K. Tsuen Wan District - 186 - K. Tsuen Wan District Appendix II - K Tsuen Wan District Summaries of Written/Oral Representations Item No.* DCCAs Representations EAC’s Views No. W O 1 All 1 - Supports the provisional The supporting view is noted. DCCAs recommendations on all DCCAs of the Tsuen Wan District. 2 All 2 - (a) Object to re-arranging the Items (a) and (b) DCCAs order of the DCCA codes These proposals are not as it will cause confusion accepted because: to electors. It may also discourage electors from (i) allocating codes to voting and increase the DCCAs is for the sake of chance of casting the votes easy identification of wrongly. DCCAs on the boundary maps and providing the (b) Propose to assign new public with a quicker and easier way in locating the codes to newly created DCCAs only, for example, DCCA(s) which they are looking for. According the DCCA code for the to the established new K03 (Tsuen Wan working principles, when South) should be K19. drawing up the provisional recommendations, the EAC will rationalise the allocation of the DCCA codes for all administrative districts by assigning the codes in a clockwise direction with a view to making the DCCAs with consecutive codes contiguous to each other as far as possible, so that it is easier for the public to locate the * W: Number of written representations. O : Number of oral representations. K. Tsuen Wan District - 187 - K. Tsuen Wan District Item No.* DCCAs Representations EAC’s Views No. W O DCCA(s); (ii) the DCCA codes are not directly related to electors’ voting; and (iii) there is a representation supporting the rationalisation of DCCA codes. It considers that the DCCA codes in the provisional recommendations have enabled the public to locate the DCCAs on the maps more quickly (please see item 1 of General Issues in Appendix II). 3 All 1 - (a) Supports the provisional Item (a) DCCAs recommendations on K07 The supporting view is noted. (Tsuen Wan Centre), K08 (Discovery Park), K09 (Fuk Loi), K10 (Luk Yeung), K12 (Tsuen Wan Rural), K14 (Lai To), K15 (Allway), K16 (Cheung Shek), K17 (Shek Wai Kok), K18 (Lei Muk Shue West) and K19 (Lei Muk Shue East). (b) Holds reservation on the Item (b) provisional The view is noted. recommendations on K01 (Tak Wah), K02 (Yeung Uk Road), K03 (Tsuen Wan South), K04 (Hoi Bun), K11 (Ma Wan) and K13 (Ting Sham). K. Tsuen Wan District - 188 - K. Tsuen Wan District Item No.* DCCAs Representations EAC’s Views No. W O (c) Proposes to restore the Item (c) name of K05 (Tsuen Wan This proposal is not accepted West) to “Lai Hing” which because in the 2015 was used in the 2011 DC delineation exercise, the Ordinary Election. DCCA concerned was named as “Tsuen Wan West” to reflect its geographical location. The public are used to the DCCA name. Change of the DCCA name may cause confusion to the public. (d) Objects to the provisional Item (d) recommendations on K05 This proposal is not accepted (Tsuen Wan West) and because the number of K06 (Clague Garden), and affected DCCAs under the proposes to transfer Ocean proposal made in the Pride and The Pavilia Bay representation will be one from K05 (Tsuen Wan more than that in the West) to K06 (Clague provisional recommendations. Garden) because the above The affected populations two housing estates are under the proposal will be geographically closer to larger, too. K06 (Clague Garden) and the expected intake date of both estates will be after June 2019. Re-delineation of the boundaries of the DCCAs would not have any significant impact on their populations. (e) Proposes to name K13 Item (e) (Ting Sham) as “Sham This proposal is not accepted Ting” to reflect that Sham because there is no apparent Tseng has a greater difference between the population than other areas proposed name “Sham Ting” in the DCCA. made in the representation and the name “Ting Sham” made in the provisional recommendations. K. Tsuen Wan District - 189 - K. Tsuen Wan District Item No.* DCCAs Representations EAC’s Views No. W O (f) Taking into account the Item (f) development of Lantau, The proposal made in the proposes to put K11 (Ma representation involves Wan) in the Islands District alteration of administrative in the delineation exercise district boundaries, which for the 2023 DC Ordinary does not fall under the Election. purview of the EAC. The EAC has referred this view to the Government for consideration. 4 K01– 1 - Objects to the provisional This proposal is not accepted Tak Wah recommendations. Proposes because: to re-delineate the DCCAs and K02 – change the names of some (i) according to the proposal Yeung DCCAs. Details are as made in the Uk Road follows: representation, the population of K06 K03 – K01 (Tak Wah) (Clague Garden) Tsuen includes the areas in the east (8 054) will be below the Wan of Tai Ho Road, the south of statutory permissible South Castle Peak Road, the west of lower limit (-51.48%); and Texaco Road, and the north of K04 – Sha Tsui Road. (ii) the number of affected Hoi Bun DCCAs under the K02 (Yeung Uk Road) proposal made in the K05 – includes the areas in the east representation will be 10 Tsuen of Wo Tik Street, the south of more than that in the Wan Sha Tsui Road, the west of provisional West Texaco Road, and the north of recommendations. The Yeung Uk Road. Renaming affected population under K06 – of the DCCA is required. the proposal will be Clague larger, too. Garden K03 (Tsuen Wan South) includes the areas in the east K07 – of Tai Ho Road, the south of Tsuen Yeung Uk Road, the west of Wan Texaco Road, the north of Centre Wing Shun Street, and Vision City. K08 – Discovery K04 (Hoi Bun) Park includes Riveria Gardens. K. Tsuen Wan District - 190 - K. Tsuen Wan District Item No.* DCCAs Representations EAC’s Views No. W O K09 – K05 (Tsuen Wan West) Fuk Loi includes the areas of Yau Kom Tau, Ting Kau, Bayview K10 – Garden, Belvedere Garden Luk Phase 3, Serenade Cove and Yeung The Pavilia Bay. Restores the name of the DCCA to “Lai K12 – Hing”. Tsuen Wan K06 (Clague Garden) Rural includes the areas of Ocean Pride, Clague Garden Estate, K13 – Skyline Plaza and Tsuen Wan Ting Plaza. Sham K07 (Tsuen Wan Centre) K14 – includes the areas of Tsuen Lai To Wan Centre, and Tsuen King Garden. Renaming of the K15 – DCCA is required. Allway K08 (Discovery Park) K16 – includes the areas of Cheung Discovery Park and Fuk Loi Shek Estate. Renaming of the DCCA is required. K17 – Shek Wai K09 (Fuk Loi) Kok includes the areas in the east of Tai Chung Road, the south of Hoi Pa Street and Castle Peak Road – Tsuen Wan, the west of Tai Ho Road North, and the north of Tai Pa Street. Renaming of the DCCA is required. K10 (Luk Yeung) includes Luk Yeung Sun Chuen, and the areas in the north of Castle Peak Road, the south and the east of Sai Lau Kok Road. K. Tsuen Wan District - 191 - K. Tsuen Wan District Item No.* DCCAs Representations EAC’s Views No. W O K12 (Tsuen Wan Rural) proposes to rename the DCCA as “Tsing Lung Tau”. K13 (Ting Sham) includes the areas of Bellagio, Rhine Garden, Ocean Pointe and Sham Tseng Village. Renames the DCCA as “Sham Tseng”. K14 (Lai To) includes the areas of Hanley Villa, Belvedere Garden Phases 1 and 2, The Panorama and Summit Terrace. K15 (Allway) includes the areas of Allway Gardens, Tsuen Tak Gardens, Kam Fung Garden, The Cairnhill, The Cliveden, Kwong Pan Tin Tsuen and Pak Tin Pa San Tsuen. K16 (Cheung Shek) includes Cheung Shan Estate, the north of Cheung Pei Shan Road, and the village houses along and in the vicinity of Route Twisk. K17 (Shek Wai Kok) includes Shek Wai Kok Estate and its nearby areas. 5 K01 – 1 - (a) Objects to the provisional Item (a) Tak Wah recommendations on the This representation is not transfer of Vision City accepted because based on K03 – from K01 (Tak Wah) to the 2015 original DCCA Tsuen K03 (Tsuen Wan South). boundary, the population of Wan K01 (Tak Wah) (21 511) will South exceed the statutory K. Tsuen Wan District - 192 - K. Tsuen Wan District Item No.* DCCAs Representations EAC’s Views No. W O K04 – permissible upper limit Hoi Bun (+29.59%). With a view to maintaining the population within the statutory permissible range, it is necessary to transfer some of the buildings in K01 (Tak Wah) to the adjacent DCCAs. Given that the new DCCA K03 (Tsuen Wan South) adjacent to K01 (Tak Wah) has sufficient room to absorb the excessive population of K01 (Tak Wah), the provisional recommendations proposed to transfer Vision City which is closest to K03 (Tsuen Wan South) from K01 (Tak Wah) to K03 (Tsuen Wan South). (b) Proposes to transfer Item (b) Waterside Plaza from K04 This proposal is not accepted (Hoi Bun) to K03 (Tsuen because the population of Wan South). K04 (Hoi Bun) will fall within the statutory permissible range. According to the established working principles, adjustment to its existing boundary is not required. 6 K03 – 1 - (a) Objects to the provisional Item (a) Tsuen recommendations on K05 This proposal is not accepted Wan (Tsuen Wan West). because: South Proposes to use Tai Ho Road as the eastern (i) according to the proposal K05 – boundary of K05 (Tsuen made in the Tsuen Wan West) and transfer the representation , the Wan Pavilia Bay from K05 population of K03 (Tsuen West (Tsuen Wan West) to K03 Wan South) (21 280) will (Tsuen Wan South) exceed the statutory because: permissible upper limit K.