1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 19 TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2014 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARAVIND KUMAR MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.8372/2014 (CPC) BETWEEN: SRI A SUDHAKAR REDDY S/O A VENKATASUBBA REDDY AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS R/AT NO.10/4-1, PARK ROAD, JEEVANAHALLI COX TOWN BANGALORE 560005. …..APPELLANT (BY SRI VISWANATHA SETTY V, ADVOCATE ) AND: 1. M/S BEML (HQ & MKTG., ) SC/ST EMPLOYEES WELFARE ASSOCIATION, BEML SOUDHA BANGALORE 560027 REP BY ITS PRESIDENT SRI SAMPATH 2. SHRI R SAMPATH S/O RAJAGOPAL AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS R/AT NO.36, 5TH FLOOR UNITY BUILDINGS BANGALORE 560 002. 2 3. SRI P KRISHNAPPA S/O NANJUNDAPPA AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS R/AT PUDISETTY HALLI TEKAL (POST) MALUR TALUK, KOLAR DIST.-563 117. 4. SRI VISHWANATH A S/O H R ANANTHA RAMAIAH AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS R/AT NO.10, SUBHA SOPNALI CO-OP HOUSING SOCIETY (R) DEENDAYAL CROSS ROAD THAKURWADI DOMBIVILLI (W). 5. SMT S SHANTHA KUMARI W/O SWAMY VEDACHALAM AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS R/AT NO.357, ASHWINI NILAYAM MANJUNATHANAGAR OORGAUM PET K G F 563 121. 6. SRI VENUGOPAL V S/O LATE V VEDACHALAM AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS R/AT NO.357 ASHWINI NILAYAM MANJUNATHANAGAR OORGAUM PET, K G F -563 121. 7. SRI K SATHYANARAYANA S/O LATE KRISHNA MURTHY AGED ABOUT 34 YRS., R/AT NO.267 VISWESHRAIAH NAGAR 3 5TH ‘C’ MAIN ROAD GANGENAHALLI HMT LAYOUT BANGALORE560032. 8. SRI SYED FAREEDUDDIN AHMED S/O SYED UMMER AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS R/AT NO.2750, SAWDAY ROAD MANDI MOHALLA MYSORE 570021. 9. SMT SUSHILA VERMA W/O V L VERMA AGED ABOUT 56 YRS., R/AT NO.717, 8TH MAIN 14TH CROSS, 3RD PHASE J P NAGAR BANGALORE 560078. 10. SMT MARY ALOYSIUS W/O ALOYSIUS AGED ABOUT 40 YRS., R/AT NO.230/B, 8TH MAIN 2ND CROSS, MATHIKERE BANGALORE 560051. 11. SRI MADHUSUDHANA K V S/O SRI R S VARADACHAR AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS, R/AT NO.94, 7TH CROSS ARAVINDA NAGAR MYSORE- 23. 12. SRI R CHINNA DURAI SRI M RAMASWAMY AGED ABOUT 50 YRS., R/AT NO.8, ‘F’ STREET JAYARAJ NAGAR 4 ULSOOR (POST) BANGALORE 560008. 13. SRI T RAVEENDRA S/O RAMACHANDRA BADHYA AGED ABOUT 40 YRS., R/AT NO.10, 6TH PARALLEL ROAD CHAMARAJAPET BANGALORE 560018. 14. SRI D JAGADEESH S/O LATE D T SATHYANARAYANA RAO AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS R/AT NO.17, 9TH MAIN ROAD TATA SILK FORM BANGALORE 560028. 15. SRI DR JAGADEESHWARI D/O LATE CHINNAPPA AGED ABOUT 40 YRS., R/AT NO.134, 3RD TYPE QRTS., BEML TOWN SHIP, BEML NAGAR KGF 563 115. 16. SRI P JAYAPRAKASH S/O LATE E PETER AGED ABOUT 28 YRS., R/AT NO.105, NEAR TOLGATE DR AMBEDKAR HIGH SCHOOL COROMANDEL (POST) KGF -563 115. 17. SMT SAIRA BANU W/O SRI HAMEED KOUNJI AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS R/AT NO.832, NORTH NEW EXTENSION PATEL STREET 5 OORGAUMPET KGF 563 115. 18. SRI T VISWANATH S/O T S RAMAMURTHY AGED ABOUT 38 YRS., R/AT NO.1444 ANUGRAHA, 4TH CROSS, 6TH MAIN, 2ND STAGE, 1ST PHASE, BEML LAYOUT RAJARAJESHWARI NAGAR BANGALORE 560 098. 19. SMT NIRMALA DEVI W/O SRI M MURUGYAN AGED ABOUT 37 YRS., R/AT NO.W27-625 KANNAN BUILDING 1ST CROSS OPP CITY MUNICIPAL GROUND ROBERTSONPET (POST), KGF 563 115. 20. SRI IBRAHIM KHATEEBULLA S/O SRI ABDUL RASHEED AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS R/AT S T BLOCK PALLA KADAI OORGAUM (POST) KGF 563 115. 21. SRI KRISHNAMURTHY S/O SRI VENKATARAMAIAH AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS R/AT KUPPANAHALLI C A HALLI (POST) BANGARAPET TALUK 563 114 KOLAR DIST . 6 22. SRI P SUGUMAR S/O LATE PONNU SWAMY AGED ABOUT 42 YRS., R/AT NO.231, 9TH CROSS VIJAYANAGAR BEML NAGAR (POST) KGF 563 115. 23. SRI G RANGAN S/O SRI GOVINDA SWAMY AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS R/AT NO.216, B-7 2ND FLOOR, KALLAHALLI KENGSINGTON ROAD SIVANACHETTY GARDEN (POST) BANGALORE 560 042. 24. SMT R SAROJA W/O S RANGAMANOHARAN AGED ABOUT 28 YRS R/AT NO.33 A TYPE, BEML NAGAR KGF 563 115. 25. SRI N S MANJUNATH S/O LATE N B SHAMANNA AGED ABOUT 36 YRS., R/AT NENUMANAHALLI S B HALLI (POST) KOLAR TALUK, KOLAR DIST. 26. SMT USHA RAVI SHANKAR S W/O RAVI SHANKAR S AGED ABOUT 37 YRS., R/AT NO.111/1124 SRI LAXMINARASHIMA PRASAD 19TH MAIN, 17TH CROSS 1ST BLOCK 7 RAJAJINAGAR BANGALORE 560010. 27. SMT KAMAKSHI S W/O LATE B KESHAVA MURTHY AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS R/AT C/O T R KUMAR HARSHITHRAJ BUILDING JAKKUR (POST) BANGALORE 560064. 28. SRI T DEVARAJULU NAIDU S/O LATE T G NAIDU AGED ABOUT 40 YRS., R/AT NO.89/4 RAYAPPA GARDEN COX TOWN BANGALORE 560 005. 29. SRI R B KITTUR S/O B M KITTUR AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS R A/T MANAGER (SERVICES)-22615 BEML ENGINE SERVICE CENTER BELAWADI (POST) MYSORE. 30. SRI S V KUMAR S/O LATE N SUBRAMANYASWAMY AGED ABOUT 26 YRS., R/AT NO.64, 5TH CROSS BANGALORE 560018. 31. SMT S LEKHA D/O G SHIVA SHANKAR AGED ABOUT 19 YRS., R/AT NO.25/1, 4TH CROSS ROBERTSONPET KGF 563 122. 8 32. SRI N LAKSHMINARAYANA S/O LATE N S NANJUNDAIAH AGED ABOUT 59 YRS., R/AT NO.72/1, 3RD CROSS SRIRAMPURAM BANGALORE 560021. 33. SRI S RAMESHA S/O A SRINIVASAIAH AGED ABOUT 31 YRS., R/AT NO.29 MARUTHI NAGAR MAIN ROAD YELAHANKA, BANGALORE 560064. 34. SMT S B PRAMILA W/O SRI T MAHANDRAN AGED ABOUT 38 YRS., R/AT NO.128 6TH B MAIN ROAD REMCO LAYOUT VIJAYANAGAR EAST BANGALORE 560040. 35. SMT NAGAMANI NAGARAJ W/O SRI G NAGARAJ AGED ABOUT 31 YRS., R/A NO.143, BEML LAYOUT, 1ST STAGE, 2ND CROSS, BASAWESHWARANAGAR BANGALORE 560079. 36. SMT G BANUMATHI W/O V S PANDURANGA AGED ABOUT 43 YRS, R/AT NO.245, TYPE A BEML NAGAR BEML NAGAR (POST) KGF 563 115. 9 37. SRI P UDHAYA KUMAR S/O LATE PERUMAL AGED ABOUT 43 YRS., R/AT NO.197 NEW ORIENTAL LINE COROMANDEL (POST) KGF 563 118. 38. SMT ANNA LUCIA D/O A T JOHN AGED ABOUT 38 YRS., R/AT NO.198 TRANQUILLA MUNISWAMAPPA LAYOUT KONENA AGRAHARA VIMANAPURA (POST) BANGALORE 560017. 39. SMT REVATHI W/O B S LAKSHMINARAYAN AGED ABOUT 38 YRS R/AT NO.857, SRI NILAYA BEML LAYOUT, 4TH STAGE, RAJARAJESHWARINAGAR BANGALORE 560039. 40. SRI V RAMU S/O LATE VEDACHALAM AGED ABOUT 32 YRS., R/AT NO.357 ASHWINI NILAYAM MANJUNATHA NAGAR OORGAUMPET KGF 563 122. 41. SRI P VEERABHADRAPPA M BADIGER S/O SRI MANAPPA AGED ABOUT 41 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.9 10 GANESH NAGAR, 15TH CROSS SIDDARUDHA MATH OLD HUBLI 580034. 42. SMT MALA TONY W/O I S ROCK TONY AGED ABOUT 32 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.40 2ND CROSS, PIPE ROAD ROBERTSONPET KGF 563 122. 43. SRI D VENKATESHWARA S/O B S DIWAKAR RAO AGED ABOUT 30 YRS RESIDING AT NO.247 2ND TYPE, BEML NAGAR BEML NAGAR (POST) KGF 563 115. 44. SMT B M VATSALA W/O A PURUSHOTHAMAN AGED ABOUT 41 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.23 MARUTHI, J V SETTY ROAD R S PALAYA M S NAGAR (POST) BANGALORE 560033. 45. SRI T G SRINIVASA MURTHY S/O T S GUNDU RAO AGED ABOUT 61 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.56, 8TH MAIN BEML LAYOUT, WCR BASAVESHWARANAGAR BANGALORE 560079. 46. SRI RADHA KRISHNA S/O LATE NARASIMHAN 11 AGED ABOUT 43 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.69 7TH MAIN, 3RD CROSS SRIRAMPURAM BANGALORE 560021. 47. SRI N DAYANANDA RAO MANAE SRI DARSHANA MANAE S/O NARAYANA RAO MANAE AGED ABOUT 41 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.30/3 VENKATESWARA ASHRAYA KRISHNA RAO SINDIA ROAD V V PURAM BANGALORE 560079. 48. SRI L V VISWAMURTHY S/O SRI L VEERACHARYA AGED ABOUT 58 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.10 CHANDRASHEKARN ROAD 3RD STAGE, BEML LAYOUT RAJARAJESHWARI NAGAR BANGALORE 560098. 49. SMT V MANGAMMA W/O VENKATARAMA AGED ABOUT 35 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.70 VENKATESHWARA NILAYAM KAVERI NAGAR BEML NAGAR KGF 563 115. 50. SRI SHIVAMALLU S/O SRI KARIYAPPA AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS R/AT NO.248, 13TH MAIN, 12 BANASHANKARI 1ST STAGE BANGALORE. 51. SMT SUSANA W/O SRI IMMANUEL SUBASH AGED ABOUT 45 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.5 2ND TYPE, BEML TOWN SHIP BEML NAGAR KGF 563 115. 52. SMT NIYAZ BEGAM W/O SRI MD SIRAJUDDIN AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS RESIDING AT N.372 BOWRILALPET ROBERTSONPET KGF 563 122. 53. SRI K GHANDIRAMAN S/O SRI K K KOTTAIAN AGED ABOUT 52 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.4 4TH OFFICERS QTRS BEML NAGAR KGF 563 115. 54. SMT H R BHAGYALAKSHMI W/O SRI H K ANANDA MURTHY AGED ABOUT 40 YRS., R/AT NO.190, SRI KRISHNA, BEML LAYOUT BHARAT NAGAR BEML NAGAR (POST) KGF 563 115. 55. SMT MADHU MANI N K W/O K NAGARAJAPPA 13 AGED ABOUT 40 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.B-63 OFFICERS QTRS BEML NAGAR KGF 563 115. 56. SRI U M VISHNUMURTHY S/O U R MADHAV RAO AGED ABOUT 32 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.41 10TH MAIN BANASHANKARI 2ND STAGE BANGALORE 560070. 57. SRI DANIEYAL S/O SRI YESHAPPA AGED ABOUT 34 YRS., RESIDING AT C/O MANIKYA JOSEPH NO.44, 2ND TYPE BEML NAGAR KGF 563 115. 58. SMT POORNIMA W/O S GIRIRAJ AGED ABOUT 38 YRS., RESIDING AT 1ST MAIN BASAVANAGUDI NANJANGUD TOWN NANJANGUD 571 301. 59. SRI P R RAMACHANDRAN NAIR S/O SRI P K RAMAN NAIR AGED ABOUT 55 YRS., RESIDING AT NO.119 AISHWARYA, KAVERY NAGAR (EXTN) BEML NAGAR (POST) KGF 563 115.