Submodular Functions, Optimization, and Applications to Machine Learning | Spring Quarter, Lecture 14 | http://j.ee.washington.edu/~bilmes/classes/ee596b_spring_2014/ Prof. Jeff Bilmes University of Washington, Seattle Department of Electrical Engineering http://melodi.ee.washington.edu/~bilmes May 18th, 2014 f (A) + f (B) f (A B) + f (A B) Clockwise from top left:v Lásló Lovász Jack Edmonds ∪ ∩ Satoru Fujishige George Nemhauser ≥ Laurence Wolsey = f (A ) + 2f (C) + f (B ) = f (A ) +f (C) + f (B ) = f (A B) András Frank r r r r Lloyd Shapley ∩ H. Narayanan Robert Bixby William Cunningham William Tutte Richard Rado Alexander Schrijver Garrett Birkho Hassler Whitney Richard Dedekind Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F1/54 (pg.1/57) Logistics Review Cumulative Outstanding Reading Good references for today: Birkhoff, \Lattice Theory", 1967. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F2/54 (pg.2/57) Logistics Review Announcements, Assignments, and Reminders This is a special extra lecture on lattices that is not given during regular lecture time. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F3/54 (pg.3/57) Logistics Review Class Road Map - IT-I L1 (3/31): Motivation, Applications, & L11: More properties of polymatroids, Basic Definitions SFM special cases L2: (4/2): Applications, Basic L12: polymatroid properties, extreme Definitions, Properties points polymatroids, L3: More examples and properties (e.g., L13: sat, dep, supp, exchange capacity, closure properties), and examples, examples spanning trees L14: Lattice theory: partially ordered L4: proofs of equivalent definitions, sets; lattices; distributive, modular, independence, start matroids submodular, and boolean lattices; ideals L5: matroids, basic definitions and and join irreducibles. examples L15: L6: More on matroids, System of L16: Distinct Reps, Transversals, Transversal L17: Matroid, Matroid and representation L18: L7: Dual Matroids, other matroid L19: properties, Combinatorial Geometries L20: L8: Combinatorial Geometries, matroids and greedy, Polyhedra, Matroid Polytopes, L9: From Matroid Polytopes to Polymatroids. L10: Polymatroids and Submodularity Finals Week: June 9th-13th, 2014. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F4/54 (pg.4/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Outline We're next going to study lattices and submodular functions. In doing so, we'll better be able to understand certain properties of polymatroidal extreme points and ultimately SFM. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F5/54 (pg.5/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Partially ordered set A partially ordered set (poset) is a set of objects with an order. Set of objects V and a binary relation which can be read as \is contained in" or \is part of" or \is less than or equal to". For any x; y V , we may ask is x y which is either true or false. 2 In a poset, for any x; y; z V the following conditions hold (by 2 definition): For all x; x x: (Reflexive) (P1.) If x y and y x; then x = y (Antisymmetriy) (P2.) If x y and y z; then x z: (Transitivity) (P3.) We can use the above to get other operators as well such as \less than" via x y and x = y implies x y. Also, we get x y if not 6 ≺ x y. And x y is read \x contains y". And so on. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F6/54 (pg.6/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Partially ordered set A partially ordered set (poset) is a set of objects with an order. In a poset, for any x; y; z V the following conditions hold (by 2 definition): For all x; x x: (Reflexive) (P1.) If x y and y x; then x = y (Antisymmetriy) (P2.) If x y and y z; then x z: (Transitivity) (P3.) The order n(P ) of a poset P is meant the (cardinal) number of its elements. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F7/54 (pg.7/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Partially ordered set Given two elements, we need not have either x y or y x be true, i.e., these elements might not be comparable. If for all x; y V we have x y or y x then the poset is totally ordered. 2 There may exist only one element x which satisfies x y for all y. Since if x y for all y and z y for all y then z x and x z implying x = z. If it exists, we can name this element 0 (zero). The dual maximal element is called 1 (one). We define a set of elements x1; x2; : : : ; xn as a chain if x1 x2 xn, which means x1 x2 and x2 x3 and · · · ... xn 1 xn. While we normally thing of the elements of a chain − as distinct they need not be. The length of a chain of n elements is n 1. − Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F8/54 (pg.8/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Partially ordered set Example 14.3.1 + Let V = Z be the set of positive integers and let x y mean that x is less than y in the usual sense. Then we have a poset that is actually totally ordered. Example 14.3.2 Let V consist of all real single-valued functions f(x) defined on the closed interval [ 1; 1], and let g f mean that g(x) f(x) for all − ≤ ≤ x [ 1; 1]. Again poset, but not total order. 2 − Any subset of a poset is a poset. If S V than for x; y S, x y ⊆ 2 is the same as taken from V , but we just restrict the items to S. Any subset of a chain is a chain. Two posets V1 and V2 are isomorphic if there is an isomorphism between them (i.e., a 1-1 order preserving (isotone) function that has an order preserving inverse). We write that two posets U and V are isomorphic by U V . Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring' 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F9/54 (pg.9/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Partially ordered set duality. The dual poset is formed by exchanging with . This is called the converse of a partial ordering. The converse of a PO is also a PO. We write the dual of V as V d. U and V are dually isomorphic if U = V d or equivalently V = U d. When U = U d then U is self-dual. Example 14.3.3 The set U = 2E for some set E is a poset ordered by set inclusion. See Figure (C). Note that this U is self-dual. Example 14.3.4 n Given an n-dimensional linear (Euclidean) space R . A subset of n M R is an affine set if (1 λ)x + λy M whenever x; y M and ⊆ −n 2 2 λ R.A linear subspace of R is an affine set that contains the origin. 2 Subspaces can be obtained via some A; b such that for every y M, n 2 y = Ax + b for some x R . 2 n The set of all linear subspaces of R is a poset (ordered by inclusion), and such a set is self-dual. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F10/54 (pg.10/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Partially ordered set (C2) {a,b,c,d} (C) {a,b,c} {a,b,c} {a,b,d} {a,c,d} {b,c,d} (C3) 1234 {a,b} {a,c} {b,c} (B) 12 {a,b} {a,c} {a,d} {b,c} {b,d} {c,d} (A) y 6 4 {a} {b} {c} x 3 2 {a} {b} {c} {d} 1 14/23 1/234 124/3 13/24 123/4 134/2 12/34 ∅ ∅ 1 1 1 1 1 c d e d e d a a f c b c 1/23/4 14/2/3 1/24/3 13/2/4 12/3/4 1/2/34 a c a b b a b c b (D) 0 (E) 0 (F) 0 0 0 (G) (H) 1/2/3/4 cover y covers x if x y and there exists no z such that ≺ x z y. Note that the inequalities are strict here. We write ≺ ≺ x y if y covers x. A< chain is saturated if it is a chain of the form x1 x2 xn ≺ ≺ · · · ≺ such that x1 x2 xn (i.e., we have a sequence of coverage ··· relationships where< <xi+1 <covers xi for each i < n). Hasse diagram: We can draw a poset using a graph where each x V is a node, and if x y we draw y directly above x with a 2 connecting edge, but no other edges. Prof. Jeff Bilmes EE596b/Spring 2014/Submodularity< - Lecture 14 - May 18th, 2014 F11/54 (pg.11/57) POSs Lattices Distributive Lattices Modular Lattices Submodular Lattices More on Lattices Partially ordered set Hasse-diagram: We can draw a poset using a graph where each x V is a node, and if x y we draw y directly above x with a 2 connecting edge, but no other< edges.