APPENDIX I Cultural Resources Report CULTURAL RESOURCES INVENTORY AND EVALUATION REPORT IN SUPPORT OF SECTION 106 OF THE NHPA for the CAMPO WIND PROJECT WITH BOULDER BRUSH FACILITIES Reviewing Agency: Bureau of Indian Affairs Pacific Region 2800 Cottage Way Sacramento, California 95825 Contact: Dan Hall Prepared by: 605 Third Street Encinitas, California 92024 Brad Comeau, MSc, RPA, Angela Pham, MA, RPA, Micah Hale, PhD, RPA and Rachel Hoerman, PhD, MAY 2019 Printed on 30% post-consumer recycled material. Cultural Resources Inventory and Evaluation Report for the Campo Wind Project with Boulder Brush Facilities NATIONAL ARCHAEOLOGICAL DATABASE (NADB) INFORMATION Authors: Brad Comeau, MSc, RPA; Angela Pham, MA, RPA; Micah J. Hale, PhD, RPA and Rachel Hoerman, PhD Firm: Dudek Project Proponent: Terra-Gen Development Company LLC 11512 El Camino Real, Suite 100 San Diego, California 92130 Report Date: April 2019 Report Title: Cultural Resources Inventory and Evaluation Report for the Campo Wind Project with Boulder Brush Facilities, San Diego County, California Type of Study: Phase I Archaeological Survey; Phase II Archaeological Evaluation New Sites: CWA-S-001, CWA-S-004, CWA-S-005, CWS-S-006, CWS-S-007, CWS-S- 008, CWS-S-009, CWS-S-010, CWS-S-011, CWS-S-012; ECWEP-I-015, ECWEP-SW-001, ECWEP-SW-003, ECWEP-SW-005, ECWEP-SW-006, ECWEP-SW-007, ECWEP-SW-009, ECWEP-SW-011, ECWEP-SW-017, TW-S-001, TW-S-002, TW-S-003, TW-S-007,TW-S-008, TW-S-009, TW-S- 010, TW-S-011, TW-S-012, TW-S-013, TW-S-014, TW-S-015, TW-S-016, TW-S-017, TW-S-030, TW-S-031, TW-S-033, TW-S-034, TW-S-035 Updated Sites: CA-SDI-4005, CA-SDI-6891, CA- SDI-7136, CA-SDI-7138, CA-SDI- 7139, CA-SDI-7140, CA-SDI-7145, CA-SDI-7148, CA-SDI-7149, CA- SDI-7151, CA-SDI-7152, CA-SDI-7156, CA-SDI7163, CA-SDI-7258, CA-SDI-8198, CA-SDI-8939, CA-SDI-8945, CA-SDI-8946, CA-SDI- 8962, CA-SDI-8963, CA-SDI-8968, CA-SDI-8977, CA-SDI-8980, CA- SDI-8985, CA-SDI-8986, CA-SDI-9018, CA-SDI-9050, CA-SDI-9059, CA-SDI-17205, CA-SDI- SDI-18048, CA-SDI- SDI-18049, CA-SDI- SDI- 19859, CA-SDI-20368, CA-SDI-20586, CA-SDI-20587, CA-SDI-20588, CA-SDI-20590, CA-SDI-20591, CA-SDI-20592, CA-SDI-20593, CA- SDI-20594, CA-SDI-20597, CA-SDI-20598, CA-SDI-20599, CA-SDI- 20604, CA-SDI-20605, CA-SDI-20607, CA-SDI-20608, CA-SDI-20610, CA-SDI-20611, CA-SDI-21776, P-37-024023, P-37-025680 10212 i May 2019 Cultural Resources Inventory and Evaluation Report for the Campo Wind Project with Boulder Brush Facilities New Isolates: CWA-I-001, CWA-I-002, CWA-I-003, CWA-I-004, CWA-I-005, CWS-I- 006, CWS-I-008, CWS-I-008, CWS-I-010, CWS-I-011, CWA-S-002, ECWEP-I-001, ECWEP-I-006, ECWEP-I-008, ECWEP-I-009, ECWEP-I- 012, ECWEP-I-013, ECWEP-I-014, ECWEP-I-016, ECWEP-I-017, ECWEP-I-018, ECWEP-I-020, ECWEP-I-025, ECWEP-I-028, ECWEP-I- 029, ECWEP-I-030, TW-I-001, TW-I-002, TW-I-003, TW-I-004, TW-I- 005, TW-I-006, TW-I-007, TW-I-008, TW-I-014, TW-I-015, TW-I-016, TW-I-017, TW-I-018, TW-I-019, TW-I-020, TW-I-021, TW-I-022, TW-I- 023, TW-I-024, TW-I-025, TW-I-026, TW-I-027, TW-I-028, TW-I-029, TW-I-030, TW-I-031, TW-I-033, TW-I-039, TW-I-040, TW-I-041, TW-I- 042, TW-I-043, TW-I-045, TW-I-046, TW-I-047, TW-I-050, TW-I-051, TW-I-052, TW-I-054 Updated Isolates: P-37-032854 USGS Quads: Township 16S, Range 7E, Sections 19, 20, 29, 31, and 32; Township 17S, Range 7E, Sections 5, 6, 7, and 8; Township 17S, Range 6E, Sections 1, 3, 10-15, 17, 20-22, 27, 28, and 33-36; and Township 18S, Range 6E, Sections 3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 15, and 17 on the Campo, Tierra Del Sol, Cameron Corners, Sombrero Peak, and Live Oak Springs, CA 7.5’ Acreage: 2768 acres (APE) Permit Numbers: None Available Keywords: Inventory; survey; lithic scatter; projectile point; groundstone; ceramic scatter; biface; millingstone; human remains; debitage; midden; habitation; ceramic scatter; artifact scatter; Obsidian Butte; chert; chalcedony; volcanic; quartz; brownware, buffware, bowl; historic refuse; cans; bottle; ranching; coral; Campo; Section 106; NHPA; NRHP; NAGPRA; Boulder Brush; Campo Wind; railroad; historic road 10212 ii May 2019 Cultural Resources Inventory and Evaluation Report for the Campo Wind Project with Boulder Brush Facilities TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page No. NATIONAL ARCHAEOLOGICAL DATABASE (NADB) INFORMATION ....................... I MANAGEMENT SUMMARY .................................................................................................VII 1 INTRODUCTION..............................................................................................................1 1.1 Project Description and Area of Potential Effects .................................................. 1 1.1.1 Project Description...................................................................................... 1 1.1.2 Area of Potential Effects and Area of Direct Impacts ................................ 2 1.2 Existing Conditions ................................................................................................. 2 1.2.1 Environmental Setting ................................................................................ 2 1.2.2 Records Search Results on the Reservation .............................................. 14 1.2.3 Record Search Results on Private Land .................................................... 20 2 REGULATORY CONTEXT ..........................................................................................23 21 36 CFR 800 and Section 106 of the NHPA .......................................................... 23 2.2 Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act ................................... 25 2.3 Archaeological Resources Protection Act ............................................................ 26 3 RESEARCH DESIGN .....................................................................................................29 3.1 Integrity and Structure of Archaeological Deposits.............................................. 29 3.2 Chronological Placement ...................................................................................... 30 3.3 Settlement and Site Function ................................................................................ 32 3.4 Subsistence ............................................................................................................ 34 4 METHODOLOGY ..........................................................................................................37 4.1 Survey Methods .................................................................................................... 37 4.2 Evaluation Methods .............................................................................................. 38 4.3 Native American Correspondence and Participation ............................................ 41 5 SURVEY RESULTS ........................................................................................................43 5.1 Archaeological Sites ............................................................................................. 43 5.1.1 Previously Recorded Sites ........................................................................ 46 5.1.2 Newly Recorded Sites ............................................................................... 66 5.2 Archaeological Isolates ......................................................................................... 77 5.3 Built Environment Resources ............................................................................... 80 6 EVALUATION RESULTS .............................................................................................83 6.1 Evaluation Results of Archaeological Sites Within the ADI ................................ 83 6.2 Evaluation Results of Built Environment Resources .......................................... 120 10212 iii May 2019 Cultural Resources Inventory and Evaluation Report for the Campo Wind Project with Boulder Brush Facilities TABLE OF CONTENTS (CONTINUED) Section Page No. 7 SUMMARY AND MANAGEMENT CONSIDERATIONS ......................................123 8 REFERENCES ...............................................................................................................125 9 LIST OF PREPARERS AND PERSONS AND ORGANIZATIONS CONTACTED.............................................................................133 APPENDICES A SCIC Records Search Results – CONFIDENTIAL B Confidential Figures and DPR Site Records – CONFIDENTIAL C Résumés of Key Personnel D NAGPRA Documents – CONFIDENTIAL E Previous Studies Performed by ASM in the APE – CONFIDENTIAL F Figures TABLES 1-1 Previous Studies Performed on the Reservation within 0.25 Miles of the APE ................15 1-2 Previously Recorded Resources on the Reservation within 0.25 Miles of the APE .................18 1-3 Previous Studies Performed on Private Lands within 1.0 Miles of the APE .....................20 1-4 Previous Recorded Resources on Private Lands within 1.0 Miles of the APE..................22 4-1 Level of Effort for Evaluated Sites within the ADI ...........................................................41 5-1 Archaeological Sites Recorded Within the Project APE ...................................................43 5-2 CA-SDI-7140 Bedrock Milling Features ...........................................................................48 5-3 Isolates Recorded within the Project APE .........................................................................78 5-4 Built Environment Resources Recorded within the Project APE ......................................80 6-1 Cultural Resources Identified in the ADI ..........................................................................83