Cockshott, W.P. and Cottrell, A. Towards a new socialism., Nottingham: Spokesman (1993) http://eprints.gla.ac.uk/4478/ 4th July 2008 Glasgow ePrints Service https://eprints.gla.ac.uk T O W A R D S A N E W S O C I A L I S M W. P A U L C O C K S H O T T A N D A L L I N C O T T R E L L ii About this book Towards a New Socialism was first published in 1993 by Spokesman, Bertrand Russell House, Gamble Street, Nottingham, England, and printed by the Russell Press, Nottingham. The text is copyright W. Paul Cockshott and Allin Cottrell. Paul Cockshott ([email protected]) currently works at the Turing Insti- tute of the University of Glasgow, and Allin Cottrell ([email protected]) in the Department of Economics at Wake Forest University, North Carolina. The authors wish to thank Maria Black, Ron Buchanan and Greg Michaelson for useful discussions of the ideas in this book. Allin Cottrell also wishes to acknowledge assistance in the form of research grants from Elon College, North Carolina, and the Kerr Bequest at the University of Edinburgh. Preface to the Swedish edition It is now ten years since most of Towards a New Socialism was written. The developments of the last decade|less dramatic than its predecessor|do not make us wish to revise the book's main thesis. We still believe that, the Soviet experience notwithstanding, an efficient, democratic socialism is both techni- cally feasible and desirable. We stand by our attempts to sketch in some detail what such a socialism might look like, while recognizing that they are but a contribution to discussion. In some ways, developments of the 1990s have brought our ideas closer to reality. We talk of planning the economy using a network of computers. When we first floated this idea the Internet was in its infancy; now it is a major fact of life and the technology needed to permit large scale sharing of information in real time is a commonplace. The computer speeds we took as our benchmark in assessing the feasibility of planning calculations have (predictably) been su- perceded many times over. In this edition we have updated some of the dis- cussion in chapter 3 accordingly. It is not just that technological developments have been favorable to our proposals: the Internet has also spawned a sort of cooperative culture that is essentially communist, whether or not the partici- pants would be happy to accept that description. We're thinking, for example, of the sharing of technical expertise via Usenet, and the \open source" software movement. These developments are particularly relevant for our discussion of information and incentives in chapter 9. In other ways, our \new socialism" may seem further removed from reality today than it was in the early 1990s. A new reader asked us recently, \Do you have any suggestion about how to reach the proposal of TNS from our present situation?" Good question. That a new form of society is technically feasible, and arguably morally superior, does not mean that it will be realized. That requires, at minimum, that large numbers of people wish very much for it to be realized|that they are ready to take the risks associated with fundamen- tal change. It is easier to imagine a widespread desire for change emerging in a context of social misery and disruption, as in times of war or economic depression. But after a rocky start the 1990s were a decade of growth, prosper- ity and (mostly) peace for the major capitalist countries. The Asian financial meltdown of 1997 did not have the systemic consequences some anticipated; continuing fighting in the Balkans did not drag the major nations into war. It is not surprising that few people were drawn to discussion of radical alternatives to the existing social order. Although it is hard to predict the timing and nature of the next crisis that could put thought of alternatives back on history's agenda, we can identify various background conditions that have motivated us, and others, to explore and promote alternatives even in \good times" for the present system. We have iii iv updated the statistical material on inequality in chapters 1 and 2: the story is essentially the same as it was a decade earlier. The prosperity of the 1990s has been shared just as unequally as that of earlier decades of growth, if not more so. And while the Club of Rome's warnings of environmental catastrophe in the 1970s may have been premature, the early twenty-first century faces global warming as a daily reality. It is difficult to see how anything other than a socially planned response could be efficacious. Anyway, we are very grateful to Anders Axelsson for proposing a Swedish edition of Towards a New Socialism, and giving us the opportunity to update some of our points. We have the impression that the book, while it has not exactly been a best-seller, has found some thoughtful and enthusiastic readers. We hope the new edition will help recruit more such readers, and to broaden the discussion among socialists of what exactly it is that we hope to achieve. Paul Cockshott Glasgow, Scotland, July 2000 Allin Cottrell Winston-Salem, North Carolina, July 2000 Contents Introduction 1 Why is social democracy inadequate? .................. 2 In what sense was the USSR socialist? .................. 3 What can be learnt from the failure of Soviet socialism? ........ 5 What is the theoretical basis for a new socialism? ............ 7 Synopsis of the book ............................ 7 1 Inequality 11 Sources of inequality ............................ 11 Exploitation .............................. 12 Unemployment ............................ 16 Infirmity and old age ......................... 17 Women's economic subordination .................. 18 Summary .................................. 21 2 Eliminating Inequalities 23 Benefits of income redistribution ..................... 25 How much would one hour's labour produce? ........... 25 Equality more effective than growth ................ 27 Inequalities of labour ............................ 27 Differential payment for education/skill? .............. 28 Specific labour shortages ....................... 29 Differential payment for `personal qualities'? ........... 31 Skilled labour as a `produced input' ................... 33 Comparison with historically existing socialism ............. 35 Appendix: skilled labour multiplier .................... 37 3 Work, Time and Computers 39 Economies of time ............................. 39 Objective social accounting ........................ 42 Defining labour content .......................... 43 The problem of scale ............................ 45 The idea of complexity ........................ 45 Simplifying the labour value problem ................ 46 The Internet and labour values ...................... 48 v vi Contents 4 Basic Concepts of Planning 51 Planning and control ............................ 52 Capitalist goals second order ....................... 54 What would be first-order goals? ..................... 55 Levels of planning ............................. 55 5 Strategic Planning 59 Planning the industrial structure ..................... 59 The environment and natural resources ................. 62 The time dimension of production .................... 64 Market and non-market distribution ................... 66 Rights of citizenship ......................... 66 Freedom of choice ........................... 66 Coping with scarcity ......................... 67 Costs of metering ........................... 67 Agriculture ................................. 67 6 Detailed Planning 71 Planning in the USSR ........................... 76 Detail planning and stock constraints .................. 78 A new plan-balancing algorithm ..................... 79 The harmony function ........................ 79 Stages of the algorithm ....................... 81 Economic cybernetics in Chile ....................... 83 7 Macroeconomic Planning 85 Macro accounting in labour-time ..................... 85 Household saving and credit ........................ 89 Interest on savings? ......................... 93 Tax policy .................................. 94 Ground rent .............................. 95 Excise tax ............................... 96 Taxation and Accumulation ..................... 96 8 The Marketing of Consumer Goods 97 Market-clearing prices ........................... 98 Consumer goods and the macro plan ................... 99 Comparison with capitalist markets ................... 101 Conclusion ................................. 103 conc1 .................................... 103 9 Planning and Information 105 Information and property ......................... 105 Requirements of a statistical service ................... 106 Product coding ............................ 106 Unified stock control ......................... 107 Standardised message formats .................... 107 Obtaining technical coefficients ................... 107 Information: social problems ....................... 107 Information, performance measures and incentives ........ 108 Contents vii Evaluating the performance of enterprises ............. 109 Statistical assessment for producer goods enterprises ....... 109 Against monopoly .......................... 110 Rewards and sanctions? .......................... 111 10 Foreign Trade 113 Technology and trade patterns ...................... 116 Low wage and high wage economies ................... 117 Advantages of trade deficits ........................ 118 International trade in context of socialism ................ 120 State demand for foreign currency ................