laZ]hpl'Mhma^kb`am%ma^k^ÍlZg^Zm L^im^f[^k*2,2'ËOZ\ahgÍlib\mnk^%bg_Z\m%\Zg[^mZd^g ibe^h_g^pliZi^kl_k^lah__ma^ik^ll%fZdbg`Z[kb`am ZlZlmZm^f^gmh_Zma^hkrh_iahmh`kZiar%Ziahmh`kZiar lieZlabgma^lngeb`am'Hg^iZi^kblinee^]_hkpZk]_khf maZmlahpl^o^krmabg`ma^k^blmhlahp[nmpbmalhf^& ma^ibe^mhlahpmph_khgm&iZ`^iahmh`kZial3bghg^%Z mabg`ngmkZgleZmZ[e^e^_mho^k'Ma^ib\mnk^bllm^^i^]bg rhng`i^klhgahe]lZ\abe]hkZ]hee4bgma^hma^k%ma^ bfieb\Zmbhglihd^gZg]nglihd^g3Zg^pllmZg]hgZ Ö`nk^bgma^k^Zk%ZiiZk^gmerZiheb\^h_Ö\^k%lZenm^lma^ fZchk&\bmr\khllkhZ]lh_aZk]en\dZg]Z[Zg]hg^]ahi^' Ö`nk^bgma^_hk^`khng]%pahl^Zmmbk^ln``^lmllhf^hg^