The Clerk to the Patents Court Web Site http://www.justice.gov.uk ARCHIVE OF COMPLETED OR SETTLED PATENTS COURT TRIALS JANUARY 2011 TO DECEMBER 2013 TRIALS FROM 2011 08/10/2015 15:45 Case Ref: HC09C04031 CAT Reading time: 1 day Gedeon Richter Plc v Bayer Schering Pharma AG Sitting time: 3-5 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 21.02.2011 Claimants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Joe Delaney (3 New Square) FIXED ON Solicitors: Bird & Bird 11/2009 Ref: L Brazell Judgment reserved on Defendants 01.03.2011 Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Tom Hinchliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Simmons & Simmons Judgment given on Ref: M Döring 17.03.2011 NCN: Heard by: Floyd J [2011] EWHC 583 (Pat) Case Ref: HC10C00883 CAT Reading time: 2 days H. Lundbeck A.S v Norpharma SpA Sitting time: 6 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 14.03.2011 Claimants Dr. Justin Turner QC & Dominic Hughes, 3 New Square FIXED ON Howrey LLP 05.05.2010 Ref: P. Inman Judgment reserved on Defendants 24.03.2011 Andrew Lykiardopoulos, 8 New Square Cumberland Ellis Judgment given on Ref: QJML INF 3 1 14.04.2011 NCN [2011] EWHC 907 (Pat) Heard by: Floyd J Case Ref: HC06C03050 CAT Reading time: Les Laboratories Servier v Apotex Sitting time: 3-4 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 14.03.2011 Claimants Counsel: Antony Watson QC & Simon Salzedo FIXED ON (3 New Square & Brick Court Chambers) 05.11.2010 Solicitors: Taylor Wessing Ref: Mr S Cohen Judgment reserved on 16.03.2011 Defendants Counsel: Iain Purvis QC & Andrew Lykiadopoulos Judgment given on (11 South Square & 8 New Square) 29.03.2011 Solicitors: Bristows Ref: 453/B/09360 0041 NCN: [2011] EWHC 730 (Pat) Heard by: Arnold J Case Ref: HC09C04064 Hospira, Inc. & anr v Amgen Inc. SETTLED HC10C01233 CAT Reading time: 1 day Nokia OYJ (Nokia Corporation) v IPCom GmbH & Co. KG Sitting time: 3-4 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 11.04.2011 Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & James Abrahams (8 New Square) FIXED ON Solicitors: Bird & Bird 08.07.2010 Ref: J Mutimear Judgment reserved on Defendants 20.04.2011 Counsel: Henry Carr QC & Brian Nicholson (11 South Square) Solicitors: Bristows Judgment given on Ref: Miles Jelf 16.06.2011 NCN: [2011] EWHC 1470 (Pat) Heard by: Floyd J Case Ref: HC09C04770 CAT Reading time: 4 days Medimmune Ltd v Novartis Pharmaceuticals UK Ltd Sitting time: 15 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 02.05.2011 Claimants Counsel: Richard Meade QC & Tom Mitcheson FIXED ON (8 New Square & 3 New Square) 12.03.2010 Solicitors: Marks & Clerk Ref: L3940/MG/WJ Judgment reserved on 27.05.2011 Defendants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC with Justin Turner QC & Joe Delaney Judgment given on (3 New Square) 05.07.2011 Solicitors: Allen & Overy Ref: Nicola Dagg NCN: [2011] EWHC 1669 (Pat) Heard by: Arnold J Case Ref: HC10C02910 CAT Reading time: 2 days Cephalon Inc. & ors v Orchid Europe Ltd & anr Sitting time: 5-6 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 09.05.2011 Claimants Counsel: Henry Carr QC & Piers Acland QC (11 South Square) FIXED ON Solicitors: Simmons & Simmons 19.11.2010 Ref: 1496-26/RBF/BXXH Judgment reserved on Defendants 13.05.2011 Counsel: Michael Tappin QC & Adrian Speck (8 New Square) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing LLP & Latham Watkins Judgment given on Ref: JMM/KFM 24.06.2011 NCN: Heard by: Floyd J [2011] EWHC 1591 (Pat) Case Ref: HC10C00879 Janssen-Cilag NV v Bayer Corporation SETTLED Case Ref: HC10C03103 CAT Reading time: 1 day Ranbaxy (UK) Ltd v Astrazeneca AB Sitting time: 3-4 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 07.06.2011 Claimants Counsel: John Baldwin QC & Mark Chacksfield (8 New Square) FIXED ON Solicitors: SJ Berwin 19.11.2010 Ref: 1555/R21261.14/3614241.1CJAT Judgment reserved on Defendants 10.06.2011 Counsel: Henry Carr QC with Tom Mitcheson & Miles Copeland Judgment given on (11 South Square & 3 New Square) 15.07.2011 Solicitors: Bristows Ref: 245/SAF/10281 0006 NCN: [2011] EWCH 1831 (Pat) Heard by: Kitchin J Case Ref: HC09C04080 CAT Reading time: ½ day Select Healthcare (UK) Ltd v Cromptons Healthcare Ltd & anr Sitting time: 3 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 20.06.2011 Claimants Counsel: Ashley Roughton (Hogarth Chambers) FIXED ON Solicitors: Gowings LLP 22.07.2010 Ref: B000059 Judgment reserved on Defendants 22.06.2011 Counsel: Heather Lawrence (11 South Square) Solicitors: Williams Powell Judgment given on Ref: J Excell 15.07.2011 NCN: [2011] EWHC 1830 (Pat) Heard by: Kitchin J Case Ref: HC08C00391 Leo Pharma v Sandoz SETTLED Case Ref: HC10C03618 CAT Reading time: 3 days Convatec Ltd & ors v Smith & Nephew Healthcare Ltd & ors Sitting time: 15 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 04.07.2011 Claimants Counsel: Piers Acland QC with Brian Nicholson & Geoffrey Pritchard FIXED ON (11 South Square & 3 New Square) 08.12.2010 Solicitors: Latham & Watkins Ref: LC/IB Judgment reserved on 08.11.2011 1st & 2nd Defendants Counsel: James Mellor QC & Miles Copeland Judgment given on (8 New Square & 3 New Square) 21.12.2011 Solicitors: Bristows Ref: 393/PGW/10403 0019 3rd Defendants Counsel: Justin Turner QC & Mark Chacksfield (3 New Square & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Slaughter & May Ref: SXXM/RAZD/JMD 4th Defendants Counsel: Andrew Norris (Hogarth Chambers) NCN: Solicitors: Kingsley Napley [2011] EWHC 3461 (Pat) Heard by: HHJ Birss QC (Sitting as a judge of the High Court) Case Ref: HC09C02361 Atrium Medical Corporation & anr v DSB Invest Holding SA SETTLED Case Ref: HC10C00864 Kohler Mira Ltd v Norcoss Group Ltd SETTLED Case Ref: HC10C04610 Actavis UK Ltd v Novartis SETTLED Case Ref: HC09C03989 Elmo-Tech Ltd & anr v Guidance Ltd & anr SETTLED Case Ref: HC10C01095 Kuka Systems & Thompson Friction Welding Ltd v Mike Dorsett & SETTLED Magna International Case Ref: HC10C02854 Astrazeneca AB v Krka SETTLED Case Ref: HC08C00958 CAT Reading time: 1½ days Fabio Perini SpA v LPC Group PLC & ors Sitting time: 8 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 03.10.2011 Claimants Counsel: Justin Turner QC & Miles Copeland (3 New Square) FIXED ON Solicitors: Collyer Bristow 29.07.2010 Ref: J Cohen Judgment reserved on 2nd Defendants 19.10.2011 Counsel: Anthony Watson QC & Tom Hinchcliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing LLP Judgment given on Ref: 04.04.2012 4th Defendants Counsel: Anthony Watson QC & Tom Hinchcliffe (3 New Square) Solicitors: Harvey Ingram LLP Ref: P McAleer NCN: [2012] EWHC 911 (Ch) Heard by: Norris J TRIALS FROM 2012 Case Ref: HC11C00127, HC11C00131 CAT Reading time: 1 day Bayer Schering Pharma AG v Genentech Sitting time: 5-6 days (to be heard with Regeneron action) WINDOW (5 days) Representatives 11.01.2012 Claimants FIXED ON Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) 16.03.2011 Solicitors: Simmons & Simmons Ref: Ms M. Noor Judgment reserved on 25.01.2012 Defendants Counsel: Michael Tappin QC (8 New Square) Judgment given on Solicitors: Marks & Clerk 22.03.2012 Ref: Mr M. Gilbert Claimant in Regeneron Action Counsel: Richard Meade QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Bird & Bird Ref: Mr P. Kelleher NCN: [2012] EWHC 657 (Pat) Heard by: Floyd J Case Ref: HC10C04779, HC11C0553 & HC11C01095 CAT Reading time: 1 day Teva UK Ltd & anr v Astrazeneca AB Sitting time: 3-4 days Inatas Pharmaceuticals Ltd & anr v Astrazeneca AB Hexal AG & anr v Astrazeneca AB WINDOW (5 days) 20.02.2012 Representatives FIXED ON Claimants (4779) 17.02.2011 Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC & Tom Mitcheson (8 New Square & 3 New Square) Judgment reserved on Solicitors: Pinsent Masons 27.02.2012 Ref: J Singer – 641975.07043 Judgment given on Claimants (553 & 1095) 22.03.2012 Counsel: Daniel Alexander QC & Adrian Speck (8 New Square) Solicitors: Taylor Wessing Ref: SCC/MZS/CWH Defendants Counsel: Piers Acland QC & Mark Chacksfield (11 South Square & 8 New Square) Solicitors: Bristows Ref: S Field - 324/SAF/10281003 NCN: [2012] EWHC 655 (Pat) Heard by: Arnold J Case Ref: HC10C01989 CAT Reading time: 1 day Wagner International AG & ors v Earlex Ltd Sitting time: 4-5 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 12.03.2012 Claimants Counsel: Richard Davis (Hogarth Chambers) FIXED ON Solicitors: Field Fisher Waterhouse 18.01.2011 Ref: DMK Judgment reserved on Defendants 16.03.2012 Counsel: Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) Solicitors: Redd Judgment given on Ref: Sara Ashby 18.04.2012 NCN: [2012] EWHC 984 (Pat) Heard by: Floyd J Case Ref: HC10C04270 Shire Pharmaceutical Contracts Ltd v Mount Sinai School of Medicine SETTLED of New York University Case Ref: HC09C04478 Orasure v D D D Ltd & others SETTLED Case Ref: GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals v Novartis AG SETTLED Case Ref: HC11C03433 Syngenta Ltd & ors v Chemsource Ltd & anr SETTLED Case Ref: HC10C02358 CAT Reading time: 2 days Danisco A/S v Novozymes A/S Sitting time: 6 days Representatives Claimants WINDOW (5 days) Counsel: Andrew Waugh QC & Tom Mitcheson (3 New Square) 19.03.2012 Solicitors: Arnold & Porter Ref: DCLP/CMS FIXED ON 01.10.2010 Defendants Counsel: Simon Thorley QC & Miles Copeland (3 New Square) PATENT REVOKED Solicitors: Bird & Bird BEFORE TRIAL Ref: MM/EP see [2013] EWHC 155 (Pat) Heard by: Case Ref: HC10C02983 Nuance v Vlingo SETTLED Case Ref: HC11C01111 SanDisk IL Ltd & anr v Kingston Technology Europe Ltd & anr SETTLED Case Ref: HC11C04177 Vision Critical Limited v Future Route Limited SETTLED Case Ref: HC09C03755 CAT Reading time: 1½ days Molnlycke Healthcare v BSN Medical Sitting time: 5-6 days Representatives WINDOW (5 days) 08.10.2012 Claimants Counsel: Iain Purvis QC & Anna Edwards-Stuart (11 South Square) FIXED ON Solicitors: Charles Russell LLP 05.07.2011 Ref: IW Judgment reserved on Defendants 18.10.2012 Counsel: Richard Meade QC (8 New Square) Solicitors: Powell Gilbert LLP