UNSETTLED GERMANS: THE RECEPTION AND RESETTLEMENT OF EAST GERMAN REFUGEES IN WEST GERMANY, 1949-1961 By Eric H. Limbach A DISSERTATION submitted to Michigan State University, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY History 2011 ABSTRACT UNSETTLED GERMANS: THE RECEPTION AND RESETTLEMENT OF EAST GERMAN REFUGEES IN WEST GERMANY, 1949-1961 By Eric H. Limbach This study focuses on the migration of East German refugees into West Berlin and West Germany between the establishment of the GDR and FRG in 1949 and the construction of the Berlin Wall in 1961, an influx that, over the course of twelve years, totaled more than three million individuals. While the newcomers were physically indistinguishable and, apart from a few regional differences, shared a common language, culture and religious background with those already residing in West Germany, the presence of these refugees, like that of many other groups of migrants, was still considered a significant danger to the public order – a perception that was deeply rooted in the historical context of migration in Germany. In response to the influx, the Federal Republic and West Berlin established a comprehensive registration process for refugees, which attempted to determine whether refugees had a valid reason for their flight, and set up temporary camps to accommodate those awaiting resettlement in West Germany. Longer-term solutions included the creation of new employment opportunities and the construction of adequate (and permanent) housing in West German cities. However, these efforts required the cooperation of organizations and agencies at several levels of government, and disagreements among the West German Länder, West Berlin, and the Federal Government had a significant impact on the reception process. The ongoing migration of refugees also created new areas of concern, in particular the perceived overcrowding of West Berlin and the shifting demographics in both East and West Germany. The West German Government invested heavily in the international effort to study, categorize and propose solutions to problems of migration in the postwar era, creating a network of researchers, bureaucrats and leading politicians that maintained a significant influence over government decisions. One particular concern shared by the government and public in West Germany was that uncontrolled migration of refugees from East to West Germany would have a negative impact on a future reunified German state. However, the construction of the Berlin Wall in 1961 effectively rendered these debates moot. Once the refugees ceased to arrive by the thousands, those remaining in West Berlin were quickly resettled and within a few years, issues of German refugee migration were no longer at the forefront of West German public discourse. Copyright by Eric H. Limbach 2011 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation would have been impossible if not for the assistance of many individuals. I owe a great debt to the various professors who have supported my studies: Norman Goda, Kevin Uhalde, and Sholeh Quinn at Ohio University, and Chris Celenza, Mark Kornbluh, Katherine Dubois, Kristie Macrakis, Lewis Siegelbaum, Karrin Hanshew, Sean Forner, and Steve Gold at Michigan State. I must, however, single out three professors who were particularly important: Philip Bebb, at Ohio University, who convinced me that I had a future in academia and whose tragic and untimely death three years ago prevented me from celebrating this accomplishment with him; Milton Muelder, an emeritus professor at Michigan State who endowed the fellowship that funded my study for four years; and most of all Leslie Page Moch, a true Doktormutter, whose advice and support it has been a singular privilege to enjoy. I must also thank my friends and colleagues at Michigan State for making the Department of History a collegial place to work. My thanks also go to the librarians at Michigan State and Case Western Reserve University for their willingness to put up with seemingly interminable ILL requests, as well as the archivists and others at the National Archives at College Park, the Landesarchiv Berlin, the Niedersachsisches Hauptstaatsarchiv and the Bundesarchiv Koblenz. In addition to those named above, Bethany Hicks, Erika Jackson, Lauren Kientz, Brandon Miller, Ted Mitchell, Ryan Pettengill, Nik Ribianszky, Ben Sawyer, Elise Wagner, Robert Lee, Andreas Gestrich, John David Wyneken, Julia Woesthoff, Corrina Unger, Heinrich Hartmann, Josef Ehmer, Jesse Olszynko-Gryn and Marlou Schrover all provided valuable comments on various portions of this dissertation. Finally, I must also thank my parents, Jon and Linda, as well as my wife, Abby, for providing unquestioning support and a sense of perspective through my years of study, research and writing. v TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................. vii INTRODUCTION – The Twelve-Year Emergency .............................................................1 CHAPTER 1 – The Problem of Migration in German History ...........................................19 CHAPTER 2 – “Heroes of the Questionnaire”: Reaction and Control in the Refugee Reception Process ......................................................46 CHAPTER 3 – Moving Out of the Camps: Refugee Resettlement, Employment, and Housing Construction ........................................94 CHAPTER 4 – Studying the Danger of Demographic Change: Controversies at the Intersection of Government and Academia ........................................131 CHAPTER 5 – “Building Blocks or Dynamite”: The Possibility of Reunification and the Problem of Migration .........................................188 CONCLUSION – The Price of Ambivalence ...................................................................209 BIBLIOGRAPHY .............................................................................................................216 vi LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AER – Association for the Study of the European Refugee Problem AWR – Association for the Study of the World Refugee Problem BAK – Bundesarchiv Koblenz BMGDF – Bundesministerium für gesamtdeutsche Fragen (Federal Ministry for all-German Questions) BMVFK – Bundesministerium für Vertriebene, Flüchtlinge, und Kriegsgeschädigte (Federal Ministry for Expellees, Refugees, and War Victims) DIVO – Deutsche Institut für Volksumfragen (German Institute for Public Polling) DRK-B – Deutsche Rote Kreuz – Berlin (German Red Cross – [West] Berlin) LAB – Landesarchiv Berlin NARA – National Archives and Records Administration NSHA – Niedersächsisches Hauptstaatsarchiv REMP – Research Group for European Migration Problems vii MAPS East and West Berlin in the 1950s A: 8 Kuno-Fischer Str. - Main Reception Center, 1950-1953 B: Other reception offices, 1950-1953 C. Proposed reception center, Spandau (never built) D. Tempelhof Airport E. Marienfelde Emergency Reception Camp, opened 1953 F. Mehringplatz G. Kladow East and West Germany in the 1950s A. West Berlin B. Uelzen Emergency Reception Camp C. Giessen Emergency Reception Camp Introduction: The Twelve-Year Emergency In the early hours of Sunday, August 13th, 1961, members of the East German People’s Police and construction workers from the German Democratic Republic sealed the border between East and West Berlin and began constructing the system of barriers that would quickly become known as the Berlin Wall. By the time most Berliners realized what was happening, the western half of the city – the areas occupied by American, British and French soldiers since the end of the Second World War – had been enclosed by barbed wire. Within a week, concrete barriers and a five-foot concrete block wall were erected to demarcate the border: the first version of what would become the iconic structure of the Cold War in Germany. With these actions, the East German government effectively ended a decade of nearly free movement between the two halves of Berlin, and, by extension, between the two German states. It also ended the unregulated migration of hundreds of thousands of its own citizens every year through West Berlin into West Germany, nearly four million in all between 1949 and 1961; such losses could not be overlooked, even in the GDR’s own statistical reports. Yet while the Wall itself has become the focal point of Cold War history in Berlin and Germany – witness the recent twentieth anniversary celebrations of its fall in 1989 – it was built more than sixteen years after the end of the war and twelve years after the two German states were established. In retrospective accounts of the political give and take that developed between the superpowers and their German proxies during the 1950s, it is hard to escape the notion that the construction of the Wall was somehow inevitable. There is some truth to this perspective: many 1 Germans, from both East and West, may have been shocked at the audacity of a full border closure through the center of Berlin, but it is unlikely that they were surprised on that August 13. Indeed, at several points during the previous decade, fears that the East Germans were on the verge of “shutting the gate,” replicating the measures taken in 1952 to close off the much longer border between East and West Germany, influenced the number of refugees registering their arrival in West Berlin and West Germany. During these twelve years, the border that would come to be demarcated by the Berlin Wall, along with the border between the two German states,