i Index Description Date Vol. Paqe PART ONE - THE PLEADINGS Indictment Sept. 9, 1959 Back of Indictment Sept. 9, 1959 Notice of Appeal to Ontario Court of Appeal filed on behalf of Steven Murray Truscott Oct. 10, 1959 Supplementary Notice of Appeal to the Ontario Court of Appeal filed on behalf of Steven Murray Truscott Jan. 7, 1960 Order in Council commuting sentence of death imposed upon Steven Murray Truscott to life imprisonment Jan. 21, 1960 Notice of Application for Leave to Appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada on behalf of Steven Murray Truscott Feb. 9, 1960 Order in Council referring the case of Steven Murray Truscott to Supreme Court of Canada, pursuant to Section 55, Supreme Court Act Apr. 27, 1966 PART TWO - EVIDENCE Opening Remarks Witnesses CORPORAL JOHN WATSON ERSKINE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne 1ly Re-examina tion by Mr. Hays Recalled - Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays HELEN DOREEN BLAIR (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly ii Index Description Vol. Paq? SHIRLEY IHRPER (for Compla inant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays 1 118 Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly 1 126 DR. JOHN LLYWELLY'N PENISTAN (for Coxpla inant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Flays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne l.ly Re-examina t ion by YxQ Hays JOCELYNE GODDETTE (for ~omplainant) Exarriination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly INSPECTOR JGiR0L3 GRAHAM (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly Recalled Cross- examination by Mr. Donne lly Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly Re-examina tion by Mr. Hays PPC. DONALD TKEYBLAY (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Re-examina tion by Mr. Hays Recalled Examination .in Chief by Mr. Eays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly Reca Zled Esamina t ion in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly He-examina tion by Mr. Hays Recalled Examination ir?. Chief by Mr. Mays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly MRS. DOREEN LJERVIS (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cr oss-exarnina tion by Mr. Donne lly iii Index ~escription Vol. Paqe CHARLES WILFRED GODDETTE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays ROBERT LAWSON (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Re-examina t ion by Mr. Hays KENNETH GEIGER (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly R0E;B HARRINGTON (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly RONALD DEMARAY (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly MRS. ANN NICKERSON (for complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr, Donnelly MRS. DOROTHY BOHONUS (for Compla inant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly WARREN HATEIERALL (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly STEWART WESTEY (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly WILLIAM MCKAY (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr . Donne1 ly RICHARD GELLATLY (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays 2 350 I Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly 2 357 Re-examina t ion by Mr. Hays 2 361 I iv Index Description Vol. Paqe MRS. BEATRICE GEIGER (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Reca lled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly SERGEANT WILLIAM MCCAFFERTY (for ~omplainan t) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr.. Donnelly PHILIP BURNS (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly MICHAEL BURNS (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly MRS. DONNA DUNKIN (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly ARNOLD GEORGE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays 3 3 96 Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly 3 410 Re-examina tion by Mr . Hays 3 42 5 JOHN CAREW (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays '3 430 @r oss-examina tion by Mr. Donnelly 3 432 LYN JOHNSTON (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly I LESLIE BALFOUR HARPER (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays 3 448 Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly 3 452 I BRYAN GLOVER (for complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays 3 460 I Cross-examination by Mr . Donnelly 3 469 - Re-examina tion by Mr. Hays 3 481 Re-cross-.examination by Mr . Donnelly 3 482 I v Index Description Vol. Paqe THOMAS GILLETTE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Re-examina t ion by Mr. Hays PAUL DESJARDINE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly Re-examina t ion by Mr, Hays Recalled Examinati~n in Chief by Mr. Mays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne 1ly GEORGE ARCHIBALD (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examina tion by Mr. Donnelly LORRAINE WOOD (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly ANDREA BUCK (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays DOCTOR JOSEPH ALEXANDER ADDISON (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examina tion by Mr, Donnelly Recalled re-exam, by Mr, Hays Recalled re-exam. by Mr. Hays Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Kays ~r oss-examination by Mr. Donnelly DOCTOR DAVID HALL BROOKS (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Re-examina tion by Mr. Hays' Recalled re-exam, by Mr. Hays Recalled re-exam, by Mr. Hays Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Re-examina tion by Mr. Hays vi Index ~escription Vol. Paqe SERGEANT CHARLES NORMAN ANDERSON (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly PPC . HENRY DONALD HOEBS (for Complainant) ~xaminationin Chief by Mr. Hays Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly SERGEANT ROY FRANK JOHNSON (for Compla inant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Re-examination by Mr. Hays SERGEANT FREOERICK JOHN WHEELHOUSE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examina tion by Mr, Donnelly CLARENCE TROTT ( for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays ~ross-examination by Mr. Donnelly ALFRED SAUNDERS (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays GEORGE HO-MER THOMPSON (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays vii Index Description Vol. Paqe JOSEPH H.L. PIGUN (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly MISS BEULAH WILKINS (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays SANDRA ARCHIBALD (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Er. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Re-examination by Mr. Hays AIDA ARCHIBALD (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examina tion by Mr. Donnelly CORPORAL KEITH LIPSCOMBE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-esamina tion by Mr . Donne lly Recalled Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly MRS. MABEL GRAY (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly Cross-examination by Mr. Donne lly TEUNIS VABJDBNDOOL (for Complainant) Examinzition in Chief by Mr. Hays Cr oss-examina tion by Mr. Donne lly GERALD DURNIN (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays CORPORAL ELMER SNELL (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donne 1ly CORPORAL HARRY MOFFAT SAYEAU (for ~omplainan t) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly viii Index Description - Vol, Paqe SHERMAN EWIN ERGWN (for complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays 5 92 7 Cross-examination by Mr. Dorrnelly 5 951 Re-examina tion by Mr. Hays 5 991 Re-cross-examination by Mr. Donnelly 5 997 PPC . JAWS ROBERT MOOM (for Complainant) Examins tion in Chief by Mr. Hays 5 1003 Cross--examina t-.ion by .Yr. Donne lly 5 1005 JOSEPH LEBEI, LEGER (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Mr. Hays 5 1007 Cross-examination by Mr. Donne1 ly 5 1011 CORFORAI, GEORGE WILLIAM EDENS (for Complainant) Exa~ninationin Chief by Px. Hays Cross-examination by Vx . Donne lly F/O GLEN IIESRZ: SAGE (for Complainant) Examination in Chief by Yx., Hays 5 1023 Cross--exanha tion by M.r. Donnelly 5 1035 MARJOR.XE JEAN GARDNER (fcr Complainant) Esamination in Chief by Mr. Hays Cross-examha tion by Mr. Donnelly JOSEPH ChLYERT (for Accused) Examination in Chief by Yx. Donnelly Cross-examina tion by Mr. Hays Re-examina tion by Mr. Donnelly DOCTOR BERmLY BROWN (for Accused) Examination in Chief by Mr ., Donnelly Cross-examination by Mr, Hays Re--e~.amination by Mr. Donnelly GRACE CAREW (for Accused) Examination in Chief by Mr. Donnelly GRANT CAREW (for Accused) Examination in Chief by Mr. Donnelly LESLIE SPILSBURY (for Accused) Examination in Chief by Mr.