INTERNET ENEMIES REPORT 2012 ENNEMIS OF THE INTERNET / 12 MARCH 2012 / WORLD DAY AGAINST CYBERCENSORSHIP//////////////////////////// 2 WORLD MAP OF CYBERCENSORSHIP................................3 INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................4 ENEMIES OF THE INTERNET BAHRAIN....................................................................................................................13 BELARUS...................................................................................................................15 BURMA......................................................................................................................17 CHINA.........................................................................................................................19 CUBA.........................................................................................................................23 IRAN..........................................................................................................................25 NORTH KOREA..........................................................................................................28 SAUDI ARABIA.........................................................................................................30 SYRIA........................................................................................................................32 TURKMENISTAN.......................................................................................................35 UZBEKISTAN.............................................................................................................36 VIETNAM...................................................................................................................38 COUNTRIES UNDER SURVEILLANCE AUSTRALIA...............................................................................................................40 EGYPT........................................................................................................................42 ERITREA....................................................................................................................44 FRANCE.....................................................................................................................46 INDIA.........................................................................................................................50 KAZAKHSTAN...........................................................................................................53 MALAYSIA.................................................................................................................56 RUSSIA......................................................................................................................58 SOUTH KOREA..........................................................................................................61 SRI LANKA................................................................................................................63 THAILAND.................................................................................................................64 TUNISIA.....................................................................................................................66 TURKEY......................................................................................................................68 UNITED ARAB EMIRATES........................................................................................70 ENNEMIS OF THE INTERNET / 12 MARCH 2012 / WORLD DAY AGAINST CYBERCENSORSHIP//////////////////////////// 3 WORLD DAY AGAINST CYBER-CENSORSHIP Internet enemies Countries under surveillance ENNEMIS OF THE INTERNET / 12 MARCH 2012 / WORLD DAY AGAINST CYBERCENSORSHIP//////////////////////////// 4 BESET BY ONLINE SURVEILLANCE AND CONTENT FILTERING, NETIZENS FIGHT ON This report, which presents the 2012 list of countries that are The revolution of microblogs and opinion aggregators and the “Enemies of the Internet” and “under surveillance,” updates the faster dissemination of news and information that results, combi- report published on 12 March 2011. ned with the growing use of mobile phones to livestream video, are all increasing the possibilities of freeing information from its The last report1, released in March 2011 at the climax of the Arab straightjacket. The mixing of journalism and activism has been Spring, highlighted the fact that the Internet and social networks accentuated in extreme situations such as Syria, where ordinary have been conclusively established as tools for protest, cam- citizens, appalled by the bloodshed, are systematically gathe- paigning and circulating information, and as vehicles for free- ring information for dissemination abroad, especially by the dom. In the months that followed, repressive regimes responded international news media, so the outside world knows about the with tougher measures to what they regarded as unacceptable scale of the brutal crackdown taking place attempts to “destabilize” their authority. In 2011, netizens were at the heart of the political changes in the Arab world and el- Even the total news and information blackout in North Korea, sewhere. They tried to resist the imposition of a news and infor- the “Hermit Kingdom,” is being challenged. Mobile phones give mation blackout but paid a high price. those who live near the Chinese border the possibility of being linked to the rest of the world. And the border is sufficiently po- At the same time, supposedly democratic countries continued rous to allow mobile phones, CDs, DVDs and USB flash drives to set a bad example by yielding to the temptation to prioritize containing articles and other content to be smuggled in from security over other concerns and by adopting disproportionate China. measures to protect copyright. Internet users in “free” countries have learned to react in order to protect what they have won. In Turkmenistan, an “Information 2.0” war was started by a Some governments stepped up pressure on technical service deadly explosion at an arms depot in the Ashgabat suburb of providers to act as Internet cops. Companies specializing in Abadan in July 2011. For the first time, netizens managed to online surveillance are becoming the new mercenaries in an break through the regime’s wall of silence2 by using their mobile online arms race. Hacktivists are providing technical expertise phones to film video of the explosion and its aftermath and post to netizens trapped by a repressive regime’s apparatus. Diplo- it online. They subsequently paid a high price. mats are getting involved. More than ever before, online freedom of expression is now a major foreign and domestic policy issue. Saudi Arabia’s relentless censorship has not been able to pre- vent women from fighting for the right to drive or vote and get- ting their fight relayed on the Internet, attracting the international NEW MEDIA KEEP PUSHING BACK community’s attention and, as a result, a degree of attention wit- THE BOUNDARIES OF CENSORSHIP hin the country. In 2011, use of online information to rally support was not limited Online social networks complicate matters for authoritarian re- to “political” goals. The Internet also buzzed with condemnation gimes that are trying to suppress unwanted news and informa- of corruption and social abuses, including the protests by the tion. It was thanks to netizens that Tunisians learned about the residents of the Chinese village of Wukan against the seizure of street vendor who set himself on fire in Sidi Bouzid and Egyp- their farmland by unscrupulous officials, and the documentation tians learned about Khaled Said, the young netizen who was of electoral fraud in Russia. beaten to death by police outside an Alexandria Internet café. It was thanks to social networks that Sidi Bouzid and Khaled Said In Vietnam, it is still dangerous to blog about the Chinese-run became news stories and went on to become cornerstones of bauxite mines and their disastrous impact on the environment1. the Arab Spring. The highland region where the mines are located is virtually sea- 2 http://www.rferl.org/content/citizen_journalism_scores_breakthrough_ 1 http://12mars.rsf.org/2011/en/ in_turkmenistan/24266428.html ENNEMIS OF THE INTERNET / 12 MARCH 2012 / WORLD DAY AGAINST CYBERCENSORSHIP//////////////////////////// 5 led off. Its few visitors cannot take cameras, video-cameras or smartphones with them. The aim is to prevent the dissemination MORE CONTENT FILTERING of potentially-embarrassing video footage. The Bauxitevietnam. info website is nonetheless managing to obtain information and As soon as the uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt got under way, is doing its best to cover the situation. most regimes that censor the Internet quickly reinforced online content filtering in a bid to head off any possibility of similar unrest spreading to their own countries. Some regimes have adopted INTERNET AND MOBILE PHONE filtering as standard tool of governance, one that strengthens their hold on power. Livestreaming sites and social networks are SHUTDOWNS BECOME often the most affected. COMMONPLACE In Uzbekistan, the government blocked access to forums where ordinary members of the public discussed the Arab revolutions. Repressive regimes have learned the lesson. Keeping the In China, the word “Jasmine” and the word “Occupy” followed media at bay, intimidating witnesses and blocking access to a by the name of a Chinese city were