ZOBODAT - www.zobodat.at Zoologisch-Botanische Datenbank/Zoological-Botanical Database Digitale Literatur/Digital Literature Zeitschrift/Journal: Spixiana, Zeitschrift für Zoologie Jahr/Year: 2016 Band/Volume: 039 Autor(en)/Author(s): Ortiz Antonio S., Rubio Rosa Maria, Guerrero Juan José, Garre Manuel, Hausmann Axel Artikel/Article: Integrated taxonomy, phylogeography and conservation in the genus Chelis Rambur, [1866] in the Iberian Peninsula (Lepidoptera, Erebidae, Arctiinae) 273- 286 ©Zoologische Staatssammlung München/Verlag Friedrich Pfeil; download www.pfeil-verlag.de SPIXIANA 39 2 273-286 München, Dezember 2016 ISSN 0341-8391 Integrated taxonomy, phylogeography and conservation in the genus Chelis Rambur, [1866] in the Iberian Peninsula (Lepidoptera, Erebidae, Arctiinae) Antonio S. Ortiz, Rosa M. Rubio, Juan J. Guerrero, Manuel Garre & Axel Hausmann Ortiz, A. S., Rubio, R. M., Guerrero, J. J., Garre, M. & Hausmann, A. 2016. Inte- grated taxonomy, phylogeography and conservation in the genus Chelis Rambur, [1866] in the Iberian Peninsula (Lepidoptera, Erebidae, Arctiinae). Spixiana 39 (2): 273-286. The taxonomy of Chelis, a genus distributed within the Palaearctic region, is re- vised based on morphological and molecular data (DNA barcodes) in the Iberian Peninsula. The neighbour-joining and maximum likelihood trees, combined with adult male genitalia and morphology, support the existence of three species indicat- ing two major lineages, one corresponding to mountainous taxa (Chelis arragonensis and C. cantabrica), with restricted distribution, and the other represented by Chelis maculosa, a taxon with a broad European distribution and a great number of in- fraspecific taxa. Haplotypic variation is highly concordant with species taxonomy; the variation at a continental scale reveals a significant geographic pattern of haplo- groups: C. arragonensis is restricted to the mountains of Central Spain and C. canta- brica is endemic to the Western Cantabrian Mountains. C. maculosa includes sev- eral distinct haplotypes with a marked intraspecific genetic divergence (0.79- 1.83 %) and C. simplonica is endemic to the Alps and presents low interspecific di- vergence from C. cantabrica (1.5 %), requiring further investigation. Antonio S. Ortiz, Rosa M. Rubio, Juan J. Guerrero & Manuel Garre, Department of Zoology and Physical Anthropology, University of Murcia, Campus de Espi- nardo, 30100 Murcia, Spain; e-mail: [email protected] Axel Hausmann, SNSB – Bavarian State Collection of Zoology, Münchhausenstr. 21, 81247 Munich, Germany Introduction the taxonomic interpretation of the status for a num- ber of taxa (Dubatolov 1988, Karsholt & Razowski Arctiine moths (Erebidae, Arctiinae) are a mega- 1996, Witt et al. 2011, Karsholt & Nieukerken 2013). diverse subfamily of Lepidoptera with about 11 000 Some of these taxa have quite a broad distribution described species (Scoble 1992). The European fauna from Europe to the Siberian mountains and steppes, is particularly well known with 113 species (Witt for example with Chelis maculosa (Gerning, 1780), et al. 2011), as illustrated by the decrease in the C. caecilia (Lederer, 1853) and C. dahurica (Boisdu- description of new species during the last decades, val, 1834). Other taxa are thought to be restricted although such findings are usually confined to the to particular areas and mountains from the Eastern Mediterranean region or to other mountain areas Iberian Peninsula (C. arragonensis (Staudinger, 1894)), (e. g. Ylla et al. 2010: genus Setina, Macià et al. 2013: the Cantabrian mountains (C. cantabrica Macià et al., Chelis cantabrica). The genus Chelis Rambur, [1866] 2013) or the Alps (C. simplonica (Boisduval, 1840)). is considered to include 2-10 species depending on C. maculosa is an extremely variable species in size, 273 ©Zoologische Staatssammlung München/Verlag Friedrich Pfeil; download www.pfeil-verlag.de colouration, wing pattern and size of spots. Accord- the Iberian Peninsula remain contentious. To solve ing to different authors it includes the subspecies them, the study of additional characters, rather than C. m. mannerheimi (Duponchel, 1836), C. m. honesta solely morphological characteristics, is needed. Al- (Freyer, 1843), C. m. stertzi (Schulz, 1902), C. m. flava though the study of the genitalia provides valuable Spuler, 1906, C. m. radiata Rebel, 1910, C. m. rosina criteria for species recognition, their preparation is Oberthür, 1911, C. m. marsicana Dannehl, 1929, time consuming, limiting the use of this approach C. m. centralhispanica Daniel, 1935 (= C. m. serratica for large-scale specimen sorting and examination. Agenjo, 1937), C. m. arlanzona Agenjo, 1937, and The recent integration of morphological and DNA- C. m. nordiberica Agenjo, 1937, amongst others. Witt based approaches has proven to be an effective et al. (2011) considered C. maculosa to occur in the way to accelerate species discovery and delineation Central and Southern parts of Europe, from the (Lumley & Sperling 2010, Padial & De La Riva 2010, North Eastern Iberian Peninsula to the Balkans and Schlick-Steiner et al. 2010), as well as to assist in de- the Eastern European steppes, but it is absent from tecting previously cryptic species (Hebert et al. 2004, the North Western and Northern parts of Europe. Huemer & Hausmann 2009, Hausmann & Huemer The subspecies present in the Iberian Peninsula is 2011, Mutanen et al. 2012a). Integration of molecular C. maculosa stertzi (Schulz, 1902); it was described methods with morphological analyses may accelerate from the Italian Alps although Toulgoët (1985) and biodiversity inventories and corroborate the status Fernández-Vidal (2012) considered it to be an indi- of doubtful taxa (Smith et al. 2009). The present vidual form of the nominal subspecies. investigation was prompted by results obtained C. arragonensis is considered to be endemic to the during an effort to barcode all Macroheteroceran Iberian Peninsula, from the Pyrenees towards Central Lepidoptera species in the Iberian Peninsula, which Spain. C. arragonensis was formerly considered to revealed that specimens of the genus Chelis are sepa- be a form or a subspecies of C. maculosa although it rated into definite sequence clusters. In this paper occurs sympatrically with C. maculosa stertzi in the we analyse phenotypic characters, COI sequences Northern half of the Iberian Peninsula. The female and geographical distribution of the lineages to as- genitalia of the two species are very similar but the sess differences between groups of populations in male genitalia show slight but recognizable differ- Iberian Peninsula. ences. However, Pérez-de Gregorio et al. (2001) only considered the presence of three subspecies in the Material and methods Iberian Peninsula: C. m. maculosa distributed from the Central Pyrenees to the Cantabrian Mountains; Morphological study C. m. stertzi from the Eastern Pyrenees and inner One hundred and fifteen adult specimens of the Chelis Catalonian Mountains; and C. m. arragonensis in genus from the Iberian Peninsula and three from the the Iberian System, Sierra of Guadarrama and the Alps were identified as Chelis maculosa (36 specimens), provinces of Zamora and Burgos. Ylla et al. (2010) C. arragonensis (70), C. cantabrica (7) and C. simplonica (2). considered the presence of only two subspecies, Adult specimens were examined externally in order to stertzi and arragonensis, while Fernández-Vidal (2012) evaluate possible differences in their colouration, spot and Magro (2013), following the criteria of Witt et al. size and wing shape, and were dissected using a stand- (2011), displayed the C. maculosa and C. arragonensis ard procedure (Fibiger 1997) with minor modifications. distribution in the North Western half of the Iberian Genital structures were examined using a Zeiss Stemi Peninsula. With respect to C. simplonica, Fernández- 2000-C stereomicroscope with a digital camera (Insight Vidal (2012) considered that the record from Puerto Firewire, 18.2. Color Mosaic, Diagnostic Instruments Inc. USA). Final pictures were taken by Canon Digital de Pajares could be right (in spite of its low altitude, Camera EOS 550D with an ultra-macro objective. Geni- 1420 m, in comparison with the Alps), but also tal structures were compared with those published by considered that it could be a mislabelled specimen. Witt et al. (2011) to get an initial identification. Speci- Magro (2013) mentioned at least three different mens are deposited in the collection of the Department overlapping areas for C. maculosa and C. arragonensis of Zoology and Physical Anthropology of the Universi- in Central Spain. dad de Murcia (Spain) except C. simplonica specimens In the latest version of the Fauna Europaea which are deposited in Tiroler Landesmuseen in Inns- (Karsholt & Nieukerken 2013), four taxa have been bruck (Austria). recognized in Europe, of which only C. maculosa is thought to occur in the Iberian Peninsula. Finally, Molecular study Macià et al. (2013) have described C. cantabrica, a Eighteen adult male specimens of Chelis were processed species closely related to C. simplonica. Therefore, the and sequenced at the Canadian Centre for DNA Barcod- taxonomic problems concerning the genus Chelis in ing (CCDB, Guelph) to obtain DNA barcodes using the 274 ©Zoologische Staatssammlung München/Verlag Friedrich Pfeil; download www.pfeil-verlag.de standard high-throughput protocol described by Ivano- 1980), and Neighbour-joining (NJ) and Maximum Like- va et al. (2006). Data of sampling localities are indicated lihood