View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by DigitalCommons@Macalester College Macalester College DigitalCommons@Macalester College Political Science Honors Projects Political Science Department 5-4-2009 The rP oblem with Eating Money: Remittances and Development within Senegal's Muridiyya Rebecca F. Sheff Macalester College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/poli_honors Part of the Economics Commons, Geography Commons, International and Area Studies Commons, and the Political Science Commons Recommended Citation Sheff, Rebecca F., "The rP oblem with Eating Money: Remittances and Development within Senegal's Muridiyya" (2009). Political Science Honors Projects. Paper 18. http://digitalcommons.macalester.edu/poli_honors/18 This Honors Project is brought to you for free and open access by the Political Science Department at DigitalCommons@Macalester College. It has been accepted for inclusion in Political Science Honors Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Macalester College. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Problem with Eating Money: Remittances and Development within Senegal’s Muridiyya Rebecca Sheff Advisor: David Blaney Department of Political Science Macalester College May 4, 2009 ABSTRACT Contemporary development theory is poorly equipped to understand remittance-based development occurring in transnational spaces that partially escape the control of the state. An extended case study of the Muridiyya, a Sufi brotherhood in Senegal, reveals how collective remittances from Mouride transmigrants become tools for community-level development when channeled through transnational religious associations. I argue that remittance-based development projects transform the political, economic, and social contexts in which they are embedded, including the relationship between the Muridiyya and the state. Development theory must be reconceptualized to account for how remittance-based development defies conventional understandings of the scales of economic and social activity. TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements .......................................................................................................................... iv Glossary .......................................................................................................................................... .v Introduction......................................................................................................................................1 Chapter 1: Remittances and Transmigration....................................................................................6 Chapter 2: The Internal Logic of the Muridiyya............................................................................27 Chapter 3: Urbanization, Transmigration and Associational Life.................................................40 Chapter 4: Dahiras and Remittance-Based Development..............................................................54 Chapter 5: Marabouts, Politicians and the Rise of Disciple Power...............................................75 Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................91 Works Cited.................................................................................................................................101 iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank my advisor, David Blaney, for all of his support and advice throughout this project. Thanks are also due to Bobby Painter, Zoe Whaley, T. J. Powers, Andy Ver Steegh, Kabir Sethi, Oriel Fernandes, and Caroline Ettinger, whose laughter kept me going. Finally, thanks to Dave Hanold for his encouragement and patience along the way. v GLOSSARY Amal Labor Baraka Blessing; gift of grace; divinely derived power Cheikh A master or Muslim religious leader Dahira Association (urban or transnational) of disciples Dara Collective work group in the service of a marabout Hadiyya Financial contribution of a talibé to his marabout Jebëlu Submission to a marabout Khalifa-General Supreme head of the Mouride brotherhood Marabout French word for religious notable Modou Modou Senegalese transmigrant Mouride Aspirant Sadaqa Charity Sufism Islamic mysticism; emphasizes use of esoteric means to get closer to God Talibé Disciple of a marabout Tarbiyya Education of the soul Tariqa Brotherhood; path for bringing oneself closer to God Xidma Religiously-oriented work; being at the service of somebody (Cruise O’Brien 1971; Babou 2002a) 1 INTRODUCTION “When Senegalese go abroad, it’s just so they can work and earn money and send it home, so they can develop their own country. They don’t waste money.” So insists a Mouride migrant whom I interviewed while studying in Senegal in the spring of 2008. This migrant is a member of a Sufi Muslim brotherhood called the Muridiyya, which is one of the most powerful political and economic entities in contemporary Senegal (Cruise O’Brien 1983:133; Riccio 2000:73; Babou 2003:331). The brotherhood currently claims more than one-third of the population of Senegal as its followers (Babou 2003:311-312). For the past several decades, Mourides have migrated in large numbers to European and American cities and formed transnational associations which serve multiple functions, including creating development projects providing infrastructure, health care, and social services in Senegal. I worked with one such association that conducted development projects in and around the city of Touba in Senegal. There, I noticed a particular disdain common among returning migrants for those who “waste” their earnings on non-essential goods and activities. In Senegal, excessive consumption is spoken of through the metaphor of eating; “eating money” is the common expression for wasting resources. The migrants with whom I spoke were, for the most part, quick to insist that they used their remittances in a responsible and productive manner and that their primary commitments were to care for their families and their communities. I sought to know more about the extent to which Mouride migrants’ enduring orientation toward their places of origin is driven by their religious convictions, and with what economic and political impacts. I wanted to understand what factors enable the brotherhood to both assist its followers in migrating abroad and also retain their loyalty, such that Mouride migrants remain committed to developing their communities in Senegal and particularly in 2 Touba. Using the Muridiyya as a case study, this paper examines how remittances become tools for community-level development when channeled through transnational religious associations. While Dakar is the official capital of Senegal, Touba is the religious capital of the Muridiyya and therefore critical to this analysis as the site at which much of the brotherhood’s remittance-based development takes place. In selecting Touba’s location, just over one hundred miles inland from Dakar (see http://bbsnews.net/bbsn_photos/topics/Maps-and-Charts/senegal pop.sized.jpg), Cheikh Amadou Bamba (the founder of the Muridiyya) sought to isolate his disciples from the distractions of the world as they pursued a pure lifestyle guaranteeing them entry to paradise in the afterlife. Touba therefore represents Cheikh Amadou Bamba’s vision of creating an ideal society on earth (see http://www.assemblee-martinique.com/joomla/images/ stories/news/cheikh_amadou _bamba.jpg). The city has gained such symbolism that it is often called the capitale du mouridisme . Mourides both in Senegal and abroad consider Touba to be their spiritual center, their source of guidance and inspiration. Touba has become “essentially the locus and fulfillment of eschatological desire” for Mourides (Ross 1995:230). For that reason, the holy city has become the focus of many Mouride migrants’ community-level development projects; as one of my informants noted, “It is the immigrants who build the city.” 1 Gueye (2001:107) accurately identifies Touba as “a conglomerate of paradoxes that spell out the complexity of the relationship between the state and a Muslim brotherhood.” Touba essentially exists as a state within a state. The population of Touba is second only to that of Dakar yet the city continues to enjoy the legal status of a village rather than a municipality (Gueye 2001:107). In 1928, the French colonial administration signed a fifty-year lease on 1 In this paper, I am examining the Muridiyya and not the other brotherhoods in Senegal (e.g. the Tijaniyya or Qadiriyya) for their political and economic impact on state-society relations is not as significant. Thus, when discussing transmigration and remittance-based development, I focus exclusively on Mouride migrants and not migrants of other faiths from Senegal. 3 Touba as a private domain controlled by the Khalifa-General (the head of the brotherhood). The city thus escaped the control and regulation of the colonial authorities. Then, in 1976, only two years before its lease was set to expire, the brotherhood integrated itself into the independent state’s administrative structure by securing legal recognition as a communauté rurale autonome (autonomous rural community) (Ross 1995:245). Touba is the only entity in Senegal with this particular legal status. The national government has also demonstrated a consistent willingness to exempt Touba from certain national laws. Instead, the