2008 AMTA HAMILTON NATIONAL INTERCOLLEGIATE MOCK TRIAL TOURNAMENT MARCH 7TH – MARCH 9TH, 2008 BUTLER COUNTY GOVERNMENT SERVICES CENTER HAMILTON, OHIO HOSTED BY: MIAMI UNIVERSITY MOCK TRIAL 2008 AMTA HAMILTON NATIONAL INTERCOLLEGIATE MOCK TRIAL TOURNAMENT MARCH 7TH‐9TH, 2008 TABULATION ROOM SUMMARY Team Name & Number Round I Round II Round III Round IV Summary Bellarmine ∆ v. 524 (H) π v. 436 (B) π v. 992 (AA) ∆ v. (E) University Knights W W W W W L W T 6‐1‐1 852 (CC) +3 +6 +5 +3 +3 ‐5 +4 0 University of ∆ v. 842 (Y) π v. 668 (S) ∆ v. 846 (R) π v. (BB) 5‐1‐2 Cincinnati Bearcats T W W W W W L T CS: 15 644 (Q) 0 +14 +7 +3 +4 +6 ‐4 0 Clark University ∆ v. 436 (B) π v. 448 (EE) π v. 684 (O) ∆ v. (K) Cougars W L W W W L L W 5‐3 520 (M) +1 ‐18 +4 +3 +1 ‐6 ‐11 +1 π v. 810 (FF) ∆ v. 846 (R) π v. 418 (I) ∆ v. (C) Colby College Mules L L L L L L W L 1‐7 608 (GG) ‐1 ‐4 ‐14 ‐1 ‐2 ‐7 +9 ‐5 Cornell University π v. 520 (M) ∆ v. 852 (CC) π v. 610 (J) ∆ v. (FF) 3‐5 Big Red L W L L W L L W CS: 18.5 436 (B) ‐1 +18 ‐5 ‐3 +5 ‐3 ‐1 +16 Fordham College at ∆ v. 608 (GG) π v. 796 (E) π v. 524 (H) ∆ v. (B) Lincoln Center W W L L L L W L 3‐5 810 (Y) +1 +4 ‐27 ‐15 ‐10 ‐5 +1 ‐16 Hamilton College π v. ∆ v. 224 (C) ∆ v. 608 (GG) π v. (S) Continentals L L L L W W W L 3‐5 646 (C) ‐1 ‐1 ‐21 ‐22 +2 +7 +17 ‐5 Harvard University π v. 684 (O) ∆ v. 810 (FF) ∆ v. 828 (BB) π v. (CC) 5‐1‐2 Crimson W T W W W W L T CS: 20.5 796 (E) +6 0 +27 +15 +4 +5 ‐4 0 Harvard University π v. 858 (Z) ∆ v. 992 (AA) ∆ v. 668 (S) π v. (M) 5‐3 Crimson W W L L W W W L CS: 16.5 797 (K) +11 +1 ‐1 ‐3 +13 +21 +11 ‐1 Howard University ∆ v. 796 (E) π v. 467 (A) ∆ v. 520 (M) π v. (N) 5‐2‐1 Bison L T W W L W W W CS: 17 684 (O) ‐6 0 +19 +7 ‐1 +6 +15 +1 Lafayette College ∆ v. 610 (J) π v. 372 (G) π v. 844 (F) ∆ v. (O) 4‐4 Leopards W L W L W W L L CS: 16.5 466 (N) +1 ‐1 +6 ‐4 +11 +2 ‐15 ‐1 Lafayette College π v. 828 (BB) ∆ v. 684 (O) π v. 646 (C) ∆ v. (F) Leopards L L L L W W L L 2‐6 467 (A) ‐2 ‐9 ‐7 ‐19 +9 +15 ‐1 ‐6 Page 2 2008 AMTA HAMILTON NATIONAL INTERCOLLEGIATE MOCK TRIAL TOURNAMENT MARCH 7TH‐9TH, 2008 TABULATION ROOM SUMMARY Team Name & Number Round I Round II Round III Round IV Summary University of ∆ v. 372 (G) π v. 645 (Q) π v. 797 (K) ∆ v. (I) Maryland Terrapins W W L L L L W L 3‐5 668 (S) +3 +2 ‐3 ‐7 ‐13 ‐21 +5 ‐17 Miami University ∆ v. 844 (F) π v. 797 (K) ∆ v. 852 (CC) π v. (H) Redhawks W W W W W L W W 7‐1 992 (AA) +10 +4 +3 +1 +5 ‐3 +7 +5 Univ. of Michigan π v. 852 (CC) ∆ v. 406 (Y) π v. 810 (FF) ∆ v. (AA) 4‐4 Wolverines L L W W W W L L CS: 18 524 (H) ‐3 ‐6 +15 +13 +10 +5 ‐7 ‐5 Ohio Northern Univ. π v. 846 (R) ∆ v. 520 (M) π v. 372 (G) ∆ v. (Y) Polar Bears T L L L L L W W 2‐5‐1 448 (EE) 0 ‐3 ‐3 ‐4 ‐14 ‐11 +3 +9 Pennsylvania State ∆ v. 467 (A) π v. 610 (J) π v. 796 (E) ∆ v. (Q) 5‐2‐1 Univ. Nittany Lions W W W W L L W T CS: 18 828 (BB) +2 +9 +17 +4 ‐4 ‐5 +4 0 University of π v. 466 (N) ∆ v. 828 (BB) ∆ v. 436 (B) π v. (Z) 4‐4 Pittsburgh Panthers L W L L L W W W CS: 14 610 (J) ‐1 +1 ‐4 ‐17 ‐5 +3 +10 +8 Roger Williams ∆ v. 645 (Q) π v. 524 (H) ∆ v. 858 (Z) π v. (EE) University Hawks T L L L W L L L 1‐6‐1 842 (Y) 0 ‐14 ‐13 ‐15 +1 ‐1 ‐3 ‐9 Saint Francis π v. 668 (S) ∆ v. 466 (N) ∆ v. 448 (EE) π v. (R) 3‐4‐1 St. Bernard L L W L W W T L CS: 14.5, SOO: 3, 372 (G) ‐3 ‐2 +4 ‐6 +14 +11 0 ‐5 PD: +13 Temple University ∆ v. 448 (EE) π v. 608 (GG) π v. 645 (Q) ∆ v. (G) 4‐2‐2 Owls T W W W L L T W CS: 13 846 (R) 0 +3 +14 +1 ‐4 ‐6 0 +5 Tufts University π v. 992 (AA) ∆ v. 858 (Z) ∆ v. 466 (N) π v. (A) 3‐4‐1 Jumbos L L W T L L W W CS: 14.5, SOO: 3, 844 (F) ‐10 ‐4 +3 0 ‐11 ‐2 +1 +6 PD: ‐17 ∆ v. 797 (K) π v. 844 (F) π v. 842 (Y) ∆ v. (J) Wellesley College L L T L L W L L 1‐6‐1 858 (Z) ‐11 ‐1 0 ‐3 ‐1 +1 ‐10 ‐8 π v. ∆ v. 224 (C) ∆ v. 608 (GG) π v. (GG) Bye Team L L W W L L W L 3‐5 224 (I) ‐1 ‐1 +21 +22 ‐9 ‐15 +5 ‐9 Page 3 2008 AMTA HAMILTON NATIONAL INTERCOLLEGIATE MOCK TRIAL TOURNAMENT MARCH 7TH‐9TH, 2008 OUTSTANDING TRIAL TEAMS 1st Place 992 (AA) Miami University 7‐1 2nd Place 852 (CC) Bellarmine University 6‐1‐1 3rd Place 796 (E) Harvard University 5‐1‐2 (CS: 20.5) 4th Place 644 (Q) University of Cincinnati 5‐1‐2 (CS: 15) 5th Place 828 (BB) The Pennsylvania State University 5‐2‐1 (CS: 18) 6th Place 684 (O) Howard University 5‐2‐1 (CS: 17) 7th Place 797 (K) Harvard University 5‐3 (CS: 16.5) 8th Place 520 (M) Clark University 5‐3 (CS: 16) 9th Place 846 (R) Temple University 4‐2‐2 (CS: 13) 10th Place 524 (H) University of Michigan 4‐4 (CS: 18) Honorable Mention: 466 (N) Lafayette College 4‐4 (CS: 16.5) 610 (J) University of Pittsburgh 4‐4 (CS: 14) 372 (G) University of St. Francis 3‐4‐1 (CS: 14.5, SOO: 3. PD: +13) 844 (F) Tufts University 3‐4‐1 (CS: 14.5, SOO: 3, PD: ‐17) 436 (B) Cornell University 3‐5 (CS: 18.5) Teams Receiving Gold Bids to the 2008 AMTA National Championship Tournament Saint Paul, Minnesota April 4th – 6th, 2008 Hosted By: Hamline University www.hamline.edu/tournaments 992 (AA) Miami University 852 (CC) Bellarmine University 796 (E) Harvard University SPIRIT OF AMTA 645 (Q) University of Cincinnati 27/30 Points, Ranks = 4, 3 Positive Comments Honorable Mention: 448 (EE) Ohio Northern University 27/30 Points, Ranks = 4, 2 Positive Comments Page 4 2008 AMTA HAMILTON NATIONAL INTERCOLLEGIATE MOCK TRIAL TOURNAMENT MARCH 7TH‐9TH, 2008 ALL‐NATIONAL OUTSTANDING WITNESS AWARDS RANKS: SIDE: FROM: NAME: 19 ∆ 466 (N) Lafayette College Leopards Margi Schierberl 18 ∆ 797 (K) Harvard University Crimson Joseph Resnek 18 ∆ 846 (R) Temple University Owls Sam Weigelt 18 ∆ 645 (Q) University of Cincinnati Bearcats Alex Durst 17 π 418 (I) Hamilton College Contientals Liz Farrington 17 ∆ 684 (O) Howard University Bison Marquis H. Barnett 17 π 828 (BB) The Pennsylvania State Nittany Lions Anneke Cronje 17 π 844 (F) Tufts University Jumbos Stacey Ganina 17 π 524 (H) University of Michigan Wolverines Neal Sangal 16 π 520 (M) Clark University Cougars Kathryn V. O'Leary 16 π 796 (E) Harvard University Crimson Guy Edouard 16 π 466 (N) Lafayette College Leopards Adam Pié ALL – NATIONAL OUTSTANDING ATTORNEY AWARDS RANKS: SIDE: FROM: NAME: 20 ∆ 796 (E) Harvard University Crimson John James Snidow 19 ∆ 608 (GG) Colby College Mules Juila Duchon 19 π 797 (K) Harvard University Crimson Caitlin Donovan 19 π 992 (AA) Miami University Redhawks Gus Lazarus 17 ∆ 19 ∆ 645 (Q) University of Cincinnati Bearcats Thomas Butchko 18 ∆ 810 (FF) Fordham College at Lincoln Center Rams Robert Whitbeck 18 ∆ 684 (O Howard University Bison Jonathan Armstrong 18 π 467 (A) Lafayette College Leopards T. Dan Reynolds 17 ∆ 668 (S) University of Maryland Terrapins Coreen Mao 17 ∆ 524 (H University of Michigan Wolverines Gaurav Talwar 17 π 610 (J) University of Pittsburgh Panthers Michael Wiseman 17 π 372 (G) University of St. Francis St. Bernard Lauren Emanuelson Page 5 .