REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES COURT OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY Second Division COURT CALENDAR FOR WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2016, 9:00 A.M. rd VENUE: Second Division Courtroom, 3 Floor, CTA Building II PRESENT: HON. JUANITO C. CASTAÑEDA, JR. Associate Justice / Chairperson HON. CAESAR A. CASANOVA Associate Justice / Senior Member HON. AMELIA R. COTANGCO-MANALASTAS Associate Justice / Junior Member ATTY. JESUS P. INOCANDO, JR. Executive Clerk of Court III MS. JANICE M. LAGUNA Court Stenographer IV MS. ELVIRA D. REFORMINA Court Stenographer IV I. CRIMINAL CASE: 1. People of the Philippines versus CTA CRIM. CASE No. O-394 Neil S. Bautista & Cecilia V. Aquino (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the prosecution) ***with Judicial Affidavit of prosecution’s first witness, Alile S. Jipus, filed on February 1, 2016 PP: City Prosecutor Ferdinand U. Valbuena (notified) DC: Atty. Reginal L. Jose (notified) Sr. Asst. City Prosec. Nestor M. Dabalos (notified) Sr. Asst. City Prosec. Nida C. Tabuldan-Gravino (notified) Accused: Neil S. Bautista (notified) Special Prosecutor Napoleon P. Campos, Jr. (notified) Cecilia V. Aquino (notified) I. CIVIL CASES: 1. EDS Manufacturing, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 8830 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the respondent) ***with Judicial Affidavit of respondent’s witness, Mr. Reynoso C. Bravo, filed on October 21, 2014 ***with Judicial Affidavit of respondent’s witness, Mr. Reynante P. Martirez, filed on October 21, 2014 PC: Atty. Benigno G. Par, Jr. (notified) RC: Atty. Felix Paul R. Velasco III (notified) Atty. Jay-Ryan M. Trinidad (notified) Atty. Faith M. Farochilen (notified) Atty. Olivia P. Taganas (notified) Atty. Katrina C. Muli (notified) Calendar February 10, 2016 Page 2 of 5 2. Catering Professionals, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 8852 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the presentation of evidence of PMFTC Inc. and Philip Morris Philippines Manufacturing, Inc. on the basis of their estimates and in the determination of the reasonable costs for the production of the documents requested by petitioner) ***as per Resolution of the Court dated February 5, 2016, the presentation of the evidence for the petitioner is CANCELLED. PC: Atty. Patricia Salang (notified) RC: Atty. Victor Eleazar S.J. Santos (notified) Atty. Norlee C. Alban (notified) Atty. Oliver S. Faustino (notified) Counsel of Philip Morris: Atty. Michael P. Garcia Atty. Rodwill L. Lamac (notified) (notified) Atty. Jayson L. Fernandez (notified) Atty. Christian A. Drilon (notified) 3. Thermaprime Well Services, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 9062 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the hearing of petitioner’s Motion to Commission ICPA) ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s proposed ICPA, Ericson D. Tadeja, filed on February 3, 2016 PC: Atty. Jose Mari G. Tual (notified) RC: Atty. Romel C. Curiba (notified) Atty. Cresencio III V. Cajalne (notified) Atty. Jesse S. Alcaraz (notified) Atty. Ma. Ruby Ann P. Reas (notified) 4. Pacific Bayview Properties, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 9070 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the respondent) ***with Judicial Affidavit of respondent’s witness, Revenue Officer Eleuteria B. Sagun, filed on July 31, 2015 ***with Judicial Affidavit of respondent’s witness, Revenue Officer Teresita P. Reyes, filed on July 31, 2015 ***with Judicial Affidavit of respondent’s witness, Revenue Officer Yzarina D. Brana, filed on July 31, 2015 PC: Atty. Maria Rosario L. Bernardo (notified) RC: Atty. Mario A. Saldevar (notified) Atty. Mardomeo N. Raymundo, Jr. (notified) Atty. Ramon B. Lorenzo (notified) Atty. Bon Jeffrey M. Caluag (notified) Calendar February 10, 2016 Page 3 of 5 5. Trustmark Holdings Corporation versus CTA CASE No. 9072 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the petitioner) ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Zerlynette Z. Ong, filed on November 4, 2015 PC: Atty. Terencio R. Yumang, Jr. (notified) RC: Atty. Felix Paul R. Velasco III (notified) Atty. Valerie V. Villanueva-Perez (notified) Atty. Faith M. Farochilen (notified) Atty. Jenna Mary Leen L. Renong (notified) Atty. Robinita P. Chua (notified) Atty. Kimberly Joy L. Baraoidan (notified) 6. Moog Controls Corporation - Philippine Branch versus CTA CASE No. 9077 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the petitioner) ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Mr. Richard P. Villarico, filed on October 7, 2015 ***with petitioner’s Motion to Admit Attached Supplemental Judicial Affidavit of Petitioner’s Witness, Mr. Richard P. Villarico, filed on January 26, 2016 PC: Atty. Jose Mario C. Buñag (notified) RC: Atty. Felix Paul R. Velasco III (notified) Atty. Gay Christine C. Cortez (notified) Atty. Bernardino Paul R. Somera, Jr. (notified) 7. Wellform Trading Corporation versus CTA CASE No. 9086 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the petitioner) (For the hearing of petitioner’s Motion to Commission ICPA) *** As of date, petitioner has not yet filed its Motion to Commission ICPA and petitioner and respondent have not yet submitted the affidavits of their witnesses. PC: Atty. Terencio R. Yumang, Jr. (notified) RC: Atty. Victor Eleazar S.J. Santos (notified) Atty. Valerie V. Villanueva-Perez (notified) Atty. Jenna Mary Leen L. Renong (notified) Calendar February 10, 2016 Page 4 of 5 8. Mopen Trading represented by: Anabel P. Mozo versus CTA CASE No. 9098 Commissioner of Customs (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the petitioner) ***as of date, the parties have not yet filed their Joint Stipulation of Facts and Issues, thus no Pre-Trial Order was issued ***on January 21, 2016, the Court already issued a Resolution granting the parties a final and non-extendible period of fifteen (15) days from receipt of notice to file their Joint Stipulation of Facts and Issues. ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Junel A. Penalba, filed on October 12, 2015 ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Anabel P. Mozo, filed on October 12, 2015 PC: Atty. Lidio P. Gonzada (notified) RC: Solicitor General Florin T. Hilbay (notified) Asst. Solicitor Gen. John Emmanuel F. Madamba (notified) Assoc. Solicitor II Angelica Anne B. Recto (notified) 9. Colt Commercial, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 9110 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the petitioner) ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Cyrus S. Chung, filed on November 9, 2015 ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Cherilyn R. Chung, filed on November 9, 2015 ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Jennifer S. Mañago, filed on November 9, 2015 ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Evelyn A. Abanador, filed on November 9, 2015 PC: Atty. Vincent I. Puno (notified) RC: Atty. Ramon B. Lorenzo (notified) Atty. Sarah Jeane P. Cardona (notified) 10. Seneca Tobacco Philippines, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 9137 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (For the initial presentation of the evidence for the petitioner) ***with Judicial Affidavit of petitioner’s witness, Carel O. Ng, filed on November 6, 2015 PC: Atty. Rodolfo O. Reyes (notified) RC: Atty. Felix Paul R. Velasco III (notified) Atty. Caesar Augustus P. Blanco (notified) Atty. Faith M. Farochilen (notified) Atty. Sharwina W. Gonzales (notified) Atty. Clarissa J. Virtudes-Babaran (notified) Calendar February 10, 2016 Page 5 of 5 HEARING BEFORE THE COMMISSIONERS: 1. Toledo Power Company versus CTA CASE Nos. 8450, 8512, Commissioner of Internal Revenue 8547 & 8596 (Atty. Ma. Victoria P. Dural – Executive Clerk of Court II – 1:30 p.m.) 2. Petron Corporation versus CTA CASE No. 9111 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (Atty. Jesus P. Inocando, Jr. – Executive Clerk of Court III – 1:30 p.m.) 3. Telstar Manufacturing Corporation versus CTA CASE No. 8900 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (Atty. Ma. Victoria P. Dural – Executive Clerk of Court II – 2:00 p.m.) 4. Tanduay Distillers, Inc. versus CTA CASE Nos. 9017 & 9035 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (Atty. Jesus P. Inocando, Jr. – Executive Clerk of Court III – 2:00 p.m.) 5. Philippine Geothermal Production Company, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 9048 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (Atty. Ma. Victoria P. Dural – Executive Clerk of Court II – 2:00 p.m.) 6. First Balfour, Inc. versus CTA CASE No. 9020 Commissioner of Internal Revenue (Atty. Jesus P. Inocando, Jr. – Executive Clerk of Court III – 2:30 p.m.) -end- .