Highly charged ions: optical clocks and applications in fundamental physics M. G. Kozlov1;2, M. S. Safronova3;4, J. R. Crespo L´opez-Urrutia5, and P. O. Schmidt6;7 1Petersburg Nuclear Physics Institute of NRC \Kurchatov Institute", Gatchina 188300, Russia 2St. Petersburg Electrotechnical University \LETI", Prof. Popov Str. 5, St. Petersburg, 197376, Russia 3Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware 19716, USA 4Joint Quantum Institute, National Institute of Standards and Technology and the University of Maryland, Gaithersburg, Maryland 20742, USA 5Max-Planck-Institut f¨ur Kernphysik, Saupfercheckweg 1, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany 6Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt Braunschweig, 38116 Braunschweig, Germany 7Institut f¨urQuantenoptik, Leibniz Universit¨atHannover, 30167 Hannover, Germany (Dated: March 20, 2018) Recent developments in frequency metrology and optical clocks have been based on elec- tronic transitions in atoms and singly charged ions as references. The control over all relevant degrees of freedom in these atoms has enabled relative frequency uncertainties at a level of a few parts in 10−18. This accomplishment not only allows for extremely accurate time and frequency measurements, but also to probe our understanding of fun- damental physics, such as a possible variation of fundamental constants, a violation of the local Lorentz invariance, and the existence of forces beyond the Standard Model of Physics. In addition, novel clocks are driving the development of sophisticated technical applications. Crucial for applications of clocks in fundamental physics are a high sen- sitivity to effects beyond the Standard Model and Einstein's Theory of Relativity and a small frequency uncertainty of the clock. Highly charged ions offer both. They have been proposed as highly accurate clocks, since they possess optical transitions which can be extremely narrow and less sensitive to external perturbations compared to current atomic clock species. The large selection of highly charged ions in different charge states offers narrow transitions that are among the most sensitive ones for a change in the fine- structure constant and the electron-to-proton mass ratio, as well as other new physics effects. Recent experimental advances in trapping and sympathetic cooling of highly charged ions will in the future enable advanced quantum logic techniques for controlling motional and internal degrees of freedom and thus enable high accuracy optical spec- troscopy. Theoretical progress in calculating the properties of selected highly charged ions has allowed the evaluation of systematic shifts and the prediction of the sensitiv- ity to the \new physics" effects. New theoretical challenges and opportunities emerge arXiv:1803.06532v1 [physics.atom-ph] 17 Mar 2018 from relativistic, quantum electrodynamics, and nuclear size contributions that become comparable with interelectronic correlations. This article reviews the current status of theory and experiment in the field, addresses specific electronic configurations and sys- tems which show the most promising properties for research, their potential limitations, and the techniques for their study. CONTENTS B. Atomic physics at the extremes: Highly charged ions3 II. Background: variation of fundamental constants4 I. Introduction2 A. Atomic clocks for exploring old and new physics2 III. Electronic structure theory and tests of QED6 2 A. Theoretical treatment of QED in HCI6 I. INTRODUCTION B. Tests of QED effects in HCI7 1. Lamb-shift studies in the x-ray region7 In this review we cover current and new research di- 2. Fine and hyperfine structure transitions8 rections that arise from high precision spectroscopy and 3. Nuclear-size effects: Charge radius and magnetization distribution8 novel optical clocks using trapped highly charged ions 4. Microwave studies of the bound-electron g factor9 (HCI). The recent interest in high resolution optical spec- troscopy of HCI has been triggered by their high sensitiv- IV. HCI electronic structure and frequency metrology 10 ity to a change in the fine-structure constant α (Sec.II). A. HFS of hydrogenlike ions 11 Since the required HCI physics is generally less well B. HCI with one valence electron 12 known compared to neutral and singly-charged atoms, C. HCI with two valence electrons 13 D. HCI with three valence electrons 14 Sec. III recapitulates the current status of theory, in- E. Sn-like ions with four valence electrons 15 cluding quantum electrodynamics (QED), mostly deal- F. Ions with holes in almost filled 4f shell 15 ing with few-electron HCI. In Sec.IV we present recent theory on more complicated electronic systems that are V. Experimental methods for HCI studies 16 particularly interesting for frequency metrology, and dis- A. Early spectral observations 16 cuss them in detail. B. First laboratory methods 17 C. Early laboratory sources of HCI 17 We present the current status of experimental methods D. Production of HCI with electron beam ion traps 17 in Sec.V, with a particular emphasis on the field of op- 1. Ionization and trapping mechanism 18 tical spectroscopy (Sec. V.E). Novel methods needed for 2. Photorecombination and charge-exchange high resolution optical spectroscopy with HCI are intro- processes 18 duced in Sec. V.G andVI, and an analysis of clock shift 3. Electron-impact excitation of transitions 19 systematics with HCI candidates follows in Sec. VII. Fu- 4. Preparation of neutrals for ionization and trapping 19 ture directions of research are discussed in Sec. VIII. 5. Techniques for HCI delivery 19 E. Optical spectroscopy of HCI 20 1. Measurements of the HFS of hydrogenic ions 20 A. Atomic clocks for exploring old and new physics 2. Other optical spectroscopic observations 21 F. Electronic structure determination in HCI 21 Celestial mechanics, based on the (for their time) ex- G. Compact EBITs for novel spectroscopic applications 21 ceptionally precise measurements of astronomy, became VI. Preparation of cold highly charged ions 22 one of the most fruitful disciplines in theoretical physics A. Evaporative cooling of HCI 22 and was the key for many discoveries in other fields. In B. Sympathetic cooling of HCI 23 the same way, atomic and optical clocks (Ludlow et al., 2015), aided by advances in atomic structure theory are VII. Towards high-resolution spectroscopy 26 evolving into an exceptional driving force for the search A. Trapping 27 B. Sympathetic cooling 27 for new physics. Frequency measurements of narrow C. Quantum logic spectroscopy 29 transitions in atoms, with their universal reproducibil- D. Systematic frequency shifts 30 ity that is paradigmatic in science, serve as benchmarks 1. Magnetic field shifts 30 for the most subtle deviations from the theoretical frame- 2. Electric field shifts 31 work of physics, while high-energy physics aims at testing 3. Motion-induced shifts 31 the boundaries of our knowledge in huge facilities. These 4. Micromotion shifts 32 complementary approaches eventually aim at answering 5. Collisional shifts 33 E. Evaluation of HCI clock candidates 33 the same questions. 1. Hyperfine transitions 34 In atomic clocks, physics interactions appear as con- 2. Fine-structure transitions 34 tributions to the electronic binding energies or the tran- 3. Level crossing transitions 34 sition rates in a hierarchy now stretching over 18 or- 4. Intra-configuration transitions 35 ders of magnitude. Novel clocks are capable of address- F. Evaluation summary 35 ing those in more and more depth, and their rapid de- VIII. Other applications and future developments 36 velopment in the last decades heralds further advances. A. Tests of local Lorentz invariance 36 Progress in optical clocks is based on an improved con- B. Probing for new forces 37 trol over all degrees of freedom, including the internal C. Towards higher transition frequencies 38 state, the motion, and external fields affecting the tran- sition frequency, paired with increased accuracy of elec- IX. Conclusion 38 tronic structure calculations of atomic properties. This Acknowledgements 38 has been accomplished through the rapid development of suitable laser cooling and trapping techniques based References 38 on the pioneering work of Ashkin(1978); Aspect et al. 3 (1986); Bollinger et al. (1985); H¨ansch and Schawlow vironments, and they as well as the future ones XARM (1975); Lett et al. (1988); Metcalf and van der Straten (Hitomi Collaboration et al., 2016) and Athena (Bar- (2007); Neuhauser et al. (1978); Phillips(1998); Phillips cons et al., 2017) will produce more and more quanti- et al. (1985); Stenholm(1986); Wineland et al. (1978); tative results. This emphasizes the need for laboratory Wineland and Itano(1979). data and advanced atomic structure calculations for their However, progress in atoms (such as most HCI), that interpretation; therefore, studying HCI is essential for do not posses the required properties for cooling and astrophysics diagnostics (Beiersdorfer, 2003). In addi- trapping could not profit from these advances. This situ- tion, HCI play a central role in plasma physics (Beiers- ation has recently changed with the development of quan- dorfer, 2015), and in various aspects of fundamental re- tum logic techniques for spectroscopy in which a cooling search such as tests of quantum electrodynamics (QED) ion, trapped together with the spectroscopy ion, provides (Beiersdorfer, 2010), developing relativistic atomic struc- sympathetic cooling as well as control and readout of ture theory, and other applications (Beyer