f— ■ COURT FILE 1901-12441 Ni Clerk's Stamp COURT COURTOF QUEEN’S BENCH OF ALBERTA CLERK OF THE COURT FILED P JUDICIAL CENTRE CALGARY FEB 2 B 2020 APPLICANT TWENTY3 LTD., HARJINDER S. KUNDAN AND HARJ1NDER K KUNDAN JUDICIAL CENTRE OF CALGARY RESPONDENT SEE SCHEDULE “A” ATTACHED r FIAT: COURT FILE NO. 1901-14146 COURT COURTOF QUEEN'S BENCH OF ALBERTA Let the within Brief be filed. I JUDICIAL CENTRE CALGARY Dated this 28 day of February, 2020 APPLICANT FLOSA HOMES LTD. RESPONDENT SEE SCHEDULE “B” ATTACHEDu J.C.Q.B.A COURT FILE NO. 1901-14147 COURT COURTOF QUEEN’S BENCH OF ALBERTA JUDICIAL CENTRE CALGARY APPLICANT HARVEST HILLS PROFESSIONAL CENTRE LTD. RESPONDENT SEE SCHEDULE “C” ATTACHED DOCUMENT BRIEF OF ARGUMENT AND AUTHORITIES OF THE RESPONDENT, THE CITY OF CALGARY ADDRESS FOR The City of Calgary SERVICE AND Law, Legal Services (8053) CONTACT 12th Floor, Calgary Municipal Building INFORMATION 800 MacLeod Trail S.E. OF PARTY FILING Calgary, Alberta T2G 2M3 THIS DOCUMENT Lawyer: Cody Van Hell Telephone: (403) 268-1442 Facsimile: (403) 268-4634 File No. L8571 BRIEF OF ARGUMENT AND AUTHORITIES OF THE RESPONDENT, THE CITY OF CALGARY FOR THE SPECIAL CHAMBERS APPLICATION TO BE HEARD IN JUSTICE CHAMBERS ON MARCH 20, 2020 THE CITY OF CALGARY MCLEOD LAW LLP Attn: Cody Van Hell Attn: James E„ Polley 12th Floor, 800 MacLeod Trail S.E 2110, 250-5th Street SW Calgary, Alberta Calgary, Alberta T2P 0R4 T2G 2M3 Telephone: (403) 278-9411 (403) 268-2448 Telephone: Facsimile: (403) 271-1769 Facsimile: (403) 268-4634 Counsel for the Applicants Counsel for the City of Calgary GLENN & CARD LAW LLP Attn: Jeffrey B. Woodruff 120, 3636 - 23rd Street NE Calgary, AB T2E 8Z5 Telephone: (403) 291-2532 Facsimile: (403) 291-2534 Counsel for the Respondents i l. I U. 2 SCHEDULE“A” PAPPAS HOLDINGS LTD., ERNIE NOVAKOWSKI, GLADYS NOVAKOWSKI, PATRICK BOYD, PATRICIA PAULSON, RANDALL MARTIN KOPJAR, SARAH JANE KOPJAR, LOIS MARIE MORRISON, CLARE ELIZABETH GARDNER, KALO LANE MORRISON, KEVIN WALTER JOHNSTON, LAURA IONE JOHNSTON, DAVID KUMAR RAMJEEAWON, LUCILLE ALAYNE LAWRENCE, FRASER SKOREYKO, LINH H. PHUNG, MERAK WAI-KENG CHAN, JOYOUS CECILIA WAGNER, BANFF TRAIL 2026 LTD., DEAN ANDREW BENNETT, ARLENE GAYLE BENNETT, MAO YONG LI, PARDEEP SINGH SOOCH, MANJEET SOOCH, MELBOURNE GRAHAM VINCENT GARTNER, DAWN LILIAN GARTNER, BLAIR SEEFRIED, MICHAEL W. POWELL, IZOLDA KOLACKOVSKY, LINDA LEE LARSEN, MICHAEL ALLAN JENKINS, RYAN E. MORTSON, W. LUKE COOK, CAROLYN HILL, NATHAN ADAM MILLER, MAYA ANASTASIA KOHN, MAN YE, SONGTAO MAO, HWA-SOON YOOUN, KANG YONG YOOUN, VITSELLE K MARTEZ, LEON J. PREBEAU-MENEZES, MYKE ATKINSON, JESSYE COOK, JANICE MARIE PARKIN, JOHN MAXWELL PARKIN, JOHN P. SMITH, MOLLY B. SMITH, JINING WANG, XIAO LI SHOU, IAN HUGH PATTERSON, ZHENGSHENG YAO, HUAYING YANG, ROBERT PETER HIRSCH, LAURIE LYNN HIRSCH, EVAN ALEXANDER GILLESPIE, KATHARINE DAWN MACLACHLAN, JUI TING MAH, CHIN MAO MAH, KEVIN ERIC CHRISTIAN ANDERSON, TAMMY WONG, WARREN B. ANDERSON, YANG LIN, ALEXANDER MATCZUK, MICHAEL MATCZUK, WESLEY SHIU, MONICA SHIU, JIANMIN YANG, YONGXIN HAO, LINDA OU, XUEYING CAO, STEPHEN FREDERICK BOSCH, CLAUDIA M. BOSCH, OLGA DE SANCTIS PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION, NARENDRANATH PILLAI, DAYA NARENDRAN, 2039533 ALBERTA LTD., SARAH A. NIELSEN, GEORGE VICTOR LEE-CHEE, JESSIE LEE-CHEE, ROCKY MOUNTAIN HOLDINGS INC., COLIN YORK KING, WILLEM NAZIN GROENEVELD, LEPOLDINE GROENEVELD, WAYNE YUCHIH, JIAN PING WENG, GREGORY GEORGE GABLEHAUS, MILDRED LILLIAN MILLER, LLOYD FRANCIS MILLER, YOOK H. TONG, WINNIE A.T. TONG, LAURA KEETH-ROWLEDGE, DARREL ROWLEDGE, GOPANANDA GOPALAPILLAI, ELAMPOORANI GOPALAPILLAI, GERRIT VOORDOUW, JOHANNA KLAZINA VOORDOUW, ZHI JUN ZHANG, NIE YING ZHU, FIROZ ALI KARMALI, NOORANI KHOJA- KARMALI, JEREMY HOWDEN, KRIS RITCHIE, MARIA GUADALUPE SCHULTZ, DONGWON SHIN, YANG-HEE SHIN, 2041253 ALBERTA LTD., SUK KOON POON NG, CHIEN-AN LIAO, SARA WAN-JUNG HSIEH, SOU LOY MA, PUN TOR MA, JUSTIN SINGH SIDHU, LAURA KNOP WRIGHT, ALFRED WRIGHT, LORRAINE FLEMING, BRIAN STONE, LESIA IRENE HILDEBRANDT, RONALD WALDEMAR HILDEBRANT, MARK JOHN MCSWEENY, KELLY JEAN MCSWEENY, ELAINE STEWART, NEIL E.L. TWEEDALE, DOUGLAS H. HEXIMER, BARBARA JOSIE HEXIMER, ARTUR ADAMCZYK, SHAWN LEARN, EMILY ZHANG, HOSSEIN AGHABARATI, DOUGLAS GEORGE HALEY, MARGARET HALEY, KIN LI LIU, NURUL ISLAMKHAN.HOA TAC HOANG, MARIE MY CHAU, CAROL ANN JEFFERIES, M. PATRICIA GRAY, CLIFFORD L. HERMAN, BRADLEY DUNCAN SAWATZKY, TED FRANCIS LLOYD, JOAN SHARON LLOYD, DANIEL P. KRISA, RITA M. GAINER, DOUGLAS HUNTER, DANIEL CHEN, MEGAN CHEN, SEAN F. COLLINS, MARY N. COLLINS, MARILYN JUNE FEDDERSEN, HUAFENG WANG, BIRCHWOOD INNER CITY CORP., RODERICK NEIL BROWN, DAVID B. CUNNINGHAM, MARY M. BENNETT, AUDREY JOYCE CHEFURKA, TERRY PIDKOWA, DONNA PIDKOWA, STAN THOMAS SWACHA, DAVID GORDON YANKO, CRAIG STUART MACKENZIE, FLOSA HOMES LTD., CARLA M. AMTHOR, ERIC Y.W. LEE, DORIS Y.L LEE, KEBIN WANG, YUEQIN PEI, JEREMY A. INGRAM, DICK FAY MAR, CHIEN FUNG MAR, MANJEET SINGH SOOCH, RUPINDER KAUR SOOCH, RONALD WALTER WARDELL, CAROL LEE BARWICK, KEN PATTISON, LINDA PATTISON, EDYTHE DOREEN HAMMOND, RONALD GRANT STEWART, SAMUEL LEE, JESSICA PING LEE, LE BANG TO, PETER YANG, DONALD OLSEN, PHOEBE OLSEN, ANDREW E. BOOTHMAN, VICTORIA L, BOOTHMAN, 2146770 ALBERTA LTD., MY LINH LE, JOHN WALTER KERR, CHANDRA S. THOOM, NAGA R. MUDIGONDA, SANDEEP SINGH KANG, BALWINDER KAUR KANG, CATHCO HOLDINGS LTD., HUBERTHA HENDRIKA D'ALTORIO, SHARON 1 DOROTHY HAWKINS, SHIRLEY MARY ELAINE CREWSON, MICHAEL ANDERSON, PARAMOUNT HOMES INC., MICHAEL PRICE, XIN DING, MARY CATHERINE PICKERINE SAWATZKY, ORSON ALEXANDER ROSS, CHARLES ANDREW MCCUTCHEON, DONALDA DOROTHY MCCUTCHEON, RAYMOND S. STUART, PHI GAMMA DELTA (CALGARY) HOUSING SOCIETY, LAURA LEE GOETJEN, DANIEL BZDZIUCH, DEREK GEORGE CORMACK, JOHN E. MCILVEEN, ALAN J. MCILVEEN, DANI J. PAHULJE, LEESA BYMAN, JORDAN BYMAN, GARY ZHANG, HUA YANG, ROBERT RENNIE, KRISTY RENNIE, KARL PETER FAHRNI, GIUSEPPE VELTRI, VITTORIA VELTRI, SHUANXI SHEN, RUIHONG CHAI, LEONARD SCOTT LAMBERT, TINA LOUISE LOVELL, JUAN JUAN WANG, SAM GAINER, JOHN BOUMAN, REG W. H NATI UK, FRANCES MORGOCH, BARRY CLEMENT, FIONA CLEMENT, AMY Y. YOUNG, JOAN ADAMS, JIEYING LIN, HANLIN GUO, MIO TSUTSUI, HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN IN RIGHT OF ALBERTA, BLUEFEATHER INTERNATIONAL LTD., MAURLIN INVESTMENTS INC., 1720139 ALBERTA LTD., SHELDON DEERING, INA JOY EVELEIGH SIMPSON, CHRISTOS SAGRIOTIS, DAVID SHERWOOD, MARSHA FEHR, WILLIAM H. CLOW, PATRICK HARE, KIRK GORDON TAYLOR, TERESA DONNA TAYLOR, LILIUM CORP., SANG YOOK CHUEN WOO, JOHN INABA, MING DONG, ZEXI SUN, WILLIAM MITCHELL, ALICE MITCHELL, LI-YEN WANG, JULIANA BENNER, YIXI LIN, TERRANCE JAMES REARDON, JUDY ANN REARDON, LINDA HUMMEL, MIN LI, ERNEST FRANK HARTY, JOHN HARRY BAYRAK, ANDREW GEORGE GRUSZECKI, CONG BUI, HANH THAI VU, YAN FANG LIU, HONG CHAO LI, LYNN CLARK, ALLEN BROWN, WAI KWAN YOUNG, MYUNG JA YOUNG, DANA W. GALUSZKA, ANNIE CHUN CHEN, JAMES P. XUE, AMARPREET KAUR GILL, AMANINDER SINGH GILL, BRYAN REEDER, ALEKSANDRA M. SCHMIDT, LUCY SPERANZA SCHMIDT, DILESHKUMAR DILIP SIDHPURA, DIPALI DAMJI, MARION J. FRANTZ, MARION J.F. HILL, CLAUDE CAMPAGNE, MONICA CAMPAGNE, JENNIFER CHONG, FERLIN KANG, SHIRLEY ANNE ROBLEY, RALPH AUGUSTUS MACLEAN, JOAN NELSON, KLAIR CUSTOM HOMES LTD., FATIMA M. NUNES, ABILIO F. NUNES, STEPHEN PARR, DIANE PARR, LYNDA MARION THYGESEN, KEVIN THYGESEN, KRISTEN THYGESEN, BROOKE WADE, ANNA MARIE COLUCCI, RON COLUCCI, GARY STEPHEN STEFKO, SUSAN ELEANOR NORTON, 7241836 CANADA INC.MICHAEL PATRICK PIDGEON, WARREN SKARET, CHARLENE LIU, SURINDER KAUSHAL, DEEPMOHINDER KAUSHAL, KIM GIATRAN, HAN LAI TRIEU, THE CITY OF CALGARY, NEVILLE PESI DOODHA, RASHNA NEVILLE DOODHA, LILIE MARIE COLLINS, KENNETH CHARLES VICKERS, LINDA NOREEN VICKERS, CUIFANG WANG, HONGQIANG GE, BRIGHT GREEN INTERNATIONAL INVESTMENT CORP., XENIA HILDEGARD KRENZ, MURRAY C. MCCARGAR, MARI-ANNA MCCARGAR, MARIE E. FRASER, SONGBO SU, LUBOMIR HRAZDIRA, MARIA HRAZDIRA, A. RICH DEJEET, EILEEN MARJORIE BRIERLEY, ANDREW SCOTT CHALMERS, JAMES ROBERT BASARABA, MARIO M. DJORDJILOV, SELIMKA DJORDJILOVA, MARVIN L. BURKE, ANNYNE M. BURKE, WILLIAM M. MILLER, KAREN A. MILLER, JAMIE LEE ROTHENBURGER, TODD ALFRED URNESS, MARLENE FITZGERALD- MOORE, MOHAMAD EL-TURK, EMAN EL-KADRI, DOUGLAS M BUR, NORINE L. LEGGE, MICHAEL R. LEGGE, RUSSELL P. NEUFELDT, CAROLE S.A. NEUFELDT, CONRAD WOOD KRAUSERT, JUNE B. BAUMAN, CHRISTINE SCHWAB, DARREN HANSEN, MICHELLE SAVILLE, TRAVIS FUNKE, FRANCIS GRUMMETT, ARASH TAGHIPOUR NAGHSHI, FATEMEH MOGHIMPOUR, ERIC NELSON STRAND, ZHUAN REN HE, LI YUAN TAN, MARGARET JOAN JENKINS, KENNETH SKEA, DORI SKEA, MAHMOUD MOUSSA, OMAR MOUSSA, JOHN EVERETT BASARABA, ILONA VANBERKEL, HILTON CUSTOM HOMES LTD., JOSEPH LUKE HUDSON, JEANIE S. IRVING, ARDELL DECAIRE, 1645331 ALBERTA LTD., JAMES S. THOMSON, TRACY A. THOMSON, TERESA MARIE WOODS, HOW WAN NG LAU, JOSEPH CHI YUEN KWAN PARAM JIT KAUR BRAR, DEREK LOK, MING LAU, MANMOHAN SINGH BRAR, LOK, SHAOJUN DENG, MARK LOWE, BRAD MCCANN, WAI «AU MABLE NG, RYAN MITCHELL COPELAND, DARRYL COPELAND, HARVEST HILLS PROFESSIONAL CENTRE LTD., SILVER STAR HOLDINGS INC., ARCHIBALD AGNEW, GENEVIEVE MARIE AGNEW, JIANMING MA, LI YAN, MARY E. DONNELLY, SHIRLEY BOYKO, LAKHWINDER GILL, ANNIE LEE, CASEY L. MCMECHAN, ROGER MCMECHAN, LESLIE MCMECHAN, SHUNSHENG YANG, HAIYING WANG, FREDERIC C. ALLEN, ELIZABETH ANN ALLEN, JOHN STUART WATSON, DORIS MARIE 2 WATSON, SIO-HAK CHUONG, GERALDINE CHUONG, DOUGLAS MCILLWRAITH, MARCY MCILLWRAITH, 1705614 ALBERTA CORP., ANNA CORMACK, MARGARET ELIZABETH FRASER, DWAINE COSTELLA, MARILYN JOAN COSTELLA, FRANK DOBRAVEC, FRANK P. PERESTA, JULIA B. EVERETT, DANIEL SWIATEK, DI ANE SWIATEK, JIANFANG WANG,