ANOTHER DOWKER PRODUCT 1. Introduction

ANOTHER DOWKER PRODUCT 1. Introduction

Topology and its Applications 36 (1990) 253-264 253 North-Holland ANOTHER DOWKER PRODUCT Amer BESLAGIe Department of Mathematics, George Mason University, Fairfax, VA 22030, USA Received 4 November 1988 The continuum hypothesis implies that there are (normal) countably paracompact spaces X and Y such that the product X x Y is normal and not countably paracompact. AMS (MOS) Subj. Class.: 54B10, 54D15, 54620, 03E50 product normal countably paracompact Lusin set 1. Introduction A normal space which is not countably paracompact is called a Dowker space, after an old result by Dowker that a normal space X is countably paracompact iff the product X x I is normal, where I is the closed unit interval [5]. To appreciate difficulties in making a space normal but not countably paracom- pact, recall that normality is equivalent to the statement: For every jinite closed family {F,, : n < k} (k < o) with n,,<k F., = 0 there is an open family (0, : n < k} with nnck 0, = 0 and F,, c 0, for each n. And a space is normal and countably paracompact iff for every countable closed family {F, : n < k} (k s w) with nnck F,, = 0 there is an open family { 0, : n < k} with n,,<k 0, = 0 and F, = 0, for each n. There is essentially only one known Dowker space in ZFC, constructed by Rudin [lo]; all its cardinal functions are large. Watson [15] uses a supercompact cardinal to construct another (large) example. If we go beyond ZFC, there are several “small” Dowker spaces: de Caux [3] uses 0, and Rudin [9, 111 a Suslin line to get them. In [6] Rudin uses the continuum hypothesis (CH) to construct another small Dowker space, and her construction is modified by Weiss [ 161, who uses p = c + O,(E), and Bell [ 11, who uses p = c only, to construct two more examples. For more on Dowker spaces see [12]. In [ 131, Rudin and Starbird show that if X is countably paracompact, M metric, and X x M normal, then X x M is countably paracompact. In the same paper they ask if the product of two countably paracompact spaces can be Dowker. Wage [ 141 announced that CH implies that the answer is yes, but he never published his 0166-8641/90/$03.50 @ 1990-Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. (North-Holland) 254 A. Beflagid / Another Dowkerproduct example. Assuming 0 there is a countably paracompact space X such that X xX is Dowker [2]. Here we assume CH and construct a countably paracompact space whose square is Dowker. We use an Ostaszewski technique [8] and van Douwen’s idea from [4]. Our space is a modification of Bell’s line [l]. The key idea of using a Lusin set is from [6]. A subset L of the real line is Lusin iff L is uncountable and every nowhere dense subset of L is countable. CH implies that there are Lusin sets in the line. 2. Construction We need some notation. Let A = {(Y< w 1: a is a limit ordinal}, and A’ = {cy < o, : a is a limit of limit ordinals} (i.e., A’ is the set of accumulation points of A). For any two X and Y, II will always denote the projection map from X x Y onto the first factor X. The sets X and Y will be clear from the context. If (X, a) and (Y, T) are topological spaces we let (T x 7 denote the product topology on X x Y. (Formally, u x 7 is a topology only in trivial cases, but it is a basis for the product topology. We hope that this causes no confusion.) A subset A of the plane R x R is called 2-uncountable iff there is no countable D c R so that A c (D x W) u (R x 0). Otherwise we say that A is 2-countable. In [4] 2-uncountable sets are called big sets. 2.1. Theorem. Assume CH. There exist countably paracompact spaces X and Y such that the product X x Y is Dowker. Proof. Let L be a Lusin subset of the real line and let p denote the Euclidean topology on L. Hence p x p denotes the Euclidean topology on Lx L. Also, let A={(x,y)~LxL:x=y}. Let (x a : a < wJ be a l-l enumeration of L for which there is a pairwise disjoint family { Si : n E o A A E [L x L]“} u { TA : A E [L x L]“} of stationary subsets of w, so that: (a) (VAE[LXL]“)(V~<~,)[~ET,-+~+~ET,], (b) (VA E [Lx L]“)[(clPx,A)\A is 2- uncountable+ {(x,, x,,,): (YE TA} c cl,,,A], (c) (VAE [LX L]“)[(cl,,,A) nA is 2-uncountable+ (Vn)[{(x,, x,): a E S:}c cl,x,A)ll, (d) ~_{S~:~EW~AE[L~L]~}~~{T~:AE[L~L]”}=~,\{O}. Forp<o,letLp={x,. a < p} and let pB be the subspace topology on L inherited from p. Let T = {x, E L: (3A)[a E TJ}. For n < w, define L”={x,E L: (3msn)(3A)[aES,“]}u Tu{x,}. Observe that Un_, L” = L. A. BeSlagiC / Another Dowkerproduct 255 Using CH, list [Lx L]” as (AD : p E A) so that for each /?, A, c Lp x Lo. By induction on (YE A u {0}, we construct, for i -C 2 and (Ys p < (Y+ w, families { &Ji: k < w} of subsets of Lo+,. Let T; (i < 2) be the topology on L, generated by { LJb,k : k < w A p < -y} as a (sub)basis. We require, at stage (YE A u (0): (1) rL+, is a Hausdorff topology on L,,,, and rh+, = pa+, ; (2) for every p < (Y+ w, { lJb,k: k < w} is a clopen basis for xP in (La+,, 7nfw); (3) for every p < (Y+ o, ( I!JL,~: k < w) is decreasmg; (4) for every p < (Y+w, Lp+2 is clopen in (La+,, 7:+,); (5) for every p < (Y+ 0, rb = rh+, n P( Lp); (6) for every p < a! + o and n < w, if xp E L”, then L&n UL,oc L”; (7) for every p < (Y+ o, if x0 E T or p = 0, L&n Ui,, = {x0}. Fix an increasing sequence (LYE: j < w) of ordinals less than (Y, which converges to (Y. We require furthermore: (8) If a E TA, for some A, then for every sequence (p,: j < w) of ordinals less than (Y such that for each j < w, (i) A,, = (La\&) x (L,\L,), and (ii) (x,, X,+I)E clpxp& I we have that (9) if (YE Sl, for some A and n, then for every sequence (pj: j < w) of ordinals less than (Y such that for each j < w, (i) Ap,=(L,\L,,)x(L,\L,,), (ii) A, n A c L” x L”, and (iii) (x,, .G> E cl,&, we have that (10) if (YE Si, for some A and n, then for every sequence (p,: j < w) of ordinals less than CCsuch that for each j < w, (i) n(A,,)c L,\&,, and (ii) x, E cl,II(A,J we have that xc?E CL;,, U n(A,,) J<W (Recall that 17 is the projection map onto the first factor.) At the end we let ri be the topology on L generated by lJ {rb: (Y< w,} as a (sub)basis and let Xi = (L, d) for i ~2. We use (10) to show that both X0 and X, 256 A. BeflagiC / Another Dowkerproduct are normal and countably paracompact. Conditions (8) and (9) are used to show that X,xX, is normal. And (6), (7), and (9) show that the diagonal A with the subspace topology inherited from X,xX, is not countably paracompact, thus showing X,x X, Dowker. And then since the theorem mentions X and Y, we let X = X,, and Y = X1. (We did not want to have subscripts in the statement of the theorem.) Now we construct the topologies. If (Y= 0, the points Xj, j < w, are isolated. Set Uj,k = {Xj} for each i, j, k. Trivially, (l)-( 10) hold. Assume that (Y E TA for some A. Then points x0 for (Y+ 2 < /3 < (Y+ w are isolated, so set Ug, = {xP} for each i, k, and p with LY+ 2 s p < (Y+ w. In order to get (7) for x, and x,+1 we set, for k < w, Fix an increasing sequence (cyi: j < w) of ordinals (less than (u) converging to (Y. If {A,: /3 <a A (x,, x,+,)E cl,,,A,} is finite, set, for k< w, U&=(x,} and U’ol+l,k = {x,+~}. Otherwise list {A,: p -C a A (x,, xa+J E cl,,,A,} as (A’: 1<w}. For I< w pick a point d, E A’ whose distance in the Euclidean metric from (x,, x,+J is less than l/2’, and each coordinate of dl is different from any coordinate of any d,,,, m < 1. This can be done since each A’ c L, x L, and x,, x,,, r~ L,. Let d, = (dy, d:) for 1~ w. By the induction hypothesis, each T, is stronger than pa so the sets { dy : I< w} and {d: : I< 6.1)are closed discrete in 7: and 7: respectively. For I< w and i < 2 pick a clopen neighborhood Uf of df in 7: so that (i) the family { Ui : l< w} is discrete in T: ; (ii) the diameter of Uf in the Euclidean metric is les than l/2’; and (iii) for any j<,, if dfE LLI\La,+z,then Ufc L,\L,,.

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    12 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us