dining in the sanctuary of demeter and kore 1 Hesperia The Journal of the American School of Classical Studies at Athens Volume 88 2019 Copyright © American School of Classical Studies at Athens, originally pub- lished in Hesperia 88 (2019), pp. 365–419. This offprint is supplied for per- sonal, non-commercial use only, and reflects the definitive electronic version of the article, found at <https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2972/hesperia.88.2.0365>. hesperia Jennifer Sacher, Editor Editorial Advisory Board Carla M. Antonaccio, Duke University Effie F. Athanassopoulos, University of Nebraska-Lincoln Angelos Chaniotis, Institute for Advanced Study Jack L. Davis, University of Cincinnati A. A. Donohue, Bryn Mawr College Jan Driessen, Université Catholique de Louvain Marian H. Feldman, University of California, Berkeley Gloria Ferrari Pinney, Harvard University Thomas W. Gallant, University of California, San Diego Sharon E. J. Gerstel, University of California, Los Angeles Guy M. Hedreen, Williams College Carol C. Mattusch, George Mason University Alexander Mazarakis Ainian, University of Thessaly at Volos Lisa C. Nevett, University of Michigan John H. Oakley, The College of William and Mary Josiah Ober, Stanford University John K. Papadopoulos, University of California, Los Angeles Jeremy B. Rutter, Dartmouth College Monika Trümper, Freie Universität Berlin Hesperia is published quarterly by the American School of Classical Studies at Athens. Founded in 1932 to publish the work of the American School, the jour- nal now welcomes submissions from all scholars working in the fields of Greek archaeology, art, epigraphy, history, materials science, ethnography, and literature, from earliest prehistoric times onward. Hesperia is a refereed journal, indexed in Abstracts in Anthropology, L’Année philologique, Art Index, Arts and Humanities Citation Index, Avery Index to Architectural Periodicals, Current Contents, IBZ: Internationale Bibliographie der geistes- und sozialwissenschaftlichen Zeitschriften- literatur, European Reference Index for the Humanities (ERIH), Periodicals Contents Index, Russian Academy of Sciences Bibliographies, and TOCS-IN. The journal is also a member of CrossRef. Hesperia Supplements The Hesperia Supplement series (ISSN 1064-1173) presents book-length studies in the fields of Greek archaeology, art, language, and history. Founded in 1937, the series was originally designed to accommodate extended essays too long for inclusion in Hesperia. Since that date the Supplements have established a strong identity of their own, featuring single-author monographs, excavation reports, and edited collections on topics of interest to researchers in classics, archaeology, art history, and Hellenic studies. Back issues of Hesperia and Hesperia Supplements are electronically archived in JSTOR (www.jstor.org), where all but the most recent titles may be found. For order informa- tion and a complete list of titles, see the ASCSA website (www.ascsa.edu.gr). The American School of Classical Studies at Athens, established in 1881, is a research and teaching institution dedicated to the advanced study of the archaeology, art, history, philosophy, language, and literature of Greece and the Greek world. hesperia 88 (2019) THE ABANDONMENT OF Pages 365–419 BUTRINT From Venetian Enclave to Ottoman Backwater ABSTRACT This article examines Butrint under Venetian and Ottoman rule during the period of its final settlement and subsequent abandonment, before the start of archaeological excavations (a.d. 1386–1928). On the basis of excavated Venetian houses and later burials at the site of the Roman forum, it is argued that the Republic of Venice abandoned the Butrint headland after Süleyman the Magnificent sacked the city in 1537 and that Butrint was never resettled thereafter due to environmental adversities posed by malaria and emergent wetlands. Plague, border-zone dynamics, and state decay also exacerbated local conditions. Throughout its abandonment, however, Butrint and its environs remained economically active and strategically important, primarily to Corfu. INTRODUCTION Luigi Maria Ugolini first arrived at Butrint alone in 1924 (Figs. 1, 2).1 As the first director of the Italian Archaeological Mission, having been appointed to this post earlier in the same year by the Italian Ministry of Foreign Af- fairs, he was exploring the archaeological landscape of southern Albania in search of the kingdom of Helenos and Andromache, the legendary Trojan founders of Butrint (Bouthrotos/Buthrotum), in the ancient region of Epei- 1. Ugolini 1927, pp. 153–157; 1937, ros (Epirus) in western Greece.2 Upon disembarking on the Butrint head- pp. 15–22. All dates in this article are land, he was confronted by woods and then managed, with some difficulty, a.d. unless otherwise stated. to reach ruins located near a rocky outcrop. There, he inspected walls of 2. For the Trojan ancestry of Bu- 3 trint, see Hernandez 2017b, pp. 210– ashlar masonry. Despite his desire to explore the ruins of the ancient city, 212. For a discussion of Ugolini’s early he proceeded no further. He was afraid of the wild that lay before him, exploration of Butrint, see Ugolini observing that it was late in the day and that dangerous animals roamed 1937; Hernandez 2017a; Hodges 2017. freely over the site.4 Butrint had long since been abandoned, and four years 3. Ugolini inspected the Hellenistic later Ugolini returned with a team of archaeologists to unearth its history. fortification wall at the eastern end of This article examines the archaeology and history of Butrint’s last Butrint, located northeast of the Great Basilica. settlement and period of abandonment, from the Venetian colonial era to 4. Ugolini 1927, pp. 153–154; 1937, the time before the start of archaeological excavations (a.d. 1386–1928). p. 18; 1942, p. 41. Three Venetian houses and late burials excavated at the site of the Roman © American School of Classical Studies at Athens 366 david r. hernandez N 0 100 km MACEDONIA ADRIATIC SEA Dyrrachium (Epidamnos) ALBANIA ITALY Brundisium Apollonia Tarentum Byllis Amantia Oricum Otranto Phoinike GREECE Butrint Ioannina IONIAN SEA Corfu Pyrgos Dodona Ambrakia Nikopolis Lake Butrint Diaporit Corfu Ksamil Kalivo Butrint Vrina Patras Plain Straits Corinth of Corfu Çuka e Aitoit 0 5 km forum by the Roman Forum Excavations (RFE) Project between 2005 and Figure 1. Butrint in the western 2011 provide new evidence for the city’s final phases.5 These houses are Balkans. D. Hernandez the first dwellings of the Late Medieval period to be excavated at Butrint and serve as exemplars of Late Medieval domestic architecture in Epeiros. Archaeobotanical remains collected from one house, destroyed by fire, offer unique insight into the diet and agriculture of Venetian Butrint. The latest inhumation burials excavated in the lower city also reveal a community suffering from a range of illnesses connected to the natural environment. The archaeology of the Late Medieval to early modern period is among the least researched timeframe at Butrint, as it also is for all of Epeiros.6 This seemingly gray period of the city’s afterlife, however, is surprisingly eventful. Its study is necessary to define the nature of the abandonment, to identify its causes, and to situate the site in the historical context of its region. Previous studies of this period, or of any part of it, have approached the Butrint material in five ways: (1) literary sources from political and ecclesiastical archives have been mined to reconstruct Venetian and Otto- man historical events;7 (2) topographical studies have traced the physical 5. For an overview of the RFE For a discussion of the archaeology of Project, see Hernandez 2017c, 2017d; the Late Medieval and early modern Hernandez and Çondi 2014; 2018. period in Greece and the Aegean, see 6. In this article, the Late Medieval Davies and Davis 2007. period spans the 13th–16th centuries. 7. See Soustal 2004; Davies 2013. the abandonment of butrint 367 Figure 2. View of Butrint and the 8 Vrina Plain in the 1920s, looking development of the city over time; (3) archaeological research projects have established chronologies and provided material evidence for specific southeast, showing the Venetian 9 Tower and Triangular Fortress on artifacts, monuments, and excavated sites; (4) introductory discussions the right. Ugolini 1937, p. 25, fig. 11; pertaining to the history of the city have included documentary material courtesy Butrint Foundation from travelers and artists who visited Butrint from the 17th to 20th cen- turies;10 and (5) geophysical investigations have attempted to model the long-term geomorphological changes in the landscape.11 The first three approaches focus on periods when Butrint was settled prior to the 17th cen- tury, while the fourth summarizes post-settlement history in the context of Butrint’s “rediscovery.” The fifth supplies environmental data for both the Venetian and Ottoman phases of the city within a broader framework of diachronic landscape change. The present study aims, in part, to assess and unify this body of scholarship, in order to clarify the processes of urban decline and determine what activities occurred at Butrint during its period of abandonment. Historical and archaeological evidence and scholarship are considered in the context of landscape formation processes, which reveal the dynamic environmental factors that played a leading role in the city’s later evolution and demise. Research of archaeological material from the early modern period, in particular, requires an approach that bridges the current methodological divide between the fields of archaeology and history.12 8. See Martin 2004; Crowson 2007; Bowden, Culwick, et al. 2011; Bowden, 2004; Hodges 2006a. Hodges 2013b. Francis, et al. 2011. For the Junia Ru- 11. See Lane 2004; Bescoby 2007, 9. For the acropolis, see Greenslade, fina well, see Sebastiani 2008; Sebas- 2013; Bescoby, Barclay, and Andrews Leppard, and Logue 2013. For fortifi- tiani et al. 2013. For pottery, see Rey- 2008; Ariztegui et al. 2010; Morellón, cations, towers, and castles, see An- nolds 2004; Vroom 2004, 2006; see Anselmetti, et al. 2015. drews et al. 2004; Karaiskaj 2009; also Vroom in Sebastiani et al.