Dual actions for massless, partially-massless and massive gravitons in (A)dS Nicolas Boulangera, Andrea Campoleonib, Ignacio Cortesec aGroupe de M´ecanique et Gravitation, Unit of Theoretical and Mathematical Physics, Universit´ede Mons – UMONS, 20 place du Parc, 7000 Mons, Belgium [email protected] bInstitut f¨ur Theoretische Physik, ETH Zurich, Wolfgang-Pauli-Strasse 27, 8093 Z¨urich, Switzerland [email protected] cDepartamento de F´ısica de Altas Energ´ıas, Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares – UNAM, Circuito Exterior s/n, Cd. Universitaria, 04510 Ciudad de M´exico, Mexico [email protected] Abstract We provide a unified treatment of electric-magnetic duality, at the action level and with manifest Lorentz invariance, for massive, massless as well as partially-massless gravitons propagating in maximally symmetric spacetimes of any dimension n > 3. For massive and massless fields, we complete previous analyses that use parent-action techniques by giving dual descriptions that enable direct counting of physical degrees of freedom in the flat and massless limit. The same treatment is extended to the partially- massless case, where the duality has been previously discussed in covariant form only at the level of the equations of motion. The nature of the dual graviton is therefore clarified for all values of the mass and of the cosmological constant. 1. Introduction nal spin-2 field and its dual, in a manifestly Lorentz-invariant fashion. On the other hand, the pair of dual fields does not In this note, we complete and extend previous analyses on enter the action in a duality-symmetric way. For such a demo- dual formulations of massive and (partially) massless spin-2 cratic appearance of electric and magnetic fields inside the ac- theories in (A)dS backgrounds of arbitrary dimension n > 3. tion, the price to pay is the loss of manifest spacetime co- We resort to the parent-action technique employed in the pa- variance, as explained for massless spin-2 and higher-spin the- pers [1–10] in order to derive equivalent, dual actions in the ories around flat spacetime in the papers [22–24] and refer- sense of Fradkin and Tseytlin [11]. In brief, in this framework ences therein. In the same, non manifestly Lorentz-covariant one obtains two equivalent second-order actions — whose field framework, a double-potential formulation of linearised grav- equations are related by electric-magnetic duality — by elim- ity around (A)dSn spacetime was studied in [25, 26] for n = 4 inating different sets of fields from a common “parent” first- and in [27] for n > 4. As for what concerns partially-massless order action. In (A)dSn these techniques have been employed fields of maximal depth, the paper[28] providesan off-shell for- for massless and massive gravitons, while the partially-massless mulation exhibiting a nearly manifest electric-magnetic dual- case has been discussed recently only in n = 3[12]. The same ity symmetry. Interestingly enough, manifest duality-invariant setup has also been used in the context of Hoˇrava-Lifshitz grav- formulations of linearised gravity, in the presence of sources, ity [13]. have been given in [29] and in an alternative way in [30]; in the For all values of the mass and of the cosmological constant, partially-massless case, see also [31]. Finally, the integrability we furnish dual formulations at the action level and in a mani- properties of duality-symmetric systems were studied in [32]. festly Lorentz-invariant way. The dual actions that we built are In more details, the unified treatment of spin-2 duality pre- such that the flat and massless limits are smooth, thereby mak- sented in this note leads to the following results: arXiv:1804.05588v1 [hep-th] 16 Apr 2018 ing the identification of the physical degrees of freedom and In the case of a massless graviton in (A)dS, we complete of the helicities straightforward. In the partially-massless case • [14], we obtain for the first time a dual, manifestly covariant the programme sketched in [10] by linking the dual action action principle featuring a mixed-symmetry gauge field. obtained therein to its Stueckelberg formulation admitting At the level of the field equations, (self-)duality symme- a smooth flat limit; try, often named pseudo (self-)duality, has been studied in flat For partially massless spin-2 field in (A)dS, we obtain a spacetime for linearised gravity in [15, 16]; see also [17]. In • dual description at the action level, thereby elevating the (A)dS4 , pseudo-duality symmetry for partially massless spin-2 duality from a pseudo to a genuine off-shell duality; fields was studied in [18, 19]. These are first steps towards the establishment of an equivalence between theories, for which an In the massive case in (A)dS, we clarify the flat limit of the off-shell duality relation is necessary. In flat spacetime, the du- • dual model presented in [6] in that we have Stueckelberg ality between the massless Fierz-Pauli action and the Curtright gauge fields representing the dual spin-2, spin-1 and scalar action [20, 21] was proven in the series of works [2–4]. sectors. Therefore, our actions admit a smooth flat limit in The action principles that we present feature both the origi- both electric and magnetic formulations. 1 In sections 2 and 3 we recall the main features of the first- When m = 0 the fields of spin one and zero decouple from order description of massive spin-two fields, that we use as a the spin-two sector and one recoversthe usual first-order formu- parent action. Section 4 collects our original results on dual lation of linearised gravity in (A)dS. At µ = 0, the sole scalar formulations for spin-2 fields in (A)dS. sector decouples and one obtains a first-order description ofa partially-massless graviton, propagating helicities two and one in the flat limit. With the manifestly unitary conventions used 2. The parent action in (1)–(3), one can set µ to zero by tuning the mass m R only in dS (σ = 1). In section 4.2 we shall show that partially-∈ We consider as parent action the first-order Stueckelberg ac- − tion describing, for generic values of the parameters, the propa- massless fields in AdS can be described in this formalism at the gation of a massive spin-2 field in a constant curvature back- price of flipping the sign of the spin-one kinetic term, which ground [33]. It is obtained by coupling the free actions for makes their lack of unitarity manifest. massless fields of spin two, one and zero. It thus comprises Eq. (1) can be expressed in terms of the field [2] the kinetic terms for these fields,1 bc a a bc ab cd ac bd Y | = ω | + g ωd g ωd , (9) | − | (2) ǫabcp[n 3] ab c 1 a qb c p[n 3] which is antisymmetric in its first two indices and transforms as = − ω h + ω qω e¯ H − , (1) L −2(n 3)! ∇ n 2 ! 2 − − bc bc [b c]d (n 2)µ [b c] δY |a = aΛ + 2¯ea dΛ − e¯a ξ . (10) ∇ ∇ − n 1 (1) ǫabc[n 2] ab 1 k l c[n 2] = − F A Fkl e¯ e¯ H − , (2) − L 2(n 2)! ∇ − 4 ! The spin-2 kinetic term can then be cast in the form (from now − on we will omit the integration measure dnx √ g brought by ǫ 1 a1 an = a1 an n − (0) = ab[n 1] a k b[n 1] e¯ e¯ det(¯e)ǫ ··· d x) − π ϕ πk e¯ H − , (3) ··· L (n 1)! ∇ − 2 ! − (2) a bc 1 bc a 1 ab c = bhc Y |a Y | Yab c + Y |bYac , (11) together with cross couplings and mass terms: L ∇ | − 2 | n 2 | ! − while the cross couplings and mass terms read ǫabc[n 2] ab a d b a b cross = − (n 1)m ω A + mF d h e¯ + µπ A e¯ L (n 1)! − = 2m ab ab a − cross Y |bAa mF ha b µπ Aa 2 2 (4) L − n 2 − | − (n 2)µ a b a b m 2 a b c[n 2] (12) − h h m µ ϕ h e¯ ϕ e¯ e¯ H − . 2 − 2 (n 2)µ b a 2 nm 2 − 4 − − (n 2) − ha bh | h + m µ h ϕ + ϕ , − − 4(n 1) | − n 2 2 (s) − − The full action is the integral of = = + cross and it is = a L s 0 L L where h ha denotes the trace of the linearised vielbein. invariant under the gauge symmetries | bc P As recalled in section 3, eliminating the auxiliary fields Y |a, Fab and πa from the parent action one obtains a second-order a a ab 2m a L δh = ξ Λ e¯b + ǫ e¯ , (5a) description of a massive spin-2 field in terms of the linearised ∇ − n 2 − metric and the fields Aµ and ϕ, which reduces to the Fierz-Pauli µ2 δωab = Λab + e¯[aξb] , (5b) action for m = 0. In section 4 we will instead show how elim- ∇ n 1 b inating the fields ha , Aa and ϕ leads to its dual description, − | and involving mixed-symmetry fields for generic values of n. a ab ab δA = ǫ m ξ e¯a , δF = 2m Λ , (6) ∇ − 3. Electric reduction δϕ = µǫ, δπa = m µ ξa . (7) bc ab a − − The equations of motion for Y |a, F and π arising from [h, Y, A, F,ϕ,π] allow to solve for them algebraically. E.g.