THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO IRENIC MODERNISM: THE EARLY WORK OF DAVID JONES AND W. H. AUDEN A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE DIVISION OF THE SOCIAL SCIENCES IN CANDIDACY FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY JOHN U. NEF COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL THOUGHT BY JOSEPH EDWARD SIMMONS CHICAGO, ILLINOIS JUNE 2019 !" S#$%& TABLE OF CONTENTS L#'( ! I&&)'("*(#!+'.........................................................................................................................#, L#'( ! T*$&-'..................................................................................................................................., A./+!0&-123-+('..........................................................................................................................,# A$'("*.(........................................................................................................................................,### C4*5(-" 1: I+("!1).(#!+...................................................................................................................1 C4*5(-" 2: A2*#+'( (4- P!-( *' D#,#+- T"*+'5*"-+( E%-$*&&........................................................62 C4*5(-" 7: R#()*&' ! R-.!2+#(#!+................................................................................................98 C4*5(-" 9: T4- P"!$&-3 ! P!-(#. F"*("#.#1-.............................................................................192 C4*5(-" 6: T4- P-*.- ! P!-(#. I+(-"5"-(*(#!+...........................................................................197 C4*5(-" :: T! C-*'- "!3 M-+(*& F#24(.....................................................................................27: B#$&#!2"*54%................................................................................................................................289 ### LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS I&&)'("*(#!+ 1: D*,#1 J!+-', N*(#,#(%, 1929. W!!1 -+2"*,#+2, 11.6 $% 9.6 .3. P"#,*(- .!&&-.(#!+. C!5%"#24( (4- E'(*(- ! D*,#1 J!+-', "-5"!1).-1 0#(4 5-"3#''#!+.............................2 I&&)'("*(#!+ 2: D*,#1 J!+-', S()1% ! '!&1#-"' 5&*%#+2 1#.- *( (4- !!( ! (4- C"!'', .. 1921, #+/ !+ 5*5-", ;; $% 9: .3. T*(- A".4#,-. C!5%"#24( (4- E'(*(- ! D*,#1 J!+-', #3*2- "-&-*'-1 )+1-" C"-*(#,- C!33!+' CC<BY<NC<ND =7.0 U+5!"(-1>........................................................68 I&&)'("*(#!+ 7: D*,#1 J!+-', T4- B"#1-, 1970, 0!!1 -+2"*,#+2, 19 $% 11 .3. K-((&-?' Y*"1, C*3$"#12-. C!5%"#24( (4- E'(*(- ! D*,#1 J!+-', "-5"!1).-1 0#(4 5-"3#''#!+.........................;9 I&&)'("*(#!+ 9: D*,#1 J!+-', F"!+(#'5#-.- (! I+ P*"-+(4-'#', 197:, 5-+.#&, 0*(-".!&!", *+1 #+/ !+ 5*5-", 78 $% 28 .3. A32)-11 * C%3")@N*(#!+*& M)'-)3 ! W*&-'. C!5%"#24( (4- E'(*(- ! D*,#1 J!+-', "-5"!1).-1 0#(4 5-"3#''#!+....................................................................................88 I&&)'("*(#!+ 6: D*,#1 J!+-', P&*(- 6 ! T4- A+.#-+( M*"#+-", 1971, .!55-"5&*(-, 1;.6 $% 17.6 .3. I+ J!+-', T4- A+.#-+( M*"#+-", :7. C!5%"#24( (4- E'(*(- ! D*,#1 J!+-', "-5"!1).-1 0#(4 5-"3#''#!+...................................................................................................................................109 I&&)'("*(#!+ :: D*,#1 J!+-', P&*(-' 9 *+1 6 ! T4- A+.#-+( M*"#+-", 1971, .!55-"5&*(-, 1;.6 $% 17.6 .3 -*. I+ J!+-', T4- A+.#-+( M*"#+-", 69 *+1 :7. C!5%"#24( (4- E'(*(- ! D*,#1 J!+-', "-5"!1).-1 0#(4 5-"3#''#!+........................................................................................................12; I&&)'("*(#!+ ;: D*,#1 J!+-', P&*(-' 1 *+1 8 ! T4- A+.#-+( M*"#+-", 1971, .!55-"5&*(-, 1;.6 $% 17.6 .3 -*. I+ J!+-', T4- A+.#-+( M*"#+-", 9; *+1 ;9. C!5%"#24( (4- E'(*(- ! D*,#1 J!+-', "-5"!1).-1 0#(4 5-"3#''#!+........................................................................................................17: #, LIST OF TABLES T*$&- 1: S(").()"- ! A+.#-+( M*"#+-" #&&)'("*(#!+'...................................................................120 T*$&- 2: S(").()"- ! F!" (4- T#3- B-#+2: A C4"#'(3*' O"*(!"#!.............................................127 T*$&- 7: P*"*&&-&' B-(0--+ T4- A+.#-+( M*"#+-" *+1 F!" (4- T#3- B-#+2...............................126 T*$&- 9: C!35*"#'!+ ! I+ P*"-+(4-'#' *+1 AT4- S-* *+1 (4- M#""!"A.....................................191 , ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I+ "-'-*".4#+2 *+1 0"#(#+2 (4#' 1#''-"(*(#!+, I "-.-#,-1 ')55!"( "!3 (4- U+#,-"'#(% ! C4#.*2! D#,#'#!+ ! (4- S!.#*& S.#-+.-' *+1 "!3 (4- J!4+ U. N- C!33#((-- !+ S!.#*& T4!)24(. I 0!)&1 &#/- (! "-.!"1 4-"- *&'! 3% 2"*(#()1- (! 3% 1#''-"(*(#!+ *1,#'!", R!'*++* W*""-+, !" * %-*"'<&!+2 .!+,-"'*(#!+ *$!)( (4- 3!"- -..-+("#. "-2#!+' ! 3!1-"+#'( 5!-("%, *+1 (! 3% .!33#((-- 3-3$-"' J!4+ M)'-, A+1"-# P!5, *+1 M#2)-& T*3-+, !" 4-&5#+2 3- (! 1-,-&!5 * ,*2)- #+/&#+2 *$!)( (4!'- "-2#!+' #+(! '!3-(4#+2 &#/- *+ *"2)3-+(. I !0- * )"(4-" 1-$( (! 3% )+1-"2"*1)*(- 5"! -''!"', 5*"(#.)&*"&% B"-(( B!)"$!+, B*#+*"1 C!0*+, *+1 A+1"-0 O'$!"+, !" #+("!1).#+2 3- (! (4- '()1% ! E+2&#'4 &#(-"*()"- *+1 (4- 5"!$&-3' ! 3!1-"+ *-'(4-(#.' #+ (4- B"'( 5&*.-. T4- )+#C)- -+,#"!+3-+( ! (4- C!33#((-- !+ S!.#*& T4!)24( 4*' 3*1- #( 5!''#$&- !" 3- (! '()1% E+2&#'4 &#(-"*()"- ')""!)+1-1 $% .!&&-*2)-' 0!"/#+2 !+ -+(#"-&% 1#D-"-+( (!5#.'. S!, (!!, 4*,- (0! C!33#((--<*1E*.-+( .!33)+#(#-', (4- L#(-"*()"- *+1 P4#&!'!54% W!"/'4!5 *+1 (4- L)3-+ C4"#'(# I+'(#()(-. L#+1'*% A(+#5 *+1 K!+"*1 W--1* 4-&5-1 3- (! (4#+/ *$!)( 5!-(#. /+!0&-12- *+1 (4- 5!-(#. !"3 ! &# - =(4!)24 I "-3*#+ )+.-"(*#+ 04-(4-" -#(4-" ! (4-'- (4#+2' 4*,- *+% "-*&#(%>. C*"&% L*+- *+1 E&#F* S(*"$)./ L#((&- 4-&5-1 3- (! (4#+/ 54#&!'!54#.*&&% *$!)( .!33)+#(%, "-*'!+, *+1 ("*2-1% =*+1 (! 4!'( * .!+ -"-+.- !+ (4-'- (4-3-'>. A)'(#+ W*&/-" *+1 D*+ W*(&#+2 4-&5-1 3- (! (4#+/ *$!)( *#(4, '-.)&*"#'3, *+1 "-5"-'-+(*(#!+ =*+1 2*,- 3- *+ -G.)'- (! "-*1 A)2)'(#+-, M*"#(*#+, *+1 (4- S!+2 ! R!&*+1>. T!! 3*+% !(4-"' (! +*3- 2*,- 3- (4- !55!"()+#(% (! "-*1 1"* (' ! (4-#" 0!"/ *+1 2*,- 4-&5 )& .!33-+(' !+ 3% !0+. T4- D*,#1 J!+-' S!.#-(% *+1 D*,#1 J!+-' R-'-*".4 C-+(-" 5"!,#1-1 (4- ,# !55!"()+#(% (! 3--( T!3 B-"-+*(!, A++* S,-+1'-+, *+1 !(4-" -*"&%<.*"--" "-*1-"' ! (4#' !$'.)"- *)(4!". T! .&!'-, '!3- 3!"- 5-"'!+*& *55"-.#*(#!+'. I *3 2"*(- )& !" (4- .!35*+#!+'4#5, "-*& # (!! "-C)-+(&% ,#"()*&, ! 3% "#-+1' N*(4*+, P*)&, *+1 N#.4!&*', *+1 ! 3% $"!(4-"' D*,#1, L)/-, *+1 M#.4*-&. T! 3% 5*"-+(' I !0- 3% #1-* ! (4- *.*1-3#. &# - *' * &# - 0!"(4 &#,#+2. M% 0# - M*"%, *5*"( "!3 -,-"%(4#+2 -&'- '4- 4*' 1!+- !" 3-, 4*' 1!+- (4#' 1#''-"(*(#!+ (0! $#2 *,!"': B"'(, '4- #+("!1).-1 3- (! 3!1-"+#'( 5*#+(#+2H '-.!+1, '4- "- )'-1 (! (*/- *+% ! 3% '.4!&*"&% 5"-(-+'#!+' (!! '-"#!)'&%. ,## ABSTRACT IP!-("%,J W. H. A)1-+ 0"!(- #+ 1979, I3*/-' +!(4#+2 4*55-+.J T4#"(% %-*"' -*"&#-" (4-'- 0!"1' 0!)&1 4*,- 1-.&*"-1 5!-("%K' #+1-5-+1-+.- "!3 *+% -(4#.*&, 5!&#(#.*&, !" "-&#2#!)' !$&#2*(#!+'. W"#((-+ *' (4-% 0-"- (4- $"#+/ ! (!(*& 0*", 0- 3#24( ("% (! 4-*" (4-3 #+'(-*1 *13#((#+2 5!-("%?' 1- -*(, #(' *#&)"- (! '*,- (4- 0!"&1 "!3 #('-& . A)1-+?' &#+- .!+(#+)-', 4!0-,-": I#( ')",#,-'.J T4- 5!-3 (4)' 5"!3#'-' (4*( A)1-+?' ,)&+-"*$&- *13#''#!+ ! 5!-("%?' )'-&-''+-'' (! $- #('-& )'*$&-, *' * .!)+(-"$*&*+.- (! (4- )(#&#(*"#*+ ,#!&-+.- ! (4- 0!"&1 #+(! 04#.4 #( -+(-"'. M% 1#''-"(*(#!+, II"-+#. M!1-"+#'3: T4- E*"&% W!"/ ! D*,#1 J!+-' *+1 W. H. A)1-+,J .!+.-"+' (4#' 5"!3#'-1 5-*.- ! 5!-("%, *+1 4!0 #(' -5!+%3!)' B2)"-' )+1-"'(!!1 #( (! $- *.4#-,-1 (4"!)24 (4- 0"#(#+2 ! * ,)&+-"*$&% )'-&-'' 5!-3. I *"2)- (4*( J!+-' *+1 A)1-+ .!+,-"2-1 #+1-5-+1-+(&% !+ 04*( I .*&& *+ #"-+#., (4*( #', 5-*.- )& 3!1-"+#'3, 1#'(#+.( "!3 $)( #+(#3*(-&% -+(*+2&-1 0#(4 (4- I#"-J ! (4-#" .&!'-'( .!+(-35!"*"#-'? 0!"/. T4-'- .!+(-35!"*"#-' 1#,#1- #+(! (0! .*35', 04#.4 G-!"2- O"0-&& 1-'."#$-1 #+ 2-+-"*(#!+*& (-"3': *"!)+1 1970, IT4- (%5#.*& &#(-"*"% 3*+ .-*'-' (! $- * .)&()"-1 -G5*("#*(- 0#(4 * &-*+#+2 (!0*"1' (4- C4)".4, *+1 $-.!3-' *+ -*2-"<3#+1-1 '.4!!&$!% 0#(4 * &-*+#+2 (!0*"1' C!33)+#'3.J I+ '!3- 0*%' J!+-' *+1 A)1-+ 0-"- &#/- (4- .)&()"-1 -G5*("#*(-', W. B. Y-*(', J*3-' J!%.-, *+1 T. S. E&#!(, 0"#(#+2 1#L.)&(, -G5-"#3-+(*& 5!-("% #3$)-1 0#(4 "#()*& '#2+#B.*+.-. I+ !(4-"' 0*%', (4-% 3!"- "-'-3$&-1 (4- -*2-"<3#+1-1 '.4!!&$!%', 04!'- 2)#1#+2 '(*" 0*' W#& "-1 O0-+: #+4-"#(#+2 * &#(-"*"% B-&1 *&"-*1% 3*"/-1 $% 4#24 3!1-"+#'3, (4-% "-*.(-1 +!( *2*#+'( 1-.*1-+( 5*''#,#(%, $)( *2*#+'( 1-4)3*+#F#+2 ,#!&-+.-. B)( J!+-' *+1 A)1-+ 1#D-"-1 3*"/-1&% "!3 $!(4 2-+-"*(#!+' #+ (4-#" )+1-"'(*+1#+2 ,### ! 5!-("% *+1 (4- 5!-(K' 5&*.- #+ (4- 0!"&1. B!(4 0-"- $!(4 5!-(' ! 04*( #( 3-*+' (! &#,- *' homo faber #+ * 0!"&1 5!5)&*(-1 $% -&&!0 *"(#'('. U+&#/- (4- .)&()"-1 -G5*("#*(-', (4-% $-&#-,-1 (4- 5!-( (! 4*,- +! '5-.#*& *)(4!"#(%H )+&#/- (4- '.4!!&$!% .!33)+#'(', (4-% $-&#-,-1 5!-("% (! 4*,- +! 5*"(#.)&*" 5)"5!'-. F!" J!+-' *+1 A)1-+, (4!)24 * 5!-( #' $!"+ 04-+ 4- '-+'-' *+ *55*"-+( ,!.*(#!+ (! 5!-("%, 4- "-*.4-' 3*()"#(% 04-+ 4- "-.!2+#F-' (4#' '-+'- !" 04*( #( (")&% #', * )'-&-'' $)( '#2+#B.*+( 3*"/ ! !)" .!33!+ 4)3*+#(%. T4- #+("!1).(!"% .4*5(-" ! II"-+#. M!1-"+#'3J -G5&#.*(-' (4#' (4-!"% ! 5!-("% *' * 5-*.- )& *,!.*(#!+ *' !)+1 #+ J!+-'?' *+1 A)1-+?' &*(-" 0"#(#+2'. T4#' (4-!"% 1-,-&!5-1, 4!0-,-", !+&% * (-" (4-'- *)(4!"' 4*1 *"(#'(#.*&&% 0!"/-1 !)( 04*( *+ #"-+#. 5!-("% 0!)&1 &!!/ &#/-. T4- +-G( !)" .4*5(-"' 3!,- (4"!)24 * '-"#-' ! 0!"/' $% J!+-' *+1 A)1-+, ("*.#+2 4!0 * +-0 *55"!*.4 (! 5!-("% 2"*1)*&&% -3-"2-1 !,-" (4- B"'( (0! 1-.*1-' ! (4-#" .*"--"'. C4*5(-" 2 '4!0' 4!0, #+ * '-"#-' ! 5*#+(-"&% *+1 &%"#.*& 1-5#.(#!+' ! &*+1'.*5-, (4-% 1#'.!,-"-1 (4*( 5!-(#. ,#'#!+ 0!)&1 +--1 (! -3-"2-, +!( "!3 (4- 5!'#(#!+ ! *+ *)(!+!3!)' !$'-",-", $)( "!3 (4*( ! *+ #35&#.*(-1 5*"(#.#5*+(. C4*5(-" 7 &!!/' *( (4-'- *)(4!"'? -G5-"#3-+('