MFH SP SU 08 3/21/08 11:30 AM Page 1 Inside: Mass Our American Cousin page 3 Humanities Recent Grants A Publication of the Massachusetts Foundation for the Humanities Spring 2008 page 4 A Double Take on Clemente page 7 No News is Bad News Newsletter Survey By David Reich page 8 Editor’s note: The following excerpt is from an article written for Boston College Magazine, ©2008 Trustees of Boston College. Used with permission. n Saturday, November 17, seven A SIMPLE WAY FOR YOU TO HELP US: big-time editors and reporters, one cele- PLEASE TAKE OUR 10-MINUTE SURVEY. brated blogger, and a former presidential Opress secretary met on the stage of Robsham Theater to consider the latest puzzles, annoyances, and threats facing the mainstream media. The occasion of this worry-fest was a sympo- sium titled “No News is Bad News,” which like three previous fall convocations—on presidents, the voting rights act, and the Supreme Court—was organized by the Massachusetts Foundation for the click here Humanities and hosted by Boston College. Over to take the course of the afternoon, before an audience of the survey some 500, panels of speakers chewed over such topics as the challenge of the Internet, plummeting newspaper circulation (and advertising revenues), No News symposium panelists Samantha Power and Anthony Shadid shrinking staffs, and charges of liberal and conser- vative bias. The grimmest consideration of all, Adding insult to the serious prospect of injury, those however, was undertaken by the first panel—a set covering Iraq face charges of bias from the war’s sup- of war correspondents who addressed the risks and porters and critics at home and abroad. The war obligations of reporting from Iraq, where the con- Through this newsletter, we engage thousands reporter’s job is to analyze and explain the conflict, flict has resulted in the death of 124 journalists, of people across the Commonwealth by: said Shadid, and not to express pro- or anti-war including 32 in 2006 alone—a single-year record, views. But “increasingly, the political culture in the according to the Committee to Protect Journalists. I interviewing humanists whose work is United States doesn’t want that type of discussion. contributing to a more enlightened citizenry, The Boston Globe’s Kevin Cullen (Iraq, Northern It wants to know which side are you on.” I Ireland, the former Yugoslavia) and the Washington featuring grant recipients and listing As if to illustrate the point, a woman who identified Post’s Pulitzer winner Anthony Shadid (West Bank, grants made to organizations for public herself as a Boston College graduate used one of the Lebanon, Iraq) spoke of the difficulties attendant on humanities projects, floor microphones to accuse the panel of a “liberal their work in Iraq because reporters, Western I announcing humanities-related events bias that made it impossible for you to think posi- reporters especially, are increasingly seen as legiti- happening throughout the state, and tively about the war.” mate military targets—something new in the annals I getting the word out about our own public of journalism, according to the panelists. “I was only “How would you presume to know what our bias programs and events. in Iraq for a week,” Cullen said, “and I thought I is?” retorted Cullen, whose short stay in Iraq had was going to die every day. I was in Belgrade for 40 resulted in a column about some U.S. marines Or do we? days of bombing every night, and I never thought who had flown a sick Iraqi girl out of the country I’d die.” Shadid, who arrived at Robsham with what for medical treatment. We would like to hear your opinions about appeared to be a diaper tote slung over his shoulder A second audience member, equally impassioned, Mass Humanities. Do you read it all, or do (his young daughter was in the audience), and who came at the panel from the opposite angle, ask- was wounded by an Israeli round several years ago you look for certain sections? Do you attend ing whether the media would keep the country while reporting from the West Bank, noted bluntly, programs or events based on what you read from “being spun into another war,” this time “I have a daughter, and I’ve sometimes taken risks I here? Would you prefer an electronic version, with Iran. “Apologies [for being misled on the shouldn’t have taken.” During his last tour in Iraq, of certain sections or of the entire newsletter? Iraq war] aren’t what we need,” she said. “We he said, security was so perilous that “I simply could- Please take our survey and let us know how need an independent press.” n’t do my job anymore.” Without the Iraqi best to reach you. journalists who make up 80 percent of the Post’s Power responded by saying that the invasion of It should not take more than ten minutes to Baghdad staff, “the story would not be coming out,” Iraq took place during a time, following 9/11, he said, adding, “The Middle East, probably the complete. You can flip to page 8, fill out and when normal journalistic skepticism “melted away,” most relevant region in terms of news, is in some mail us the survey. Or, take the survey as had—she noted—most checks and balances ways in a process of entropy. It’s collapsing. We have within government. Citing recent editorials online at to figure out how to cover that story.” against a war with Iran in the Washington Post and www.mfh.org A third panelist, the Kennedy School of New York Times, she expressed hope that this period Government’s Samantha Power (former Yugoslavia, of immoderate trust had itself now passed. and click the Newsletter Survey button. Darfur), herself the winner of a Pulitzer for A Thank you for taking the time out to Problem from Hell, her book on genocide, described The full article, containing a review of the second and third complete it! Information we gather through the cost-benefit analysis she did when offered a panels, entitled, “Political Reporting” and “The News Business this survey will remain confidential. and the Business of News,” can be found in the newsletter reporting assignment in a war zone. Power, who section of www.mfh.org. traveled to Darfur in 2005 to interview the head of the Janjaweed militia, said, “No one had gotten to the head of Janjaweed, and there was no evidence The proceedings of all three panels may be viewed at www.bc.edu/frontrow. that we as Americans or as Westerners or as jour- nalists were targets, even though . this guy was clearly a killer par excellence.” MFH SP SU 08 3/21/08 11:30 AM Page 2 FOUNDATION NEWS BOARD NOMINATIONS SOUGHT RENOVATIONS AND MOVES Main Office 66 Bridge Street Northampton, MA 01060 (413) 584-8440 Fax (413) 584-8454 The Massachusetts Foundation for the Humanities is After choosing western Massachusetts for its sole www.mfh.org actively seeking nominations of qualified individuals to location and settling into the Shepard House at serve on its board of directors. Candidates must work or Historic Northampton, the Foundation has been STAFF reside in Massachusetts and believe in the importance of the abuzz with the sounds of change. Due to the addition David Tebaldi humanities and their relevance to contemporary life. of new staff members, we have been in the midst of Executive Director [email protected] renovating rooms and shuffling offices, while continuing Pleun Bouricius In addition to professionals in fields related to the humanities, to preserve the integrity of the historic building. The Program Officer the board consists of members with expertise in program renovation of the Shepard House began in November, [email protected] evaluation, grassroots organizing, marketing, finance, law, and should wrap up by the end of February. In addition Tiffany Lyman-Olszewski fundraising, and many other areas. If you would like to to the conversion of unused rooms into office space, Development and Communications Assistant nominate someone, or are interested yourself, please visit renovations are being made to the front rooms, bathrooms, [email protected] our website, www.mfh.org/foundation/wanted.htm, hallways and staircases. Kristin O’Connell Assistant Director for more information and a description of board [email protected] member responsibilities. Anne Rogers Systems Manager [email protected] WELCOME John Sieracki Director of Development and Communications [email protected] In the fall, the Foundation welcomed both Pleun Bouricius Melissa Wheaton and Tiffany Lyman-Olszewski to our staff. Administrative Assistant [email protected] Hayley Wood Pleun Bouricius, who was born and raised in The Hague, Program Officer The Netherlands, and has a PhD in the History of American [email protected] Civilization from Harvard University, is the Foundation’s BOARD OF DIRECTORS new Program Officer. Pleun is responsible for running small President David J. Harris grants programs and initiatives in Massachusetts history. Harvard Law School Currently, she is organizing the Foundation’s annual history Vice-President conference for small historical organizations, this year Susan Winston Leff Wells Fargo Bank entitled, “Sustaining the Future of Massachusetts History” Treasurer (see page 6). She and her husband, Tee O’Sullivan, live in John Burgess Plainfield with a dog named Sam. WilmerHale, LLP Clerk Nancy Netzer Tiffany is the Development and Communications Assistant, Boston College Tiffany Lyman-Olszewski and Pleun Bouricius with a BA from Skidmore College in English Literature. Ricardo Barreto UrbanArts Institute Before arriving at the Foundation, she held similar positions at Tapestry Health of Florence, and David A.