SSFF CCoommmmeennttaarryy 9999 5500tthh AAnnnniivveerrssaarryy EEddiittiioonn,, PPaarrtt 22 113300 ppaaggeess JJuullyy 22001199 Cover: Randy Byers: ‘Morning Glory’. Photograph S F Commentary 99 50th Anniversary Edition * Part 2 July 2019 130 pages SF COMMENTARY No. 99, 50th ANNIVERSARY EDITION, PART 2, July 2019, is edited and published by Bruce Gillespie, 5 Howard Street, Greensborough, VIC 3088, Australia. Phone: 61-3-9435 7786. Preferred means of distribution .PDF file from eFanzines.com: http://efanzines.com or from my email address: [email protected]. FRONT COVER: Randy Byers: ‘Morning Glory’: photograph. BACK COVER: Ditmar (Dick Jenssen): ‘Dancing Almond Bread’. DJ Graphic. ARTWORK: Sheryl Birkhead (pp. 17–20); John Bangsund (pp. 84–6); John Foyster (pp. 90–2); Denny Marshall (p.112). PHOTOGRAPHS: Cat Sparks (p. 4); Randy Byers (p. 6); Merv Binns (p. 8); Elaine Cochrane (pp. 13–15); Laurraine Tutihasi (p. 18); Sheryl Birkhead (p. 43); Giampaolo Cossato (p. 57); George Turner (p. 87); John Foyster (pp. 98–104). 2 Contents 4 THE GLITTERING PRIZES Patrick McGuire 5 I MUST BE TALKING TO MY FRIENDS 60 FEATURE LETTERS Bruce Gillespie 60 Gerald Murnane: Breakthrough at the age of 79 64 Mars and Beyond: Patrick McGuire, John Litchen, 6 TRIBUTES Greg Benford 6 Gillian Polack pays tribute to Vonda McIntyre 69 Always Coming Home: Yvonne Rousseau (and Ursula Le Guin) 7 Bruce Gillespie and Yvonne Rousseau pay tribute to Gene Wolfe: 71 Patrick McGuire: Polite and detailed disagreements 9 Peace, reviewed by Yvonne Rousseau 11 Ron Drummond’s dream narrative in tribute to Randy Byers 81 NOVA NOT OUT: 12 Bruce Gillespie and Elaine Cochrane: Farewell to Harry A REALLY INCOMPLETE AND VERY PERSONAL HISTORY OF THE NOVA MOB, 1970–2018 11 LETTERS Bruce Gillespie Robert Day :: Rranz Rottensteiner :: Steve Jeffery :: with much help from Kim Huett, Julian Warner, Alan Andy Robson :: John Litchen :: Leigh Edmonds :: Judy Stewart, Leigh Edmonds, Mark Plummer, and Sally Yeoland Buckrich Dick Jenssen :: Alex Skovron :: Jennifer Bryce and inadvertent help from John Foyster and John Bangsund :: 108 YVONNE GETS HER KNEES THUMPED Cy Chauvin :: Doug Barbour :: William Breiding :: Yvonne Rousseau Gregory Benford :: Gillian Polack :: Sheryl Birkhead :: 111 Dale Speirs :: Murray Moore :: Mark Plummer :: BRUCE GILLESPIE’S NOVA MOB DIARY ENTRIES Stephen Campbell :: Lloyd Penney :: John Hertz :: AUG. 1970–OCT. 2017 AND Casey Wolf :: Jeff Hamill :: John-Henri Holmberg :: MUCH OTHER INFORMATION FROM KIM HUETT Damien Broderick :: Giampaolo Cossato :: Ray Wood :: 3 The glittering prizes: Continuum 15, June 2019 Continuum 15 took place in June, long after most of the material was written for this issue of SF Commentary, which should have appeared on 1 January 2019. But the Continuum Committee got wind of the existence of a Fiftieth Anniversary Edition of SF Commentary. So they awarded me the Eternity Award for (I assume) a lifetime’s achievement. It was a complete surprise, especially as the only other winner is Mervyn R. Binns, whose achievements in fandom make mine seem puny. Many other prizes were given at either the Opening Ceremony (on the Friday night of the convention) or the Awards Ceremony (on the Saturday). Details can be accessed at either the Contin- uum website or the Australian Science Fiction Foundation site. I was particularly pleased to see that Alan Stewart won the A. Bertram Chandler Award for lifetime achievement, and Kaaron Warren won the Peter McNamara Award. The Ian Gunn Award for unrecognised efforts in fandom went to Lucy Sussex and Julian Warner, for keeping the Nova Mob going for 21 years. (The history of the Nova Mob appears later in this issue of SFC.) Photo below taken by Cat Sparks (who also won a couple of awards at Continuum): (l. to r.): Bruce Gillespie, wielding the giant hourglass that is the Eternity Award; Helena Binns; and Merv Binns, the only other winner of this award. 4 50th Anniversary Edition, Part 2 I must be talking to my friends Whence disappeared 2018 (and the first half of 2019)? It has be one magazine. Then the page length stretched to 160-plus, so seemed like a month to me. There have been a few highlights in it had to be divided into two. Then I found I had promised to 2018, especially the 50th Anniversary gathering for ANZAPA, the include some articles that still didn’t fit. So the 50th Anniversary 48th Anniversary meeting of the Nova Mob, and Jean Weber’s Big Issue now stretches to three issues, of which this is the second. Birthday Bash in February 2018. I had more freelance indexing All three should have appeared on 1 January, but they haven’t. I jobs than expected, but far fewer fanzines produced than I had had little paying work in the first half of the year, but now have planned. Only two issues of SF Commentary in 2018, whereas I been offered some indexing projects. Someday this fanzine will needed to produce five issues to empty the folder of unpublished be finished. manuscripts sitting on disk. Still, I did catch up on ANZAPA Mailing Comments in December. That had seemed an impossible task in Almost all the rest of this column was ready by December October. 2018, so you will find very few letters written about SFC 98. Thanks very much for the recent letters that have poured in. So my life has been filled by work ... and fanzine production ... Some people, such as Leanne Frahm, Gerald Smith, Jeff and reading books, listening to music, and watching films and TV Hamill, and Gerald Murnane, have written actual letters — the series ... ones you put in an envelope, attach a stamp, then flip into the pillar box. and the 50th Anniversary Issue of SF Commentary. First it was to 5 Vonda McIntyre. (Photo: Tributes Randy Byers.) Gillian Polack pays tribute to Vonda McIntyre (1948–2019) Every day a part of me is still looking for emails from Vonda McIntyre. I knew her through emails and through meetings online. We never met. Vonda is one of a half-dozen writers (who include Sherwood Smith, Deborah J. Ross, and Judith Tarr) who reached into my life when it was bleak and ... made it make sense. I will talk about the others at other times: it’s Vonda who has left a void, so I’ll tell you how she, personally, helped restore balance. Vonda read my writing. She didn’t offer platitudes. She read my writing. She proofread it. She copy-edited it. She typeset it. Vonda knew that learning mattered to me, so she explained how to set up a manuscript to make it easier for typesetting for an ebook. I only had a year of this apprenticeship, but in that year I learned more than eight publishers had taught me. It’s not that publishers don’t want writers to learn: Vonda understood that I cared and took the time to teach me. She also let me know that I can write, despite my ten thousand self-doubts. The self-doubts return and return (for so many reasons), but Vonda’s confidence will echo beind them and remind me that my doubts are not the reality. 6 Before then — long before I met Vonda in Book View Café — was 1977. She seemed a quiet, self-contained person. I didn’t get to Vonda’s writing. I grew up reading it. I won’t stop reading it. I’ll speak to her much, but her guidance at the Writers’ Workshop talk about that some other time in some other place. It doesn’t was much valued. I didn’t meet her in Seattle in 2005, and I’m surprise me a jot that Vonda saw the values I always put into my pretty sure she did not attend any of the Melbourne world fiction, given that when I was a child I loved the politics she put conventions. I value her fiction, and regret not having written in hers. I want to talk about these things. I want those emails and much about her novels and short stories. Throughout the SF that calm voice and I want her generosity in my life again. Some community, her work her always been greeted with awe. I’m glad people leave holes when they go. Vonda has left a void. that Gillian has been able to write such a precise and heartfelt tribute to her.] [Bruce writes: I met Vonda McIntyre only once, when she visited Melbourne for the Monash Writers’ Workshop at the beginning of Gene Wolfe (1931–2019) leaves us I met Gene and Rosemary Wolfe twice. In late September or 2, so maybe they thought I was a committee member. early October 1973, Jackie Franke (as she then was) drove me to their place in Barrington, about 80 miles north of Chicago. They I favour the former explanation, because Gene and I exchanged were affable hosts, and we had a great time. letters in the period after Aussiecon 2. From everything I’ve read, he became famous as a genial and amusing convention speaker Twelve years later, in 1985, Gene Wolfe was Pro Guest of Honour and panelist, as well as a staunch defender of the importance of at Aussiecon 2, the second world convention held in Melbourne. science fiction and fantasy. He gave a magnificent speech, which I must have in my collection somewhere (but where or where?). Gene and Rosemary were So another of the very greatest of the great generation of SF setting having a break, and I bowled up to them — and either they writers (which includes Le Guin, Russ, Disch, Aldiss, Wilhelm, and didn’t recognise me or didn’t want to chat.