Force Candidate Party/Independent Incumbent PCC First Round Percentage Second Round Turnout Avon and Somerset Sue Mountstevens (Elected) Independent Yes 82,708 26.08% 35,839 Kerry Barker Labour 75,538 23.82% 25,027 Mark Weston Conservative 61,335 19.34% Aaron Foot UKIP 28,038 8.84% Paul Crossley Liberal Democrat 23,429 7.39% Chris Briton Green 23,414 7.38% Kevin Phillips Independent 22,667 7.15% 317129 (25.96% ) Total 317,129 100.00% Bedfordshire Kathryn Holloway (Elected) Conservative 39,288 36.67% 8,109 Olly Martins Labour Yes 37,853 35.33% 6,661 Linda Jack Liberal Democrat 12,413 11.59% Duncan Strachan UKIP 11,012 10.28% Toni Bugle English Democrat 6,569 6.13% 107135 (23.70%) Total 107,135 100.00% Cambridgeshire Jason Ablewhite (Elected) Conservative 63,614 36.22% 17967 Dave Baigent Labour 54,426 30.99% 18,054 , Nick Clark UKIP 29,698 16.91% Rupert Moss-Eccardt Liberal Democrat 27,884 15.88% 175622 (29.3%) Total 175,622 100.00% Cheshire David Keane (Elected) Labour 72,497 39.76% 12,104 John Dwyer Conservative Yes 69,322 38.02% 12,330 Jonathan Starkey UKIP 21,991 12.06% Neil Lewis Liberal Democrat 18,530 10.16% 182340 (23.30%) Total 182,340 100.00% Cleveland Barry Coppinger (Elected) Labour Yes 32,733 41.00% 8,604 Matthew Vickers Conservative 18,196 22.79% 7,033 Steve Matthews UKIP 17,005 21.30% Sultan Alam Independent 11,895 14.90% 79829 (19.7% ) Total 79,829 99.99% Cumbria Peter McCall (Elected) Conservative 32,569 34.43% 8,776 Reg Watson Labour 22,768 24.07% 7,669 Loraine Birchall Liberal Democrat 16,053 16.97% Mary Robinson Independent 13,831 14.62% Michael Pye UKIP 9,370 9.91% 94591 (24.9%) Total 94,591 100.00% Derbyshire Hardyal Dhindsa (Elected) Labour 66,925 37.48% 11,933 178539 (23.2%) Richard Bright Conservative 61,741 34.58% 15,504 Stuart Yeowart UKIP 30,381 17.02% Tom Snowdon Liberal Democrat 19,492 10.92% 178539 (23.2%) Total 178,539 100.00% Devon and Cornwall Alison Hernandez (Elected) Conservative 69,354 24.38% 21,682 Gareth Derrick Labour 66,519 23.38% 20,723 Jonathan Smith UKIP 49,659 17.46% Bob Spencer Independent 41,382 14.55% Richard Younger Ross Liberal Democrat 35,154 12.36% William Morris Independent 22,395 7.87% 284,463 (22.10%) Total 284,463 100.00% Dorset Martyn Underhill (Elected) Independent Yes 47,738 37.86% 18,922 Andrew Graham Conservative 37,089 29.42% 7,369 Lester Taylor UKIP 21,086 16.72% Patrick Canavan Labour 20,169 16.00% 126082 (21.7%) Total 126,082 100.00% Durham Ron Hogg (Elected) Labour Yes 50,915 63.83% Peter Cuthbertson Conservative 18,797 23.56% Craig Martin Liberal Democrat 10,060 12.61% 79772 (17.36%) Total 79,772 100.00% Dyfed Powys Dafydd Llewelyn (Elected) Plaid Cymru 52,469 28.10% 22,689 Christopher Salmon Conservative Yes 47,093 25.1% 12,209 Kevin Madge Labour 34,799 18.60% Des Parkinson UKIP 20,870 11.10% Richard Church Liberal Democrat 20,725 11.1% Edmund Davies Independent 11,561 6.20% 187517 (48.9%) Total 187,517 100.00% Essex Roger Hirst (Elected) Conservative 110,858 33.50% 25,090 Bob Spink UKIP 80,832 24.42% 22,960 Chris Vince Labour 65,325 19.74% Martin Terry Independent 43,128 13.03% Kevin MacNamara Liberal Democrat 30,804 9.31% 330947 (25.2%) Total 330,947 100.00% Gloucestershire Martin Surl (Elected) Independent Yes 57,447 40.67% 21,145 Will Windsor-Clive Conservative 46,965 35.38% 4,602 Barry Kirby Labour 33,825 23.95% 138,237 (29.4%) Total 138,237 100.00% Gwent Jeff Cuthbert (Elected) Labour 76,893 46.40% 19,137 Louise Brown Conservative 50,985 30.80% 8,946 Darren Jones Plaid Cymru 37,916 22.80% 165,794 (39.0%) Total 165,794 100.00% Hampshire Michael Lane (Elected) Conservative 113,717 28.53% 40,273 Robin Price Labour 63,747 15.99% 23,997 Simon Hayes Independent Yes 60,743 15.24% Richard Adair Liberal Democrat 55,266 13.87% Roy Swales UKIP 54,115 13.58% Zero Tolerance Policing, Ex- Steve Watts Chief 35,989 9.03% Don Jerrard Independent 14,976 3.76% 398553 (28.0%) Total 398,553 100.00% Hertfordshire David Lloyd (Elected) Conservative Yes 100,262 42.25% 25,807 Kerry Pollard Labour 64,978 27.38% 20,876 Chris White Liberal Democrat 38,488 16.22% Mark Hughes UKIP 33,575 14.15% 237303 (28.1%) Total 237,303 100.00% Humberside Keith Hunter (Elected) Labour 62,010 40.31% 76,128 Matthew Grove Conservative Yes 40,925 26.61% 51,757 Mike Whitehead UKIP 27,434 17.84% Denis Healy Liberal Democrat 23,451 15.25% 153820 (22.1%) Total 153,820 100.00% Kent Matthew Scott (Elected) Conservative 88,396 33.13% 16,162 266,806 (21.0%) Henry Bolton UKIP 73,299 27.47% 14,679 Tris Osborne Labour 50,978 19.11% Gurvinder Sandher Independent 26,221 9.83% Dave Naghi Liberal Democrat 19,601 7.35% Steve Uncles English Democrat 8,311 3.11% 266,806 (21.0%) Total 266,806 100.00% Lancashire Clive Grunshaw (Elected) Labour Yes 132,261 43.77% 20,453 Andy Pratt Conservative 96,746 32.02% 22,195 James Barker UKIP 49,987 16.54% Liberal Democrat Graham Roach 23,164 7.67% 302,158 (28.10%) Total 302,158 100.00% Leicestershire Lord Willy Bach (Elected) Labour 67,991 44.69% 10,197 Neil Bannister Conservative 46,958 30.87% 11,347 Sarah Hill Liberal Democrat 19,359 12.73% David Sprason UKIP 17,815 11.71% 152123 (19.80%) Total 152,123 100.00% Lincolnshire Marc Jones (Elected) Conservative 39,441 35.22% 8,592 Victoria Ayling UKIP 28,583 25.52% 8,837 Lucinda Preston Labour 25,475 22.75% Daniel Simpson Lincolnshire Independents 18,497 16.52% 111,996 (20.70%) Total 111,996 100.01% Merseyside Jane Kennedy (Elected) Labour Yes 186,661 61.76% David Burgess Joyce Conservative 54,000 17.87% Chris Carubia Liberal Democrat 34,625 11.46% John Coyne Green 26,967 8.92% 302253 (30.20%) Total 302,253 100.10% Norfolk Lorne Green (Elected) Conservative 42,928 27.76% 17,133 Chris Jones Labour 37,141 24.02% 13,146 David Moreland UKIP 27,030 17.48% Stephen Bett Independent Yes 25,527 16.51% Jacky Howe Liberal Democrat 12,838 8.30% Martin Schmierer Green 9,187 5.94% 154,651 (23.20%) Total 154,651 100.01% North Wales Arfon Jones (Elected) Plaid Cymru 67,179 31.5% 23,049 David Taylor Labour 54,864 25.70% 9.972 Matt Wright Conservative 42,005 19.7% Simon Wall UKIP 25,943 12.10% Julian Sandham Independent 23,487 11.0% 213,506 (41.6%) Total 213,506 100.00% North Yorkshire Julia Mulligan (Elected) Conservative Yes 53,078 40.13% 11,940 132269 (22.47%) Stephen Howley Labour 34,351 25.97% 10,408 Mike Pannett Independent 30,984 23.42% James Blanchard Liberal Democrat 13,856 10.48% 132269 (22.47%) Total 132,269 100.00% Northamptonshire Stephen Mold (Elected) Conservative 46,785 40.50% 11,390 Kevin McKeever Labour 41,015 35.50% Sam Watts Independent 27,708 23.90% 115,508 (22.0%) Total 115,508 99.90% Northumbria Vera Baird (Elected) Labour Yes 180,479 55.32% Stewart Hay Conservative 58,713 18.00% Melanie Hurst UKIP 52,293 16.03% Jonathan Wallace Liberal Democrat 34,757 10.64% 326242 (32. 1%) Total 326,242 99.99% Nottinghamshire Paddy Tipping (Elected) Labour Yes 80,926 47.36% 8,823 Tony Harper Conservative 48,155 28.18% 7,950 Fran Loi UKIP 20,030 11.72% Tony Bates Independent 14,579 8.53% Jason Zadrozny Independent 7,164 4.19% 170,854 (21.40%) Total 170,854 99.98% South Wales Alun Michael (Elected) Labour and Co-operative Yes 161,529 40.89% 43,345 394990 (42.50%) Timothy Davies Conservative 70,799 17.92% 25,261 Linet Purcell Plaid Cymru 70,770 17.92% Mike Baker Independent 67,454 17.08% Judith Woodman Liberal Democrat 24,438 6.19% 394990 (42.50%) Total 393,990 100.00% South Yorkshire Alan Billings (Elected) Labour Yes 144,978 51.94% Gavin Felton UKIP 57,062 20.44% Ian Walker Conservative 29,904 10.71% Joe Otten Liberal Democrat 28,060 10.05% David Allen English Democrat 19,144 6.86% 279,148 (28.40%) Total 279,148 100.00% Staffordshire Matthew Ellis (Elected) Conservative Yes 63,123 36.26% 11,877 11,760 George Adamson Labour 54,753 31.45% Harold Gregory UKIP 27,550 15.82% Natalie Devaney Independent 22,155 12.72% Paul Woodhead Green 6,527 3.75% 174108 (21.57%) Total 174,108 100.00% Suffolk Tim Passmore (Elected) Conservative Yes 57,167 43.72% 10,926 Cath Pickles Labour 32,268 24.68% 9,363 Simon Tobin UKIP 22,094 16.90% 130,756 (24.47%) Helen Korfanty Liberal Democrat 11,726 8.97% Terence Carter Green 7.501 5.74% 130,756 (24.47%) Total 130,756 100.01% Surrey David Munro (Elected) Conservative 82,125 35.33% 17,997 Zero Tolerance Policing, Ex- Kevin Hurley Chief Yes 41,603 17.90% 16,078 Paul Kennedy Liberal Democrat 29,933 12.88% Howard Kaye Labour 28,005 12.05% Julia Searle UKIP 24,055 10.35% Jamie Goldrick Independent 14,007 6.03% Camille Juliff Independent 12,746 5.48% 232474 (28.07%) Total 232,474 100.02% Sussex Katy Bourne (Elected) Conservative Yes 114,570 41.78% 24,765 Michael Jones Labour 61,017 22.25% 25,375 Patrick Lowe UKIP 43,075 15.71% James Walsh Liberal Democrat 29,550 10.77% James Doyle Green 26,038 9.49% 274,250 (22.54%) Total 274,250 100.00% Thames Valley Anthony Stansfeld (Elected) Conservative Yes 164,554 39.93% 37,842 Laetisia Carter Labour 138,084 33.50% 34,633 John Howson Liberal Democrat 59,975 14.45% 412155 (24.2%) Lea Trainer UKIP 49,942 12.12% 412155 (24.2%) Total 412,555 100.00% Warwickshire Philip Seccombe (Elected) Conservative 33,895 31.17% 9,313 Julie Jackson Labour 27,725 25.50% 7,383 Rob Harris UKIP 14,553 13.38% David Whitehouse Independent 11,983 11.02% Nicola Davies Liberal Democrat 11,509 10.58% Ben Twomey Independent 9,076 8.35% 108741 (26.73%) Total 108,741 100.00% West Mercia John-Paul Campion (Elected) Conservative 64,514 33.37% 19,105 Daniel Walton Labour 40,870 21.14% 14,292 Peter Jewell UKIP 32,719 16.92% Barrie Sheldon Independent 27,986 14.48% John Raine Green 14,323 7.41% Margaret Rowley Liberal