Atop a Volcano

Atop a Volcano

ATOP A VOLCANO NO. 1,NO. 2005 BY LIU XIAOBO CHINA RIGHTS FORUM Freedom of expression is crucial for exposing turbances has been gradually increasing, and the level of vio- 39 the societal ills that breed discontent, and for lence has also rapidly escalated. The main impetuses for marches, demonstrations, rallies working out solutions that will lead to gen- and petitioning drives in urban areas include the following: 1) uine stability in Chinese society. workers laid off from state-owned enterprises that are closed, restructured or merged, who are not provided with new employment or adequate compensation; 2) people who feel Dedicated to preserving stability and maintaining its monop- that their rights and interests are being abused; 3) popular oly on power, the Beijing regime has grown accustomed to opposition to corruption and abuses by the Party and govern- singing the praises of China’s booming economy.Since Octo- ment, the public security bureau and judicial organs; 4) the ADDRESSING UNREST ber 2004, however, the government has faced serious chal- lower and working classes taking a stand against the growing lenges from the periphery.Clashes have occurred between the social polarization between the rich and the poor; and 5) government and ordinary citizens, involving thousands, tens social retaliation against inadequate and unjust handling of of thousands and even more than a hundred thousand people. social issues by government departments. In its October 2004 issue, the Hong Kong-based Trend Maga- The main causes of marches, demonstrations and rallies in zine (Dongxiang) reported that the Central Committee for the countryside include the following: 1) local government Comprehensive Management of Public Security published an departments infringing on or seizing the land use rights of internal report on social order during the month of September farmers who depend on the land for survival; 2) peasants revealing that there had been more than 520 marches, demon- resisting various levies imposed on them by local govern- strations and anti-government rallies in more than 170 cities ments; 3) rural migrant laborers who have part of their wages and 390 counties in 29 provinces and districts, not counting withheld or who are not paid on time; 4) rising prices of Tianjin City and the Tibet Autonomous Region.Throughout chemical fertilizers, farm implements and seeds; and 5) peas- China, 3.1 million people took part in marches, demonstra- ants having their farmland confiscated for construction proj- tions, rallies and petitioning expeditions to the capital, with ects without compensation. more than 70 street clashes taking place between the govern- Meanwhile, in places such as Anhui, Hubei and Jiangxi ment and the people. In more than 100 instances, city and Provinces, peasants have spontaneously organized county government offices were damaged or forcibly occu- “autonomous committees” and “peasants’ representative bod- pied. In many cases, buildings and vehicles were set on fire or ies” to spearhead the defense of their rights, and have gone so destroyed by demonstrators. Casualties included 200 public far as to demand the prosecution and execution of corrupt vil- security officers, military police officers and government offi- lage cadres known as “local despots.” Moreover, many intellec- cials. More than 1,000 people were arrested and charged with tuals and lawyers have begun participating in the peasants’ organizing a disturbance or various acts of violence. rights movement by providing literary,material and legal serv- The Oriental Outlook Weekly (Liaowang Dongfang Zhoukan), ices that help peasants publicize their appeals for their rights published by the Xinhua News Agency,further revealed that and expose local governments’ abuse of peasants’ rights. For 58,000 relatively large disturbances or riots occurred in 2003, example, the legal scholars Yu Meisun and Li Boguang, the an average of approximately 160 disturbances per day.In many journalist Zhao Yan and the sociologist Zhang Yaojie have been cases, administrative units of the Party and the government engaged in long-standing campaigns to help peasants in Fujian were attacked.These figures indicate that instances of social and Hebei Provinces safeguard their rights.1’ unrest increased by 15 percent in 2003 compared with the The most widely reported clashes between citizens and the previous year, and showed a seven-fold increase compared authorities occurred between October 27 and November 7, with 10 years earlier. Not only is violent confrontation much 2004 in Hanyuan County,Sichuan Province.The clashes arose more common today than it once was, but the scale of the dis- over forced relocation and inadequate compensation of vil- Wide Photos Photo: AP World lagers affected by a dam project.According to the Hong Kong- invariably abuse their power and are no longer able to rein in based Oriental Daily (Dongfang Ribao), the Chinese leadership the people’s desire for morality and justice. No matter how took the Hanyuan riots very seriously and characterized them much the government controls the media and censors the as “large-scale mass incidents.”2 Internet, it is unable to silence popular opinion. In other The Oriental Daily article reported that on November 8, 2004, words, ordinary Chinese people have developed a system of a special working group dispatched by the central government values independent of the government, producing moral and headed by Wang Yang, the vice-secretary-general of the heroes of international standing such as Ding Zilin, Bao Tong, State Council, arrived in Hanyuan.At a meeting with senior Jiang Yanyong and Gao Yaojie.4 county cadres,Wang Yang delivered the following four-point During this time of “stability at the macro level and unrest directive from Hu Jintao and Wen Jiabao: “It is understandable at the micro level,” the Communist regime, single-mindedly that the people should want to stop the dam construction. It is dedicated to the maintenance of social order, has seen the also normal that residents about to be relocated should express foundations of its pyramid-shaped power structure gradually their opinions through a variety of channels. Local residents crumble.The regime has not hesitated to employ brute force, about to be relocated should be encouraged to tell the authori- lies and bribery in its efforts to maintain stability,preserve ties what they think.They must not be prosecuted. But while one-party rule and further the interests of its minority elite. the authorities must protect the rights and interests of local res- Ultimately,however, government-imposed terror does not pre- idents slated for relocation, they must severely punish criminal serve stability,but rather creates unrest. Lack of free expres- elements who beat, smash, rob and burn.” sion, imposed from above, does not lead to consensus but to Because the Chinese government maintains strict media the build-up of resentment. In a dictatorship, only two types of censorship, the government-controlled media continue to stability are possible: the false stability of ten thousand horses restrict their coverage to economic prosperity and political sta- standing mute and motionless, or the tense stillness that pre- bility.“The era of peace and prosperity” has become a ubiqui- cedes the sudden ignition of a prairie fire. tous catchphrase. But in domestic and foreign circles, there is much talk of China sitting atop a volcano.The Wanzhou Inci- The growth of popular activism dent is seen as one example of the smoldering public dissatis- While organized popular resistance remains difficult under the faction.3 Although apparently triggered by a spontaneous street iron grip of the Communist dictatorship, the crippled reforms brawl, the massive riot, involving tens of thousands of people, have nevertheless spurred calls for freedom by disadvantaged indicates a deep-rooted public resentment and antagonism individuals, social groups and an emerging grassroots civil against government officials that can ignite the common rights movement, with protests occurring daily throughout people like dry kindling in an instant. China. Moreover, the media are hitting more “edge balls,” to use a ping-pong metaphor, pushing the boundaries of accept- A crumbling foundation able reporting in China.The Internet, by providing ordinary Westerners are often perplexed by China’s situation since the people with access to uncensored news, has rapidly become the Tiananmen Massacre in 1989.With China’s reforms crippled preferred forum for publicizing grievances and has enhanced by political corruption and growing polarization between rich the people’s ability to organize and stand up for their rights. and poor, how has it been possible for the government to sus- The growth of a grassroots civil rights movement is seen tain rapid economic growth and social stability over the past from very different angles by the government and the people. 15 years? To the Communist regime, which regards the will of the Countless predictions of the CCP’s impending demise fol- people with hostility,the movement is a clear indication of its lowing the Tiananmen Massacre proved incorrect. It became loss of control over society,and the government uses the carrot apparent that the regime of the post-totalitarian era did not of bribery and the stick of repression to curtail every move need to reestablish the legitimacy it had squandered so toward a free press or organized popular resistance. Ordinary quickly; neither was there any need to revise

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    6 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us