Higher-Spin Witten Effect and Two-Dimensional Fracton Phases Michael Pretko Center for Theory of Quantum Matter, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO 80309 (Dated: September 7, 2017) We study the role of \θ terms" in the action for three-dimensional U(1) symmetric tensor gauge theories, describing quantum phases of matter hosting gapless higher-spin gauge modes and gapped subdimensional particle excitations, such as fractons. In Maxwell theory, the θ term is a total derivative which has no effect on the gapless photon, but has two important, closely related con- sequences: attaching electric charge to magnetic monopoles (the Witten effect) and leading to a Chern-Simons theory on the boundary. We will find that a similar story holds in the higher-spin U(1) gauge theories. These theories admit generalized θ terms which have no effect on the gapless gauge mode, but which bind together electric and magnetic charges (both of which are generally subdimensional) in specific combinations, in a higher-spin manifestation of the Witten effect. We derive the corresponding Witten quantization condition. We find that, as in Maxwell theory, im- posing time-reversal invariance restricts θ to certain discrete values. We also find that these new θ terms imply a non-trivial boundary structure. The boundaries host fracton excitations coupled to a tensor U(1) gauge field with a Chern-Simons-like action, in both chiral and non-chiral vari- eties. These boundary theories open a door to the study of U(1) fracton phases described by tensor Chern-Simons theories, not only on boundaries of three-dimensional systems, but also in strictly two spatial dimensions. We explicitly work through three examples of bulk and boundary theories, the principles of which can be readily extended to arbitrary higher-spin theories. CONTENTS A Higher Rank Example 16 I. Introduction 1 References 16 II. Lagrangians 2 A. Review of Maxwell Theory 2 I. INTRODUCTION B. Higher-Spin Theories 3 1. Vector Charge Theory 3 Quantum phases of matter, such as spin liquids and 2. Scalar Charge Theory 4 quantum hall systems, are well-described in the lan- guage of gauge theory. While most studies have fo- III. θ Terms and the Witten Effect 5 cused on familiar vector gauge theories, recent theo- A. Review of Maxwell Theory 5 retical efforts have established the existence of stable B. Vector Charge Theory 6 three-dimensional phases described by higher rank sym- 1. The Direct Term 6 metric tensor gauge fields. These include both U(1) 2. The Indirect Term 7 tensor gauge theories with gapless higher-spin gauge C. Scalar Charge Theory 7 excitations1{3, and the \generalized lattice gauge the- ories" of Vijay, Haah, and Fu, which are the natural dis- IV. Two-Dimensional Fracton Phases 9 crete analogue.4,5 These tensor gauge theories are partic- A. Review of Chern-Simons Theory 9 ularly interesting due to the fact that the gauge charges B. Boundary of the Vector Charge Theory 10 necessarily behave as subdimensional particles - excita- 1. The Direct Term 10 tions which are restricted by gauge invariance to move 2. The Indirect Term 11 only within lower-dimensional subspaces of the three- C. Boundary of the Scalar Charge Theory 13 dimensional system. As examples, particles can be re- D. Realization in Two Dimensions 13 stricted to motion within a plane, a line, or even a single arXiv:1707.03838v3 [cond-mat.str-el] 27 Sep 2017 point. In this last case, where the excitation is com- V. Conclusions 14 pletely immobile, the particle is known as a \fracton." Acknowledgments 15 These exotic new particles have been a topic of intense recent research2{15,17{22, since they sit at the intersec- Appendix A: Mutual Statistics 15 tion of numerous areas of modern theoretical physics, including long-range entanglement4,5,20, quantum error Appendix B: Are θ Terms Topological? 15 correction10,11,21, glassy dynamics6,15,16, and emergent gravity.17 Appendix C: Gauge Fixing 16 In this paper, we will focus on the U(1) higher-spin Review of Maxwell Theory 16 theories, which are in some sense the simplest since they 2 build directly on intuition from the Maxwell theory of tions of Chern-Simons theory. These will include both a conventional U(1) vector gauge field. We therefore chiral and non-chiral varieties. While we first encounter expect many of the interesting stories associated with these phases at the boundary of three-dimensional sys- Maxwell theory to have natural tensor analogues. In tems, they can also occur in strictly two-dimensional sys- particular, we will here investigate the role of θ terms in tems under appropriate conditions, as we will discuss. the action for the higher-spin theories. These terms are This will be the first time the fracton phenomenon has natural analogues of the \E·B" term (conventionally pa- been stably manifested in two dimensions. rameterized by coefficient θ) which can be present in the action for Maxwell theory. The conventional θ term has no effect on the behavior of the gapless photon. However, II. LAGRANGIANS it causes the fundamental magnetic monopole of the sys- tem to pick up an electric charge given by θ=2π times In order to discuss the conventional θ term and its the fundamental electric charge. This changes the set generalizations, it is most useful to work in the La- of dyons (particles carrying both electric and magnetic grangian formulation. However, for tensor gauge the- charge) which can occur in the theory, via the Witten ories, essentially all previous work in the condensed quantization condition.23 This shift in the dyon struc- matter literature has taken place in the Hamiltonian ture is often referred to as the \Witten effect,” which has language.1{15,17{22 For gauge theories of this sort, go- received renewed attention in recent years due to its role ing between the two formulations can be a nontrivial in topological insulators and other symmetry protected task. We will therefore begin by discussing how to cor- topological phases.24{26 We will find that a similar story rectly formulate Lagrangians for higher-spin U(1) gauge holds in the higher-spin U(1) gauge theories. The action theories. for each of the higher-spin theories allows for a natural generalization of the θ term, with similar properties. As before, the gapless gauge mode will be untouched, but A. Review of Maxwell Theory the magnetic charges will pick up some amount of elec- tric charge, modifying the dyon structure of the theory. We begin by reviewing how to go between the La- We will generalize Witten's quantization condition, re- grangian and Hamiltonian formulations of standard lating the θ parameter to the amount of electric charge three-dimensional Maxwell theory. We start from the picked up by the fundamental monopole. The details of Lagrangian formulation, since this is perhaps more fa- the charge attachment will differ depending on the pre- miliar in the field-theoretic context, and use it to derive cise structure of the θ term, and we will find that some the Hamiltonian. We can write the partition function of systems admit multiple different types of θ terms. We the theory in terms of the standard Maxwell action: explicitly work through three rank 2 examples to illus- Z Z trate the general principle, which can then be readily i R d4xL i R d4x 1 F µν F Z = DA e = DA e 4 µν (1) extended to theories of arbitrary rank. µ µ Another famous feature of the standard θ term is its where the field strength is Fµν = @µAν − @ν Aµ. (For relationship with Chern-Simons theory. The θ term is ac- readers concerned about issues of gauge fixing, this will tually a total derivative term in the action, which is why be discussed in Appendix C.) More explicitly, in terms it has no effect on the low-energy gauge-mode. Neverthe- of the spatial vector potential A~ and the timelike com- less, this total derivative leads to a Chern-Simons term ponent A0, we can write this as: living on the boundary which will attach electric charge to a monopole passing into the system, causing the Wit- Z Z ~ 3 ten effect.26,27 This teaches us that quantum hall phases Z = DADA0 exp i d xdt (described by Chern-Simons theory) can naturally oc- (2) 1 _ 2 1 2 cur on the boundary of certain bulk systems coupled to (A~ − r~ A0) − (r~ × A~) Maxwell theory, such as topological insulators. And for 2 2 systems with an emergent U(1) gauge field, such as U(1) where dots indicate time derivatives. To convert to the spin liquids, the edge can naturally host topologically Hamiltonian formulation, we introduce an auxiliary field ordered phases. The θ term therefore is not only use- E~ , which will eventually play the role of the electric field ful for studying the bulk physics of Maxwell theory. It in the Hamiltonian. Inserting an appropriate Gaussian also provides a novel way of studying the physics of two- ~ dimensional quantum hall systems. In close analogy, we integral over the field E, we can write the path integral will find that the higher-spin θ terms also lead to inter- as: esting two-dimensional phases on the boundary. In this Z Z ~ ~ 3 case, however, these will not be phases which we already Z / DADA0DE exp i d xdt independently understand. Rather, the higher-spin θ (3) _ 1 2 1 2 terms open the door to a set of new two-dimensional E~ · (A~ − r~ A0) − E − (r~ × A~) phases hosting fracton excitations, via tensor generaliza- 2 2 3 (where we ignore overall multiplicative constants in the R satisfying eR = 2π.