9^k^c\VcY=neZgWVg^XBZY^X^cZKdajbZ(.Cd#)9ZXZbWZg'%%. EJGEDH:HD;I=:HD8>:I>:H IdegdbdiZVcY[VX^a^iViZi]ZhijYnd[VaaVheZXihd[jcYZglViZgVcY]neZgWVg^XbZY^X^cZ Idegdk^YZ^c[dgbVi^dcdcjcYZglViZgVcY]neZgWVg^XbZY^X^cZ IdejWa^h]V_djgcVaVcYidXdckZcZbZbWZghd[ZVX]HdX^ZinVccjVaanViVhX^Zci^ÄXXdc[ZgZcXZ HDJI=E68>;>8JC9:GL6I:G :JGDE:6CJC9:GL6I:G6C9 B:9>8>C:HD8>:IN 76GDB:9>86AHD8>:IN D;;>8:=DA9:GH D;;>8:=DA9:GH EgZh^YZci EgZh^YZci B^`Z7ZccZii 1B#7ZccZii5jchl#ZYj#Vj3 EZiZg<Zgbdceg 1eZiZg#\ZgbdcegZ5ZjWh#dg\3 EVhiçEgZh^YZci K^XZEgZh^YZci 8]g^h6Xdii 1XVXdii5deijhcZi#Xdb#Vj3 8dhiVci^cd7VaZhigV 18dchiVci^cd#7VaZhigV5ZjWh#dg\3 HZXgZiVgn >bbZY^ViZEVhiEgZh^YZci HVgV]AdX`aZn 1hejbhhZXgZiVgn5\bV^a#Xdb3 6a[7gjWV`` 1Va[#WgjWV``5ZjWh#dg\3 IgZVhjgZg EVhiEgZh^YZci ?VcAZ]b 1hejbh#igZVhjgZg5\bV^a#Xdb3 CdZb^7^iiZgbVc 1cdZb^#W^iiZgbVc5ZjWh#dg\3 :YjXVi^dcD[ÄXZg =dcdgVgnHZXgZiVgn 9Vk^YHbVgi 1YVk^Y#hbVgi5Y]]h#iVh#\dk#Vj3 ?dZg\HX]bjio 1_dZg\#hX]bjio5ZjWh#dg\3 EjWa^XD[ÄXZg BZbWZgViAVg\Z'%%. KVcZhhV=VaaZg 1kVcZhhV#]VaaZg5XYbX#Xdb#Vj3 6cYgZVhB©aaZga©``Zc 1VcYgZVh#bdaaZgad``Zc5ZjWh#dg\3 8]V^gbVc6CO=B< BZbWZgViAVg\Z'%%- 9Vk^YHbVgi 1YVk^Y#hbVgi5Y]]h#iVh#\dk#Vj3 9gEZiZg@cZhha 1eZiZg#`cZhha5ZjWh#dg\3 8dbb^iiZZBZbWZgh BZbWZgViAVg\Z'%%, <aZc=Vl`^ch 1lZWbVhiZg5hejbh#dg\#Vj3 E]^a7gnhdc 1e]^a#Wgnhdc5ZjWh#dg\3 HXdiiHfj^gZh 1hXdiiVcYhVcYhfj^gZh5W^\edcY#Xdb3 <jnL^aa^Vbh 1\jnl5^bVe#XX3 69B>C>HIG6I>DC 69B>C>HIG6I>DC BZbWZgh]^e =dcdgVgnIgZVhjgZgBZbWZgh]^eHZXgZiVgn HiZkZ<dWaZ 1VYb^c5hejbh#dg\#Vj3 EVig^X^VLddY^c\ 1eVig^X^VlddY^c\5ZjWh#dg\3 :Y^idg^Va6hh^hiVci &+7jghZab6kZcjZ! C^X`nBXCZ^h] 1hejbh_5XY]W#\dki#co3 =V^cVjai!>a[dgY :hhZm!><+(:= B:B7:GH=>E Jc^iZY@^c\Ydb ;dgYZiV^ahd[i]ZY^[[ZgZciineZhd[HEJBHbZbWZgh]^e E]dcZ;Vm/ ))"%'%"-*%%&,,- VcY[jgi]Zg^c[dgbVi^dcdci]ZHdX^Zin!dgidXdbeaZiZV bZbWZgh]^eVeea^XVi^dc!\didi]ZHdX^Zin¼hlZWh^iZ/ B:B7:GH=>E 1lll#hejbh#dg\#Vj3 ;dg[jgi]Zg^c[dgbVi^dcdc:J7HVcYidXdbeaZiZV bZbWZgh]^eVeea^XVi^dc\didi]ZHdX^Zin¼hlZWh^iZ/ I]Zd[ÄX^VaVYYgZhh[dgHEJBH^h/ 1lll#ZjWh#dg\3 X$d6jhigVa^VcVcYCZlOZVaVcY8daaZ\Zd[6cVZhi]Zi^hih! +(%Hi@^aYVGdVY!BZaWdjgcZ! K^Xidg^V(%%)!6jhigVa^V 9>K>C<VcY=NE:G76G>8B:9>8>C: I]Z?djgcVad[i]ZHdji]EVX^ÄXJcYZglViZgBZY^X^cZHdX^ZinVcY i]Z:jgdeZVcJcYZglViZgVcY7VgdbZY^XVaHdX^Zin :Y^idgVcYEjWa^h]Zg/ :Y^idg^Va7dVgY/ B^X]VZa9Vk^h 1hejbh_5XY]W#\dki#co3 B^`Z7ZccZii!6jhigVa^V X$"=neZgWVg^XBZY^X^cZJc^i 6a[7gjWV``!CdglVn 8]g^hiX]jgX]=dhe^iVa!Eg^kViZ7V\),&% EZiZg<Zgbdceg!7Za\^jb 8]g^hiX]jgX]!CZlOZVaVcY ?VXZ`@di!EdaVcY E]dcZ/ +)ç%(ç(+)ç%%)*dg%("('."+-*, H^bdcB^iX]Zaa!CZlOZVaVcY ;Vm/ +)ç%(ç(+)"%-&,dg%("('."+-&% CZVaEdaadX`!JH6 :jgdeZVc:Y^idg/ 9Vk^YHbVgi!6jhigVa^V EZiZgBaaZg 1eZiZ5Z_j]b#YZ3 9^k^c\VcY=neZgWVg^XBZY^X^cZKdajbZ(.Cd#)9ZXZbWZg'%%. &-. ]VYWZZcejWa^h]ZY#-9Vgl^clVhVlVgZi]Vii]^h]VYWZZc >ck^iZYZY^idg^Va VX]^ZkZYi]gdj\]hZaZXi^dcVcYi]VibVc]VYVXXZaZgViZYi]Z egdXZhhWnWZ^c\VWaZidWZfj^iZgji]aZhh^ci]VihZaZXi^dc What if Darwin had been a egdXZhh#=^hbV^cfjZhi^dc[gdbi]^hdWhZgkVi^dclVh»XdjaY cVijgZWZ^cÅjZcX^c\kVg^Vi^dci]gdj\]Vh^b^aVgegdXZhh diver? d[hZaZXi^dc4¼VcY]^hbV^cYg^kZg[dgi]^hfjZhi^dclVh Martin DJ Sayer ]^h[VhX^cVi^dcl^i]i]ZY^kZgh^ind[Zm^hiZcXZ#=dlZkZg! ^cXgZVhZYY^kZgh^in]VYid]VkZ^iha^b^ihVcYhZaZXi^dcXdjaY I]^h^hhjZd[9^k^c\VcY]neZgWVg^XbZY^X^cZXVgg^Zhi]Z WZV[[ZXiZYWnÄicZhh#I]ZegdXZhhiZgbZY»cVijgVahZaZXi^dc¼ [VhX^cVi^c\gZk^ZlWnCZlbVcZiVa#d[i]ZgVeZji^XV\Zcih Wn9Vgl^cdjia^cZY]dl^c]Zg^iZYY^[[ZgZcXZh^ci]ZVW^a^in [gdbi]ZhZV#&Fj^iZg^\]iani]ZVji]dgheaVXZi]Z^ghjW_ZXi idhjgk^kZ^cXdcY^i^dchd[a^b^iZYdgY^b^c^h]^c\gZhdjgXZh ^cidi]ZXdciZmid['%%.WZ^c\i]Z'%%i]Vcc^kZghVgnnZVg XVjhZYi]ZheZX^ZhidZkdakZVcYkVgn#9Vgl^c¼hi]Zdg^Zh d[i]ZW^gi]d[8]VgaZh9Vgl^cVcYi]Z&*%i]Vcc^kZghVgn d[]dlX]Vc\Zh^c\adWVahiVW^a^inXdjaY]VkZV[[ZXiZY d[i]ZWdd`Dci]Zdg^\^cd[heZX^ZhWnbZVchd[cVijgVa \Zd\gVe]^XVaY^hig^Wji^dcVYYZYidi]ZhZaZXi^dcegZhhjgZh# hZaZXi^dc0'Wjil]Vi^[9Vgl^c]VYWZZcVY^kZg4 >ilVhcdi_jhie]nh^XVakVg^Vi^dc09Vgl^cVahdXdch^YZgZY ]dlWZ]Vk^djgXdjaYX]Vc\Zl^i]^ci]ZegdXZhhd[cVijgVa ;^ghianlZbjhiVhhjbZi]Vi8]VgaZh9Vgl^clVhcdiV hZaZXi^dc#9Vgl^clVh!cdYdjWi!VlVgZd[i]ZXdcigdkZghn Y^kZg#HZVgX]Dci]Zdg^\^cd[heZX^Zhdg9Vgl^c¼hVXXdjci i]VildjaYWZXVjhZYWni]ZejWa^XVi^dcd[Dci]Zdg^\^c d[]^hkdnV\Zd[i]Z7ZV\aZ(VcYi]ZgZ^hcdbZci^dcd[ d[heZX^ZhVcY]ZYZY^XViZYVh^\c^ÄXVcieVgid[i]ZWdd` Y^k^c\#=^h\gVcY[Vi]Zg!:gVhbjh9Vgl^c!ldg`ZYl^i] idVg\j^c\V\V^chil]Vi]ZhVlVhi]ZbV^cXg^i^X^hbhd[ Zc\^cZZgh!e]nh^X^VchVcYhX^Zci^hihl]dlZgZ^ckdakZY^ci]Z Zkdaji^dcVhVi]ZdgnVcYl]n]ZXdch^YZgZY^iidWZ[VXi# ÅZY\a^c\Y^k^c\^cYjhignd[i]ZaViZ&,%%h!)Wjii]ZhX^Zci^ÄX HVYan!&*%nZVghaViZg!i]ZdkZgl]Zab^c\hX^Zci^ÄXZk^YZcXZ edhh^W^a^i^Zhd[jh^c\i]^hcZliZX]cdad\ndWk^djhaneVhhZY i]ViZkdaji^dcVXXdjcih[dgi]ZY^kZgh^ind[i]ZldgaYlZ ]^h\gVcYhdcWnVcYi]ZgZ^hcdgZXdgYd[Y^k^c\Zfj^ebZci a^kZ^c^hhi^aacdiVXXZeiZYWnbVcn!Wji!gVi]Zg!Viig^WjiZY WZ^c\dcWdVgYi]Z7ZV\aZ# id[jcYVbZciVaXgZVi^dc#. <^kZc]^h[VhX^cVi^dcl^i]W^dad\nVcYW^dY^kZgh^in!i]Z :kdaji^dc^hVi]Zdgni]Viegdk^YZhi]Z^ciZaaZXijVa[gVbZldg` ^cVW^a^inid\djcYZglViZgbjhi]VkZWZZc^cXgZY^Wan idYZhXg^WZdg\Vc^XY^kZgh^in!X]Vc\ZVcYÄicZhh#Hd!XdjaY [gjhigVi^c\[dg9Vgl^c0ZheZX^VaanVhndjXdch^YZgi]Vi! ZmVbeaZhd[i]^h]VkZXdcig^WjiZYidDci]Zdg^\^cd[heZX^Zh! egZk^djhidDci]Zdg^\^cd[heZX^Zh!9Vgl^c¼hbV^chX^Zci^ÄX ]VYlZWZZcVWaZid\^kZ9Vgl^cVhXjWVhZiVaai]dhZnZVgh Xdcig^Wji^dc]VYWZZci]ZejWa^XVi^dcd[i]ZWdd`! I]Z V\d4>VbhjgZi]Vi9Vgl^cldjaY]VkZiVg\ZiZY]^hY^k^c\ higjXijgZVcYY^hig^Wji^dcd[XdgVagZZ[h#*>bV\^cZ]dl dci]ZXdgVagZZ[hWZXVjhZi]Zn]ZaYVheZX^Va[VhX^cVi^dc[dg 9Vgl^c!edhhZhh^c\V]^\]an^cfj^h^i^kZb^cY!bjhi]VkZ[Zai ]^b#=ZldjaY^bbZY^ViZan]VkZWZZchigjX`Wni]Z]j\Z Vh]ZigVkZaaZY[dglZZ`hdci]Z7ZV\aZWZilZZcXdjciaZhh W^dY^kZgh^inhjeedgiZYWni]ZgZZ[h#L]ViZkdaji^dcVgnXajZh jcidjX]ZYEVX^ÄXXdgVaVidaah^cXaZVgWajZhZVhWjil^i]dji ldjaY]VkZWZZca^k^c\Vbdc\hii]ZY^kZgh^in4=ZbVn]VkZ VcnbZVchd[\Zii^c\jcYZglViZgidk^Zli]Za^[Zdci]Zb4 ZmVb^cZYi]ZegVlch!h]g^beh!XgVWh!adWhiZghVcYXgVnÄh] I]ZhigjXijgZVcYY^hig^Wji^dcd[XdgVagZZ[hY^Y!]dlZkZg! VcYdWhZgkZYi]Vi!ZkZci]dj\]i]ZnlZgZY^hi^cXianY^[[ZgZci XdciV^chdbZdWhZgkVi^dchi]VihjeedgiZYi]Z^YZVi]Vii]Z heZX^Zh!i]ZWdYneaVclVhZmVXiani]ZhVbZl^i]^YZci^XVa :Vgi]lVhcdihiVi^XWjilVhÄaaZYl^i]X]Vc\Z#9Vgl^c VggVc\ZbZcihd[i]ZhZ\bZcihVcYa^bWhWjil^i]Y^[[ZgZci lVh[VhX^cViZYWn]dlXdgVaVidaahXVbZidWZ#I]ZhZVidaah egdedgi^dch!h]VeZhVcYjhZh#.9Vgl^cbVnlZaa]VkZ ^ckVg^VWangdhZ[gdbYZZelViZghWjilZgZbVYZ[gdbi]Z XdcXajYZYi]Vii]ZhZheZX^Zh]VYZkdakZY[gdbVhbVaaZg h`ZaZidchd[Vc^bVahi]ViXdjaYdcanhjgk^kZ^ch]Vaadl cjbWZgd[VcXZhigVa»XgVW¼heZX^Zh#=ZbVn]VkZWZZc lViZg#+9Vgl^c¼hi]ZdgnlVhi]Vii]Zn[dgbZYVgdjcYWVhVai ViigVXiZYidi]ZXaZVc^c\WZ]Vk^djghd[lgVhhZhVcYh]g^beh he^`Zh!l]^X]]VYWZZc[dgXZYjelVgY^ci]ZlViZgXdajbc VcYjhZYY^k^c\idhZeVgViZi]ZXaZVcZgh[gdbi]Z^g]dhihid WnkdaXVc^XVXi^k^inWjiaViZghVc`WVX`^cidi]Z:Vgi]¼h dWhZgkZ]dlWdi]hj[[ZgVhVgZhjai#=^hXdcXajh^dcbVn]VkZ XgjhiaZVk^c\i]ZY^hi^cXi^kZXZcigVaVidaaaV\ddc#>ildjaY WZZci]ViXaZVc^c\WZ]Vk^djg]VYZkdakZYi]gdj\]VegdXZhh iV`ZdkZgVXZcijgnidegdkZ]^hi]Zdgn!,Wji]^hb^cYlVh d[bjijVaYZeZcYZcXZ#LViX]^c\VcVc\aZgÄh]ajg^c\^ihegZn VagZVYnbVYZjeVcYl]VilZcdlgZ[ZgidVheaViZiZXidc^Xh jh^c\VbdY^ÄZYYdghVahe^cZ!9Vgl^cbVn]VkZedcYZgZY^[ jcYZglgdiZ^ceVgiViaZVhiÄkZd[i]Z&)X]VeiZghd[Dci]Z i]ZXdbeaZm^ind[i]Zhe^cZ]VYZkdakZYi]gdj\]VegdXZhh dg^\^cd[heZX^Zh# d[hZaZXi^kZWgZZY^c\l]ZgZWnbViZhZaZXi^dc^h^cÅjZcXZY Wni]Z»WZVjinVcYh^oZ¼d[i]ZajgZ#. >cDci]Z dg^\^cd[heZX^Zh!9Vgl^cÄghidWhZgkZh]dl bVc!i]gdj\]egdXZhhZhhjX]VhYdbZhi^XVi^dcVcYhZaZXi^kZ 7Viia^c\l^i]]^hdlcWjdnVcXnXdcigdaWZXVjhZVaa\gZVi WgZZY^c\!]VYegdYjXZYVc^bVahi]VilZgZY^hiVcikVg^Vcihd[ hX^Zci^hihVgZeddgY^kZgh!9Vgl^cbVn]VkZldcYZgZY i]Z^gdg^\^ch^cdcanV[Zli]djhVcYnZVghZ#\#!i]ZYdbZhi^X ]dli]Zi]djhVcYhd[Äh]^c[gdcid[]^blZgZbV^ciV^c^c\ Yd\Xdb^c\[gdbi]Zl^aYlda[VcYY^[[ZgZciheZX^Zh^c i]Z^gWjdnVcXn#7Z^c\XVgZ[jaidXViX]VWdcniZaZdhiÄh]! YZXVYZhi]ZgZlZgZ&*YZh^\cViZYheZX^Zhd[Yd\^c9Vgl^c¼h 9Vgl^cXdjaY]VkZY^hhZXiZY]^hheZX^bZcidgZkZVaV\Vh" X]^aY]ddY!WjidkZg*%Wni]Zi^bZDci]Zdg^\^cd[heZX^Zh ÄaaZYhl^bWaVYYZg#7jibdgZi]Vci]^h!]ZbVn]VkZldg`ZY &.% 9^k^c\VcY=neZgWVg^XBZY^X^cZKdajbZ(.Cd#)9ZXZbWZg'%%. djii]Vii]ZÄh]lVhVWaZidgZ\jaViZi]ZVbdjcid[\Vh^ci]Z GZ[ZgZcXZh WaVYYZg!i]ZWaVYYZglVhVbdY^ÄXVi^dcd[eVgid[i]Z\jiVcY! ^chdbZXVhZh!^i]ZaeZYi]ZÄh]id]ZVgWZiiZgjcYZglViZg & CZlbVc9?!8gV\\<B!7ViiZgh]^aa8C#I]ZgVeZji^XV\Zcih VhlZaa#L]^aZ]ZlVheZg[dgb^c\i]ZY^hhZXi^dc!^ildjaY [gdbi]ZhZV/W^dY^kZgh^in!X]Zbd"Zkdaji^dcVgn^ch^\]iVcY ]VkZWZZcVh]VbZcdiidZmVb^cZi]ZWVh^Xe]nh^dad\nd[ VYkVcXZhidi]ZZcYd[9Vgl^c¼h'%%i]nZVg#9^k^c\VcY i]ZWaddYd[i]ZÄh]0]ZldjaY]VkZY^hXdkZgZYi]Vii]Z =neZgWVg^XBZY^X^cZ#'%%.0(.)/'&+"(*# ' 9Vgl^c8#Dci]Zdg^\^cd[heZX^ZhWnbZVchd[cVijgVa eaVhbVlVhVha^\]ianY^ajiZYkZgh^dcd[[jaahZVlViZg#6 hZaZXi^dc!dgi]ZegZhZgkVi^dcd[[VkdjgZYgVXZh^ci]Zhigj\\aZ bdgZYZiV^aZY^ckZhi^\Vi^dcd[bVg^cZVcY[gZh]lViZgVc^bVah [dga^[Z!&hiZYc#AdcYdc/?d]cBjggVn0&-*.#*%'ee# ldjaY]VkZh]dlc]^bVigZcYl]ZgZWni]ZbdgZVYkVcXZY ( 9Vgl^c8#?djgcVad[gZhZVgX]Zh^cidi]ZcVijgVa]^hidgnVcY i]ZVc^bValVh^cZkdaji^dcVgniZgbh!i]Z[jgi]Zgi]Z^dc^X \Zdad\nd[i]ZXdjcig^Zhk^h^iZYYjg^c\i]ZkdnV\Zd[=#B#H# Xdbedh^i^dcd[^ihWaddYeaVhbVlVhgZbdkZY[gdbi]Vi 7ZV\aZgdjcYi]ZldgaY!jcYZgi]ZXdbbVcYd[8Vei#;^ioGdn! d[hZVlViZg#&%7nbV^ciV^c^c\VcYgZ\jaVi^c\^ih^ciZgcVa G#C#!'cYZYc#AdcYdc/?d]cBjggVn0&-)*#*'%ee# e]nh^dad\n!VcVc^bVal^aaWZcZÄiVh^il^aaWZbdgZVWaZid ) 9^X`E#9Vgl^cVcYY^k^c\#=^hidg^XVa9^k^c\I^bZh# XdciZcYl^i]Zck^gdcbZciVaX]Vc\Z# '%%.0),/-".# * 9Vgl^c8#I]ZhigjXijgZVcYY^hig^Wji^dcd[XdgVagZZ[h0WZ^c\ i]ZÄghieVgid[i]Z\Zdad\nd[i]ZkdnV\Zd[i]Z7ZV\aZjcYZg DcXZÄh]Zh]VYbdgZXdcigdad[i]Z^ge]nh^dad\n!i]Zci]Z i]ZXdbbVcYd[8Vei#;^iogdn!G#C#Yjg^c\i]ZnZVgh&-('id cZmihiZebVn]VkZWZZcidaZVkZlViZgVaid\Zi]Zg#I]Z &-(+#AdcYdc/Hb^i]!:aYZgVcY8d0&-)'#'&)ee# bdkZbZci[gdblViZgidaVcYldjaYdWk^djhan]VkZWZZcV + 9dWWh9#GZZ[bVYcZhh/8]VgaZh9Vgl^c!6aZmVcYZg6\Vhh^o bV_dgZkdaji^dcVgnhiZe!VcY9Vgl^cbVn]VkZWZZci]^c`^c\ VcYi]ZbZVc^c\d[XdgVa#CZlNdg`/EVci]Zdc7dd`h0'%%*# VWdjii]^hVh]Zhjg[VXZY[gdb]^hY^kZVcYXVj\]iV\a^behZ (%+ee# d[Vbe]^W^djhWaZcc^Zh»lVa`^c\¼dci]Z[dgZh]dgZ#6[iZg , ?dcZhH#8dgVa/VeZhh^b^hi^ceVgVY^hZ#AdcYdc/6WVXjh0 V[ZlaVg\Zgjbhi]Vic^\]idci]Z7ZV\aZ!9Vgl^cldjaY '%%,#')'ee# YdjWiaZhh]VkZXdbZjel^i]i]Zdg^ZhVhidl]nÄh]ldjaY - ?dcZhH#Dg^\^cd[heZX^ZhgZk^h^iZY#CZlHX^Zci^hi# aZVkZlViZgVcYl]ViVYVeiVi^dchVaadlZYi]ZbidYdhd#&&!&' '%%.0',()Hjeea/-ee# .