2016 Final Evaluation of the Building a Constituency for Peace Project FINAL REPORT [НАЗВАНИЕ ОРГАНИЗАЦИИ] | [Адрес организации] 0 Final Evaluation of the Building a Constituency for Peace Project Final Report December 2016 Prepared by: Natalia Kosheleva International Consultant E-mail: [email protected] Elmira Kerimalieva National Consultant E-mail: [email protected] 1 Content List of abbreviations ...................................................................................................................................... 4 Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................................... 5 Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................................... 6 1 Background ............................................................................................................................................... 10 2 Object and context of evaluation ............................................................................................................. 10 2.1 Project Theory of Change and expected results ............................................................................... 10 2.2 Project implementation .................................................................................................................... 11 2.3 Project reach ..................................................................................................................................... 12 2.4 Project management ......................................................................................................................... 13 2.5 Budget ............................................................................................................................................... 13 2.6 Expected gender results .................................................................................................................... 13 2.7 Context .............................................................................................................................................. 14 3 Purpose, objectives and scope of evaluation ........................................................................................... 15 3.1 Purpose ............................................................................................................................................. 15 3.2 Objectives .......................................................................................................................................... 15 3.3 Scope ................................................................................................................................................. 16 4 Evaluation methodology and limitations ................................................................................................. 16 4.1 Values that undergird evaluation design and implementation ........................................................ 16 4.2 Evaluation Management ................................................................................................................... 17 4.3 Evaluation design .............................................................................................................................. 17 4.4 Data sources and data collection methods ....................................................................................... 19 4.5 Sample of project sites ...................................................................................................................... 20 4.6 Analysis and interpretation ............................................................................................................... 20 4.7 Limitations ......................................................................................................................................... 21 5 Findings .................................................................................................................................................... 22 5.1 Clarification of the project intent ...................................................................................................... 22 5.2 Relevance .......................................................................................................................................... 22 5.3 Effectiveness ..................................................................................................................................... 28 5.4 Efficiency ........................................................................................................................................... 48 5.5 Sustainability ..................................................................................................................................... 50 5.6 Gender Equality and Human Rights .................................................................................................. 52 6 Conclusions............................................................................................................................................... 53 7 Lessons Learned ....................................................................................................................................... 54 8 Recommendations ................................................................................................................................... 55 Annexes ....................................................................................................................................................... 57 Annex 1. Terms of Reference .................................................................................................................. 57 2 Annex 2. Key Documents Consulted ....................................................................................................... 70 Annex 3. Project stakeholders consulted in the course of evaluation .................................................... 72 Annex 4. Evaluation matrix ..................................................................................................................... 74 Annex 5. BCP Project Results Map .......................................................................................................... 82 Annex 6: Data Collection Tools ............................................................................................................... 83 Figures Figure 1. Simplified results map of the BCP project. ................................................................................... 18 Figure 2. Shares of girls and boys in class and MSPS study group. ............................................................. 35 Figure 3. Changes for MSPS students.......................................................................................................... 36 Figure 4. Changes for MPF students. .......................................................................................................... 40 Figure 5. Map of changes for students. ...................................................................................................... 41 Figure 6. Interrelations between right-holders and duty-bearers. ............................................................. 44 Tables Table 1. Project operational structure. ....................................................................................................... 11 Table 2. Project sites. .................................................................................................................................. 12 Table 3. Sources of data and related data collection methods. ................................................................. 19 Table 4. Reach of project components. ...................................................................................................... 20 Table 5. Sample of project sites. ................................................................................................................. 20 Table 6. Responses to project presentation to potential participants. ...................................................... 23 Table 7. Project contribution to SDGs. ........................................................................................................ 25 Table 8. Project effect on targeted conflict drivers. ................................................................................... 26 Table 9. Achievement of performance targets for LSG component. .......................................................... 29 Table 10. Delivery mechanisms used by LSG component. .......................................................................... 30 Table 11. Problems targeted by action plans. ............................................................................................. 30 Table 12. Targeted youth problems. ........................................................................................................... 31 Table 13. Local perspectives on LSG component. ....................................................................................... 32 Table 14. Local perspectives on LSG component - continued. ................................................................... 32 Table 15. Achievement of performance targets by MSPS component. ...................................................... 33 Table 16. Delivery mechanisms used by MSPS component. ....................................................................... 34