18/12/2013 SUPPLEMENTARY LIST SUPPLEMENTARY LIST FOR TODAY IN CONTINUATION OF THE ADVANCE LIST ALREADY CIRCULATED. THE WEBSITE OF DELHI HIGH COURT IS www.delhihighcourt.nic.in INDEX PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS ---------> J-1 TO J-1 REGULAR MATTERS --------------------> R-1 TO R-56 FINAL MATTERS (ORIGINAL SIDE) ------> F-1 TO F-8 ADVANCE LIST -----------------------> 1 TO 62 APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)-> 63 TO 79 (FIRST PART) APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)-> 82 TO 90 (SECOND PART) COMPANY ----------------------------> 91 TO 91 ORIGINAL SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY I)-----> 92 TO 100 SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY ---------------> 101 TO NOTICE IN VIEW OF THE ENSUING WINTER VACATION 2013, FRESH MATTERS AND APPLICATIONS WILL ALSO BE LISTED ON THURSDAY, THE 19th DECEMBER, 2013. NOTES 1. LPA matters being listed before Hon'ble DB-VIII in Part-D of Regular matters list will be taken up on every working day. 2. Regular matters will not be taken up for hearing by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw from 18.12.2013 to 20.12.2013. Hence Regular matters list is not being published. However, RFA 158/2007 which is a Part-Heard matter, will be taken up on Thursday i.e. 19.12.2013. 3. Hon'ble Mr.Justice R.V. Easwar will not be holding Court today. Dates will be given by the Court Master. DELETIONS 1. W.P.(C) 7918/2011 listed before Hon'ble DB-II at item No.2 is deleted as the same is fixed for 18.02.2014. 2. CM 16993/2013 in W.P.(C) 7843/2013 listed before Hon'ble DB-III at item No.1 is deleted. 3. CM 17002-03/2013 in W.P.(C) 2097/2013 listed before Hon'ble DB-VI at item No.21 is deleted. 4. C.M. 20310/2013 in R.C. Rev. 376/2013 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice V. K. Shali at item no. 27 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manmohan Singh. 5. CRL.M.A. 19070/2013 in CRL.M.C. 5276/2013 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sunil Gaur at item No.22 is deleted. 6. MAC.APPL. 815/2013 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Suresh Kait at item No.47 is deleted as the same is already listed at item No.46. 7. MAC.APPL.815/2013 listed before Sh. K.K. Nangia, Registrar(O) at item No.27 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Suresh Kait. REGISTRAR(LISTING) 18.12.2013 J-1 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENTS (APPLT. JURISDICTION) 18.12.2013 COURT NO. 6 (DIVISION BENCH-6) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA AT 10.30 A.M 2. CEAR 7/2000 COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE RAHUL KAUSHIK VS. M/S GRANDS CARD INDUSTRIES & ORS. BHUVNESHWARI PATHAK AT 2.15 P.M 1. W.P.(C) 2494/1997 U.K. PAINT INDUSTRIES PROPRIETOR G.L. RAWAL M/S U.K. PAINT (INDIA) LIMITED & ANR. RAJESH RAWAL VS. COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS & OTHERS RAHUL KAUSHIK BHUVNESHWARI PATHAK HIGH COURT OF DELHI 17TH DECEMBER, 2013 REGISTRAR (LISTING) 18.12.2013 R- 1 ( Regular Matters) 18.12.2013 REGULAR MATTERS COURT NO. 2 (DIVISION BENCH-2) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BADAR DURREZ AHMED HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIBHU BAKHRU CASES OF PERSONS ABOVE 65 YRS. OF AGE (SENIOR CITIZENS) NO.2. RFA(OS) 15/2013-----FOR 9.1.14 IN ANMM 1. RFA(OS) 93/2010 KRISHAN KUMAR AGGARWAL AND ORS VIJAY K GUPTA,KAMAL MEHTA NB: HMJ S. RAVINDRA BHAT Vs. LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION 1A. RFA(OS) 14/2011 SYED AIJAZ HASAN ASHOK GURNANI,BAHAR U. Vs. MALIK MOHAMMED TAHSEEN BARQUI,CAV,SHARIQ ZAIDI REGULAR MATTERS NO.1-----------DISPOSED OF NO.2. W.P.(C) 4324/1994---FOR 23.1.14 IN ANMM 2A. W.P.(C) 1175/1994 M/S HINDALCO INDUSTRIES LTD. MEERA BHATIA,ANJALI VOHRA Vs. ASSISTANT COLLECTOR, CENTRAL EXCISE, MIRZAPUR 3 . FAO(OS) 551/2006 PRADEEP ANAND ABHIJIT SINHA, CICCU Vs. ITC LTD. AND ORS MUKHOPADHAYA, RAJAN NARAIN, PRAVIN BAHADUR, ABHIJEET SINGH, VIPLAV SHARMA, MANOJ V GORGE, SUHAIL DUTT 4 . FAO(OS) 402/2007------| VIJAY SAWHNEY M.K.GARG, SAKET SIKRI, ANKIT CM APPL. 2839/2008 | Vs. MRILANI CHOPRA AND ORS SWARUP, MOHIT PAUL | 5 . FAO(OS) 404/2007------| CDR. AJAY K.SAWHNEY MANOJ SWARUP, M.K.GARG, ANKIT Vs. G.B.PANT UNIVESITY OF SWARUP, MEET MALHOTRA AGRICULTURE AND TECHNOLOGY THROUGH ITS VICE CHANCELLOR AND ORS 6 . W.P.(C) 7527/2007 BHURIA AND ORS. GAURAV SARIN, CHARUL SARIN, Vs. UOI AND ORS. RAMESH RAY, RAJ SINGH MAHTUR, MALDEEP SIDHU 7 . FAO(OS) 86/2008 NATIONAL PUBLISHING HOUSE AND S.P. SINGH, S K MISHRA, ANR. CHANDRA SHEKHAR Vs. ARVIND KUMAR SINGH AND ANR. 7A. RFA(OS) 94/2009 V. SREENIVAS B.K. CHAUDHARY,VIKAS NB: HMJ S. RAVINDRA BHAT Vs. M/S FELEX ENTERPRISES PVT AGGARWAL,ANSHU LTD AND ANR MAHAJAN,VARTIKA SAHAY,VIJAY VERMA 8 . FAO(OS) 281/2009------| MODI TELECOMUNICATION LTD. ATUL NANDA, KHAITAN AND CO. WITH FAO(OS) 282/2009 Vs. UOI FAO(OS) 283/2009 | 9 . FAO(OS) 282/2009 | MODI TELECOMUNICATION LTD. ATUL NANDA, GAURAV, KHAITAN Vs. UOI AND CO. 10. FAO(OS) 283/2009------| MODI TELECOMUNICATION LTD. ATUL NANDA, KHAITAN AND CO. Vs. UOI 11. FAO(OS) 289/2009 DURGA LAXMI BUILDERS MOHINDERJIT SINGH RUPAL, Vs. VICE CHANCELLOR SANDEEP SHARMA UNIVERSITY OF DELHI AND ANR. 12. FAO(OS) 302/2009 M/S S.D.TECHNICAL SERVICES AMRIT OBEROI PVT LTD Vs. UOI AND ANR 13. FAO(OS) 317/2009 KALYANPUR CEMENTS LTD. AK BHARDWAJ, PAVAN KUMAR CM APPL. 10357/2009 Vs. UOI 14. FAO(OS) 336/2009-----| SATISH MEHRA VINOD KUMAR, NARESH KAUSHIK, | Vs. K.C.MEHRA AND ORS. PRATITI RUNGTA 15. FAO(OS) 363/2009 | P.R.MALHOTRA P. GAUTAM, RAKESH TIKKU, | Vs. K.C.MEHRA AND ORS. NARESH KAUSHIK 16. FAO(OS) 416/2009-----| SONAL MEHRA AND ORS P. GAUTAM, RAKESH TIKU, Vs. K C MEHRA AND ORS NARESH KAUSHIK, VINOD KUMAR 18.12.2013 R- 2 ( Regular Matters) COURT NO. 3 (DIVISION BENCH-3) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP NANDRAJOG HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.KAMESWAR RAO [NOTE: COUNSELS ARE REQUESTED TO PROVIDE BRIEF SYNOPSIS/PHOTOCOPIES OF THE JUDGMENTS RELIED UPON BY THEM. REGULAR MATTERS NO.11,12,13,14,15,16,17,20,21,22,22A,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,31A,31B,32,33, 35,36,37,38,39---------------------------------------------------DISPOSED OF NO.9. W.P.(C) 4386/2011-----OTHER BENCH 1A. W.P.(C) 139/2000--------| UOI V.S.R. KRISHNA,K.R. SUB TO O/N PH Vs. MANISHA SHARMA AND ORS. SACHDEVA,ATUL JHA,SUHAIL | DUTT,KAVIRAJ SINGH,SHYAM BABU,RAJ MATHUR,LINK | LEGAL,VINAY PRAKASH GOEL 1B. W.P.(C) 8444/2003 | UOI RAKESH CHAHAR,K.R. SUB TO O/N PH Vs. NAIRUPMA KUMAR AND ORS. SACHDEVA,KAVIRAJ SINGH,S.K. | PATHAK 1C. W.P.(C) 12413-14/2006---| UOI AND ANR SANJAY KUMAR PATHAK,KAVI RAJ SUB TO O/N PH Vs. NEELAM SANGHI SINGH 1 . W.P.(C) 4764/2011------| NDMC AND ANR PARAS CHAUDHARY,PRAMOD KUMAR NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH Vs. SD VERMA AND ORS SHARMA,SAAHILA LAMBA 2 . W.P.(C) 2267/2011 | NDMC AND ANR PARAS CHAUDHARY,KARAN SINGH NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH Vs. PURAN CHAND AND ORS BHATI,SAAHILA LAMBA 3 . W.P.(C) 332/2011 | NEW DELHI MUNICIPAL COUNCIL AND AMANDEEP JOSHI,AMIT NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH ANR. PAWAN,PRAMOD GUPTA,SAAHILA Vs. LAKHPAT SINGH AND ORS. LAMBA 4 . W.P.(C) 1752/2011 | NDMC AND ANR KANIKA AGNIHOTRI,SANJIV SAHA NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH Vs. NARENDER KUMAR GAUR AND ANR 5 . W.P.(C) 2337/2013 | NDMC THR DIRECTOR ARUN BHARDWAJ NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH Vs. M.P.DWIVEDI AND ORS 6 . W.P.(C) 340/2011 | NDMC AND ORS. PARAS CHAUDHARY,RASHMI CHOPRA NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH Vs. NDMC AUTO WORKSHOP EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION 7 . LPA 666/2011-----------| NDMC AND ORS PARAS CHAUDHARY,ARVIND NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH Vs. RAM AVTAR GUPTA AND ANR SHAH,CAV,SAAHILA LAMBA 8 . W.P.(C) 3287/2013 NEW DELHI MUNICIPAL COUNCIL KANIKA AGNIHOTRI NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH Vs. KRISHAN LAL AND ORS. 9A. W.P.(C) 3832/2012 RANVIR SINGH RANVIR SINGH,RAJINDER NISCHAL NO.1 Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 10. W.P.(C) 2735/2010 UNION OF INDIA AND ANR. SUDHIR WALLIA,NISHA PRIYA IST 5 CASES Vs. NISHA PRIYA BHATIA BHATIA,RESPONDENT IN PERSON,RICHA KAPOOR 18. W.P.(C) 6433/2010 S C DUBEY C HARI SHANKAR,SHASHI RANJAN Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS 19. W.P.(C) 2551/2011 BHARTI BHARDWAJ LOKESH KUMAR SHARMA,NARESH Vs. UPSC AND ORS KAUSHIK,AS SINGH,ANJANA GOSAIN,RISHI KANT SINGH 18.12.2013 R- 3 ( Regular Matters) 20B.W.P.(C) 142/2013 NYAYA BHOOMI THROUGH ITS J.K.MITTAL IST 5 CASES PRESIDENT Vs. GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS 34 . W.P.(C) 7622/2002 SURENDER SINGH MANAV TULI, BS MATHUR, Vs. THE GOVT. OF DELHI AND ORS. L.R.KHATANA 40 . W.P.(C) 244/2002------| UOI & ANR. SANJIV SHARMA | Vs. THE DEFENCE MARINE | ENGG.TECH.S | 40A. W.P.(C) 7885/2007-----| UOI THE SECRETARY MINISTRY H.K.GANGWANI, OF DEFENCE PRASHANTI PRASAD Vs. SEWA SINGH 41 . W.P.(C) 2047/2002 RAM PRASAD P.K.MALIK Vs. UOI AND ORS 41A.W.P.(C) 2320/2002 RAJBIR SINGH G.S.RANA,ANUJ AGARWAL Vs. UOI AND ORS.