PAPER C SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS as at 31 October 2010 (Q3 10/11) Ref Appellant Type Details/site Appeal Procedure/ Appeal Overall Start Date date of H/I decision duration (if known) and of appeal date (in weeks) ON-GOING APPEALS P/01319/09 Mr J Ball R Detached house with vehicular access 20 Jan 10 WR off Steyne Road; associated landscaping to include retaining walls and hardstanding – land rear of Hilarion, Somerset Road, Seaview P/01083/08 Mr Rae R Demolition of hotel; residential 04 Feb 10 WR DISMISSED 34+ Bowdery development comprising 3 storey block 04 Oct 10 of 11 flats & 3 maisonettes to include accommodation within roofspace; associated parking & landscaping – Curraghmore Hotel, 22 Hope Road, Shanklin E/19324/C Mr J Kohn E Material change of use from residential 07 April 10 H DISMISSED 26+ to mixed use of residential, 07 Oct 10 B&B/Boarding house and private members club – Casati House, 4 West Street, Ryde P00847/09 Mr G Brown R Demolition of garage; detached house 08 March 10 WR ALLOWED 31+ with parking; alterations to vehicular 14 Oct 10 access (revised plan) – land adjacent 9, and rear of 1-9 Cambridge Road, East Cowes 1 P/00910/09 Mr G Collins R Demolition of building; construction of 12 March 10 WR detached building to provide swimming pool, gym & sauna; 11 holiday cottages; parking; tennis court; bin store & cycle parking (revised plans)(readvertised application) – The Brambles Centre, Monks Lane, Freshwater P/01847/09 Mr Hau RA Retention of 1 x illuminated projecting 12 March 10 WR sign; 1 x illuminated main fascia sign and 4 x smaller illuminated fascia signs – Ming Garden, 38-39 St James Street, Newport P/01241/09 Ms M Perrott R Removal of condition 4 on 19 March 10 WR DISMISSED 28+ TCPL/14933/G & LBC/14933/H to allow 06 Oct 10 the dwelling to be occupied separately from Yard Farm – The Cart House, Yard Farm, St Johns Road, Wroxall P/00021/09 Cornwall Light R Three wind turbine generators with hub 30 March 10 I & Power Ltd height of 80m & rotor diameter of 90m (tip height 125m); control building, access tracks, underground electrical cables & temporary construction compound – Cheverton Farm, Cheverton Down, Cheverton Shute, Shorwell P/01332/09 Rotapoint Ltd R Alteration, conversion and extension of 30 March 10 WR Long Barn as unit of living accommodation (revised scheme) – Longlands Farm, Sandown Road, Bembridge P/01333/09 Rotapoint Ltd RL LBC for alteration, conversion and 30 March 10 WR extension of Long Barn as unit of living accommodation (revised scheme) – 2 Longlands Farm, Sandown Road, Bembridge P/01464/09 Mr A Gibbs R Demolition of dwelling; construction of 01 April 10 WR ALLOWED 27+ two detached dwellings with parking – 11 Oct 10 Copperfields, Youngwoods Way, Alverstone Garden Village P/01105/09 The Caravan Refusal to Proposed amendment to planning 06 April 10 WR INVALID Club accept an permission P/01105/09 for Alterations to amend- internal layout of toilet block and ment as provision of disabled access ramp; non- extension of existing roadways within material site to provide circulatory network; provision of wardens pod and associated fencing - Southland Caravan Park, Winford Road, Newchurch E/23333/B Mr & Mrs Morris E The erection of railings and screening to 14 April 10 I create a first floor balcony on the rear elevation of the property – 2b Coronation Avenue, Cowes P/01894/09 Mr & Mrs Nigh R Demolition of dwelling and outbuilding; 14 April 10 WR proposed replacement detached house with integral garage; alterations to vehicular – Culverthorpe, Skinners Hill, Newchurch P/01784/09 Mr J Hart R Demolition of workshop buildings; 26 April 10 WR ALLOWED 23+ residential development of two detached 07 Oct 10 houses and a pair of semi-detached houses with parking and new access drive off Main Road; closure of existing access; proposed footpath (revised scheme) – Land adjacent Sans Souci, Main Road, Havenstreet 3 P/01007/09 Tollgate (IW) RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for 21 April 10 WR Ltd proposed use of holiday bungalows for permanent residential purposes all year round (No’s 1-4 & 6-28) – Tollgate Holiday Bungalows, Duver Road, Seaview P/00961/09 Weaver Bros R Demolition of part of building & house; 21 April 10 WR ALLOWED Ltd 1987 refurbishment of existing shop to include 13 Oct 10 Pension Fund extensions forming light industrial units, staff rooms & w.c; construction of detached block of 4 light industrial units & w.c; parking, (revised scheme) – Co- op Stores, 155 Mill Hill Road, Cowes P/00043/10 Mr M Pittard R Two storey extension to form three 20 April 10 WR DISMISSED 25 holiday units to include roofspace 12 Oct 10 accommodation; parking – Old School House, Church Road, Shanklin P00979/09 Mr G Lewis R Outline for four detached dwellings and 15 April 10 WR DISMISSED 25+ alterations to vehicular access (revised 08 Oct 10 scheme) - 27 Pondwell Close, Ryde P/01673/09 Mr M Pittard R Removal of condition 2 on P/01660/06 28 April 10 WR ALLOWED 25 which states that the holiday units shall 20 Oct 10 be limited to holiday use and shall not be used as permanent or main residences – 22 Church Road, Shanklin P/01324/09 NB Holdings Ltd R Proposed detached dwelling to include 26 April 10 WR DISMISSED 24+ roofsp[ace accommodation & integral 15 Oct 10 garage; dormer windows on front elevation; vehicular access (revised scheme) – land adjacent 28 High Park Road, Ryde P/00002/10 Mr & Mrs D RLDC LDC for continued use of property as 16 June 10 I 4 Woodmore residential – Buttercup Barn, Palmers Road, Wootton Bridge E/22278/F Mr L Sixsmith E Material change of use of the land to 25 May 10 WR motor vehicle sales by the display of cars on the land and the installation of a mobile home and decking - Safeway Vehicle sales on Land adjacent Merrie Gardens Farm, Newport Road, Lake P/01455/09 Mr & Mrs R Conversion & extension of garage/store 19 May 10 WR Twining to form bungalow (revised scheme) – Garage/store adjoining Trumartin, Woolverton Road, Ventnor P/00230/10 Tristmire Ltd R Partial demolition of former bakery; 19 May 10 WR DISMISSED 20 single/2-storey extension and 06 Oct 10 conversion of building to form residential unit – Erics Bakery, 10 Clarendon Street, Newport P/00370/10 Weaver Bros. R Conversion & extension of garage/store 26 May 10 WR Ltd and office to create 2 residential units (revised scheme) – 9 Weavers Yard, Lane End Road, Bembridge P/00327/10 Mr W R Demolition of fire damaged property; 08 June 10 WR ALLOWED 16+ Hetherington replacement detached dwelling; re- 11 Oct 10 roofing & cladding to detached garage – Stumps, Wellwood Glade, Ryde P/00270/10 Mr J Timmons R Proposed terrace of three houses with 25 June 10 WR parking; vehicular access from St David’s Road – land adjacent 74 – 82 St David’s Road, rear of 113 – 121 and between 111 and 113 Adelaide Grove, East Cowes 5 P/00492/10 Mr E Wright R Demolition of three garages; outline for 19 July 10 WR 3-storey block of 6 flats with parking and use of existing 5 garages (revised scheme) – land adjacent Orchardleigh Car Park, Orchardleigh Road, Shanklin (rear of 53 High Street) P/00890/09 Rotapoint Ltd R Demolition of building; three/four storey 21 July 10 WR block of 4 town houses with ground floor parking; vehicular access (further revised scheme)(readvertised application) – Beachlands, Esplanade, Ventnor P/01939/09 Mr A Williams – R Demolition of dwelling; proposed 19 July 10 WR FW construction of two pairs of semi- Developments detached houses with parking; vehicular access off Albany Road and Worsley Road (revised scheme) – land at and rear of 896 Albany Road, Newport P/00597/10 Mr A Tickner R Proposed detached house with integral 18 Aug 10 WR garage and vehicular access off Worsley Road – land to rear of 108 Albany Road, Newport P/00490/10 Mr A Gill R Demolition of single storey rear 24 Aug 10 HAS ALLOWED 8 extension; alterations; construction of 05 Oct 10 single storey rear extension to form kitchen/family room – 8 Osborn Road, East Cowes P/01442/09 Mr J Kerr R Demolition of garage; residential 02 Sept 10 WR development of 5 houses in courtyard complex with parking and access off Mill Hill Road (revised scheme) – land at and rear of 46 Mill Hill Road, Cowes 6 P/00938/10 Mrs K Sowerby R Replacement of planning permission WR (P01241/07 – TCP/28442: demolition of garage & porch; construction of 2 storey end of terrace dwelling; vehicular access) in order to extend the time limit for implementation – land at 66 Nodes Road, Cowes P/00038/10 Queens Mews R Demolition of garage; proposed pair of 14 Sept 10 WR (Ryde) Ltd semi-detacdhed houses with parking; vehicular access (revised scheme) (revised plans) – land adjacent Queens Keep, East Hill Road, Ryde, P/00417/10 Redwood R Proposed detached house; vehicular 15 Sept 10 WR Developments access – site at 41 & 43 Mayfield Road, Ltd Ryde P/00418/10 Redwood R Proposed pair of semi-detached 15 Sept 10 WR Developments houses; vehicular access – site at 41 & Ltd 43 Mayfield Road, Ryde P/00640/10 Mrs N Cutting R Demolition of outbuildings; replacement 05 Oct 10 HAS outbuilding to form garage & utility room with store and games room over – Knighton Farm Cottage, Knighton Shute, Newchurch P/00748/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of house in multiple 22 Sept 10 H occupation – 38 Station Avenue, Sandown P/00749/10 Mr C Prew R Continued use of house in multiple 22 Sept 10 H occupation – 9 Carter Street, Sandown P/00411/10 Mr L Thorne RLDC Proposed single storey rear extension – 29 Sept 10 WR Beach Cottage, Castlehaven Lane, Niton 7 P/00717/09 Mrs P Cotton Proposed detached dwelling with 22 Sept 10 WR integral garage;